View Full Version : question about blinder alerts
abdrury
01-28-2005, 01:38 AM
well, i'm definitely "sold" on an x50. i also want to get the m-20, but i just wanted to make sure that the audible warning provided by blinder's in-cabin speaker is sufficient to rely upon laser detection. why do i ask when i will be x50-equipped? well, i'm afraid it will not be good for me to mount my x50 as low as recommended because my car (04 jetta) has a rather high rear deck that i'm sure will block the rear view of the x50.
i figure that i will have to mount the detector about mid-windshield, which in that case wouldn't it be too high for effective laser detection? so i might as well go for the "high as possible" approach to mounting the x50, yes? if my assumptions are correct, than my question about blinder's audible warning stands.
if mounting the x50 low will be okay despite the high rear deck, than i guess all is well :D thanks!
ps - awesome site, roy :D
BiGeAsYgUy
01-28-2005, 01:51 AM
well, i'm definitely "sold" on an x50. i also want to get the m-20, but i just wanted to make sure that the audible warning provided by blinder's in-cabin speaker is sufficient to rely upon laser detection. why do i ask when i will be x50-equipped? well, i'm afraid it will not be good for me to mount my x50 as low as recommended because my car (04 jetta) has a rather high rear deck that i'm sure will block the rear view of the x50.
i figure that i will have to mount the detector about mid-windshield, which in that case wouldn't it be too high for effective laser detection? so i might as well go for the "high as possible" approach to mounting the x50, yes? if my assumptions are correct, than my question about blinder's audible warning stands.
if mounting the x50 low will be okay despite the high rear deck, than i guess all is well :D thanks!
ps - awesome site, roy :D
Mount all radar detectors as high as possible because the distance increases the higher the radar detector is. If you have the $400, get a Valentine One because it is the only radar detector with arrows and 2 antennas (1 front and 1 rear) because it has a patent on this. Just remember, the V1 beats the X50 in rear radar detection by 2-3 miles in Ka band detection and it picks up 9 sources of any type of radar as opposed to the X50 with 8 (4 X, 2 K, 2 Ka) sources.
abdrury
01-28-2005, 02:32 AM
i appreciate the advice, but i've done my research & the x50 seems better for me personally...(this coming from someone who always held the v1 at such high esteem).
somewhere on radarbusters.com, roy advises against mounting the detector high; that is why i made the initial inquiry. i really dont want to start a "high vs. low" debate here, just looking for a straight-forward answer. thanks!
Iknox
01-28-2005, 06:06 AM
Yea i did my home work to before i got the x50 im glad u are going with the x50 i got mine from Roy :D Anyway ur getting a laser jammer your best bet is to raise it up if u want hell put it in the back seat lol J/K dont do that lol im glad u picked the x50 check out my post reply
http://www.radardetector.net/viewtopic.php?t=264
http://www.radardetector.net/viewtopic.php?t=250
Anyway have a good one
Peace
abdrury
01-28-2005, 12:04 PM
thanks for the support, but this isnt really about "x50 vs. v1." :wink:
so you're saying that if i did mount my x50 high, then it would pick up laser detection that is being shot at my front bumper area? i thought the latest SML test showed that NO RDs picked up on the laser when being shot at the headlights :?
sorry, i guess this isnt so much a "laser jammer" question... :oops:
compu44
01-28-2005, 12:08 PM
Mounting the detector high will pretty much wipe out any chance of laser detection when it's on your bumper, but by that time it's too late unless you're using veil. Mounting the Escort high will increase the line of sight in some situations, and will position the detector to see through windows ahead of you. This gives you a chance to detect laser when it's targeting a car in front of you. I'd suggest reading this:
http://www.valentine1.com/laserhowto/
abdrury
01-28-2005, 01:07 PM
so basically, high-mounting will not detect laser hitting ME, but rather someone else? ok, that makes sense :D and, mounting low would be pointless considering that i've been shot already? my best bet for avoiding laser is definitely an m20, yes?
oh yeah, that brings up a question i have about laserveil...if my x50 cant detect that I'M being shot by laser, then what good does laserveil do?
it seems to me that laserveil needs to be combined with an m20 for greatest results...
these are all assumptions on my part; i'm just looking for clarification on what i *think* could be correct judgements...thanks!
SmaartAasSaabr
01-28-2005, 03:14 PM
Really I don't think the height matters, since the X50 doesn't look backwards anyway. It does have a rear lidar sensor IIRC but you really need that :roll:
abdrury
01-28-2005, 05:32 PM
yeah, but my question is in regards to front laser detection; not rear. thanks anyways!
the only thing i'm concerned about regarding rear detection is the fact that low mounting could be detrimental to the RDs ability to "see" out the back efficiently, due to the high rear deck in my car. thus decreasing it's radar-sensing capabilities from behind.
again, i'm no expert. just trying to see if my assumptions are correct. tia!
jimbonzzz
01-28-2005, 10:25 PM
yeah, but my question is in regards to front laser detection; not rear. thanks anyways!
Something to think about:
Maybe you should be a little more concerned with rear laser protection. A vey common laser speed trap method used by police is to sit on an overpass directly over the road and target vehicles that pass underneath, then radio the vehicle ID to chase cars. You usually don't see them targeting on the far side of the overpass...
well, i'm afraid it will not be good for me to mount my x50 as low as recommended because my car (04 jetta) has a rather high rear deck that i'm sure will block the rear view of the x50.
The X50 doesn't have any "rear view": no rear radar antenna or lidar sensor. Any rear radar it receives will be reflected off of things in front of you, billboards, road signs, other vehicles etc. So you dont need to take the rear view into account when mounting the X50...
so i might as well go for the "high as possible" approach to mounting the x50, yes?
Yes, in my opinion.
For maximum radar detection, I recommend mounting high. The higher it is, the more "line of sight" you would have with the targeting radar. If you do the math, a foot higher could give you an extra 1/3 mile or more, which could make a difference.
If you are going to have a blinder too, that should be sufficient enough for lidar warnings.
Jim
compu44
01-28-2005, 10:35 PM
so basically, high-mounting will not detect laser hitting ME, but rather someone else? ok, that makes sense :D and, mounting low would be pointless considering that i've been shot already? my best bet for avoiding laser is definitely an m20, yes?
Yes the M20 will give you your best chance.
oh yeah, that brings up a question i have about laserveil...if my x50 cant detect that I'M being shot by laser, then what good does laserveil do?
most of the time the escort can detect laser on you. if that's what you're going for, for example if you have veil but no blinder, you should mount low. veil will usually cause the officer to need more than one shot. If you're not using other countermeasures, one shot and you're done, so best to try to detect before it's on you, thus mount high.
it seems to me that laserveil needs to be combined with an m20 for greatest results...
yeah, that would be ideal to team up the X50, a can of Veil, and a Blinder.
these are all assumptions on my part; i'm just looking for clarification on what i *think* could be correct judgements...thanks!
compu44
01-28-2005, 10:39 PM
The X50 doesn't have any "rear view": no rear radar antenna or lidar sensor. Any rear radar it receives will be reflected off of things in front of you, billboards, road signs, other vehicles etc. So you dont need to take the rear view into account when mounting the X50...
Jim
actually, the x50 does have a lidar sensor to the rear. it's the little black doodad on the top of the detector up near the mount on the left. pretty visable in this picture.
http://akamaipix.crutchfield.com/products/2004/036/x036P85X50R-f_dmt.jpeg
Not sure how much good it does, but it is there, as it is on the RX65 and most other detectors.
abdrury
01-28-2005, 10:52 PM
sounds good! thanks for all your help guys!
i may be back concerning hardwiring or programming issues :P until then, this seems to be a pretty cool site with lots of great info & opinions; i'm sure i'll be around :D
Radar Roy
01-28-2005, 11:24 PM
First off this is a "family message board" so I have deleted BiGeAsYgUy
icon!
Secondly, I disagree with your assessement on where to mount your detector "high". I know that Mike V recommeds this but I do not
Third, the 8500 and X50 does have a bi-directional antenna, receives front and rear
Sorry, but I would post more, but on cell phone in El Paso and I am limited to what I can post on this small keypad
Yes, the Blinder is what I would recommend for laser. If you get that, then it would not matter on how you mount your detector.
jimbonzzz
01-29-2005, 12:31 AM
Third, the 8500 and X50 does have a bi-directional antenna, receives front and rear
Fact: Horn antennas are directional. The Passport's antenna faces forward only.
So, just how can the 8500 have a bi-directional antenna???
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v230/jimbonzzz/Passport8500.jpg
Sounds to me like "Bi-Directional" is just another buzz word used for marketing hype, same as "360º Protection", "11 Band" etc.
Sure, any horn antenna is bi-directional if there is enough stuff to reflect a signal back to it.
Heh, "Bi-directional horn antenna" is an oxymoron. :D
Jim
joop1987
01-29-2005, 03:11 AM
Hey jimbonzzz, do you have a picture of the other side of the 8500?
jimbonzzz
01-29-2005, 10:34 PM
Sure...
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v230/jimbonzzz/8500_2.jpg
happya$$
01-30-2005, 06:59 AM
From ALL of the research that I have done, the V1 is the ONLY portable detector with two antennas. They have a patent on this. I personally LOVE the rear antenna and this is why. The other day when I received about a mile warning in Sheffield Village, The V1 alerted me that there was an officer straight ahead of me. I made a left turn and the V1 alerted me that the officer was behind me and to the side. About a minute later the signal got stronger. By the time he was two cars behind me. If I would have had any other detector I would have just assumed that the detector was just catching deflections and I would have increased my speed and POSSIBLY got a speeding ticket. From my experiences in Sheffield Village they use instant on but what they mostly do is have their radar units on LOW power (K band). They are THE BEST at using their radar units. I have been in Hudson, Stow, Avon Lake, Solon, Twinsburg, Monroe Falls, Cuyahoga Falls, Oakwood, Vermillion, Sandusky, Huron, Sheffield Lake, Bay Village, Cleveland, Bedford, Bedford Heights, Middleburg, and a few other places that I cant remember right now.
Veil Guy
01-30-2005, 11:03 AM
abdrury,
Radar detectors generally only have problems seeing laser when close - less than 700'.
SML's '03 test demonstrated the V1 to be the only windshield-mount detector able to detect laser at 500'. All of the top detectors were able to see laser from 1000'. This year the V1 didn't alert at 500'. This could have been related to placement on the windshield which was not mentioned.
Remember that the laser pattern only increases as distances increase. At distances greater the 500' (at which point one should be able to visually identify a laser trap) your X50, RX65, or V1 should be able to alert you to laser, VEIL will be doing its job at interfering with laser's abliity to get you.
The Veil Guy 8)
compu44
01-30-2005, 12:15 PM
jimbonzz-
sorry if it came off that I was trying to say that passport has two radar antennas- I know it doesn't.
I was trying to clarify that the 8500 has two laser sensors, one for front and one for rear.
jimbonzzz
01-30-2005, 12:29 PM
jimbonzz-
sorry if it came off that I was trying to say that passport has two radar antennas- I know it doesn't.
I was trying to clarify that the 8500 has two laser sensors, one for front and one for rear.
No apology necessary, I was definitely wrong about the LIDAR sensors in that post, I don't think you came off wrong at all.
My more recent post with the internal pic of the 8500 was in response to Roy, where he said that the Escort has a "Bi-Directional Antenna"...
Jim
sethy
01-30-2005, 03:39 PM
It is marketing, there is not a bi-directional antenna in the X50. They advertise 360 degree protection on escorts site because they know radar bounces off of objects.
As for personal experiance, sometimes when my detector is going off for a long time, I reach up and unlatch it and turn it around. It goes from a * Brap * ...... *brap.......*brap* to a solid tone. So I know for a fact that the thing cant truely detect from behind other then reflections off of objects.