Results 1 to 2 of 2
  1. #1
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005

    Default City attorney flags traffic light cameras, Columbia, MO

    City attorney flags traffic light cameras

    By MATTHEW LeBLANC of the Tribune’s staff
    Published Sunday, February 19, 2006

    It looks as if the latest push to install red-light cameras at Columbia intersections will proceed with caution.

    Mayor Darwin Hindman in January asked the Columbia Police Department to gather information on the cost and effectiveness of the systems, marking the third time since 1997 police received such a directive.

    However, a report from the city’s lawyer urges staff to step back from the study to examine several legal issues surrounding the systems, including a bill filed recently in the Missouri General Assembly that would ban the use of the cameras to catch drivers who run red lights.

    In a report to the Columbia City Council scheduled for review tomorrow, City Counselor Fred Boeckmann said there are "serious legal problems" with the systems.

    In the report, Boeckmann cites state Sen. Jason Crowell’s bill and concerns over whether the registered owner of a vehicle caught on camera running a red light should be ticketed if he or she was not driving the car at the time.

    Columbia City Manager Bill Watkins and Police Chief Randy Boehm each said the legal questions should be answered before a more complete report on the cameras is submitted to the council.

    But Hindman isn’t so sure. He said yesterday the pending legislation should not have an effect on whether the city should implement red-light cameras.

    "If we can get a red-light camera company to take the risk … I don’t see why we should be holding it up," Hindman said.

    Boeckmann’s suggestion wouldn’t stop the study, but it would slow it down. Hindman had hoped to have a report to the council by tomorrow’s meeting, though it is now likely to come after Crowell’s bill is acted upon by state lawmakers.

    The legislative session ends May 12.

    "At this point, it’s premature to make recommendations," Boehm said. "So, what we’re doing is taking more time."

    Boeckmann said a full report would be completed, though he is unsure when.

    "This was just kind of an interim report," he said. "We’re just pointing out some of the problems. We’ll follow this up."

    Red-light cameras continue to be controversial in Missouri, though several other cities across the country have installed the systems. Only the St. Louis suburb of Arnold is using them in Missouri. Florissant and Springfield each have passed ordinances that allow the cameras.

    Though debate continues over the effectiveness of the cameras to stop car crashes and deter drivers from running red lights, Hindman and Boehm have said they are convinced the systems would work well in Columbia.

    Columbia police last year issued nearly 400 tickets to drivers for traffic signal violations, down from nearly 500 in 2004.

    Crowell, a Cape Girardeau Republican, introduced his bill amid concerns that the cameras invite too much government intrusion and cited concerns that camera companies sometimes share revenues from fines.
    Laser Interceptor Dual, Laser Interceptor Quad, Valentine 1 & The Escort 8500 X50 - Blue, Uniden BC296D, GRE500, Lasershield, 2011 Kia Soul +, Yamaha FZ6, 2005 Black Dodge Neon SRT-4,

  2. #2
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005


    Another Version of the story:

    Mayor endorses red-light cameras
    The city attorney recommends against using the devices.


    February 19, 2006


    The cameras photograph the rear of the car and license plate or the face of the driver when a car runs a red light.

    Tickets are then mailed to either the car’s owner or the driver, depending on the system.

    Mayor Darwin Hindman said Saturday he is “absolutely in favor” of installing cameras on traffic lights to catch red-light runners despite a report by City Attorney Fred Boeckmann advising against the devices.

    Boeckmann’s report, which will be presented to the City Council on Monday, recommends against installing cameras at this time because of legal questions that surround the systems and pending legislation in the Missouri Senate that would prohibit the devices’ use.

    Boeckmann said there are conflicting studies and opinions regarding how effective the devices are in reducing accidents and injuries.

    But Hindman said the cameras have important benefits.

    “We’re taking action to save people’s lives and prevent injury,” he said.

    The cameras monitor intersections by automatically photographing vehicles that run red lights, producing a picture of either the rear of the car and license plate or the face of the driver. Tickets are then mailed to either the car’s owner or the driver, depending on the type of system.

    Boeckmann said systems that photograph the car’s license plate and ticket the vehicle’s owner seem to be more popular because they eliminate the privacy concerns some opponents cite, as the driver and passengers are not photographed unknowingly.

    It is also much easier to send citations to a vehicle’s registered owner rather than try to discover the identity of a driver from a photograph, Boeckmann said.

    Missouri law considers the registered owner of the vehicle as the operator in the case of parking violations, he said.

    But, Boeckmann said in the report, “It is doubtful that a presumption involving a red-light violation would be treated the same as a parking violation.”

    The consequences for running a red light are more serious because it is considered a moving violation. This can add points to the owner’s driving record and could increase the owner’s insurance rates.

    Boeckmann said in the report that photographing the driver’s face avoid these problems but that identifying the driver is time-consuming. It is possible that some drivers may never be identified, he said.

    Hindman said the city would be able to overcome financial risks through an agreement with private companies that operate the cameras.

    Some companies install the cameras at no up-front cost and then maintain and operate the systems in exchange for a portion of the fines.

    Hindman said a vendor’s financial involvement with the cameras makes the devices “seem like a risk-free agreement for the city.”

    Sen. Jason Crowell, R-Cape Girardeau, has proposed a bill banning the cameras’ use, questioning the legality of using a picture to convict a driver of disobeying traffic laws. The bill was sent to a committee in January.

    Crowell said he worries about private-sector involvement in traffic enforcement. He said he’s bothered that some camera companies make money on each ticket issued and that, in some places in the country, the companies decide the timing of the light cycles at camera locations and have a role in writing the tickets.

    Columbia should go ahead with the cameras despite the bill, Hindman said.

    The city should not allow one person’s proposal to “veto our effort” to save lives, he said.

    Three Missouri cities have approved the use of red-light cameras. Arnold has a camera system in place, and Florissant and Springfield are in the process of implementing them.

    City Manager Bill Watkins said city staff feels it “might be a little premature” to begin using red-light cameras.

    “We’ll feel more comfortable when we know what the legislature will do,” he said.

    The City Council will review Boeckmann’s report at its regular meeting at 7 p.m. Monday in the fourth-floor council chambers of the Daniel Boone City Building.

    If the council expresses interest in the cameras, the city would be prepared to further examine them, Watkins said.
    Laser Interceptor Dual, Laser Interceptor Quad, Valentine 1 & The Escort 8500 X50 - Blue, Uniden BC296D, GRE500, Lasershield, 2011 Kia Soul +, Yamaha FZ6, 2005 Black Dodge Neon SRT-4,



Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 03-30-2012, 08:50 AM
  2. City attorney: Speed cameras could increase workload
    By StlouisX50 in forum News Stories
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 02-10-2011, 04:35 AM
  3. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 01-28-2011, 10:55 AM
  4. MO - City of Columbia Plans for More Red Light Cameras
    By StlouisX50 in forum News Stories
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 01-13-2011, 09:57 AM
  5. TX - City considering red light traffic cameras
    By richardboy316 in forum News Stories
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11-22-2006, 07:46 AM


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts