View Full Version : Flashing Headlights to warn of Radar Trap in PA
Maestro
06-19-2007, 02:47 PM
Doing some research I ran across this court case
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/opposting/supreme/out/j-255-98mo.pdf
Talks about how the police ticketed a person for flashing their high beams during the day. They were obviously warning on coming drives of a speed trap. The ticket got thrown out after taking it to the State Supreme Court. They said the law was missapplied.
But there was a desenting opinion, here it is and one of the Judges was not there so this case could have gone the other way.
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/opposting/supreme/out/j-255-98do.pdf
This is interesting, the judge felt the person should have been cited for obstructing governmental operations.
proudNMAmember
07-15-2007, 07:40 PM
Flashing your headlights to warn of an upcoming beartrap is a great thing.
dj_taranu
08-02-2007, 02:03 PM
It`s always done all over Europe, the flashing of headlights towards oncoming traffic, to alert them of a radar trap...
jwardell
08-03-2007, 09:51 AM
This is why you should flash your regular lights on and off instead. Nothing illegal with that.
Maestro
08-03-2007, 10:14 PM
This is why you should flash your regular lights on and off instead. Nothing illegal with that.
Actaully, it could be illegal I found an Ohio case where a was actually charged with obstruction and they won on a techincality, but they said that waring others of a police using radar could be obstructing people operations.
The reason the state lose in that case was they could not prove they person was actually warning others.
MEM-TEK
08-03-2007, 11:49 PM
*****
Stealthcb
08-05-2007, 10:52 PM
I turn my foglights on and off to warn people. Let's see the cop tell me THAT is unsafe.
McArcane
08-05-2007, 11:21 PM
me too. i got pulled in ohio for flashing the brights, but the leo was nice enough to let me go (it was night and he was coming the other way so i actually had flashed him) Ive never had a problem flashing the fogs but then again i dont think they are as good of a warning for other drivers and are most likely overlooked as a warning.
HwyBear
08-06-2007, 06:04 PM
I would hope that the one's flashing their lights do not do so when police have traps set up in school zones, playground or residential areas......these are target areas where speed should not be tolerated and these driver's need to be hammered, and not just warned to slow down on this particular day when radar is around.
EG(your wife and child are walking in your area, slow area, a car zooming into the area gets "flashed" slows down, goes by the radar........next day your family is again walking, same car comes through, not being flashed, doesn't slow down, and blows a tire, loses control and takes your family out?....driver might have thought about the ticket they had the day B4 in that area and be driving slower)
Highway different story!
McArcane
08-06-2007, 08:37 PM
very true, i agree..
ELVATO
08-06-2007, 09:29 PM
I would hope that the one's flashing their lights do not do so when police have traps set up in school zones, playground or residential areas......these are target areas where speed should not be tolerated and these driver's need to be hammered, and not just warned to slow down on this particular day when radar is around.
EG(your wife and child are walking in your area, slow area, a car zooming into the area gets "flashed" slows down, goes by the radar........next day your family is again walking, same car comes through, not being flashed, doesn't slow down, and blows a tire, loses control and takes your family out?....driver might have thought about the ticket they had the day B4 in that area and be driving slower)
Highway different story!
If you are going to talk about "what ifs" then you could also try:
A LEO is running radar. The same guy is flying and your family is walking. Since no one flashes him, he doesn't slow down, and, before he gets to the radaring LEO, blows out his tire and takes out your family because no one reminded him to slow down.
But yes, I understand what you are saying ;) Just giving an example :)
HwyBear
08-07-2007, 07:44 AM
But yes, I understand what you are saying ;) Just giving an example :)
Good One ! :D
gimlethillgene
02-27-2008, 03:30 AM
I've heard that flashing lights to warn of speed traps is illegal in PA.
If the intent was public safety than warning approaching drivers to slow down would help to control speed of vehicles.
Seems like the powers that be are more interested in getting more money than public safety.
Gene
lugnuts
02-27-2008, 06:22 PM
If the intent was public safety than warning approaching drivers to slow down would help to control speed of vehicles.
you would think
Seems like the powers that be are more interested in getting more money than public safety.
Gene
yes it does.
Maestro
02-27-2008, 11:42 PM
I've heard that flashing lights to warn of speed traps is illegal in PA.
If the intent was public safety than warning approaching drivers to slow down would help to control speed of vehicles.
Seems like the powers that be are more interested in getting more money than public safety.
Gene
if you read the case it is not illegal, actually PA allows you to flash your light to signal to someone to move over so you can pass them. People believe this is actual illegal when it is not. it just upsets the person who is getting flashed so they assume it is not allowed, I'll have to see if I can find the rules of the road for this one.
Maestro
05-07-2008, 09:24 AM
This is why you should flash your regular lights on and off instead. Nothing illegal with that.
Actaully, it could be illegal I found an Ohio case where a person was actually charged with obstruction and they won on a technicality, but they said that warning others of a police using radar could be obstructing the people's operations.
The reason the state lost in this case was they could not prove the person was actually warning others.
GrandCentral
06-02-2008, 09:11 PM
In NY most people don't know **** about road signals people sit in the Left lane going 50 MPH and when they get flashed they don't move and they don't get what you are doing. I flash my brights, put my hand up, and mouth slow down, speed trap, cop ahead anything if you are too inattentive to take that warning you deserve the ticket. I find down south or in rural areas people get it more, also they drive on more 2 lane highways which helps.