PDA

View Full Version : Need some pointers



WheelieChuck
12-03-2008, 09:41 PM
Hi Guys,

New to the forum here. I've never used a radar detector before and I'm thinking about getting one for my motorcycle because I've had a few buddies getting ridiculous tickets recently. A buddy got a ticket for going 60 in a 55 and another low 40's in a 35. I know I'm always 5-10 above the posted speed limit easy and I really don't feel like getting a ticket.

Anyway, from my own research and lurking on this board, I think I want either the TPX, V1 with HARD, RX65 with HARD, or Escort 9500 with HARD.

TPX seems to have the best set up, but looks like the other 3 has been around longer and people seems to swear by them. Any reason that I should shy away from the TPX and go with the other 3? I'm not opposed to get the other 3 it's just that the TPX set up seems so slick and easy.

djrams80
12-04-2008, 01:13 AM
Hi Guys,

New to the forum here. I've never used a radar detector before and I'm thinking about getting one for my motorcycle because I've had a few buddies getting ridiculous tickets recently. A buddy got a ticket for going 60 in a 55 and another low 40's in a 35. I know I'm always 5-10 above the posted speed limit easy and I really don't feel like getting a ticket.

Anyway, from my own research and lurking on this board, I think I want either the TPX, V1 with HARD, RX65 with HARD, or Escort 9500 with HARD.

TPX seems to have the best set up, but looks like the other 3 has been around longer and people seems to swear by them. Any reason that I should shy away from the TPX and go with the other 3? I'm not opposed to get the other 3 it's just that the TPX set up seems so slick and easy.The TPX mounts much nicer than the other 3 RDs you mentioned, but it's performance is pretty bad.

YTCD
12-04-2008, 01:30 AM
I would say a 9500 for a motorcycle or if you run sometimes a v1 so you know where their coming from.

I think the quiteness and "real alert" features are neccessary for a bike. When that led goes off you want it to actually be a cop because on a motorcycle you don't have the time to process alerts and don't have time for the false alerts, because your much more seceptable to ignore them than in a car.

Later a 9500ix is the choice I would suggest for sure, order from radar busters they have a great Moto section.

WheelieChuck
12-04-2008, 09:16 AM
Hey djrams,

From what I've found on the web, seems like the performance of TPX is adequate. SML certified it, Radar Roy liked it, and from the web, seems like there are a lot of satisfied customers. Why do you say its performance is bad?

djrams80
12-04-2008, 02:50 PM
Hey djrams,

From what I've found on the web, seems like the performance of TPX is adequate. SML certified it,SML's RD testing is useless. According to them, everything works great.

http://www.radardetector.net/forums/detector-counter-measure-reviews/37654-usual-sml-results-joke.html


Radar Roy liked it, and from the web, seems like there are a lot of satisfied customers. Why do you say its performance is bad?

Roy basically saying that it's better than a Cobra is not really a ringing endorsement. It looks to me that what Roy likes about this product is that it's Motorcycle friendly and his liking for it is not really based upon peformance. I'd bet money that this product performs below the top Whistlers and below the Bel Vector series RDs, especially on Ka band. With the fact that the newer police radar units are getting harder and harder to detect, without proper testing, I wouldn't trust this product, performance wise.


One of the downsides I noted in my blog entry in my review was the false alerts. I was pleased when I met up with Wayne and Adam again, this time at the 2008 Radar Detector Shoot Out in El Paso, and they told me that they changed the filtering characteristics of their unit based upon my observations.


Overall the TPX system is on par with the mid class radar detectors such as the Whistler Pro-78 and would outperform any Cobra on the market today.

http://www.radarroy.com/2008/06/adaptive-technology-motorcycle-radar-detector-system/

WheelieChuck
12-05-2008, 12:51 AM
So sounds like for someone like me who is more concerned about motorcycle compatibility and isn't a hard-core radar detector guy, the TPX would do, right?

djrams80
12-05-2008, 02:00 AM
So sounds like for someone like me who is more concerned about motorcycle compatibility and isn't a hard-core radar detector guy, the TPX would do, right?My opinion is that a RD should first function well as a RD, then the convenience factor is somewhere after that. I talked to a GOL member today and we discussed a few RDs that we felt should be on the list of RDs tested at the next GOL event and this RD was specifically mentioned. If you can wait a few months, we will all know for sure how this RD performs.

