View Full Version : When is Car and Driver doing their next test?
fallen8511
02-08-2005, 11:58 AM
Just wondering if they will do a Great Detector Test again soon, since the V1 and the 8500 have both been updated.
2002 was a long time ago.
jimbonzzz
02-08-2005, 12:41 PM
I would like to know the same thing.
GuruReports is supposed to have a test out, was supposed to be in late '04 but last I saw it will be released sometime in '05:
http://www.gurureports.org/specialreports/radardetectortest.1.html
If anyone doesn't know much about GuruReports, they did a car wax test that generated a lot of controversy on some car boards...
marlinspike
02-08-2005, 12:46 PM
Their wax report was bo-O-O-O-o-gus
Richard
jimbonzzz
02-08-2005, 01:16 PM
Heh, if you want to start a really long thread on a car board, just post something like:
"I'm a newbie, and I have a few questions:
What is the best wax?
What is the best oil?
What is the best radar detector?"
Jim
stalkervision
02-08-2005, 01:23 PM
Just wondering if they will do a Great Detector Test again soon, since the V1 and the 8500 have both been updated.
2002 was a long time ago.
Ya Mike V. needs another "unbiased test" so that he can base all his advertising on it and "diss" everyone else..Especially when the main guy that oversees the tests at C/D is on Valentine's payroll and always has been... :wink: :P Guess who will win the next radar detector test.... I will even predict the scores for you all..
Valentine1.........98% out of 100% maybe 99%
Escort.........82% of 100
Bell.........67% of 100%
joop1987
02-08-2005, 02:36 PM
Everyone knows that Zaino is the best car polish, V1 is the best radar detector, and Lexol is the best for leather, windex and newspapers and best for windows, armor all the best for tire dressing, Mobile 1 best oil.
jimbonzzz
02-08-2005, 03:01 PM
Here's another angle:Klasse topped with Pinnacle Souveran (or S100 to go cheap); Stoner's Invisible Glass for windows, Meguire's Endurance for tires. GM for vehicles (oops did I say that out loud?) just kidding joop :P
I'll definitely have to agree though about the oil and the detector :D
marlinspike
02-08-2005, 03:24 PM
Here's the real run down (i.e. what I say are the best).
First off, Klasse is good, the method that "test" says is the best way to apply wax is horrific. You know you're dealing with a bogus company when they recommend a clay bar (yes, Griot's has some good stuff, but they're pretty much a bunch of rip off artists). Stoner's invisible glass was the worst glass cleaner I ever used. I really wish I had lost the money rather than spend it on that. Meguire's Endurance: meh, it's meguires, not bad not great...though watch out for their wheel cleaner. There was a class action suit because it'll stip the paint off your wheels (did to mine, but I wasn't in on the suit). Oil...Mobil 1 ain't bad, but oil is actually somewhat engine specific (well, not engine, how you drive). If you don't do much highway, go with Amsoil since they have less ash.
Now that we are done with where I disagree, how about what I like?
Wax: very very car/storage/driving situation dependant. Recommending a wax is like recommending...um, I dunno...something that is very individual dependant. Lexol is one of the best for leather. There are other, much more expensive ones, that are good, but I'd venture to say no better so not worth the cost. As far as glass, two choices: One Grand if you like a pump, Wurth if you like aerosol. Armor-all is not good for tires or dashboards etc. It's great probably 60% of the time, but 40% of the time it will literally ruin your rubber/plastic/vinyl product. I don't know what chemical has to be present for armor all to disagree with it, but when it does, it's nasty (DON'T use armor all in a 64.5 Mustang). I like One Grand ERV, though the best for seals is Wurth (Wurth does just about everything best...let's face it, the German's got us beat on cars).
Oh, and a plug for my favorite car care store, www.carcareonline.com. Larry actually knows something about cars unlike those GuruReports people.
Richard
SmaartAasSaabr
02-08-2005, 03:41 PM
I still find it odd that VR's website tells of V1's superiority to inexpensive detectors, with a September 1995 issue of C/D to back them up...
I have the issue in question, it clearly stated V1 was the best, but the bar graphs to show range were not large enough to cover the entire V1 range, which the article stated...
It's a 10-year old test!
stalkervision
02-08-2005, 03:47 PM
I still find it odd that VR's website tells of V1's superiority to inexpensive detectors, with a September 1995 issue of C/D to back them up...
I have the issue in question, it clearly stated V1 was the best, but the bar graphs to show range were not large enough to cover the entire V1 range, which the article stated...
It's a 10-year old test!
Yup you've just stumbled into "Car and Driver's radar detector tests (Twilight Zone)" :wink: :shock:
Veil Guy
02-21-2005, 11:11 PM
Wait until you read the Ultimate Radar Detector Review:
You won't miss the C/D reviews. If we did our job right - and we worked hard to- this comparison should address most questions out there about the best of the best.
Tomorrow, should be the day for its release!
I can't wait.
The Veil Guy 8)
SETITOFF
02-22-2005, 11:12 AM
Veil Guy, you can't wait??? You got the rest of us holding our breath under water. :oops: See the face changing color? :shock: Eyes about to pop out?
sethy
02-22-2005, 11:25 AM
I still find it odd that VR's website tells of V1's superiority to inexpensive detectors, with a September 1995 issue of C/D to back them up...
I have the issue in question, it clearly stated V1 was the best, but the bar graphs to show range were not large enough to cover the entire V1 range, which the article stated...
It's a 10-year old test!
Yup you've just stumbled into "Car and Driver's radar detector tests (Twilight Zone)" :wink: :shock:
I like how Mike V's latest test against the escort was against the 8500 & not the 8500 x50 in his latest test.
stalkervision
02-22-2005, 12:00 PM
I still find it odd that VR's website tells of V1's superiority to inexpensive detectors, with a September 1995 issue of C/D to back them up...
I have the issue in question, it clearly stated V1 was the best, but the bar graphs to show range were not large enough to cover the entire V1 range, which the article stated...
It's a 10-year old test!
Yup you've just stumbled into "Car and Driver's radar detector tests (Twilight Zone)" :wink: :shock:
I like how Mike V's latest test against the escort was against the 8500 & not the 8500 x50 in his latest test.
well that doesn't surprise me one bit... :wink:
Hessen
02-26-2005, 06:53 PM
When Valentine can afford to pay for another "impartial" test.... :P
Radarboy12312
04-03-2005, 09:00 PM
Just wondering if they will do a Great Detector Test again soon, since the V1 and the 8500 have both been updated.
2002 was a long time ago.
I can already tell you who the winner will be. The Valentine One
jimbonzzz
04-03-2005, 09:28 PM
Just wondering if they will do a Great Detector Test again soon, since the V1 and the 8500 have both been updated.
2002 was a long time ago.
I can already tell you who the winner will be. The Valentine One
You're probably right, especially if the test includes rear detection or a "quick-trigger" test:
http://www.radardetector.net/V1-vs.-8500-X50-instant-on-shootout-865t.php
BTW, welcome to the forum :D
Jim
BiGeAsYgUy
04-03-2005, 09:48 PM
Jimbonzzz, ban this radarboy12312 because he is a troll that picks fights on every board he goes on like Carreview.com and Epinions.com. He goes by the name X508500 or RADARBOY12312 and he has been banned from both of those boards but he keeps coming back with fake names and the same old rants with crappy English.
Here is an example of his crap:
http://www.epinions.com/content_171149004420/show_~allcom
YOU ARE NOT WELCOME HERE RADARBOY12312, YOU CANNOT SPELL AND YOU ARE A LITTLE PUNK!!
compu44
04-03-2005, 09:56 PM
Hehe, i've got him on my ignore list on epinions already :D
jimbonzzz
04-03-2005, 11:34 PM
Jimbonzzz, ban this radarboy12312 because he is a troll that picks fights on every board he goes on like Carreview.com and Epinions.com. He goes by the name X508500 or RADARBOY12312 and he has been banned from both of those boards but he keeps coming back with fake names and the same old rants with crappy English.
Hehe, i've got him on my ignore list on epinions already :D
Don't worry guys, I'll definitely keep an eye on him!
Jim
BiGeAsYgUy
04-03-2005, 11:39 PM
He has already started his crap so it won't take long before he gets banned.
Radarboy12312
04-03-2005, 11:48 PM
He has already started his crap so it won't take long before he gets banned.
Dude for the last time iam just giving out my opinion and unlike you I don't have to name call.
Radarboy12312
04-03-2005, 11:52 PM
Jimbonzzz, ban this radarboy12312 because he is a troll that picks fights on every board he goes on like Carreview.com and Epinions.com. He goes by the name X508500 or RADARBOY12312 and he has been banned from both of those boards but he keeps coming back with fake names and the same old rants with crappy English.
Hehe, i've got him on my ignore list on epinions already :D
Don't worry guys, I'll definitely keep an eye on him!
Jim
Iam not doing anything wrong iam just giving out my opinion now whats wrong with that.
Oh and by the way you don't have to keep in eye on me.
BiGeAsYgUy
04-03-2005, 11:53 PM
This is a quote from RADARBOY12312 aka X508500 on Epinions.com, "I have tested the X50 and the Valentine so i am not just saying this. My testing shows that the X50 had about a 20 second lead on K band,10 to 15 second lead on KA band,and yes it even had about a 5 second lead on laser."
This idiot is a troll that will start fights with everyone so everyone ignore him. He claims to hate the V1 and bashes it all the time but he also claims to have owned 5 V1's in the past. Get a life loser!!!
Radarboy12312
04-04-2005, 12:12 AM
Just wondering if they will do a Great Detector Test again soon, since the V1 and the 8500 have both been updated.
2002 was a long time ago.
I can already tell you who the winner will be. The Valentine One
You're probably right, especially if the test includes rear detection or a "quick-trigger" test:
http://www.radardetector.net/V1-vs.-8500-X50-instant-on-shootout-865t.php
BTW, welcome to the forum :D
Jim Thanks its good to be on this board and I hope to give out some good info on radar detectors
BiGeAsYgUy
04-04-2005, 12:16 AM
Just wondering if they will do a Great Detector Test again soon, since the V1 and the 8500 have both been updated.
2002 was a long time ago.
I can already tell you who the winner will be. The Valentine One
You're probably right, especially if the test includes rear detection or a "quick-trigger" test:
http://www.radardetector.net/V1-vs.-8500-X50-instant-on-shootout-865t.php
BTW, welcome to the forum :D
Jim Thanks its good to be on this board and I hope to give out some good info on radar detectors
We don't need to hear your information(crap) RADARBOY12312 aka X508500 aka --- Removed ----
sethy
04-04-2005, 12:58 AM
bigeasy, dont start releasing personal information about someone, thats bad carma. I'll keep an eye on him :) You got any links over to epinions on this character?
BiGeAsYgUy
04-04-2005, 01:01 AM
bigeasy, dont start releasing personal information about someone, thats bad carma. I'll keep an eye on him :) You got any links over to epinions on this character?
He used to go by radarboy12312 over there but he changed his name to X508500 to get around the lifetime ban that was put on him at Epinions.com and Carreview.com. Take a look at this link and you will see that other people know about him and his childish ways:
http://www.epinions.com/content_171149004420/show_~allcom
compu44
04-04-2005, 01:12 AM
<<<<<<<<<<< agrees with bigeasy, Radarboy posts the same copy and paste comments on every review he can find about the 8500 or the V1.
carlito
04-04-2005, 10:38 AM
what car and driver needs to do is test them rockymountainradar jammers
they help rmr to scam folks out off money i think there just a scam to cause they let them advertise those rockymountainradar jammers that dont work!
and also the v1 will be#1
carlito
04-10-2005, 01:29 PM
the reason i say that car&driver needs to test rocky mountain products
is because that is where most new folks buy them from. that ad they advertise in there mag selling them and also cause that fool kent at rmr said no one had the balls to print something bad about them in car&driver!
what do you guys think? :evil:
Hessen
04-10-2005, 01:49 PM
Pat Bedard of C/D is apparently a "paid consultant" of Mike Valentine, so C/D's results are suspect in my opnion.
I would take SML's , Radar Roy's or Craig Peterson's test outcomes more seriously than C/D's.
C/D will probably not test RMR against Valentine...
cause what if they found themselves "having to" declare RMR the "winner" :shock:
:lol:
jimbonzzz
04-10-2005, 02:18 PM
Pat Bedard of C/D is apparently a "paid consultant" of Mike Valentine, so C/D's results are suspect in my opnion.
I would take SML's , Radar Roy's or Craig Peterson's test outcomes more seriously than C/D's.
