View Full Version : Need some help with Scanner Antenna...
Hey guys,
I Have a little situation here, I am having trouble deciding which scanner antenna to use, here is what I have
-Radioshack Pro-2051
-Magnet Mount Antenna
-Stock Antenna
-Rubber duck antenna from my handheld
Here is my situation, I am about to take a long road trip and would like to use my pro-2051 to it best ability, the problem is, since this is only gonna be use temporarily from time to time, I do not want to mount an antenna on my car, I have a nissan 350z which has a very low roof line, i would like to have an antenna inside the car, my friend gave me the magnet mount antenna but on the box it says it can only handle speeds up to 65 mph
So here is my dilema, I don't know which antenna to use, I have read that the antennas work best when they are vertical, however, i can mount the magnet antenna sideways (horizontal) across the rear hatchback with relative ease, or I could use either the stock antenna or the rubber antenna, my main concern is to get maximum range for the highway patrol alert function and to also be able to listen in to cb chat
If someone could give me suggestions, it would be greatly appreciated
Thanks
crazyVOLVOrob
06-30-2005, 03:00 AM
It all depends on the frequencies you want to focus on....best range would be with an external antenna...I'm not sure which band the highway patrol alert board cast on but get an antenna suited for that...Also i might suggest using a CB as well
Thanks for the quick reply,
An external antenna is not really an option due to the fact that the only one i would be able to use would be a glass mount, but all of my windows have metal film on them
Of the 3 antenna's that I have, which would you recomend?
stalker
06-30-2005, 06:18 AM
I would go the magnet mount antenna, its going to be much better than a duckie
edweird
06-30-2005, 07:41 AM
If you don't work for a press organization, or do not hold an amatuer radio operators license, then in FL it is illegal to INSTALL a scanner in your car. The FL AG says that either mounting an antenna on the car and/or hooking it up to the power in your car constitutes installation.
Leaving a handheld with it's own antenna and batteries running in a car is OK. (Crazy huh?)
I'd use a cup holder or one of those suction cup grip things to hold it up in a window until you are out of the state.
Google "scanner state laws" and you can see that FL, KY, MI, and I think NY among others have some rules. In ever case I do belive there's an exemption for press and Hams. Why? Because both the press and Hams (via ARRL) have legal lobbies.
Ed
AZ-GT
06-30-2005, 09:40 PM
If you go to Unidens website and check scanner accessories you'll find a length of wire and a connector designed to go on the inside of your window. Probably good enough for what you have in mind.
crazyVOLVOrob
07-01-2005, 12:17 AM
is also depends on the unit you want and the frequencies the radioshack 800mhz duckie antenna is great for 800mhz channels
RensoreK
01-24-2006, 06:26 PM
If you don't work for a press organization, or do not hold an amatuer radio operators license, then in FL it is illegal to INSTALL a scanner in your car. The FL AG says that either mounting an antenna on the car and/or hooking it up to the power in your car constitutes installation.
Leaving a handheld with it's own antenna and batteries running in a car is OK. (Crazy huh?)
I'd use a cup holder or one of those suction cup grip things to hold it up in a window until you are out of the state.
Google "scanner state laws" and you can see that FL, KY, MI, and I think NY among others have some rules. In ever case I do belive there's an exemption for press and Hams. Why? Because both the press and Hams (via ARRL) have legal lobbies.
Ed
You can no longer even HAVE a scanner in the car, batteries or not.
http://www.flsenate.gov/cgi-bin/view_page.pl?Tab=session&Submenu=1&FT=D&File=hb169704er.html&Directory=session/2005/House/bills/billtext/html/
StlouisX50
02-17-2006, 12:08 PM
Actualy you might be able to get around that if you have a scanner that has weather alert technology.
Use the magnet mount for best performance because you can mount it anywhere and it is not permanent so if you put it on the highest point of your car i.e. roof you don't have to worry about damage. The Antenna Specialist Mon-51 is excellent. Anything is better than a rubber duckie antenna or indoor antenna.
stalker
02-17-2006, 11:57 PM
I still say the thru glass mount is the best for covert installs.
If you want stealth there is a super-gainer antenna by Watson W-881 it is a handheld antenna and that would be inside your car. It doesn't take up much space and it is very thin.
EEnerd
04-19-2006, 07:49 AM
There is also an adapter/splitter box that taps your existing AM/FM car radio antenna and allows you to at least get a piece of metal outside the car for use as an antenna. It'll be better than a rubber duck but not as good as a 'real' external scanner antenna on any frequencies above 150mhz. It will be pretty good on CB bands (~27Mhz). Car antennas are designed for VHF frequencies (obviously, upper end of the FM band is 108Mhz)- however I think any piece of metal acting as an antenna outside the car, even if not particularly resonant at the desired frequency (say, 800mhz) will work better than an interior rubber duck antenna.
PS I'm not sure I would believe the speed rating on the mag mount. It will probably stick at higher speeds than advertised. If you are concerned, look for a smaller antenna with a smaller loading coil (presents less surface area to the wind). You may be going from a 5/8wave to a 1/4 wave or smaller, but that's OK.
Here are a couple options for using the stock radio antenna on a scanner:
"Adds scanner reception capability to standard AM/FM car antennas without harming AM/FM reception. Easy to install. Comes with coax cables. 25-1000 MHz"
AM/FM AUTO ANTENNA COUPLER FOR SCANNERS WITH BNC CONNECTORS
Model Number: ANT63BNC
http://www.scannerworld.com/content/product/model/ANT63BNC
AM/FM AUTO ANTENNA SCANNER COUPLER WITH MOTOROLA CONNECTOR
Model Number: ANT63MOT
http://www.scannerworld.com/content/product/model/ANT63MOT