My guess is that this RD will do very poorly at the next GOL. The reason that I think this way is that the RD industry is patent driven. This means that all the good ideas are not able to be copied by a new startup company with a new product such as this. Without infringing on current patents, it is very difficult to make a good performing RD. Specifically, I think this RD will perform fine on X and K band detection, but will perform extremely poorly on Ka band and will lack effective false alert suppression. That's bad news when about 80% of the new radar guns purchased by the PDs out there being Ka band.

I know this product seems perfect for you are looking to use it for, but without any controlled testing done on it, I'd have to discourage purchasing it at this time. My suggestion is to wait for a few months for the GOL testing results or, if you can't wait that long, purchase something that we know works properly against today's threats. Just my $.02.

WheelieChuck
12-05-2008, 10:17 AM
Thanks djrams80. I'll be going to the motorcycle show (in Long Beach) this weekend and I'm going check it out there. The company that I buy most of my toys for my bike, Cycle Gadgets, will be there and they are always knowledgeable about their products and they only carry products that they vouch for, so I'll see what they have to say about it and if any of their customers have had issues with it.

I know they are no radar detector experts like you, but they are bike experts and I want to get their perspective as well.

YTCD
12-05-2008, 11:04 AM
Thanks djrams80. I'll be going to the motorcycle show (in Long Beach) this weekend and I'm going check it out there. The company that I buy most of my toys for my bike, Cycle Gadgets, will be there and they are always knowledgeable about their products and they only carry products that they vouch for, so I'll see what they have to say about it and if any of their customers have had issues with it.

I know they are no radar detector experts like you, but they are bike experts and I want to get their perspective as well.

Believe me thats not going to matter. People that have cobra radar detectors think they are the best things in the world and they do almost absolulty nothing. This is why many cobra users get tickets and wonder why.

The bike shop isn't going to know any more than you do. TPX has great options for bikes and a great install package for a clean install but believe me you don't want their product.

If your going to spend money in a detector why not spend it on something that works unless your into just show. Heres the way I'll put it, if you want to waste hundreds or thousands of dollars on a detector that isn't going to give you any advantages and that you will not and shouldn't trust then get it but if you actually want something that is going to work then get a Escort or Valentine product. Im not saying the TPX won't work, it will work to a certain extent but in a lot of situations its not going to help you much. Your going to get a ticket plain and simple, much faster than if you have a nice good performing detector. And cops love street motorcycles, because of the persona so be prepared for quite a few I/O attacks.

alpinestars_2002795
12-05-2008, 04:51 PM
I also agree An escort for a motorcylest is your best option. Also roy used to sell enclosed plastic cases that where sealed from weather. This is how I would run a detector on a bike then hardwire it. That way it wouldn't get ruined, they also make mounts so you can mount it nice flat level to the road surface. I firmly beleive DJrams would not lead you down the wrong path. He is a very intelligent guy from what i've seen. And so is Roy Reyer. But just as DJ said he never commented it's preformance simply it was easily mountable.

As for a detector if your not on a High and mighty budget. And in need of a detector on steriods as all of us enthusist's love. If you are truely on a meger budget which unfortunatly in these rough times in the USA alot of us are.

I would suggest the same case maybe that roy sold the plexy glass type of sealing case, and seeing maybe if you could make a whistler pro 78 fit in there instead.

Best of luck with your application just got done installing a teather on my bike last night for ice racing.

X2 YTCD good points my friend good points as well.

:). Cheers.



AlPiNe~:)

AirMoore
12-05-2008, 09:18 PM
I have been riding for a 'fair amount of time' (with an RD)... and I prefer the Escort products over anything on them. Case closed. I would not trust a TPX system to protect me on my bike.


I am backing DJ on this 100%.

alpinestars_2002795
12-05-2008, 09:49 PM
^x2



AlPiNe~:)

AirMoore
12-05-2008, 10:00 PM
The key here is: We are telling you what we trust to protect us as hobbyists.


The people you buy everything from (cycleg...) are going to tell you what they must, in order to sell you something as store owners.

I am not saying they are just going to try to slime-ball you into ordering whatever they can: they may be genuinely interested in providing the best equipment for specific customers... In the end though, we have no stake in whatever you buy... it has no impact what-so-ever on us! BUT they (in some slight way) always have a stake in your money... it is a business: they have to be concerned with your money.


Your choice. ;)


------------
PS: Off-topic... Alpine: Sorry I could not attend the invitational this year (Please tell NMA I thank him for his PM's) and sorry I did not get back to him before the event to let you guys know. I am just extremely busy during the school-semester and there is virtually no way I can swing it to get out there and back. I would love too attend one if it was held earlier in the year (summer for example). Also the weather would be much nicer for me. Thanks.