C/D will probably not test RMR against Valentine...
cause what if they found themselves "having to" declare RMR the "winner" :shock:
:lol:
Apparently Mr. Peterson believes that he can make himself appear cleaner by spreading the muck around. Unfortunately, his observations about Car and Driver are at variation with the facts.
>But don't get the impression few automotive journalists consult or
>otherwise engage in commerce with automotive-related companies. Low pay
>has always encouraged auto writers to accept outside jobs as a matter of
>survival. Car & Driver, for example, whose detector reviews are accepted
>as gospel by many, piously claim their staffers have no allegiances to
>companies whose products they test. But they neglect to mention their
>long tradition of feeding at the manufacturers' trough even as they test
>these same manufacturers' cars. A 1990 front page Wall Street Journal
>story scrutinized C/D's penchant for double-dipping in great detail.
>I'll e-mail you a copy if you'd like.
The consulting activities referenced in that WSJ article were the residue from a previous Editor-in-Chief of Car and Driver, the one who is currently in charge of the auto magazine that publishes Mr. Peterson's efforts. As a result of that article, William Jeanes, who was then Car and Driver's editor, instituted a conflict of interest policy to prohibit such activities. Those writers, including me, who lost income because of the change, recieved compensatory salary increases. When I became Editor four years ago, I continued the no consulting policy, which is enforced to this day.
>Among those mentioned in the WSJ article was Patrick Bedard, their most
>senior editor, who has routinely consulted to auto manufacturers and who
>has been on the Valentine payroll since 1981. He drove Valentine's Indy
>car in two Indy 500s and is a close personal friend. Unlike me, Bedard
>works for only one detector manufacturer, Valentine, perhaps explaining
>why during this 16-year period no one but Valentine has ever won a
>detector test. Meanwhile Bedard dutifully cranks out stories praising
>Valentine and C/D names him as one of the "Ten Best Friends of the
>Automobile".
Mr. Peterson would do well to read those radar detector tests before criticizing them. None of them were written by Pat Bedard, nor has he participated in ANY radar detector tests during my tenure at Car and Driver, which dates back to October 1980. In fact, Bedard doesn't even live in Michigan, where the magazine is headquartered and where all of the radar detector tests are conducted.
Furthermore, even when consulting was allowed pre-1990, none of the authors of our radar detector tests (Don Sherman, Nicholas Bisson-Dath, and I) consulted for any of the detector manufacturers.
Nor is it true that Valentine associated detectors have won every Car and Driver test. A Uniden won our 1995 test of budget detectors. Another Uniden won our 1989 test. And a Cobra unit tied for the win in our 1987 test.
If this analysis of Car and Driver's radar detector tests is representative of Mr. Peterson's scrutiny and throughness, it is no surprise that his detector tests usually strike us as peculiar. Perhaps he would be well advised to refining his detector test procedures rather than attempting to deconstruct ours.
Csaba Csere
Editor-in-Chief
Car and Driver
Hessen
04-10-2005, 02:26 PM
Thanks Jim.....I did not know that......BUT..... that still does not negate the fact the C/D allows RMR to advertise their worthless crap in their magazine.....I wonder if Csaba has a "response" to this issue
carlito
04-10-2005, 02:29 PM
well all i know if car and driver keeps letting rocky mounatin radar advertise there products that dont work then EVERYBODY who works for car and driver IS A SCAMMER know matter what :twisted:
jimbonzzz
04-10-2005, 02:33 PM
A lot of them do it, I see RMR ads in Automobile magazine too. I guess cash is king, if RMR is willing to pay $ for the advertising space the mags are all over it. The only thing that will likely stop that is if people quit buying the RMR units so that they can't afford to advertise...it's a vicious cycle...
The connection between Mike V and Bedard is very true though. I have a book "Expert Driving" published by Valentine Research....written by Patrick Bedard. Whether that effects C&D's tests is hard to say...
Jim
carlito
04-10-2005, 07:11 PM
yes jim thats ture about automobile magazine they are all a scam with
rocky mounatin radar :lol:
stalkervision
04-12-2005, 06:42 AM
Pat Bedard of C/D is apparently a "paid consultant" of Mike Valentine, so C/D's results are suspect in my opnion.
I would take SML's , Radar Roy's or Craig Peterson's test outcomes more seriously than C/D's.
