PDA

View Full Version : Question - Anyone *definitively* ID the ZR4 as LED-based?



TSi+WRX
05-31-2008, 12:42 PM
LED, as in (L)ight (E)mitting (D)iode, versus laser-diode.

Why am I asking for a confirmation? -->

This popped-up on RR.net:


OK I talked with their head tech Jim and learned a lot of great things. ...I thought I read somewhere on this forum that the ZR4 was LED based, but in fact it is a diode based system. He was actually very surprised that people thought it was LED, so that was good to learn.
....and further, that this "head engineer" of Escort's laughed at the notion that various "internet hobbyist sources" could possibly offer any sort of correct information regarding their product.

Now, I know that the ZR3 as well as the Blinder have been taken apart here on RD.net - and photographed for reference, too. And I know, from my own experience disassembling my ZR3, that it is indeed LED-based.

From all the current data on the ZR4, I'm inclined to believe my fellow "internet hobbyists" - that the ZR4 is LED-based, and in my discussions with '09 Milan, I've maintained that it is likely a "vocabulary" concern - and perhaps even company marketing-line issue - that's keeping "Jim at Escort" sticking to the line that the ZR4 is "diode-based," as in LED-based, without recognizing the fact that in the hobbyist community, "diode-based" has come to take on the connotation that the system uses laser-diode(s).

So, can anyone out there find definitive evidence that the ZR4 is LED-based?

thestaton
05-31-2008, 12:47 PM
Without a doubt.


LED, as in (L)ight (E)mitting (D)iode, versus laser-diode.

Why am I asking for a confirmation? -->

This popped-up on RR.net:


....and further, that this "head engineer" of Escort's laughed at the notion that various "internet hobbyist sources" could possibly offer any sort of correct information regarding their product.

Now, I know that the ZR3 as well as the Blinder have been taken apart here on RD.net - and photographed for reference, too. And I know, from my own experience disassembling my ZR3, that it is indeed LED-based.

From all the current data on the ZR4, I'm inclined to believe my fellow "internet hobbyists" - that the ZR4 is LED-based, and in my discussions with '09 Milan, I've maintained that it is likely a "vocabulary" concern - and perhaps even company marketing-line issue - that's keeping "Jim at Escort" sticking to the line that the ZR4 is "diode-based," as in LED-based, without recognizing the fact that in the hobbyist community, "diode-based" has come to take on the connotation that the system uses laser-diode(s).

So, can anyone out there find definitive evidence that the ZR4 is LED-based?

TSi+WRX
05-31-2008, 12:53 PM
^ I'm not doubting that the ZR4 is LED-based, either. ;) Its physical similarities to the ZR3 can't be overlooked, it's IR-video signature is nearly the same, and heck, if it's chocked *that* full of laser-diodes, and still fails "the Stalker test" so miserably (in that the Stalker seems to be an acid-test of LED-based jammers), then something is definitely way, way faulty over at Escort.....

Still, what this particular hobbyist has pointed out is undeniable - that to-date, no-one has yet produced conclusive physical evidence that the ZR4 is LED-based, and that it's currently a "he-said/she-said" game between guys like us, and the powers-that-be over at Escort.

It's not a matter of trust anymore - rather, that there needs to be some solid proof.....

Lucky225
05-31-2008, 07:42 PM
well, it is diode based, Light Emitting Diodes lmfao

thestaton
05-31-2008, 07:45 PM
If the professor catches this thread he can explain it better than I can. But it sounds like they are just playing a word game at the moment.

TSi+WRX
06-01-2008, 02:33 PM
^ +1 to both of the above posts, as that's what I precisely think, too. :)

ELVATO
06-01-2008, 03:59 PM
In IR, it seems weaker than an M40 (the video is somewhere in the vid section.)

Also, looking at it, you can see the row of LEDs light up when you hit it (in IR mode of course.)

TSi+WRX
06-01-2008, 07:21 PM
^ Agreed to both, good brother. :)

But as Milan points out, currently, it is indeed one's words against another's. I don't think anything is going to convince him (or totally satisfy me, either, to tell you the truth, even though I do know better :p ) until someone does a full tear-down.

I have no doubt, at all, that the ZR4 is LED-based.......it's just that some incontrovertible evidence would be nice. :)

<<JAZZY>>
06-01-2008, 07:38 PM
Wow, Escort is lying about their products...SHOCKING!!:rolleyes:

ELVATO
06-01-2008, 08:12 PM
In IR, it seems weaker than an M40 (the video is somewhere in the vid section.)

Also, looking at it, you can see the row of LEDs light up when you hit it (in IR mode of course.)

Here's the vid I'm talking about.
Random IR vids (http://blip.tv/file/952271)

TSi+WRX
06-01-2008, 09:00 PM
Wow, Escort is lying about their products...SHOCKING!!:rolleyes:

^ I don't particularly think that Escort is lying - rather, that they're sticking to the line that a light-emitting diode is just that, a "diode."

It's just a way to work the vocabulary, to favor their marketing.

Do I agree with this? No, not given the rather known community reference of "diode-based jammers" as being laser-diodes.

But if they had to press the case, it's hard to call them "wrong," exactly, either.......