PDA

View Full Version : Shifting before a turn.



supercowpowers
11-22-2010, 08:01 AM
So I had to drive my fiance's mother's 2nd gen CR-V yesterday. It's a manual, believe it or not. As I adjusted everything and tested out the controls I realized I was in trouble - to touch the gas while my foot was on the brake would have required a strange contortion involving nearly lifting my ass out of the seat. My first manual car is my Miata I've had for 3 years. I figured out how to heel-toe within about a week of buying it and I haven't done anything different since then, so I never learned any other way.

I decided that my plan would be to brake a little early and try to downshift before starting a turn. That worked, in that I was drive it, but it completely threw off my sense of timing so I either went into turns too fast or too slow, and sometimes I still ended up shifting as I was starting a turn. That didn't cause any problems at reasonable speeds but I know that's a bad habit.

So my question is: what is the "proper" method? Surely these European countries I've heard about where you have to take your test on a manual have this figured out. My fiance's family all drive manuals, and from observing them I see that they either just lug the engine through the turn and shift afterward, shift during the turn, or just don't bother rev-matching at all.

ivirovets
11-22-2010, 08:53 AM
Clutch in before the turn, shift into gear you need, scrub speed before the turn, then in the turn revmatch and off the clutch softly to gas through the turn? That's what I'd do. No need to heeltoe if you're just driving normally not trying to maintain the highest speed possible through the turn, but this is not an expert opinion by far. I don't drive stick too regularly.

supercowpowers
11-22-2010, 08:59 AM
Clutch in before the turn, shift into gear you need, scrub speed before the turn, then in the turn revmatch and off the clutch softly to gas through the turn? That's what I'd do. No need to heeltoe if you're just driving normally not trying to maintain the highest speed possible through the turn, but this is not an expert opinion by far. I don't drive stick too regularly.

You're right, it works if you're not trying to maintain the highest possible speed. That's my fiance's brother's method.

The issue with it is that you might not realize you're at the highest possible speed for the traction you have if the road is wet, icy, or you just didn't realize the turn was as sharp as it is. Any mistake in rev-matching during a turn will put an extra load on the tires, which could overwhelm them and cause problems.

ivirovets
11-22-2010, 09:03 AM
That's a good point, didn't think about that. Not driving manual regularly I forgot all about the jerk that comes with bad rev matching and the fact that it could cause a loss of traction. Maybe letting off the clutch very slowly would ease some of that? Bad for wear I know but safety..

AirMoore
11-22-2010, 09:34 AM
They really need to make people take their road-test in manual cars (as I did)...

THEN make mandatory motorcycle safety courses (even if they don't intend to get a license)... these questions would answer themselves.

supercowpowers
11-22-2010, 09:55 AM
They really need to make people take their road-test in manual cars (as I did)...

THEN make mandatory motorcycle safety courses (even if they don't intend to get a license)... these questions would answer themselves.

Right. That's basically what I'm asking, what they teach people to do in places where it's a requirement.

I've managed with my current car for 3 years because I can heel-toe in it. I'm just wondering what you're supposed to do if you're faced with a car that has a pedal arrangement that doesn't support that. I can't think of any good options.

ivirovets
11-22-2010, 11:01 AM
AirMoore- I took a motorcycle course and I have a license, They never taught proper shifting on corners in slippery conditions. The class was a joke.

Obsidian
11-22-2010, 11:04 AM
You should finish your braking and shifting before the turn, control your car with the throttle and accelerate after the apex ... that's the fastest way through the turn. Downshifting or braking in a turn is a good way to spin.

switch626
11-22-2010, 11:15 AM
It will be easier if you get in the habit of using the gas or brake separately (never at the same time). Minor speed adjustments are made with the gas pedal. Once you get comfortable with that things will be much smoother.

The proceess:

1. Push in the clutch and brake as you approach the turn until you reach the speed you want to hold in the turn.
2. Shift into the appropriate gear and release the clutch. You might choose a lower gear and rev a little, which allows you to dump more speed by easing up on the gas (if needed)
3. If in a lower gear, you're set to accelerate out of the turn. If you couldn't do the lower gear, you will have to GENTLY down shift and accelerate out of the turn.

Whether you go with the lower gear depends on the turn, chosen speed, and the gearing of the car. The best advice is to be conservative with your speed when driving a car you don't know intimately well. Go slow in turns until gear selection is second nature.

supercowpowers
11-22-2010, 11:17 AM
You should finish your braking and shifting before the turn, control your car with the throttle and accelerate after the apex ... that's the fastest way through the turn.
Right, which is why I heel-toe in my personal car. There has to be an "official, nanny-state approved" method of only using two pedals at once, because not all cars (or drivers) are built for heel-toe.

