PDA

View Full Version : Early Adopters; BEL STi Driver



RapidTransitSystem
12-18-2005, 04:32 PM
So who here purchased the BEL as soon as it came out? Please post your opinions/reviews ASAP. Also who intends to buy the unit in short time?

Andrew G.

RapidTransitSystem
12-18-2005, 04:46 PM
I was actually thinking about making the jump myself. I was displeased with my X50; POP falses, reports of the Self-Cal and service required; made me a bit uneasy with my $300-something dollar purchase. So I question why I would want another BEL product, but I formerly owned an 8500 NON-X50 and that unit impressed the hell out of me. Seems to me that both BEL and V1 have had their share of problems since introducing POP.

The other thing you need to think about in regards to BEL is that if they took better care of their customers they would be more like an APPLE that puts out a new IPOD every 6 months or so. Minus the false (perceived by some) advertising about upgradeablity. Apple has never done anything like that imo. But if BEL had top notch service and reliability I don't think people would be making such a stink about them not being upgradeable.

In all honesty V1 seems to be more like Apple with in regards to customer service, maybe better than apple, because I dont know too many apples that are upgraded that often by the factory. Its most often a brand new unit, not an upgraded one. There are many dynamics to this argument, but I think you get the idea.

So I think I've narrowed it down to the V1 and the BEL STi Driver. I would like to buy from Roy, but if the unit doesnt live up to expectations I wouldn't want to return to Roy. So maybe I'll buy from BEL. Or maybe I'll get the V1.

Oh well I got off my own topic for a bit. So whos making the jump, I'm thinking about getting on the boat myself.

SmaartAasSaabr
12-18-2005, 05:03 PM
V1 is a lot like Apple. Expensive and the owners are very brand loyal.

But Apples suck

tjbender
12-18-2005, 05:08 PM
Spectre invisibility means nothing to me, as RDs are legal everywhere I might even remotely need to drive through. Therefore, if I upgrade anytime soon, it'll be to the V1--but I'm probably not upgrading unless/until Ku hits the streets, and I don't see that happening ever in America.

RapidTransitSystem
12-18-2005, 05:09 PM
Its clear to me that you think Apples suck.

Ok well since noone bothered to repond to my query in another post I guess I will post it here about the STi, before I shell out 450 I would like some answers, I guess im jumping the gun a bit since noone has the unit yet; at least to my knowledge.
-------------------------------------

Ok can you guys see any weaknesses in this new setup. I am hopeful that there will be no one real achilles heel. I would like better sensitivity from belscort, as well as better filtering. I want to be alerted to real POP 10/10ths of the time too.

I dont think the Multinovas are a real problem in the states yet, unless they start using them on the freeways, and the ACLU is all over camera ticketing methods, their claim is that its a violation of privacy rights, and RI recently was forced to do away with a their new speed enforcement vans equipped with cameras and a speed sign for ticketing purposes.

So my questions on this new unit boil down to this:
1. Quality of laser performance and scrutiny/filtering? Hopefully Blistering!
2. Quality of POP filtering and reception?
3. Ability to detect quick very short bursts of radar and laser for POP and Stealth mode, this is a software issue to me, so hopefully the STi has taken care of both of these concerns.

SmaartAasSaabr
12-18-2005, 05:25 PM
Personally I am considering the STI once I hear some solid reviews coming out.

spankyaf
12-18-2005, 05:35 PM
I'm participating in the pre buy cuz I'm not sure my RX65 is up to snuff and I'm tired of watching out for the Spectre man.

I dont have the angst some folks have with Bel just dont have the history with RDs so I'm fairly confident its going to perform as advertised. The Bel statements are pretty unequivocal.

Hessen
12-18-2005, 06:48 PM
I will admit that I am considering buying an STI.
But a few things are holding me back.