C/D will probably not test RMR against Valentine...
cause what if they found themselves "having to" declare RMR the "winner" :shock:
:lol:
Apparently Mr. Peterson believes that he can make himself appear cleaner by spreading the muck around. Unfortunately, his observations about Car and Driver are at variation with the facts.
>But don't get the impression few automotive journalists consult or
>otherwise engage in commerce with automotive-related companies. Low pay
>has always encouraged auto writers to accept outside jobs as a matter of
>survival. Car & Driver, for example, whose detector reviews are accepted
>as gospel by many, piously claim their staffers have no allegiances to
>companies whose products they test. But they neglect to mention their
>long tradition of feeding at the manufacturers' trough even as they test
>these same manufacturers' cars. A 1990 front page Wall Street Journal
>story scrutinized C/D's penchant for double-dipping in great detail.
>I'll e-mail you a copy if you'd like.
The consulting activities referenced in that WSJ article were the residue from a previous Editor-in-Chief of Car and Driver, the one who is currently in charge of the auto magazine that publishes Mr. Peterson's efforts. As a result of that article, William Jeanes, who was then Car and Driver's editor, instituted a conflict of interest policy to prohibit such activities. Those writers, including me, who lost income because of the change, recieved compensatory salary increases. When I became Editor four years ago, I continued the no consulting policy, which is enforced to this day.
>Among those mentioned in the WSJ article was Patrick Bedard, their most
>senior editor, who has routinely consulted to auto manufacturers and who
>has been on the Valentine payroll since 1981. He drove Valentine's Indy
>car in two Indy 500s and is a close personal friend. Unlike me, Bedard
>works for only one detector manufacturer, Valentine, perhaps explaining
>why during this 16-year period no one but Valentine has ever won a
>detector test. Meanwhile Bedard dutifully cranks out stories praising
>Valentine and C/D names him as one of the "Ten Best Friends of the
>Automobile".
Mr. Peterson would do well to read those radar detector tests before criticizing them. None of them were written by Pat Bedard, nor has he participated in ANY radar detector tests during my tenure at Car and Driver, which dates back to October 1980. In fact, Bedard doesn't even live in Michigan, where the magazine is headquartered and where all of the radar detector tests are conducted.
Furthermore, even when consulting was allowed pre-1990, none of the authors of our radar detector tests (Don Sherman, Nicholas Bisson-Dath, and I) consulted for any of the detector manufacturers.
Nor is it true that Valentine associated detectors have won every Car and Driver test. A Uniden won our 1995 test of budget detectors. Another Uniden won our 1989 test. And a Cobra unit tied for the win in our 1987 test.
If this analysis of Car and Driver's radar detector tests is representative of Mr. Peterson's scrutiny and throughness, it is no surprise that his detector tests usually strike us as peculiar. Perhaps he would be well advised to refining his detector test procedures rather than attempting to deconstruct ours.
Csaba Csere
Editor-in-Chief
Car and Driver
see remarks below they wouldn't fit with the quote also..stalker :wink:
stalkervision
04-12-2005, 06:42 AM
I find Csaba remarks less then honest here. Pat Bedard or Mike Valentine have never ever denyed Craig's charges and this is HIGHLY SUSPECT especially when it comes to Mike Valentine and his nasty remarks about Craig Peterson in the past and on his website. I have articles on radar and radar detectors from old issues of c/d showing pics Mike V and Bedard as "buddy-buddy" as old fishing pals and the remarks Bedard makes in these articles are telling about how close they really are...Then you have got to ask yourself why does the V-1 ALWAYS absolutely destroys the competition in every c/d test and other radar detector tester doesn't show this from other magazines and sites...? Casba sites the "el-cheepo" test as proof they aren't biased at c/d but I have that test article and it appears to be an "accidently abberation" on c/d's part as someone besides old Pat apparently supervised this test because of the results! (pat must have been busy at the time and after all it was a cheepo-detector test :wink: ) In all the before and after c/d tests the V-1 just blows the competition away as it always seems to do on c/d.. :wink: I have plenty of Proof Pat Bedard "oversees" these "tests" unlike what old csba says and his saying Bedard doesn't even live in Michigan shows just how lame his argument really is. After all are we living in horse and buggy times? :P
when Bedard and Mike V. come out and PROVE they aren't in cohoots only then I will believe it and even at that I will be suspect of their info as I am of their "tests"... :lol: