View Full Version : First time GPS buyer needs advice
StealthRex
10-30-2008, 12:55 AM
So I want to add to my cars toys, and get a gps to go along with my V1, just wondering peoples opinions, or questions I want to ask myself when in search of the perfect GPS match.
As always, thanks! I love the advice on this forum.
crazyVOLVOrob
10-30-2008, 08:51 AM
So I want to add to my cars toys, and get a gps to go along with my V1, just wondering peoples opinions, or questions I want to ask myself when in search of the perfect GPS match.
As always, thanks! I love the advice on this forum.
I have had good luck with garmins My c330 is a beast. and My c550 is a great unit unit the power cord broke into 3 pieces
RadarKid
10-30-2008, 01:43 PM
So I want to add to my cars toys, and get a gps to go along with my V1, just wondering peoples opinions, or questions I want to ask myself when in search of the perfect GPS match.
As always, thanks! I love the advice on this forum.
GARMIN NUVI.
My opinion: 255W
I'm in love with mine. The other day I was showing my girlfriend how the small Speed Limit sign appears while on the highway showing you the posted limit where you are. As Im pointing to the GPS saying "Speed Limit 65" we're approaching an ACTUAL Speed Limit sign on the road that says "Speed Limit 55"......Before I could get the words out of my mouth that the GPS was inaccurate, it updated to "Speed Limit 55" at the EXACT moment we passed the new sign. We were amazed.
StealthRex
10-30-2008, 09:34 PM
Ok, I was starting to look at the garmin page today, but it looks like gibberish, what are the functions that I need to ask myself if I want (in english). I can bet that you'll be happy with most garmins after you buy them, but why do you like them? Besides the posted speed limit sign, sounds like another thing a cop can tell you if you get pulled over, "Your thingy on the dash even says what the speed limit is" lol.
The Breeze
10-31-2008, 12:20 AM
I use the Tom Tom one 3rd addition. It is pre programmed for all of North America, and is updateable for free. I love the thing. Very easy to use and does what I need it to do. I can recommend it without any reservations for an entry level GPS.
RadarKid
10-31-2008, 07:24 AM
Ok, I was starting to look at the garmin page today, but it looks like gibberish, what are the functions that I need to ask myself if I want (in english). I can bet that you'll be happy with most garmins after you buy them, but why do you like them? Besides the posted speed limit sign, sounds like another thing a cop can tell you if you get pulled over, "Your thingy on the dash even says what the speed limit is" lol.
There's a TON to love about the Garmins. First of all its pure simplicity. It's got a lot of great features, but within a day or so of using it; you'll be a pro.
My 255W connects within seconds, while (even with all the latest updates) my 260 would take up to 5min at times. Way longer than it took for my 9500i to connect. The refresh rate smokes the 260 as well, so theres NO herky jerky movement of your vehicle on the map, all turns are smooth and you pass intersections dead on. The full QWERTY keyboard is a must have for me after coming from a non-W model. The non-QWERTY's are just a jumbled line with no ryhme or reason to it, which makes putting text in a MAJOR PITA. Most of the W models have the QWERTY, if not all. It has a great "Points of Interest" database for searching out restaurants, shops, etc. You can zoom into the maps and it'll show you actual contour maps of the elevation as well.
While in the map mode, you can tap the screen and toggle between an overhead flat map, or back into the 3D at any time. The top left corner shows your next move and how far off it is, and a tap of the icon in that corner allows you to scroll through each additional turn you'll be making. In the map mode, bottom left of the map always shows your current speed as well. You can pull up a sub menu by tapping the speed icon; which gives you your current speed, heading (N-E-S-W), as well as your past top speed, average speed, trip time, and more. Bottom right you'll also have a ETA. I love this as well, knowing what time you'll arrive is great (and very accurate). Traffic updates are available as well.
You can add your own "Points of Interest" like schools, speed cams, etc. as well. Not of much importance to me, but it does also have a card slot for pictures etc. It comes stocked with North America maps, and Canada, yet more can be purchased.
