-
Redline problem again?
-
Re: Redline problem again
-
Re: Redline problem again
How does the unit work on other known sources?
-
Re: Redline problem again
-
Re: Redline problem again
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
What frequency?
24.056
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
OpenRoad
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
What frequency?
24.056
Exellent question CJ!
And whoa........just 6MHZ inside the normal K Bandwidth (24.050 - 24.250).
I believe that's why your RedLine is cutting in and out on you OpenRoad......the frequency of that speed sign is hovering right on the fringe. The M3's frequency readout is fairly accurate but not absolute, so the gun itself could be entirely out of spec. The radars in those signs are usually old beaten up units to begin with, then they finish life doing 24 x 7 shifts in a trailer! The RedLine itself might be running a little tight on the low end but I'd give the bulk of the blame to that radar unit. After many many hours of continuous operation the gunn diodes wear out and drift way off center.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
nine_c1
Quote:
Originally Posted by
OpenRoad
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
What frequency?
24.056
Exellent question CJ!
And whoa........just 6MHZ inside the normal K Bandwidth (24.050 - 24.250).
I believe that's why your RedLine is cutting in and out on you OpenRoad......the frequency of that speed sign is hovering right on the fringe. The M3's frequency readout is fairly accurate but not absolute, so the gun itself could be entirely out of spec. The radars in those signs are usually old beaten up units to begin with, then they finish life doing 24 x 7 shifts in a trailer! The RedLine itself might be running a little tight on the low end but I'd give the bulk of the blame to that radar unit. After many many hours of continuous operation the gunn diodes wear out and drift way off center.
Exactly why i asked. Thank you. :cool:
-
Re: Redline problem again
I think this is an antenna issue with loose internal connection. Note when I'm stopped dead in front of the sign, as soon as I start to pull away it alerts - likely from the bumpy road causing it to make contact again.
Unfortunately the video scan rate makes the speed sign unreadable, but you can see it shows speed when cars go by. The video is a little long, as I spent all of 3 minutes editing it....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ks_kvkVw6Q
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
Quote:
Originally Posted by
nine_c1
Quote:
Originally Posted by
OpenRoad
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
What frequency?
24.056
Exellent question CJ!
And whoa........just 6MHZ inside the normal K Bandwidth (24.050 - 24.250).
I believe that's why your RedLine is cutting in and out on you OpenRoad......the frequency of that speed sign is hovering right on the fringe. The M3's frequency readout is fairly accurate but not absolute, so the gun itself could be entirely out of spec. The radars in those signs are usually old beaten up units to begin with, then they finish life doing 24 x 7 shifts in a trailer! The RedLine itself might be running a little tight on the low end but I'd give the bulk of the blame to that radar unit. After many many hours of continuous operation the gunn diodes wear out and drift way off center.
Exactly why i asked. Thank you. :cool:
I'll go with that for now, and do a bit more checks. Kinda scary to see a sign reading speed on cars with no alert, or a scattered one.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
OpenRoad
I think this is an antenna issue with loose internal connection. Note when I'm stopped dead in front of the sign, as soon as I start to pull away it alerts - likely from the bumpy road causing it to make contact again.
Unfortunately the video scan rate makes the speed sign unreadable, but you can see it shows speed when cars go by.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ks_kvkVw6Q
Its certainly in the realm of possibility, but being that close to the fringe of K band and the less then perfect Spc mode its just as likely that the sign is out of tune. Keep an eye on it.
-
Re: Redline problem again
I'll probably check it against some other steady source, see if it does the same.
Thanks for the info - sounds reasonable that it's "on edge". If it flakes out on some other freq closer to center of range, I'll send it back for a check. For now, I'll chock this one up to 'anomaly'.
I have another (this is getting really old) 2,000 miler coming up next week back to Bay Area.
-
Re: Redline problem again
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quality Belscort products for ya ...I learned my lesson years ago. V1 or Whistler have always been reliable.
-
Re: Redline problem again
I've seen my V1 miss fringe-edge K band encounters as well, so it's not limited to the Redline.
Sounds here like the issue is more the trailer than the Redline, but check against some other sources to make sure.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jag42
Quality Belscort products for ya ...I learned my lesson years ago. V1 or Whistler have always been reliable.
I have had a similar experience with Escort too. My RedLine is still running strong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
KaPro
How is it on Ka band?
Good point too, K & KA use the same antenna, so its likely if K is having issues due to a loose antenna KA should too.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jag42
Quality Belscort products for ya ...I learned my lesson years ago. V1 or Whistler have always been reliable.
