View Full Version : Update/Revision/Correction to our Review
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 12:21 PM
I think I finally found out why my latest V1 has an increased tendency to false on "K-band" relative to its older brother, the V1 v1.7.
In examing the affect "L" mode has on K sensitivity (which I believe is none) I stumbled across an error that I have likely made with respect to some of my interpretations of the V1's alerts.
During some part of my driving route I may have inadvertantly left the "H" feature set in a way that enabled Ku reception!
The thing is that the V1 Ku alerts with the identical tone as K! - the only difference being that the K-led band indicator does not light. The bogey counter displays a little period/dot next to the numeral displayed. I am certain that some of the alerts that we had believed were, in fact, Ku! Mea culpa! :shock:
When I confirmed (yesterday) that Ku was disabled, the falsing rate was more in line with the older V1.
First, I want to apologize to everyone , for my mis-interpretation of some of those K/Ku alerting cases.
Second, I am going to contact VR on Monday to share what I think is [at least part] of the answer [as we couldn't figure it out] and to suggest a filtering option like the "L" mode to apply to Ku because it feels like X-falsings - which can be tamed by this operation mode - and suggest a different tone selection (how about X-tone if they do not wish to add a unique tone like that of the RX65.
Third, I am going, to revise/update/correct for the record, our review to reflect this [new] realization.
Fourth, will run some additional comparisons between the the RX65 Pro and the latest V1 with both Ku bands enabled. (We have done some relatively brief comparisons and found the RX65 to be quieter than the V1 with Ku enabled.) Why do this? Because Ku is still used in some parts of Europe and may be stateside very soon.
If it acts like X-band - which it might - bettering filtering may be in order.
Would any of you who have V1s with Ku reception capability turn this mode on and provide some of your experiences, as a result?
In the meantime, I have some revising to do...
The Veil Guy 8)
Jon_Doh
03-06-2005, 01:03 PM
Thank your for updating your review and for your honesty. In my tests of the V1 v1.8 pre pop it certainly didn't false a lot on K band. In fact, in many geographic areas it seemed to false less than v1.7. Having the Ku band turned on certainly would make sense re the increased falsing.
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 01:37 PM
Coupled with the fact that it alerts with the same tone as K and 1) disabling POP did not seem to diminish the frequency of "falses" since Ku may have been the culpbrit [at least with some of them] and 2) the v1.7 that I own does not have Ku reception ability.
Again, I can't be sure if this capability was enabled during our videoing of the detectors POST/programming features that we did after our road test and just before our initial public release of our report.
But, given that I did find it enabled yesterday and the detector did have a noticeable increase of "K/Ku" alerts during our drive circuit yesterday and I can't be certain that it wasn't enabled [on at least part of our trip], I believe, in fairness to our readers and to the manufacturer that I should give VR all the benefit of any doubt...
Jon_Doh, would you try enabling the "H" function and see if you see a marked increase in falsing in your area. I would like to flush this out as quickly as possible.
The Veil Guy
V1 Dave
03-06-2005, 02:33 PM
I have been running with Ku on I get a false about every other day.
Only one LED, never in the same place. Either another detector or heard some cell phones might cause this?
happya$$
03-06-2005, 02:39 PM
I have had my KU on for about a month now and received my first KU false at the laser car wash yesterday
compu44
03-06-2005, 02:50 PM
I've had Ku on with my RX65 for about 2 months, I believe, and haven't heard it go off yet.
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 02:52 PM
happya$$,
what exactly is a laser carwash?
The Veil Guy 8)
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 02:53 PM
V1 Dave,
overhead satellites, perhaps? :wink:
The Veil Guy 8)
jimbonzzz
03-06-2005, 03:23 PM
I think Ku falses DO come from other detectors. I know for a fact that the LOs in some of today's detectors sweep the Ku range.
Today, I set up the RX-65 and the V1 w/pop (Ku turned on) on the test bench, a few feet apart, with both of them turned on. The BEL caused weak Ku falses on the V1. This happened multiple times over an hour period. I got a couple of weak X-band falses too, but most of them were on Ku. It was sort of random, but on average I would get an alert every 6-7 minutes, and it never went for 10 minutes without at least one Ku alert. With the BEL turned off, for almost 40 minutes now, the V1 hasn't falsed once.
I'll take a guess on why the alerts didn't happen more often: the timing has to be just right. The V1 has to be looking for Ku at the exact same time that the BEL's LO is tuned to Ku during it's normal sweep. Both detectors have different sweep schemes/rates, and it would likely take some minutes for these events to occur at exactly the same time.
Could this be what you experienced in your testing Bob?
Jim
marlinspike
03-06-2005, 03:27 PM
My experience is like V1Dave's. I get about one Ku false every two outings (on my drive from MD to NC today I got 2 falses). It's always just one dot on the strength meter and it goes away after 1 beep.
Richard
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 03:59 PM
jimbonzzz,
I wouldn't rule anything out. But yesterday I drove only with the either V1 in operation and on the same route.