Downshifting or braking in a turn is a good way to spin.Right, which is what I meant by "cause problems" when I said "Any mistake in rev-matching during a turn will put an extra load on the tires, which could overwhelm them and cause problems," I just didn't feel like elaborating.

If you can't shift in a turn, that just leaves before it or after it. I've seen that before it doesn't work very well, so I'm guessing that you're supposed to just coast through the turn in a high gear with no throttle and shift once it's obvious you'll make it. I know that's much less fun, but this whole question was provoked by a vehicle that isn't necessarily fun anyway.

Obsidian
11-22-2010, 05:48 PM
If the pedals make it difficult, you don't need to heel-toe to rev match. You can blip the throttle, clutch and shift without heel-toe, just be quick about it. Or you can buy a 370Z with sport package and it will rev match for you :)

Freebird
11-22-2010, 06:30 PM
If the pedals make it difficult, you don't need to heel-toe to rev match. You can blip the throttle, clutch and shift without heel-toe, just be quick about it. Or you can buy a 370Z with sport package and it will rev match for you :)

True, I use this method. I brake, clutch,blip,shift, and turn in to apex, then throttle out from the apex. Takes some practice to get it right but after years of doing it this way it is second nature.

AirMoore
11-22-2010, 06:32 PM
AirMoore- I took a motorcycle course and I have a license, They never taught proper shifting on corners in slippery conditions. The class was a joke.
100%, 100%
(Getting % signs used up so they show up correctly in forum)

There are different kinds... I guess should have specified something more a long the lines of an ART motorcycle class where they teach you this at nausea.


Essentially as Obisidian says: All shifting and braking should be done before a corner... leaving 100% of the traction via the contact patch left to: (no shock here) - turn. If you try downshifting, braking etc (anything besides keeping a steady throttle)... you are going to use less than 100% of your traction allotted for the turn to brake. If you have the ability to brake mid-corner and not cause the tires to come unlocked from the pavement, you would have made it via just turning anyways.


-ART classes will teach you this sort of thing at length.

It is important to note that certain things like trail-braking (motorcycles), e-braking... especially well under throttle (cars)> drifting/rallying can come into play, but in general... when turning give 100% of your contact patch dedicated to turning. If you can brake or downshift mid-corner, it is likely that you never would have had an accident/issue anyways.

ivirovets
11-22-2010, 06:46 PM
That makes a lot of sense. Clear explanation, thanks.

category4
11-22-2010, 07:15 PM
Left paddle down-shift, right paddle up-shift,left foot brake, right foot accelerator, problem solved.

NormSky
11-22-2010, 07:43 PM
Don't try braking and accelerating in the middle of a turn. Most cars today after Toyota have throttle shut offs and could send you in a loop.

When someone says throttle mid-turn, think throttle maintence.

AirMoore
11-22-2010, 08:48 PM
Left paddle down-shift, right paddle up-shift,left foot brake, right foot accelerator, problem solved.

(Manual) Clutches+sticks beat paddles for control every-time though, paddles have the speed and precision which cannot be afforded with (manual) clutches. Its a trade off IMHO, and neither solves the problem.

For example I live where we actually get harsh winter weather (Ice covered by a foot of snow, with freezing rain on-top of that) and all my friends with paddle-shifters wish they had a pedal-clutch and stick... but on the track in beautiful weather... they love it.

KaPro
11-24-2010, 07:27 AM
You should finish your braking and shifting before the turn, control your car with the throttle and accelerate after the apex ... that's the fastest way through the turn. Downshifting or braking in a turn is a good way to spin.
Exactly.

category4
11-25-2010, 01:21 AM
Left paddle down-shift, right paddle up-shift,left foot brake, right foot accelerator, problem solved.

(Manual) Clutches+sticks beat paddles for control every-time though, paddles have the speed and precision which cannot be afforded with (manual) clutches. Its a trade off IMHO, and neither solves the problem.

For example I live where we actually get harsh winter weather (Ice covered by a foot of snow, with freezing rain on-top of that) and all my friends with paddle-shifters wish they had a pedal-clutch and stick... but on the track in beautiful weather... they love it.

On ice everything sucks!!! The only thing different I see is having to press on the clutch, which I don't miss. I would rather have the paddles, your hands never leave the wheel and that's where they need to be.

Guess it's personal preference, whatever makes you comfortable behind the wheel is best for you.

Paperlantern
11-27-2010, 08:19 PM
Heel-Toe should NOT be something you are doing in day to day driving. Its for maximum performance through turns. Driving a passenger vehicle on regular roads should NEVER require this, and if you cannot do it without using it, you're doing it wrong.

1 foot = 1 pedal. Always. Ive never felt the need to heel-toe in a passenger vehicle on regular roads, the thought of it is preposterous to me. I didn't think ANYONE would have a reason to do it, this is the first I've EVER heard of anyone NEEDING to drive with this technique under normal circumstances. Wild.

NormSky
11-27-2010, 08:47 PM
Practice daily in the dry, that way when it's wet or snowy it becomes second nature. Best place to practice is on side streets near your house. Lower speed practicing will make it easier to recover if your foot slips off the brake pedal. :)

Z1NONLY
11-27-2010, 09:08 PM
On the street, I just remove my foot from the gas pedal (coast) Push the clutch with my left foot, shift to the gear I want to take the corner in with my right hand, and, while still holding the clutch with my left foot, I use my right foot to raise the revs for the gear I'm about to engage. Then let off the clutch, and once the transition to the lower gear is complete, remove my foot from the gas pedal and over to the brake to supplement the moderate engine braking now taking place.

It's basically heel toe-ing without the toe part. (simple rev-matching) When I approach a corner during street driving, I usually allow myself enough time so that I don't have to combine braking and shifting in the same moment.

supercowpowers
11-27-2010, 10:53 PM
I feel like I failed to communicate or let this thread get off track or something. I know you're not supposed to shift in a turn. I know how and why to rev match. If heel-toe is not an option for some reason, the only other methods I can see are to shift before braking, shift before turning, or shift after turning. I'm just wondering which method is best/least risky/smoothest/the one "they" say you should use...


Heel-Toe should NOT be something you are doing in day to day driving. Its for maximum performance through turns. Driving a passenger vehicle on regular roads should NEVER require this, and if you cannot do it without using it, you're doing it wrong.

1 foot = 1 pedal. Always. Ive never felt the need to heel-toe in a passenger vehicle on regular roads, the thought of it is preposterous to me. I didn't think ANYONE would have a reason to do it, this is the first I've EVER heard of anyone NEEDING to drive with this technique under normal circumstances. Wild.

I'm approaching a corner. I gotta brake. I gotta shift. I can figure out some compromised, slow way of accomplishing these things at different times, or combine them. Mazda didn't build the car, nor did I buy it, to gingerly coast through corners after a leisurely period of light braking and unhurried shifting. I've never had my foot slip from the brake, I always have my foot on the brake up until the corner entry, and I'm always in the proper gear to have the most control and easiest exit from the corner. Is it really such a terrible thing if it's something I'm good at and it makes my driving smoother and more pleasurable? It's never caused an accident or even a close call, and I'm sure the people behind me appreciate my efficient manner of turning and getting out of their way.


On the street, I just remove my foot from the gas pedal (coast) Push the clutch with my left foot, shift to the gear I want to take the corner in with my right hand, and, while still holding the clutch with my left foot, I use my right foot to raise the revs for the gear I'm about to engage. Then let off the clutch, and once the transition to the lower gear is complete, remove my foot from the gas pedal and over to the brake to supplement the moderate engine braking now taking place.


So you just shift, then brake? (I just assume rev-matching, it's not a proper shift without it) I can see how that would work, unless you need to do something like go from fifth to second to turn from a fast road to a driveway.

Paperlantern
11-28-2010, 08:50 AM
Why cant you brake and shift at the same time? Why do you have to brake THEN shift?

Shift WHILE you are braking and you don't need the engine or transmission for anything anyway, then move foot from brake to gas with clutch still in, revmatch and accelerate out of the turn.

supercowpowers
11-28-2010, 09:24 AM
Why cant you brake and shift at the same time? Why do you have to brake THEN shift?

Shift WHILE you are braking and you don't need the engine or transmission for anything anyway, then move foot from brake to gas with clutch still in, revmatch and accelerate out of the turn.

That counts as "shifting before turning," which, as I explained in my original post, is what I first had the idea to try and wasn't very good at because I'm used to being able to make fine adjustments to my speed the whole way up to the corner. However, my current technique required some practice before I was good at it, so I suppose any other would as well.

What you explained is what I already do when I'm not in a hurry, like for just having to slow down for traffic.

Z1NONLY
11-28-2010, 12:27 PM
On the street, I just remove my foot from the gas pedal (coast) Push the clutch with my left foot, shift to the gear I want to take the corner in with my right hand, and, while still holding the clutch with my left foot, I use my right foot to raise the revs for the gear I'm about to engage. Then let off the clutch, and once the transition to the lower gear is complete, remove my foot from the gas pedal and over to the brake to supplement the moderate engine braking now taking place.


So you just shift, then brake? (I just assume rev-matching, it's not a proper shift without it) I can see how that would work, unless you need to do something like go from fifth to second to turn from a fast road to a driveway.

I bolded the rev matching part in my post. As for 5th to 2nd shifting for a turn, the gear you are in isn't really an issue. It's The relationship between the gear you want (2nd in this case) and the road speed you approach the turn with.

If you are putting along in 5th gear at 40 mph, it will just require more rev's before engaging second. (In my car, that's approximately 4-5k rpm's) Then, after the shift is complete, letting off the gas will cause some engine braking that will work with the brakes to bring the car down to 15-ish MPH for the driveway.

If you are traveling at a speed that's outside of the range of the gear you want to take the turn in, (2nd in my car does a little over 60mph) Then you are driving in a rather spirited manner, and would probably want to do so in a vehicle other than a CR-V.

supercowpowers
11-28-2010, 09:37 PM
If you are traveling at a speed that's outside of the range of the gear you want to take the turn in, (2nd in my car does a little over 60mph) Then you are driving in a rather spirited manner, and would probably want to do so in a vehicle other than a CR-V.

lol. You addressed exactly what I was wondering with a pretty sensible solution. Second in my car goes to, I think, about 55 MPH, with the poor hamsters furiously spinning away at nearly 7,000 RPM, which is probably why I developed the heel-toe habit in it.

I suppose the real answer to my original question is that there is no "one true" method. The decision of which technique to use just depends on the situation. Sometimes it's important to slow down and get the hell off the road quick, and sometimes you have all the time in the world. Sometimes you're going too fast for the gear you want, and sometimes it's no problem. This judgment is something I'll try to develop in my personal car so I'm not lost when I have to drive something else.

ELVATO
11-28-2010, 10:50 PM
When I drive my parents' 250 PS, I just slow down, and shift mid turn then accelerate out when taking turns at lights, or clutch + brake, release brake and select gear (usually 2nd) and release clutch as I'm exiting turn (for when I turn on to streets.) Never really bother with rev matching, though.

Never tried it, but pretty sure that thing is not set up to heel-toeing.

AirMoore
11-29-2010, 09:23 AM
Left paddle down-shift, right paddle up-shift,left foot brake, right foot accelerator, problem solved.

(Manual) Clutches+sticks beat paddles for control every-time though, paddles have the speed and precision which cannot be afforded with (manual) clutches. Its a trade off IMHO, and neither solves the problem.

For example I live where we actually get harsh winter weather (Ice covered by a foot of snow, with freezing rain on-top of that) and all my friends with paddle-shifters wish they had a pedal-clutch and stick... but on the track in beautiful weather... they love it.

On ice everything sucks!!! The only thing different I see is having to press on the clutch, which I don't miss. I would rather have the paddles, your hands never leave the wheel and that's where they need to be.

Guess it's personal preference, whatever makes you comfortable behind the wheel is best for you.

To be fair I haven't driven paddles too much in the horrible weather, only the usual "winter weather" here... but I like clutches more, just for the fact that you can control the transition from the power-train to the ground, whereas with paddles you cannot... for me that is huge plus in the worst of the worst winter weather... far superior for control.

Paperlantern
11-29-2010, 10:13 AM
When I drive my parents' 250 PS, I just slow down, and shift mid turn then accelerate out when taking turns at lights, or clutch + brake, release brake and select gear (usually 2nd) and release clutch as I'm exiting turn (for when I turn on to streets.) Never really bother with rev matching, though.

Never tried it, but pretty sure that thing is not set up to heel-toeing.

NOT rev matching isn't necessarily wrong, but it does wear out the clutch faster. That's all.

dkaparis
11-29-2010, 06:12 PM
Why cant you brake and shift at the same time? Why do you have to brake THEN shift?

Shift WHILE you are braking and you don't need the engine or transmission for anything anyway, then move foot from brake to gas with clutch still in, revmatch and accelerate out of the turn.

While the clutch is depressed, the engine is not there to force the driving wheels to spin, thus if you break at the same time, on a slippery road you can easily lock the wheels.