I have text to speech, so it says the street names instead of just "turn left." The speed limit icons are great, and dead on accurate in my experience (no cop is going to see the icon unless he has the same unit himself, its not that obvious). The "Where Am I" feature is awesome, where at any given time you can select it, and it'll come up with the nearest address (#, Street, City/Town, and State), exact lat/long as well as buttons to pull up the nearest Police Stations, Hospitals, etc. I like how at night it changes the screen over to dark blue for the surround area instead of the bright tan color during the day that could be harsh on the eyes. I'm sure I'm forgetting things...this was just a stream of thoughts that came to mind.
Not a fan of the TomToms. Weaker UI's, slower updates, and they use less satellites for acquisition. I spent months researching them in depth before I made my purchase.
fire65
10-31-2008, 01:01 PM
I have the Garmin 330, one yr old, and just got the Tom Tom One 3rd edition. The are both good units. I am swayed a little more toward the Garmin.
fire65
10-31-2008, 01:03 PM
I have the Garmin 330, one yr old, and just got the Tom Tom One 3rd edition. They are both good units. I am swayed a little more toward the Garmin.
RadarKid
10-31-2008, 01:10 PM
I have the Garmin 330, one yr old, and just got the Tom Tom One 3rd edition. They are both good units. I am swayed a little more toward the Garmin.
There's no comparison.
TomTom spends their dough on ads, and GARMIN spends it on their product; and it shows. If you want to go the cheap way, grab a TomTom to sit beside your Cobra detector. If you want electronics for GPS that ranks at the same level as ESCORT and VALENTINE for detectors, pick up a GARMIN or MAGELLAN.
The Breeze
10-31-2008, 01:23 PM
There's no comparison.
TomTom spends their dough on ads, and GARMIN spends it on their product; and it shows. If you want to go the cheap way, grab a TomTom to sit beside your Cobra detector. If you want electronics for GPS that ranks at the same level as ESCORT and VALENTINE for detectors, pick up a GARMIN or MAGELLAN.
Both do the same thing, and the tomtom works. What more do you want? You’re not trying to save yourself with a GPS, so what’s the point of spending more money for getting the same thing…directions to where you want to go? The tomtom can be plugged into the computer and kept up to date with all current everything. Mine does everything I need it to do and more…perfect! It aint always about having the best, but just getting the job done.
RadarKid
10-31-2008, 01:29 PM
Both do the same thing, and the tomtom works. What more do you want? You’re not trying to save yourself with a GPS, so what’s the point of spending more money for getting the same thing…directions to where you want to go? The tomtom can be plugged into the computer and kept up to date with all current everything. Mine does everything I need it to do and more…perfect! It aint always about having the best, but just getting the job done.
I want the best electronics for UI and functioning.
It's all relative. Since we're in the RadarForum, I'll make that analogy again.
A Cobra detector "does the same thing" as a V1 or Escort 9500i relatively speaking. They both "detect radar".........like anything else......some just perform better than others. That's the point. You arent "getting the same thing" but you can think so if you want (considering you OWN a TomTom, I'm not surprised). Most people owning electronics that are lesser performers than other brands generally stick to defending their units as "the same" and those that have owned/used both know better.
CJR238
10-31-2008, 03:51 PM
I agree 100% Radarkid.
Why even bother getting a TomTom at all when you can get GPS on your cell phone, and they even come with traffic. That's all i use and never get lost.:D
GARMIN or MAGELLAN are definitely a better investment.
IMO, ether get the best out there, or go for a GPS enabled navigator cell phone, if we are looking to just get the job done.:D
And my GPS on my cell phone has almost everything a top GPS unit will provide.
category4
10-31-2008, 07:31 PM
I love my Garmin's and everyone at work that has a Magellan or Tom Tom eventually switches to Garmin.
languy99
10-31-2008, 09:25 PM
well I just got a new garmin 260 and after installing the updates it works perfectly(connects fast, no signal problems). If you don't need a wide screen ( I didn't because it would not fit where I wanted it to) the 260 is a great GPS for the price. WallyWorld has it for 197, I actually got mine on sale from circuit city for 200 out the door.
thestaton
11-01-2008, 12:01 PM
Check out the Garmin Nuvi 750 if you don't want traffic. 760 if you want traffic.
Or if you want to save a lot of money you can pick up the Nuvi 660 for almost nothing, and it comes with traffic.
RadarKid
11-01-2008, 12:14 PM
well I just got a new garmin 260 and after installing the updates it works perfectly(connects fast, no signal problems). If you don't need a wide screen ( I didn't because it would not fit where I wanted it to) the 260 is a great GPS for the price. WallyWorld has it for 197, I actually got mine on sale from circuit city for 200 out the door.
as stated earlier, I had the 260 with the updates, and it sucked compared to the 255.
didnt connect as fast, herky jerky movement, horrible keypad, etc.
No comparison
LordV
11-04-2008, 07:50 PM
well I just got a new garmin 260 and after installing the updates it works perfectly(connects fast, no signal problems). If you don't need a wide screen ( I didn't because it would not fit where I wanted it to) the 260 is a great GPS for the price. WallyWorld has it for 197, I actually got mine on sale from circuit city for 200 out the door.
X2. Ive had the 260 for 2 months now and have more than put it through it's paces. The unit has performed flawlessly. IMO, for the price, you can't go wrong.
RadarKid
11-05-2008, 07:30 AM
X2. Ive had the 260 for 2 months now and have more than put it through it's paces. The unit has performed flawlessly. IMO, for the price, you can't go wrong.
until you try a 255, you can't really compare.
and having used both extensively myself.....I can tell you they're not even close.
lordhamster
11-07-2008, 01:08 PM
There's no comparison.
TomTom spends their dough on ads, and GARMIN spends it on their product; and it shows. If you want to go the cheap way, grab a TomTom to sit beside your Cobra detector. If you want electronics for GPS that ranks at the same level as ESCORT and VALENTINE for detectors, pick up a GARMIN or MAGELLAN.
Um, I understand you like your Garmin but high end TomTom units are awsome.
What if you know that a certain highway is closed, try to avoid a road or a highway on your Garmin.
Hit a road block along the way? Your Garmin only has a detour button that will then avoid the rest of the current road segment, even if its 100s of miles long. I have a Garmin Nuvi 760 and a TomTom 930. Don't get me wrong, they are both great units but the TomTom is much more configurable and is better for advanced users.
RadarKid
11-07-2008, 01:13 PM
Um, I understand you like your Garmin but high end TomTom units are awsome.
What if you know that a certain highway is closed, try to avoid a road or a highway on your Garmin.
Hit a road block along the way? Your Garmin only has a detour button that will then avoid the rest of the current road segment, even if its 100s of miles long. I have a Garmin Nuvi 760 and a TomTom 930. Don't get me wrong, they are both great units but the TomTom is much more configurable and is better for advanced users.
research or try the 255. it does the same for detours that your TomTom930 does
lordhamster
11-07-2008, 01:44 PM
research or try the 255. it does the same for detours that your TomTom930 does
No it doesn't. Sure you can insert a via point into a route, but try doing that while you are on a route.
Trust me, the detour functionality on the Nuvis (except the Nuvi 5000) is pathetic to say the least.
RadarKid
11-07-2008, 02:32 PM
No it doesn't. Sure you can insert a via point into a route, but try doing that while you are on a route.
Trust me, the detour functionality on the Nuvis (except the Nuvi 5000) is pathetic to say the least.
Never had a problem. Perfect example was an accident on the highway where a tanker truck rolled over. I hit detour, it routed me off the next exit, and back onto Rt 95 2 miles down. Completely avoided the standstill.
Other times I've inserted a destination point while driving (to avoid construction) without a problem as well. Maybe you just don't have enough experience using your unit.
TomToms are pathetic
nomore55
11-07-2008, 03:07 PM
So I want to add to my cars toys, and get a gps to go along with my V1, just wondering peoples opinions, or questions I want to ask myself when in search of the perfect GPS match.
As always, thanks! I love the advice on this forum.
Not that there is any correlation to the V1, but the Garmin units sure are sweet.
Why not go to the store (Circuity City, Best Buy, etc.) to play and see what appeals to you? The Garmin interface is most excellent.
Enjoy.
thestaton
11-07-2008, 03:13 PM
Never had a problem. Perfect example was an accident on the highway where a tanker truck rolled over. I hit detour, it routed me off the next exit, and back onto Rt 95 2 miles down. Completely avoided the standstill.
Other times I've inserted a destination point while driving (to avoid construction) without a problem as well. Maybe you just don't have enough experience using your unit.