(To the original poster... sorry for going off topic, but Alpine posting just reminded me).

alpinestars_2002795
12-06-2008, 12:18 AM
X2 Again with what Airmoore said. ^


Also Airmooore next years test date is listed below check it out it might appeal a tad more

As for NMA i'll let him know, he's been extremely busy lately. But i will pass the message along for you ;).

And no hard feelings man. I'm in school starting this winter trust me I understand finding time while your studying isn't always easy. Although Glad to see you back on the board Airmoore :)



AlPiNe~

WheelieChuck
12-06-2008, 02:28 AM
Thanks for all the comments.

Well, I went to the show today after work and Cycle Gadgets wasn't there. But the TPX guys were. Actually a guy and a chick. I talked to the guy, forgot his name, a young looking guy, very friendly, apparently one of the founders. I asked him a bunch of questions and were happy with what he had to say about his product. I asked him straight up how's the performance compared to V1 or Escort, and he straight up said that if that if detection range is the only thing that you are concerned with, V1 or Escort probably have an edge on the TPX. But, looking at the overall usefulness on a bike, he believes his product is the best, and I don't blame him for being confident with his product.

He put it this way: if you were shopping for a new bike, you wouldn't want to base the purchase decision strictly on the engine's performance. You also want to check out the brakes, handling, ergonomics, appearance, and kick the tires and checkout other things first. You'd look at the overall package. Now apply that to a radar detector for a bike. Yeah, V1 or Escort might have better range, but looking at the overall package, he thinks that the TPX is better than the others. I agree with him. There was also a fella there that chimed in about how he's had one since this summer and really liked it and how it had saved him a few times on the 15 and 395.

To make an already long story a bit shorter, I then went over to one of the dealers at the show that sells the TPX and got one there. Then I come home to read all your posts. But no buyer's remorse yet. I'm actually excited about trying it out. I'm going to install it tomorrow and next week I'll be taking a ride to San Jose and it'll be the perfect trip to see if it does what it supposed to, or if I'll be returning it and get a V1 or Escort instead.

Will keep you posted...

YTCD
12-06-2008, 02:42 AM
Hope you enjoy it.

But performance is far from what escort also offers you. As far as his analogy the escort 9500ix is a much better choice. You have customer service that is by far the best I've seen by any company in this market. Tpx I'm not sure about but I doubt their as good as escort. You have the ability to update the detector via from home instead of sending it in for any updates or software changes or in your case maybe no updates at all, red light and speed camera detection, reliability, locks out the falses, gps capabilities which will help for future inventions and more, and much much more. Honestly if I'm telling the truth I think you made the wrong decision but that is most definatly up to you (no offense intended).

Point in view, I honestly think that their is not one thing that txs brings that is better than escort & the 9500ix except it's built for a more custom install and that's the honest to god truth


Thanks for all the comments.

Well, I went to the show today after work and Cycle Gadgets wasn't there. But the TPX guys were. Actually a guy and a chick. I talked to the guy, forgot his name, a young looking guy, very friendly, apparently one of the founders. I asked him a bunch of questions and were happy with what he had to say about his product. I asked him straight up how's the performance compared to V1 or Escort, and he straight up said that if that if detection range is the only thing that you are concerned with, V1 or Escort probably have an edge on the TPX. But, looking at the overall usefulness on a bike, he believes his product is the best, and I don't blame him for being confident with his product.

He put it this way: if you were shopping for a new bike, you wouldn't want to base the purchase decision strictly on the engine's performance. You also want to check out the brakes, handling, ergonomics, appearance, and kick the tires and checkout other things first. You'd look at the overall package. Now apply that to a radar detector for a bike. Yeah, V1 or Escort might have better range, but looking at the overall package, he thinks that the TPX is better than the others. I agree with him. There was also a fella there that chimed in about how he's had one since this summer and really liked it and how it had saved him a few times on the 15 and 395.

To make an already long story a bit shorter, I then went over to one of the dealers at the show that sells the TPX and got one there. Then I come home to read all your posts. But no buyer's remorse yet. I'm actually excited about trying it out. I'm going to install it tomorrow and next week I'll be taking a ride to San Jose and it'll be the perfect trip to see if it does what it supposed to, or if I'll be returning it and get a V1 or Escort instead.

Will keep you posted...

djrams80
12-06-2008, 03:29 AM
:hmmmm2:

alpinestars_2002795
12-06-2008, 07:55 AM
^ X2 to YTCD except on escorts CS, that is well known that Belscorts CS is definetly in the lacking dept. Other than that I agree 100 percent. Personally Whistler has some of the best CS i've ever delt with, next to blinder. As for V1 well let's just say i've actually even been cussed at on the phone which isn't very professional? I can't say that about belscort, but then again they have been so picky at times not even willing to send me a new speaker so i can solder it back on myself. They'd rather have me spend 80 bucks to have them do something that simplex. Which is garbage. Also when I had a friend buy a 9500ix from another person 2nd hand, and got it for 175 bucks instead of 500 it upset them that much that they refused to even retune it. Even if he paid the out of warrenty of 80 dollars. Which is rediculous, not to mention childish and greedy if you ask me. That and they've even told users that they don't beleive they have problems such as overheating with 9500ci's when they actually do. Crazyvolvorob knows all about this first hand. Also they claim they offer updates and support yet where is such support for the GX-65 and the 9500i that they claimed would be there? IDK just my .02 on belscort and VR's CS i've heard my fair share of horror stories so beware of that. Plus i've had my own experiences. Sent in a Bel STi Driver, the retuned it lasted a month, fell out of tune now for the second time yet they want me to pay to send it in to them, and for them to retune it? Garbage if you ask me.

Especially when I hardly even use my Bel STi compared to my X-50 because I try to save it for when I truely need the stealth going through Canada. As for every thing else YTCD said X2 i totally agree, and I also agree with DJrams statment :hmmmm2::hmmmm2:.


AlPiNe~:sheep:

crazyVOLVOrob
12-06-2008, 11:33 PM
AirMoore, How do you hear the alerts from your radar detector on your bike?

AirMoore
12-07-2008, 09:35 AM
AirMoore, How do you hear the alerts from your radar detector on your bike?



I have used various ways to do it honestly.
Currently (This past season) It depended:


With my dad (he has his own X50/H.A.R.D. system on his bike): I just watch for his brake-lights... and I would have the V895 (with nothing but it on full-volume... since it didn't matter much) I could still hear the V895, as long as I was below ~75 I would say. :)


When I am by myself: I use headphones... BUT: I DO NOT put them in my ears. My helmet has a Velcro-piece right across the front of it (for a neck-gaurd on a bike to protect you from cold wind)... its the 'fluffy side' of Velcro (if you will). So I took some Velcro (the 'rough side') and mounted it on the back of each earphone. Now when I hop onto the bike, it takes all of 10seconds to set-up (I just put my helmet on, get on the bike grab the ear-phones, stick them together via the Velcro... and viola).

TO answer any questions people have: Yes it is loud enough at high-speed to hear... its extremely loud in the helmet (I even wear earplugs on long trips). The Velcro bond will rip off in the case of an accident... so I don't rip the RD off and so I don't have a cord there to choke me. I have never had any problems with LEO's, and I have never had any problem with them falling off or the like.


Again, thats what I am using right now... over the past 5 years I don't even know all the things I used (I even had my first whistler on my bike... before I got into this as a hobby).

To be honest now: I am starting to slow down a lot on my bike, so sometimes I won't even bring one, because I will ride so casual (We are talking out on desolate back roads at 3AM I cruise @10-20MPH to star gaze), that the RD is more of a distraction then a benefit.

alpinestars_2002795
12-08-2008, 10:25 AM
Ya, airmoore i found myself doing the same these days. It's like now that I know all the things I know from this board i find myself second guessing the need for speed although every once in awhile as GTO_04 found out I still feel a need forspeed while out joyridding.

As for hearing headphones in your helmet i can attest to this we used to use two way radio's while on trailrides on mx bikes, and on the ice while doing 120mph and i could still hear my pit crew just fine. Ofcourse untill they disallowed and banned radio usage, which I thought was lame.

OFF TOPIC but: PS: Airmoore NMA PM'd You just for FYI.

AlPiNe~:)

zr1
12-08-2008, 11:43 PM
I'm not saying the TPX system has bad performance, nor do I think anybody else is........yet. We're just saying it's an unknown until it's tested in a controlled environment using the scientific method.

I hope it works well for you and I hope it has good performance.

As a biker, I do 10k+ miles a year, from daily commuting, to weekend canyons, to multi-state trips. I definitely can appreciate the care that the TPX team put in on making the gizmo bike-friendly. There's issues that bikers have with putting electronics on the bike instead of the safe/dry environment of a cage...er...I mean...car.

