PDA

View Full Version : Whistler Pro-73 Review: Part One



gtp405
09-25-2005, 02:02 AM
Hey,

I just got a Whistler Pro-73, and there seems to be very little information on this radar detector, or any Whistler at that, so I'm going to do a review on it for everyone. I only took it on a small trip tonight, but in a few weeks, when I've used it quite a bit, I'll write a big review. Until then, there won't be much on LEO encounters (haven't had one yet), but for now, I'll write everything else.

Important things to note before you read this:

-The detector has been in highway mode every time I've used it so far; however I am driving in the city.
-The detector is mounted below the rear view mirror, as high as it can get without the mirror getting in the way of the rear laser reception.
-POP mode is on.
-I'm driving a '99 Grand Prix GTP. I couldn't mount a detector too low in the car because of the way the dash is designed, although I like to mount high anyways.

*Display*

I can really see where this display would be hard to see in the sun, but mounting it high helps a lot. One of the main reasons I decided to get the Pro-73 vs. the Pro-58, was the display. The 73's display is much more user friendly for selecting options/turning features on and off. Do note, I've never used a 58, just seen pictures of the display, so, this display review is probably a little bias, but the pictures of the 58 give me a pretty good idea of how it would be to work with. Another thing I like about the display is that, instead of just giving a number for signal strength, it gives you a bar graph as well. There is a dim feature for night time too, with 3 levels: regular, dim, and dark mode. Regular is nice and bright, dim is perfect for night time driving in the city where there are street lights, and dark mode is perfect for pitch black roads with no light at all.

*Ease of use*

Once you get used to this detector, it's really easy to operate. Turning it on is simple (obviously :roll: ) and once you turn it on, it goes through a "boot" process, and tests every alert except laser. Then it shows whether certain options are enabled or not. Then it finishes, and says what mode you are in. There is highway, city, city 1, and city 2. Highway is obvious, all bands, full sensitivity. City mode is the same as highway mode except when a weak alert comes about, it beeps twice, and then stops, unless the signal gets stronger. City 1 mode is decreased X-band sensitivity, and city 2 mode has no X-band. Adjusting options is really easy, but first, let's talk about the buttons (you can't set options without the buttons! 8). The buttons are nice, but the only bad thing I noticed is that you have to push them firmly, otherwise they don't do anything. All in all they do work well though. Some buttons have one function, some have two. Basically, if it has one function, you hit it, and it does what it is labeled to do. If it has two functions, you hit it to do one function, and hold it down to do the other function. Once you hold down the menu button, it goes into a mode where you use the volume buttons to turn things on and off, and continue to tap the menu button to cycle through the different options. Here are the options you can set (in order):

-Tone: Select between 3 different tone sets
-Test: Here you choose whether or not you want each band to test its tone at startup as mentioned earlier.
-VG-2: Enable or disable VG-2 detection
-SR: Enable or disable Safety Radar detection
-Voice: Enable or disable a voice that tells you what band the detector has picked up
-POP: Enable or disable POP detection mode
-B SVR: This enables or disables a battery saver, which automatically turns the detector off after 3 hours if no buttons have been pushed. It's nice if you forget to turn the detector off when you leave your car.

*Falsing*

I can't give you a very in depth review on falsing, as I haven't been using this detector long enough. But, on my trip tonight, (round trip), I only got 2 falses (they were Ka). And they were only on my way to my destination, not when I was coming back. And, maybe a coincidence, but I noticed that both falses happened when I was completely stopped. I had POP detection enabled, so that probably played a role. Even though this detector has no special indicator of POP detection, it's pretty easy to figure out. If it's constant on, it will beep, and it won't stop until you leave the area, if it's instant on, the detector will say "pulse", so if it just beeps Ka for a few seconds, you know it must be POP, and there's a good chance it's a false alert.

*Moutning*

This detector is a breeze to mount. Everything about this detector is kind of small, and I mean that in a good way. It doesn't get in the way of your field of view etc. There are two ways to use this detector, mounted on the windshield, or, set on the dash. The unit comes with both a suction cup mount, and a dash pad. Personally, because I like to mount high, I used the suction cups. It uses two suction cups and a small rubber stopper, instead of 3 suction cups, or one huge one. It's in an upside-down triangle shape, two suction cups on top, then the rubber stopper at the bottom. The quick release works great, goes on easy, and comes off easy. No problems there. The metal mounting bracket is strong, but just flexible enough so you can bend it to angle properly with your window. The straight cord (this one doesn't come with a coiled cord) is long and light weight, and goes in the detector well. You can tell when you're plugging this unit in that you won't have to worry about the power cord falling out, both the end that fits in the detector, and the end that goes into your car, fit very tight.

*Quality*

Personally, I think this product is very good in this department, especially for the price. The only thing that I noticed is that when the detector is attached to the mounting bracket, you can wiggle the bracket just a little bit. But, that does not mean that the quick release/mounting mechanism inside the detector is no good, because it works very well, as stated earlier, it slides in and out no problem, and clicks in nicely. This is just a small problem that doesn't really matter anyways, as the amount of wiggle is completely acceptable, it won't be flopping all over the place, so don’t worry about that. When I got this detector, the box was designed nice inside, and held the detector well, for safety in transit. The unit itself seems very solid, and looks very well built. I also noticed that the suction cups were soft and flexible, so much that they reminded me of huge contacts, and they held very well to the windshield.

There's much more to come as I use it more, and have some LEO encounters. Thanks for reading! Expect a part two to be out sometime in October.

carlito
09-26-2005, 10:05 AM
nice! keep us postted





carlito

SpeedFreak
09-26-2005, 08:32 PM
Thanks for the review! I was looking to get a backup RD and i think it will be the 73, looking foward for the 2nd part :wink:

boomerman
09-26-2005, 10:14 PM
GTP405 nice post!!
There are other reviews here for the PRO58 and 73.
I have posted a few results of my own with the PRO58.

The only difference between the PRO 58 and the 73 is the display which you mentioned and the voice alerts on the 73. Everything else is exactly the same.
As you can see by your owners manual since it is the same one for both units.

KA falses are going to be very common with this unit! Get used to it.
That has been one of my complaints about this unit since I got it.

I expect falses with x band and k but not as many KA as I have had with my PRO58 unit.
My unit has even been sent back to Whistler and they say it is within factory specs so I can rule out on getting a bad one.

For the money it is a good unit when it gets real alerts but the falses just drive me crazy :lol:

Speedqueen and I are going to do some testing on the PRO58 and the 1773 with the Kustom Falcon K band gun that I just got so I will be posting some results in the next few weeks.

I think for the most part you will be very happy with your purchase.
Get out there and give us some reports.

ES13Raven
09-29-2005, 09:47 PM
KA falses are going to be very common with this unit! Get used to it.
That has been one of my complaints about this unit since I got it.
It depends on where you live....

I get a few Ka falses, but more K. Overall, I would say that the Pro-58 does well with filtering out falses. I run City-2 Mode which turns off X band. No falses there. :wink:

SportsFan
10-24-2005, 10:27 PM
Hey,

I just got a Whistler Pro-73, and there seems to be very little information on this radar detector, or any Whistler at that, so I'm going to do a review on it for everyone.................

There's much more to come as I use it more, and have some LEO encounters. Thanks for reading! Expect a part two to be out sometime in October.

Hey gtp, great thread. Thanks for sharing your opinion and info. I am in the market for a radar detector, and this model (Whistler Pro-73) is one I am seriously considering and looking at.

So since you said you would have a "part two out sometime in October"....and we're nearing the end of the month, what can you add and/or share with us about your experiences?

gtp405
10-28-2005, 06:49 PM
Just letting you know I'm still here! To everyone else wondering about my part two, I don't want to post yet because I haven't had any LEO encounters yet in the roughly two months I've had it. Quite rediculus, I know. There is very little traffic enforcement where I live, and for some reason, most of the traffic attention seems to be on the west side of my city, wheras I live on the more eastern side. However, my friend has had the same detector as I have, for about as long as I have, and he happened to make a trip into Chicago, and got a lot of hits on the highway. Mostly X band here in Illinois. He's had about 4 encounters so far and he said he had more than enough time to slow down with all of them. Note that one of the hits was pulse, and the detector performed well, he hasn't had a laser hit yet though.

If there are any specific questions you have about the unit though, feel free to post here and I'll try to check back and reply as quickly as possible.

Thanks for your patience!

gtp405

ES13Raven
10-30-2005, 02:06 PM
KA falses are going to be very common with this unit! Get used to it.
That has been one of my complaints about this unit since I got it.

Bomerman,

Do you have POP on or off?

boomerman
10-30-2005, 05:15 PM
I have POP on.I have used it with POP on and off no difference in falsing.

ES13Raven
10-30-2005, 06:16 PM
Yes you did.... :wink:

Well I was able to disable the "P" POP/Pulse setting like he said but the funny thing after I did that I got falses in places I never did before.

I drive the same route everyday to and from work and in several spots I would get KA falses of all things.

I would not recommend using this setting.
I was just wondering if you still had it in POP off mode, and that is why you were getting so many Ka falses. I was just curious, because I hardly get any on Ka, but I get a lot more on K.

I also think the K range is better than Ka on the 58.

boomerman
10-30-2005, 07:39 PM
Yes I did say that and like I said it makes no difference in falses the thing still falses only more with the POP off.

I let Jimbonzzz use it for a couple of weeks and he had the same results as me with it falsing on KA.
Jim and I thnk the unit is reporting some k alert falses as KA falses.
I know if I trigger my kustom falcon K band gun fast enough it will report ka alert on the unit.
My 1773 falses the same as the pro58 does.
I think it is just a whistler trademark hahahahaaha.

I am glad yours does not false as much as mine does, I guess you could say that is both good and bad news.
Good news it does not false as much, bad news may also mean that it may not be as sensitive or not working correctly. :lol:

My PRO 58 has been sent back to Whistler and it is within factory specs so I know it is working correctly.

Just last night I am driving with it and all of a sudden it goes to KA pulse at full strength and I was the only one on the interstate and no one was around for miles.
The V1 just sitting as quiet as could be, If I would have belived the whistler I would have been slamming on the brakes :lol:

I think I am going to get rid of the PRO58 and try one of the new models such as the 1776 or 1778 even though whistler says the pro and the 1700 series are built to the same specs.

jimbonzzz
10-30-2005, 08:16 PM
Yeah it did report some known K-Band sources as Ka. compu44 said the same thing about another Whistler unit...

Jim

compu44
10-30-2005, 09:08 PM
Yeah it did report some known K-Band sources as Ka. compu44 said the same thing about another Whistler unit...

Jim

That unit was a Whistler 1665 (I think). It's also happened to me with a Cobra 9870. Something about the cheapies I guess.

gtp405
11-25-2005, 01:02 AM
Well, I finally got two hits on this detector, x and k band. I don't quite think it's enough for a part 2 yet but I'm getting there. My first encounter was on a small two lane road. I pulled out onto the road and laid on it, then stopped at a stop sign. After that I cruised along at a more easy pace. I was going about 52 in the 40 zone. I went over this huge hill on that road, and I mean huge, not in height, it's probably about 100 feet high, but really steep. After that, at about 750 feet from the bottom of the hill is a stoplight. It was red, so I stopped and was in the left turn lane waiting for the green arrow. I saw the pro-73 go off, but with weak signal, starting out at 1 and gaining to 3, nothing new with the pro-73 as it falses every now and then (it's really not as bad with falsing as I thought it would be, you learn how it works, and can figure our false vs. real pretty quickely). Then it goes to 4, then 5 and I knew that this was real, so I started looking around. Sure enough, a cop ended up driving up behind me with mobile constant on k band. Unfortunently, I didn't look in time to see if the pro-73 picked up the signal before the cop came over the hill. The next encounter was x band, I was driving on a somewhat hilly portion of road (small hills this time), and started picking up x band. I was looking around and I couldn't get any kind of visual, and I started to think that the cop was hiding somewhere really good, because for quite a while I couldn't see anyone anywhere. Then when I went over the 3rd or so small hill, and I saw the cop, parked at the battery store. (However I didn't see a car that he had pulled over, but the lights were flashing and his radar was on, so something was going on, weird). The x band detection was impressive, I had more than enough time to slow down, and the cop car was facing to my left, so I'm guessing the gun was too. So therefore if he had been shooting radar in my direction, I would of probably gotten an even better detection distance. Note that just like the first encounter, this officer was using constant on radar.

Will get back with more when I get more encounters!

Quinc
01-30-2006, 08:18 PM
how about an update! :D also have you tried it out in any canyon roads?