TomToms are pathetic
x2. I've been very vocal on just how pathetic tele-atlas is in the United States. It's a god damn joke of a product. I've owned the TT 720, 920T, & 930T and you couldn't pay me enough money to put one of those pieces of shat in my car and expect to get some where within a reasonable time table.
Further more any company that treats you like a criminal *tom tom* shouldn't be getting anyones business. If you buy the 920T or 930T they are supposed to give you a year of free map updates. That only applies if you are willing to scan your receipt or fax them.. *who the fck since 1985 owns a fax machine*? Furthermore why should anyone have to prove dick to them.
It's also pretty sad that I had to change out my 920T 4 god damn times just to get a working one from Best Buy. 0
If TomTom opened a US based operation I'd take a dump on their lawn.
RadarKid
11-07-2008, 03:24 PM
Not that there is any correlation to the V1, but the Garmin units sure are sweet.
Why not go to the store (Circuity City, Best Buy, etc.) to play and see what appeals to you? The Garmin interface is most excellent.
Enjoy.
nomore55 is right. There's nothing like messing with the units yourself to get a feel of what you prefer. Keep in mind the preferences of those who have used both, and returned units for "better" ones.
When you mess with them, at least for a while - disable the GPS so that its in DEMO mode where it'll appear to be driving the route you put in. The car will move along the route, and act as though it would if you were actually moving.
Pay attention to
USER INTERFACE (which keyboards you like best, and ease of navigating through the screens)
SCREEN SIZE (does it fit where you need it to? is it big enough for you to read easily? do you prefer a wide screen with full QWERTY?)
COVERAGE (in what countries do you need to use it?)
STORAGE SPACE FOR FAVORITES (how many do you need?)
NUMBER OF SATELLITES IT USES (how fast it reconnects in many situations where its been off for an extended period, or started up in a new location)
VOLUME (is it loud enough for your hearing? does it have an external jack for an earpiece?)
AUDIO CLARITY (is it clear enough for you to understand? there are different voices to select within settings that sound different)
VIDEO CLARITY (how is the resolution, and brightness?)
DOES IT DO TEXT TO SPEECH (reading the names of the streets you're turning on, and if you want/need that feature)
HOW SMOOTH ARE MOVEMENTS (are the movements little jumps of the screen? or does it flow like its driving across the map? This is hard to get an accurate idea of without USING it real time. Just make sure you have a return period to exchange it if you find something better)
DOES IT DO BLUETOOTH (do you have any preference for this feature?)
DOES IT HOLD EXTERNAL MEMORY (do you need it?)
DOES IT HAVE PICTURE VIEWER (do you need it?)
DOES IT DO MP3 PLAYBACK? (do you need it?)
My opinion is stick with GARMIN or MAGELLAN.
MAGELLANS biggest plus over a GARMIN (and I prefer GARMIN) is the fact that its QWERTY dims out letters that you don't need while typing)
nomore55
11-07-2008, 03:37 PM
If TomTom opened a US based operation I'd take a dump on their lawn.
Such passion! :D I luv it.
Yeah, I hear a lot of complaints about Tele-Atlas. I guess it's the Achilles' Heel of Tom Tom. Too bad, I believe it's a very good device otherwise. OTOH, the NAVTEQ set up appears to be near perfection (for USA users).
lordhamster
11-10-2008, 09:41 AM
I have both a Nuvi 760 and a TomTom 930 (I'm a gadget nerd what can I say). I've also previously used other units from both manufacturers. I agree TeleAtlas maps definitely used to be awful, however I've found recently they are getting better. If you use Google maps, you are using TeleAtlas. Take a look at maps.google.com for your neighborhood... thats pretty much what you get on an updated Tomtom.
Both my Nuvi and my Tomtom have the most up to date maps, however the TomTom has many more of the more recently built developments. I think that Garmin actually uses older NavTeq maps than the current ones on say maps.yahoo.com
In my area I've found that both units route well, sometimes one will pick a route I prefer over another but both units get me to where I want to be.
As to the Detour function. Thanks Radar, but I DO know how to use the unit. In fact I've had numerous discussions asking for advice etc on a dedicated GPS forum and people have had the same problems as I.
The Garmin Detour function will skip the next Road Segment. That is all it does. So, in many situations it works fine, but other times it can be a nightmare.
A few years ago, I encountered a closed highway in phoenix. There was absolutely no way to make my Nuvi 350 (at the time) detour around the thing. No combination of hitting detour button would avoid that highway.
With the newer Nuvi 760 I am now able to plan my route better by adding via points on the roads I want to travel on. If you know the exact route you want to take, and you can spend the time to sit down and force the GPS to take that route by inserting via points, then the Garmin is fine. In situations where you very quickly need to avoid a specific road or some such other units are better suited. Navigons and Magellans as far as I know have this functionality. Even the Garmin Nuvi 5000 has this, why don't the 7xx or 8xx series?
Also, its taken Garmin forever to add a next turn arrow to the interface. Finally now they are doing it on the newer units. That has been bothering me from Day 1.
When people ask for my advice I always say: For beginners I recommend Garmin. They are easy to use have great interface and are rock solid. However for advanced GPS users or Techie types, many prefer TomToms.
PS. If you go for a Garmin make sure you go for one who's model# ends in 5. These are the newer units, all of which feature a next turn indicator and also a faster processor.
Kayrac
11-10-2008, 10:18 AM
Never had a problem. Perfect example was an accident on the highway where a tanker truck rolled over. I hit detour, it routed me off the next exit, and back onto Rt 95 2 miles down. Completely avoided the standstill.
Other times I've inserted a destination point while driving (to avoid construction) without a problem as well. Maybe you just don't have enough experience using your unit.
TomToms are pathetic
i would listen to hamster on this ;)
oddly enough, Hello hamster, i was not aware you visited this forum aswell ;)
lordhamster
11-10-2008, 10:52 AM
i would listen to hamster on this ;)
oddly enough, Hello hamster, i was not aware you visited this forum aswell ;)
hey Kayrac! Nice to see you here. Yeah I used to post in this forum quite often, but lately I've been so busy with things I've just not had the time.
thestaton
11-10-2008, 12:30 PM
The biggest downfall of the Nuvi's has hamster said is the detour feature. I had the 350 some where in hell NJ when the road just randomly closed. So my only choice was to drive on random roads until the GPS could divert me around that closed road. man I was pissed.
but from the thousands of miles I've logged that's been the garmins only fault. you would think they could update that feature by now.
lordhamster
11-10-2008, 01:43 PM
The biggest downfall of the Nuvi's has hamster said is the detour feature. I had the 350 some where in hell NJ when the road just randomly closed. So my only choice was to drive on random roads until the GPS could divert me around that closed road. man I was pissed.
but from the thousands of miles I've logged that's been the garmins only fault. you would think they could update that feature by now.
I bought my Garmin 760 right around the time the 265WT was announced. I figured if that lower end unit has the next turn arrow feature, surely they'll bring it to the high end systems like the 760 with a firmware update.
No such luck.
If They put out a single über unit with all of the features they offer on their various models, I'd buy it in a second and never look back.
Things I need on a Nuvi:
1. Next Turn arrow (new nuvis have this)
2. Road Avoidance
3. Custom Detour Distance.
If they added the three above I'd buy a Nuvi and not look back. By the looks of it, the Navigon 7200T isn't half bad in this regard.
Things I'd like to see:
I'd love to see some interactive community features, like the Dash Express where traffic conditions experienced by one unit is fed back to other units on the road.
Historical traffic info would also be great. There are some roads in my area that have speedlimits of say 50, but the road is a complete disaster due to traffic lights and congestion (congestion that does not show up in traffic alerts).
partsfreak
11-10-2008, 02:47 PM
I have the Garmin 760 as well. It is really a neat gadget but you have to watch where it tells you to go. I have had it try to send me the wrong way on 1 way roads and once it wanted me to go the wrong way on an exit ramp to get on a highway. Its only as good as the maps that are available for the area. Greensboro has been doing major road reworks for the new Fedex hub for a few years now, and the unit does not recognize any of the roads around the north side of the airport. This would be a real problem for someone unfamiliar with the area trying to catch a flight on time. Especially as they would probably be relying on it to get them there. I love to put the female foriegn voices on too. The only women I can mute when I want is on the Garmin:p