As a junior-amateur-radar-detector nut, current radar detectors come in 3 basic flavors:


A-Grade (The Big Dawgs) - The $500 Escorts, Bels, and the V1
B-Grade - The $180 Bel Vector series and even the Whistler Pro-78
F-Grade - Allllllll the others


The difference is so amazing. The A-Grade detectors are in the 90-100 percentile range on performance. The B-Grade will run in the 80-85th percentile. But the others...wow! How is it they can make a detector that is so lousy at detecting radar? Well...ok, Escort/Bel/Valentine do have a good number of patents. But we're talking the 10-15th percentile!

I hope the TPX is good at it's primary function as they really did think out the other parts for motorcyclists. I'm interested to see some independent lab testing on it.

WheelieChuck
12-13-2008, 12:13 PM
Okay, got back from my trip with the TPX, and all I have to say is... this thing is awesome!

The installation went smooth and easy. Very simple and straightforward, took me about 45 minutes.

We ended up going to Sacramento because one of our buddies had to bail last minute.

I took the 5 on the way up to Sac Town and 99 on the way down. I was definitely going at a good pace both ways and aside from a handful of what I thought was false positives, the TPX sniffed out cops like a champ! What I did was I had the detector on the City No X setting and each time it goes off, I roll off the throttle and if it starts to beep again, then I get down to legal speed and look out for cops.

The first time that it really did its thing was when I had just gotten over the Grapevine and probably going at about 100+, the initial beep came on, then I backed off the throttle, then it continued to beep so I slowed down quickly to 70 and sure enough, about 30 seconds later, I see a CHP on the side of the road. Not sure if he was looking for speedsters as his vehicle was pointing with the direction of traffic, but the TPX sniffed him out. It also picked up CHP coming from the opposite direction.

On the way back, there were definitely more cops on the 99, and in Bakersfield, I think it saved me from getting a ticket. I was cruising along and the initial beep came on followed quickly by the constant beep, so I put on the brakes and I started looking around for cops. About a few seconds later I went through an overpass and as soon as I got past it, I see a CHP parked on the on ramp. At this point I thought to myself, thank God for the TPX because without it, it would've gone by him definitely faster than the posted speed limit. Just as I was finishing up my thought, a truck went zipping by me and sure enough, the CHP started moving and zoomed by me and pulled the truck over.

Now, I'm no radar detector expert by any means, but this thing saved my butt and I can't tell you how happy I am!

Anyway, I still appreciate all your input, even though I ended up getting the TPX instead of the others (in case you can't tell, I had my mind set on it from the get go). I got another trip coming to Arizona and I'll try to post here and let you know how my trip went with the TPX.

amnesia
12-18-2008, 01:26 PM
I think Wheelichuck has hit the nail on the head. It's not like driving a car, where playing with your toys is half the fun. On a bike, ergonomics is everything! The less obtrusive the better! Obviously, the TPX worked for him, and it wasn't nearly the hassle that an Escort or Valentine would be. Granted, it's not going to perform as well as an Escort or Valentine, but at least it's there and working - rain or shine; not left at home because he couldn't be bothered to set it up. I use a Whistler Cruisader (which I don't think is a great performer) because it's built in and I don't have to think about it. I've never gotten a ticket so I guess it's doing it's job.
Would I like better performance? Of course. Would I put up with any more hassle to get it? NO WAY!
Radar on a bike is a completely different issue than on a car. TPX is on the right track, and I'm sure with time they will get it right.

Just my 2 cents worth.

love4steel
03-28-2009, 12:56 PM
as far as the h.a.r.d. system you mention you'll be using... have you looked into vizalert as well. Im wondering which system is better??

zr1
05-19-2009, 09:46 AM
as far as the h.a.r.d. system you mention you'll be using... have you looked into vizalert as well. Im wondering which system is better??

I use the H.A.R.D. system and it does well. It's a single LED that lights up when your RD is alerting. You still have to look down at the RD to figure out what it is alerting to.

I don't have the VizAlert, but it is a much more intelligent system. With different LEDs in the helmet, you get the information as to what the RD is alerting to without looking down.

RacerX
05-19-2009, 01:30 PM
The H.A.R.D. is not waterproof and it's a single flashing red light like zr1 says.
the vizalert is waterproof and gives band id, so you know if it's an X false you can ignore or a ka or laser threat you need to pay attention to.

good example, you're approaching an intersection with a k band false, suddenly a ka alert comes across. with the HARD, you still have the same flashing LED, with the Vizalert, it will show the ka alert and you know something is ahead.

I run mine with the V1 and it works great. i also use the C100 for all the speed camera alerts and set the audible alert speed at 30, so i don't have to hear radar alerts under 30, which works great at cutting out a lot of false noise, but i still get the visual.