I have had a similar experience with Escort too. My RedLine is still running strong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
KaPro
How is it on Ka band?
Good point too, K & KA use the same antenna, so its likely if K is having issues due to a loose antenna KA should too.
Hummm, now you have me scared. I noticed a couple of 'odd' Ka alerts yesterday as I was driving out near a lake - did not see a LEO around, it appeared to be a bogus alert.
I'll scrutinize it closely today as I'm on a local journey to national park.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Well, I logged another 500 miles today and Redline is working fine as usual - even racked up another bona-fide save.
I'm now 100% convinced CJ's right on this one.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
OpenRoad
Hummm, now you have me scared. I noticed a couple of 'odd' Ka alerts yesterday as I was driving out near a lake - did not see a LEO around, it appeared to be a bogus alert.
Did you note the frequency?
Perhaps a sattelite dish?
I have had some strange Ka falses with the Sti-D when in the middle of nowhere but have been near TV dishes on cabins.
Just a thought.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
OpenRoad
Well, I logged another 500 miles today and Redline is working fine as usual - even racked up another bona-fide save.
I'm now 100% convinced CJ's right on this one.
That's good, glad you figured it out. Kind of of sucks when you have doubt in your RD, but its also not good to be over confident.
To be honest i don't think you will have a problem with the antenna again.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jag42
Quality Belscort products for ya ...I learned my lesson years ago. V1 or Whistler have always been reliable.
I have had a similar experience with
Escort too. My RedLine is still running strong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
KaPro
How is it on Ka band?
You meant VR right? :) Good point too, K & KA use the same antenna, so its likely if K is having issues due to a loose antenna KA should too.
Now, the redline.The reason I asked was I had an incident where the redline did not alert to a k band speed sign near my house. The STi-D did. Further down the road is a Ka band speed sign and this time the redline did alert to ka, from 200 feet! Got sent to the hospital and it's been fine since.
-
Re: Redline problem again
This brings up another question about this speed sign.
Does the FCC control those bands? I would assume so, and if this was transmitting out-of-band, it is violating FCC regs....
-
Re: Redline problem again
Why don't cops just un-tune or de-tune their RADAR guns to make them operate out-of-band? Or buy some Ku Guns... That would screw every driver out of even more of their hard earned money.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
NETWizz
Why don't cops just un-tune or de-tune their RADAR guns to make them operate out-of-band? Or buy some Ku Guns... That would screw every driver out of even more of their hard earned money.
That crossed my mind as well.....
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
NETWizz
Why don't cops just un-tune or de-tune their RADAR guns to make them operate out-of-band? Or buy some Ku Guns... That would screw every driver out of even more of their hard earned money.
2 reasons.. (1) it's illegal, as the gun would no longer meet the part 90 requirements to be operated under their license, and (2) Gunn diodes aren't "tunable".. it's not like there's a trimmer adjustment on them. They leave the factory operating at a specific frequency, and they slowly drift as they age.
As for Ku band... (1) good luck finding a gun on that frequency, and (2) good luck getting court approval to use it. If you're going to go Ku, might as well just go to X band...
-
Re: Redline problem again
Yup, speeds signs don't give tickets so it doesn't matter. If a gun is out of tune the ticket would be thrown out.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
If a gun is out of tune the ticket would be thrown out.
Agree it should be, but the only bad part would be the burden of proof on us RD users to prove that in a courtroom the LEO's RADAR gun was out of tune IMO (our word against theirs). I highly doubt this would come up though.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Akosikojak
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
If a gun is out of tune the ticket would be thrown out.
Agree it should be, but the only bad part would be the burden of proof on us RD users to prove that in a courtroom the LEO's RADAR gun was out of tune IMO (our word against theirs). I highly doubt this would come up though.
That's why there radar guns are tuned/calibrated somewhat frequently and have certificats of proof that they were. All you need to do is request proof the radar unit used was tuned/calibrated, and when.
-
Re: Redline problem again
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Akosikojak
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CJR238
If a gun is out of tune the ticket would be thrown out.
Agree it should be, but the only bad part would be the burden of proof on us RD users to prove that in a courtroom the LEO's RADAR gun was out of tune IMO (our word against theirs). I highly doubt this would come up though.
That's why there radar guns are tuned/calibrated somewhat frequently and have certificats of proof that they were. All you need to do is request proof the radar unit used was tuned/calibrated, and when.
Good Info / Agree.
-
Re: Redline problem again?
I went by there again today, this time got a regular steady alert, and surprised to see this frequency show up (also steady and not changing as I drove past).
http://www.myroadtripplanner.com/radarstuff/k24049.jpg