I may have seen such an interaction once between the RX65 and the V1 but had disabled Ku reception (or so I thought, on both of them.)
At any rate, your analysis seems to have some good merit.
The V1 tends to alert in the same areas on my drive circuit in my home area when Ku is enabled and I think they are coming from the same respective sources everytime, although I have yet to find out the location of any one of them...
The Veil Guy 8)
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 04:09 PM
marlinspike,
That's the annoying thing: when it does alert, its always one or two bars and then for one or two cycles and then nothing.
I wish there were a way to filter this stuff out because, I swear, it feels just like X-band used to be prior to the "l" or "L" filtering modes.
I wouldn't be making such a big issue with it except for two things:
1) The Ku alerts are indentical in sound to K - not a good thing, in my opinion
2) Ku may be coming to the US in the very near future - meaning this problem will only increase unless addressed by the mfr.
At any rate, I am pleased to confirm that this problem wasn't related to the POP circuitry. I think that would have been a bigger pain as the V1 doesn't specifically alert in a unique fashion to POP - so how would you know what you heard?
It is also murky because I have found no real reference to Ku capability and its alert nature in the most recent manual dated 2004 and only got wind of it through another post on a forum thread. Additionally its Ku alert is identical to my v1.7's.
I hope VR can either change the tone to X-like (since X may be on the way out) and give us the ability to filter out these weak signals.
Does anyone know if Ku is operating on door openers and motion sensors and the like?
The Veil Guy
happya$$
03-06-2005, 04:14 PM
They can change the tone to sound like a double x band beep kind of like Ka. On the V1 Ka alert is a double K band alert, brap brap= Ka, brap = K band Beep = X band, Beep Beep should equal Ku band
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 04:16 PM
I like that idea very much!
Good one, Steve.
The Veil Guy 8)
marlinspike
03-06-2005, 04:26 PM
I wish there were a way to filter this stuff out because, I swear, it feels just like X-band used to be prior to the "l" or "L" filtering modes.
Well I'm glad I wasn't using l or L on the highway today. One unmarked cop was parked in the median perpendicular to the road, shooting instant on X band through heavily tinted glass. I didn't get any warning at all until about 400 feet away, and at 50 feet away he hit me directly and I still only got 2 bars.
Richard
Veil Guy
03-06-2005, 04:31 PM
Where were you?
The Veil Guy 8)
marlinspike
03-06-2005, 04:54 PM
I can't remember exactly. Somewhere on the I-85 in NC that has a green sign instead of red and blue (I think it's the business I-85 or something). They had the normal I-85 closed today over the distance that the business I-85 exists.
Richard
marlinspike
03-06-2005, 04:59 PM
Oh, and somewhere between exit 68 and 55 on the regular I-85 (I am 99% certain it was exit 63), at the top of the on ramp there was a cop shooting always on K band but I never got more than 1 bar from him. In NC they seem to love turning the radar strength way down and not hiting you until you within like 200 feet, sometimes as short as like 30 feet. I know my detector isn't faulty since when I pulled off at my college's exit, and the town cops had their usual back to school instant-on K band trap set up I had about 1/2 mile warning, and when it was my turn I got 9 bars. I made 3 more passes back and forth trying to see if the angle (up and down) the detector is at makes a difference and I don't think it does. Which is good since now I won't always fiddle with it to get it perfectly level. It seems like the only thing that does matter is the angle side to side (i.e. is it pointing straight ahead), and even that you have a good 25 degrees in each direction before it makes any difference.
Richard
My rd dealer thinks KU in the EU is over due to 4 out of the 5 ku radar makers have gone out of business.think its called gausto 13.450 ghz speed camera are still getting made.So if that is the case the US may be getting them! (good luck) .....there maybe some other band to play with great lucky you! 8)
Veil Guy
03-07-2005, 12:34 AM
ghz1,
what country are you located? are you across the pond?
the veil guy 8)
New Zealand i deal with Radardirect .....well not that direct V1= $1200 NZD
Veil Guy
03-07-2005, 08:17 AM
kiwiland!
i have heard that the [roaming] sheep can pretty tough on the [back] roads that are many.
is this true or was some one bs'ing me?
the little i know about graeme is that he is a good guy. he happend also be the first international dealer that picked up veil. i appreciated his "leap of faith!"
btw, why are v1 (and like stuff) soo expensive in nz? is it the exchange rate or just the fact that it is harder to get things into the country or a combination?
the veil guy 8)
thinks it was the rate to start with was 1 NZD = about 50 cents US but now 1 NZD = 80 cents or so. but still the same price???????????? :cry:
3.8 million people 50 million sheep (good looking ones too!!) We are in detector heaven here no x,ku a very very small amount of k and a 'sheep load of Ka" more laser by the day im sure you can help.Long long roads few people dum cops its great!!!!!..... things are easy to get here its just plan old greed i can get rds more cheaper ebay,trade etc etc but rd direct will stand by them with a warrenty so i dont mind to paye the extra :( and yes i will go and check out veil when i get a chance but im sure the price sky high , will let you know by pm regards