1) I want to see some HONEST tests that this things works as claimed.
2) If it is UNDECTECTABLE is it a permanent fix, or will the Spectre simply be modified to detect it
"a la" PNI and Cobra.
3) My experiences with Bel and their LOUSY customer service.
4) Arranging to "Smuggle" it into Canada.

Honestly I wish Mike Valentine would off his Fat Rich A$$ and Stealth the V1.....
I'd rather give him my $ than Bel.

yaks1974
12-18-2005, 07:28 PM
the horn13 wrote:-Honestly I wish Mike Valentine would off his Fat Rich A$$ and Stealth the V1.....
I'd rather give him my $ than Bel.


Don't hold your breath!
Unless there are more RD bans in the US I doubt Valentine will do anything or spend any of his precious money to develop a unit with no LO leakage. He is only interested in the US market, he refuses to ship anywhere else!

spankyaf
12-18-2005, 08:24 PM
the horn13 wrote:-Honestly I wish Mike Valentine would off his Fat Rich A$$ and Stealth the V1.....
I'd rather give him my $ than Bel.


Don't hold your breath!
Unless there are more RD bans in the US I doubt Valentine will do anything or spend any of his precious money to develop a unit with no LO leakage. He is only interested in the US market, he refuses to ship anywhere else!

That point has been raised here but many feel Mike V wont tolerate being 2nd best to the STI if its senstivity surpasses V1

Holla
12-18-2005, 11:24 PM
Oh you can bet if the new Bel surpasses his V-1 in radar test--he will go ballistic and churn up some new software/hardware to put him #1 again.

I highly even doubt he is sitting back Waiting either--In sure he has been working on improvements for months......

crazyVOLVOrob
12-19-2005, 12:17 AM
the horn13 wrote:-Honestly I wish Mike Valentine would off his Fat Rich A$$ and Stealth the V1.....
I'd rather give him my $ than Bel.


Don't hold your breath!
Unless there are more RD bans in the US I doubt Valentine will do anything or spend any of his precious money to develop a unit with no LO leakage. He is only interested in the US market, he refuses to ship anywhere else!

That point has been raised here but many feel Mike V wont tolerate being 2nd best to the STI if its senstivity surpasses V1So he'll just make his detector more sensitive to radar....he needs to make a spectre immune detector though

stalker
12-19-2005, 12:23 AM
Personally I am considering the STI once I hear some solid reviews coming out.

ME TOO.... if i get one i am going to get Roy to open it up for me and test the exact unit against his spectre 3 before he sends it to me, only way to be sure ;)

I want to see some HONEST tests and not a SML test as they are ball lickers!!

Cheers

RapidTransitSystem
12-19-2005, 12:34 AM
I don't see how one can trust that test, because my interpretation was that BEL paid for SML to test their unit???

stalker
12-19-2005, 12:38 AM
exactly, thats why i said i want to see another test apart from SML...NO ONE SHOULD TRUST THEM.

jimbonzzz
12-19-2005, 12:54 AM
Not only was it a paid test, but also the unit tested was provided by the manufacturer.

stalker
12-19-2005, 01:37 AM
why do these idiots do this...do they think everyone will never find out?? SML become less credable with every test... I hope they are reading this too!!

RapidTransitSystem
12-19-2005, 02:23 AM
In their defense it does say at the top that the client is BEL at the top and "Beltronics, Inc. contracted with SML to determine the detectablity of their new STi Driver radar detector."

But why would an impartial authority take money from a radar detector company? That doesn't do much for credibility. So much for "The Impartial Field Testing Authority." Impartial authorities don't take money from clients, they take money from consumers who want to ensure theyre making the best possible purchase with the best possible information. Now will SML's independant test be skewed when they test the unit independantly? If the unit tests poorly that could be an account they will no longer receive (BEL).

carlito
12-19-2005, 09:26 AM
why do these idiots do this...do they think everyone will never find out?? SML become less credable with every test... I hope they are reading this too!! HELLO i am pretty sure that SML folks read this board most of the times!

nvr2fast
12-19-2005, 09:40 AM
But why would an impartial authority take money from a radar detector company? That doesn't do much for credibility. So much for "The Impartial Field Testing Authority." Impartial authorities don't take money from clients, they take money from consumers who want to ensure theyre making the best possible purchase with the best possible information. Now will SML's independant test be skewed when they test the unit independantly? If the unit tests poorly that could be an account they will no longer receive (BEL).

Not really... you are looking at it from only 1 side.

Lets assume (initially) that Carl Fors has indeed got the qualifications and knowledge he says he has (ie. he is certified, etc.) and he is not bogus.

Now, if a company such as Bel wants to show others that their products actually work, then a company would contact SML to do a test. But KEEP IN MIND that the company does NOT need to release the results of the test yet. In fact, for all you know, Bel has already had Carl Fors/SML do MULTIPLE tests over a period of a month, 2 months, or more, and each time improving the product, UNTIL finally they release the final results now. In fact, SML has, in the past, rated products POORLY.

SML will NOT release the results without the permission of the manufacturer, so really they are under no pressure to ABSOLUTELY rate the product as "good". So it is up to the manufacturer if they want to release the results or not. If the product shows medium good to good, then they probably will, if the product rates badly, then the manufacturer will probably just keep the results quiet and improve it before going back to SML for a re-test to see if their improvements really did help.

So I do beleive SML is trying to keep the results legit. It is not all transparent... like I said, it is possible this is the 3rd Bel STI Driver XR that Bel have given SML to test, and only this final version passed muster. But who cares? As long as this final product works.

Hessen
12-19-2005, 09:43 AM
The only test I'm waiting for is Roy's........So Roy how about it...... :wink:

You want to sell one of these puppies to me or not...... :lol:

carlito
12-19-2005, 10:17 AM
Sml leaft THE TESTING TO THE PROS GOL THAT IS :wink:

spankyaf
12-19-2005, 10:21 AM
How difficult is it to test Spectre invisibility? Turn on units ... Yes / No

Holla
12-19-2005, 01:05 PM
How difficult is it to test Spectre invisibility? Turn on units ... Yes / No

Thats what Im thinking....what a couple of minutes :shock:

Im thinking peeps want to know how the detector detects radar against the top 3 now--to see if it can dethrone the V-1 8)

spankyaf
12-19-2005, 01:56 PM
How difficult is it to test Spectre invisibility? Turn on units ... Yes / No

Thats what Im thinking....what a couple of minutes :shock:

Im thinking peeps want to know how the detector detects radar against the top 3 now--to see if it can dethrone the V-1 8)

There's going to be months of entertaining posts over that one

SmaartAasSaabr
12-19-2005, 02:04 PM
Ideally you'd have to test them next to one another (ie inside 1 car), then in 2 cars, moving around to see if there is any alert. Then you need to take it in a lab and scan around to see anything that might be detectable.

Holla
12-19-2005, 02:21 PM
I was sure there is alot more to it! But it seems simple and then again Im far from an expert, thats why I come here to learn :D

mplsfalls
12-19-2005, 05:43 PM
I always want to see a couple of reviews. I bought my last based on multiple reviews and I am glad that I did. Has consumer reports ever done a test on radar detectors?

stealthJamal
12-19-2005, 11:45 PM
I'd like to see Craig Peterson test the STI also. He seems to be mostly honest and unbiased unless he's testing a V1. :lol:

jimbonzzz
12-20-2005, 01:24 AM
I'd like to see Craig Peterson test the STI also. He seems to be mostly honest and unbiased unless he's testing a V1. :lol:

Results:
STI is invisible, and the V1 still sucks. :lol: :lol:
Hmmm, I wonder if he has a Spectre... :wink:

GTO_04
12-20-2005, 10:00 AM
I always want to see a couple of reviews. I bought my last based on multiple reviews and I am glad that I did. Has consumer reports ever done a test on radar detectors?


Consumer Reports will never do a test on radar detectors! They are not politically correct! If they ever did, they would probably rate the Crapra the best since it's the cheapest.


GTO_04

411
12-20-2005, 03:07 PM
Has consumer reports ever done a test on radar detectors?

I think they will never touch such a subject , for them rd are evil's tool only used by speedy maniac . For this organisation speed is only related to Unsafety . They will never think that rd are tools for avoiding obsessive fixation over enforcing legal speed limits which are based upon greedy tax collection.

Spectre versus Laser :

As for acquiring a Sti , the more I think = my monies would be more profitable in buying a top j**m . The threat is far greater being lasered then being specterised : some care and a handy kill switch do a lot for invisibility .

I would buy gladly a rdd immune rd , but still a AL6/m20/other is a better investment.

RapidTransitSystem
12-21-2005, 12:13 AM
I hope this unit isnt as susceptible to the quick trigger as the other bel units.

crazyVOLVOrob
12-21-2005, 12:36 AM
I hope this unit isnt as susceptible to the quick trigger as the other bel units.Don't fear quicktiggering hardly any cops do it they are more of a fan od instant-on so they can get a speed lock on the car

Australia
12-21-2005, 03:14 AM
The STI is due for release in OZ on Friday the 6th of Jan 06, will it be release in the States on this same day?

stalker
12-21-2005, 06:17 AM
http://www.neltronics.com.au/radardetectors2.htm

Dec 5th....seems to get pushed back all the time...

Australia
12-21-2005, 06:21 AM
I have rang around a few dealers in WA, where the distributer is located and they have no knowledge of the new STI. I sent an email to the distributer (neltronics) and they said that it would be out from the 6th of Jan next year.

Maybe it is out and they have run out of stock I am not sure, the dealers that I have spoken to don't seem to know anything about it. Only mention that I can find of it on the web in my town is down the bottom of this page, I have not called them to ask about it yet however as I only stumbled across this tonight

http://www.prestigecom.net.au/default.asp?category=Latest+Products

We are waiting in OZ for the STI also.

Although legal in WA ATM, if the law changes and I ever get picked up with one it will be embarissing as I have three neighbours that are COPs.

stalker
12-21-2005, 06:24 AM
yeah but you will find it a crapload cheaper to buy from the USA....

Australia
12-21-2005, 06:32 AM
I am all ears for good deals that will also supply to OZ and keep the warrenty intact.

Unfortunatly many don't ship to OZ.

"Radar Roy Recommends

All RadarBusters™ Radar Detectors will work in Australia.

Most Popular
Radar Roy's most popular and highest rated models are the Escort 8500, and the Bel RX65. However, we cannot ship either of these two models overseas per their company policies!"


Also we have to pay about 10% more in import tax, and with the US to AU dollar conversion the bank always wins out.

I would need to save a few hundred to buy from the states, but I am willing to and I have done form many other items in the past, just need to take eveyting into consideration.

InfoAust
12-23-2005, 08:10 AM
I don't see how one can trust that test, because my interpretation was that BEL paid for SML to test their unit???




Bel did pay SML to do the test!

If you read the SML site they even say they were contracted to Bel.

RapidTransitSystem
01-04-2006, 05:24 AM
Any more early adopters?

radardan24
01-29-2006, 12:22 AM
forget about trying the lo leakage v1's, it will take him years and 5 revisions later to counter the sti(im assuming) with respect to spectre3 etc. arrows dont mean anything but extra big bulky feAture.
want performance, use the best and read in the forum a while. dan

Road Warrior
01-29-2006, 07:01 AM
Any more early adopters?

I gotta be really crazy to spend big bucks for a new RD when my current one, cordless S2 is sooooooooooooooooooo gooooooooooooooood :D so far it alerted me against ALL K, Ka and Laser speed traps, it has no power cord (extremely important in the area where I live) and it's so easy to take it down and put it back up (... and I have never used the suction cups)... in my area Spectre units are nowhere, the bigest threat is the human eye threat only... 7 months with my S2 and very, very happy so far... very good investment (US$320 with no sales tax in Montana where I bought it from) and a very smart choice, S2 being cordless :wink:

Road Warrior
01-29-2006, 07:05 AM
Consumer Reports will never do a test on radar detectors! They are not politically correct! If they ever did, they would probably rate the Crapra the best since it's the cheapest.
GTO_04

You mean they ARE politically correct :wink:

GTO_04
01-29-2006, 09:37 AM
Consumer Reports will never do a test on radar detectors! They are not politically correct! If they ever did, they would probably rate the Crapra the best since it's the cheapest.
GTO_04

You mean they ARE politically correct :wink:

Exactly!

GTO_04

lordhamster
01-29-2006, 10:59 AM
Any more early adopters?

I gotta be really crazy to spend big bucks for a new RD when my current one, cordless S2 is sooooooooooooooooooo gooooooooooooooood :D so far it alerted me against ALL K, Ka and Laser speed traps, it has no power cord (extremely important in the area where I live) and it's so easy to take it down and put it back up (... and I have never used the suction cups)... in my area Spectre units are nowhere, the bigest threat is the human eye threat only... 7 months with my S2 and very, very happy so far... very good investment (US$320 with no sales tax in Montana where I bought it from) and a very smart choice, S2 being cordless :wink:

RW, how do you mount your detector? Do you have it on the dash? If so.. how do you secure it? I want to secure my wife's detector to the dash, but so that its easy to take down.

My V1 is mounted real high and hard to see, but its also a pain to remove...

I'm not a fan of the suction cups either. I recently saw a BMW here in cleveland with a rx65 over the instrument cluster, mounted in such a way it was level with the road.. but I could not tell exactly how he did it..

Any ideas?

Road Warrior
01-29-2006, 02:55 PM
RW, how do you mount your detector? Do you have it on the dash? If so.. how do you secure it? I want to secure my wife's detector to the dash, but so that its easy to take down.

My V1 is mounted real high and hard to see, but its also a pain to remove...

I'm not a fan of the suction cups either. I recently saw a BMW here in cleveland with a rx65 over the instrument cluster, mounted in such a way it was level with the road.. but I could not tell exactly how he did it..

Any ideas?

Due to the stalinistic laws about RDs in Ontario, you realize that I cannot disclose the details of my RD... all I can tell you is that for LASER alerts the BEST is to have it mount very low, on the dash if possible, but not obstructed by anything in front, so far I got 3/3 successfull laser alerts (as mine is always on the dash, please do NOT ask me more details about the position...), also it successfully alerted me against lots of K and Ka radar units inside police cruisers BUT for sure, for conventional radar (X, K and Ka) you gain more distance by mounting it HIGH... so it's up to you to figure it out what you really want, protection against LASER: mount it LOW, or against X (this band is off in my case), K and Ka: mount it HIGH... also mine is cordless so I don't have to worry about any power cord, I'm using rechargeable batteries... hope this one helps a little :wink: and besides the culture war (fought ONLY in the Back Alley) you see that we can easily have a very practical and very constructive discution helping each other as much as we humanly can 8)

lordhamster
01-29-2006, 02:58 PM
RW, how do you mount your detector? Do you have it on the dash? If so.. how do you secure it? I want to secure my wife's detector to the dash, but so that its easy to take down.

My V1 is mounted real high and hard to see, but its also a pain to remove...

I'm not a fan of the suction cups either. I recently saw a BMW here in cleveland with a rx65 over the instrument cluster, mounted in such a way it was level with the road.. but I could not tell exactly how he did it..

Any ideas?

Due to the stalinistic laws about RDs in Ontario, you realize that I cannot disclose the details of my RD... all I can tell you is that for LASER alerts the BEST is to have it mount very low, on the dash if possible, but not obstructed by anything in front, so far I got 3/3 successfull laser alerts (as mine is always on the dash, please do NOT ask me more details about the position...), also it successfully alerted me against lots of K and Ka radar units inside police cruisers BUT for sure, for conventional radar (X, K and Ka) you gain more distance by mounting it HIGH... so it's up to you to figure it out what you really want, protection against LASER: mount it LOW, or against X (this band is off in my case), K and Ka: mount it HIGH... also mine is cordless so I don't have to worry about any power cord, I'm using rechargeable batteries... hope this one helps a little :wink: and besides the culture war (fought ONLY in the Back Alley) you see that we can easily have a very practical and very constructive discution helping each other as much as we humanly can 8)

Out of curiosity, how long do the rechargeables last in your solo?

Do you use nimh batteries? Does the detector have any problem with alerting to low chagre prematurely?

Road Warrior
01-29-2006, 03:23 PM
Out of curiosity, how long do the rechargeables last in your solo?

Do you use nimh batteries? Does the detector have any problem with alerting to low chagre prematurely?

Continuously, about 6 hrs, that's why always have two spare ones, fully charged, in my pocket...
I'm using RAYOVAC Rechargeable NIMH... and about your last question, I think my S2 has a defect, it does NOT alert me when the batteries are low and if I don't change them on my own it turns off without any warning... so, this is a DEFECT and not how S2 is realy built... but because I know when to change them, I never have a problem with this issue :wink:

FLYBOY!!!!!
01-29-2006, 07:32 PM
[quote="Australia"]Also we have to pay about 10% more in import tax, and with the US to AU dollar conversion the bank always wins out.quote]

If the item you are having sent to AU is under $900 AU, then no GST, import taxes or duties are payable (excluding some items).
So it really does pay to get some things sent here from other countries. :D :D :D

Retailers are starting to realise that we, the customers, are waking up to the blatant rip-offs that they are throwing at us and the option of buying on the internet is becoming more and more attractive.

I would prefer to support our local businesses but if they think that I am going to stand for being ripped off by them they need to learn a lot more about customer satisfaction. :roll: :roll: :roll:

FLYBOY!!!!!
01-29-2006, 07:33 PM
[quote="Australia"]Also we have to pay about 10% more in import tax, and with the US to AU dollar conversion the bank always wins out.quote]

If the item you are having sent to AU is under $900 AU, then no GST, import taxes or duties are payable (excluding some items).
So it really does pay to get some things sent here from other countries. :D :D :D

Retailers are starting to realise that we, the customers, are waking up to the blatant rip-offs that they are throwing at us and the option of buying on the internet is becoming more and more attractive.

I would prefer to support our local businesses but if they think that I am going to stand for being ripped off by them they need to learn a lot more about customer satisfaction. :roll: :roll: :roll:

nvr2fast
01-29-2006, 07:42 PM
I know what you mean about Aussie business. When I was studying there, I went to places like Dic|< Smith and other electronic stores, and since I live in Hong Kong I know exactly how much this stuff costs to make in China and how much they distribute for.

I was amazed by the markups the Aussie places put on stuff. Now I only know about the electronics so I dont know if they're ripping people on the food, milk, etc. but its amazing.

And another thing I dont understand about Aussie... you'd finish uni/work/whatver at about 5-6pm... and by the time you get to the shopping mall, all the shops are closed! Whats up with that?! Yeah I know you got the special "late night thursdays" or whatever it was called, but in HK the retail shops are usually open till like 10pm at night, but they only open at noon or similar. This makes a he|| of a lot more sense to me.

You'd be surprised how cheap a clone of V1/Bel/etc. can be made in China... the Quality Control might not be as tight, but if the detector was made at 1/5 the price, would you still care? You could buy 2 and have one as a spare!

stalker
01-30-2006, 12:40 AM
all jy gun stuff I import from USA as it is about 1/3 the price...sooo much cheaper.

Even when I was in Seattle last year I bought 2 Burton Snowboards still cheaper than one would cost here, even after the conversion...