I set up a Excel Weight Matrix to compare the two.
The Weight Column basically means how important that feature is.
The next two are a score of how well each detector does on scale of 1 to 10.
The next two are weighted scores.
Then the weighted scores are totaled.
Keep in mind these are my own weights.
Certainly open to opinion on the unweighted scores.
I've attched the Excel spread sheet as well inside the zip file if you want to play.
EDIT: I updated the speadsheet to make it a little clearer (New Sheet has some RED Text)