View Full Version : Best Wifi Router?
stealthJamal
07-20-2009, 03:54 PM
Best to me = Fastest speed, least amount of latency, and with WPA2 encryption enabled.
Pyrofallout
07-20-2009, 04:06 PM
Best/Fastest and Wirelsss are an oxymoron.
If your serously worried about speed and latency, the real solution is to run a cable. Cat5/5e/6 is cheap. Wireless blows.
FWIW, I have a wireless router that the wife uses with the laptop. I run a WRT-350N from Linksys with DD-WRT software. Does any and everything you could ever want from a router with gigabit ethernet with 802.11n wireless.
stealthJamal
07-20-2009, 04:14 PM
I know wireless blows and running a cable is better, but in my case I am not always going to be using an Ethernet cable.
crazyVOLVOrob
07-21-2009, 12:22 PM
Wow I feel insecure about my my router after searching for the new ones. (I have 54mb/s Linksys WRT54G:o. plenty fast for me with 2 computers on my apartment server. And does a decent job of my PS3 online games. I got it for free so can't complain) but DAMN :eek: they have routers that are up 1000mb/s.
Pyrofallout
07-21-2009, 12:28 PM
Wow I feel insecure about my my router after searching for the new ones. (I have 54mb/s Linksys WAP54G:o. plenty fast for me with 2 computers on my apartment server. And does a decent job of my PS3 online games. I got it for free so can't complain) but DAMN :eek: they have routers that are up 1000mb/s.
A WAP54G is not a router, its just a wireless access point.
FoolishOne
07-21-2009, 12:41 PM
DD-WRT > everything else
AirMoore
07-21-2009, 01:17 PM
I always have had good luck with the higher-end linksys products, and thus we run it at my house...
Normally we have 5 or 6 computers, and (always) one wireless printer at night doing various things and I am still able to stream HD video (720P) through my computer... and watch F1 highlights on their website in 1280x768 @ the needed 2400KBPS rate without an issue.
crazyVOLVOrob
07-21-2009, 04:55 PM
Wow I feel insecure about my my router after searching for the new ones. (I have 54mb/s Linksys WAP54G:o. plenty fast for me with 2 computers on my apartment server. And does a decent job of my PS3 online games. I got it for free so can't complain) but DAMN :eek: they have routers that are up 1000mb/s.
A WAP54G is not a router, its just a wireless access point.
I actually have a router I misspoke the model number as I was at the office
happya$$
07-21-2009, 05:11 PM
Apple router is very good
Pyrofallout
07-21-2009, 06:43 PM
DD-WRT > everything else
This guy has the right idea. ;)
A linksys router with DD-WRT loaded is more powerful than any consumer router on the market. With features like those of business level routers, for a fraction of the cost.
FoolishOne
07-21-2009, 07:25 PM
For FREE you can turn your Linksys ("residential Cisco") into a high performance, full-blown ISP-level Cisco router.
PMoth
07-21-2009, 07:37 PM
I always have had good luck with the higher-end linksys products, and thus we run it at my house...
Normally we have 5 or 6 computers, and (always) one wireless printer at night doing various things and I am still able to stream HD video (720P) through my computer... and watch F1 highlights on their website in 1280x768 @ the needed 2400KBPS rate without an issue.
PMoth chants.... F1 F1 F1 F1 F1 !!!!!!!!!!!:D Die Bernie and Max die!!!!;)
I like the Linksys stuff. Pretty reliable and the wired connection is wicked!
crazyVOLVOrob
07-22-2009, 10:33 AM
For FREE you can turn your Linksys ("residential Cisco") into a high performance, full-blown ISP-level Cisco router.
how?:confused:
FoolishOne
07-22-2009, 11:35 AM
Using DD-WRT.
I should have been more specific. DD-WRT will get you half way there: you'll have the software of those big routers, but your hardware is a bit lacking. The processors that actually do the packet switching, et cetera, will most likely be slower on the Linksys, but with <20 (? pulled out of butt) ordinary users, you won't notice the lack of power difference.
lostidentity
07-22-2009, 02:04 PM
Wow I feel insecure about my my router after searching for the new ones. (I have 54mb/s Linksys WRT54G:o. plenty fast for me with 2 computers on my apartment server. And does a decent job of my PS3 online games. I got it for free so can't complain) but DAMN :eek: they have routers that are up 1000mb/s.
With routers that have gigabit speeds you will never end up using all of it. Those speeds could only be used in a local transfer such as over your network.
These speeds are aimed at the business class, where hundreds if not thousands of users would need access to a high speed connection.
Most DSL users in the US usually have a downstream rate of 3-5 Mbps.
Cable users share bandwidth and with DOCSIS 2 being the most prevalent standard at this time the bandwidth that is shared between an area is about 42 Mb.
Once fiber and DOCSIS 3 become more prevalent I could see these faster routers becoming useful because DOCSIS 3 supports integrating multiple channels so instead of just 42 Mb being allotted to an area 171 Mb could be (assuming they integrate 4 channels).
But on the router, if you dont like tweaking stuff get a d-link they are incredibly easy to setup. If you want to tweak everything to squeeze every last bit of bandwidth out of it get a Linksys and load DD-WRT or tomato onto it. Check your modems settings too.
Pyrofallout
07-22-2009, 03:41 PM
Wow I feel insecure about my my router after searching for the new ones. (I have 54mb/s Linksys WRT54G:o. plenty fast for me with 2 computers on my apartment server. And does a decent job of my PS3 online games. I got it for free so can't complain) but DAMN :eek: they have routers that are up 1000mb/s.
With routers that have gigabit speeds you will never end up using all of it. Those speeds could only be used in a local transfer such as over your network.
These speeds are aimed at the business class, where hundreds if not thousands of users would need access to a high speed connection.
Most DSL users in the US usually have a downstream rate of 3-5 Mbps.
Cable users share bandwidth and with DOCSIS 2 being the most prevalent standard at this time the bandwidth that is shared between an area is about 42 Mb.
Once fiber and DOCSIS 3 become more prevalent I could see these faster routers becoming useful because DOCSIS 3 supports integrating multiple channels so instead of just 42 Mb being allotted to an area 171 Mb could be (assuming they integrate 4 channels).
But on the router, if you dont like tweaking stuff get a d-link they are incredibly easy to setup. If you want to tweak everything to squeeze every last bit of bandwidth out of it get a Linksys and load DD-WRT or tomato onto it. Check your modems settings too.
You may not use the full potential of gigabit ethernet, but if you have machines with gig cards and decent hard drives you can def use more than 100Mbps. Streaming HD video over gigabit is far better than a standard 10/100 connection. Also moving large files or performing backups over a network can greatly benefit from a gigabit network.
also, even the routers that have gigabit switches built in do not usually have a gigabit port on the wan side. its pointless for consumers. hardly any consumers have anywhere near a 100mb connection.
But for the average consumer using their network for mostly internet access only any router will work just as well as the next one. Even if your running a 10mbps network, chances are your internet can't outrun that unless you have a high end internet package from isp.
also, cable is geographically shared connections, but support a whole lot more than 42 mbps collectively. and regardless of how much is shared, nearly all cable isp will still but a bandwidth cap on the modem.
that being said, docsis 3 will pwn all. :D
Tambourine-Man
07-22-2009, 04:06 PM
If you want more info, go here:
Sveasoft (http://www.sveasoft.com)
Click FAQs as there is no obvious link to their forums.
There is a good forum including info on what routers are recommended.
I run a Mesh network at my cottage on two old Linksys router that covers about 1 1/2 miles. There are better ones now.
I think the Linksys WRT310N gets good marks, but it costs about $100.
lostidentity
07-22-2009, 11:30 PM
You may not use the full potential of gigabit ethernet, but if you have machines with gig cards and decent hard drives you can def use more than 100Mbps. Streaming HD video over gigabit is far better than a standard 10/100 connection. Also moving large files or performing backups over a network can greatly benefit from a gigabit network.
also, even the routers that have gigabit switches built in do not usually have a gigabit port on the wan side. its pointless for consumers. hardly any consumers have anywhere near a 100mb connection.
But for the average consumer using their network for mostly internet access only any router will work just as well as the next one. Even if your running a 10mbps network, chances are your internet can't outrun that unless you have a high end internet package from isp.
also, cable is geographically shared connections, but support a whole lot more than 42 mbps collectively. and regardless of how much is shared, nearly all cable isp will still but a bandwidth cap on the modem.
that being said, docsis 3 will pwn all. :D
Hell yea network transfers are where its at.
HDDs are one of the biggest bottlenecks of performance on a computer.
I have a NAS setup with 10,000 rpm raptors in my basement. stream movies music and whatever else that i dont use exclusively with my computer.
On the note of docsis 3, I'm looking forward to that because we have the business package and our bandwidth will jump considerably. Maybe i will stop getting threatening letters from my isp to stop using so much bandwidth lol
ahmadr
07-24-2009, 09:01 AM
I use DD-WRT myself and it's great, but wouldn't recommend it for the non computer savvy...
My 2 cents :)
ZPrime
07-24-2009, 04:05 PM
If you're not afraid of Linux, DD-WRT plus a Buffalo or Linksys 54GL unit are great.
Otherwise, get yourself an Apple Airport. Hell, if you want dual-radio 802.11N, the Apple is one of the best units out there. I'm a big PC guy, but I recently got a Macbook Pro for work and I picked up an Airport Extreme at the same time. It has been absolutely flawless on every device in my house, where a WRT54GL running DD-WRT would drop connection from time to time. I also had issues with an enterprise-grade D-Link unit that I borrowed from work for a few months. G was ok, but 5 ghz (A) frequencies had problems from time to time.
With the Airport Extreme, I'm running 2.4 as b/g for legacy clients, and my wife and I are both connecting to a different SSID for N running on 5ghz. I have absolutely zero problems with the 5ghz radio on the airport, plus it has gigabit ports on the back and allowed me to eliminate a switch that was sitting on my TV stand for my Tivo and Xbox. :)
sethy
07-28-2009, 05:45 PM
DD-WRT > everything else
This guy has the right idea. ;)
A linksys router with DD-WRT loaded is more powerful than any consumer router on the market. With features like those of business level routers, for a fraction of the cost.
x3 that is what I am running.
I am not sure if d-link still has their routers that supply "packet bursting" which provides a connection of 108mb. However, the true speed you get is roughly a 70mb connection
stealthJamal
07-29-2009, 12:43 AM
holy $hit, it's Sethy. How you been?
thestaton
09-22-2009, 11:29 AM
Apple Airport Extremes. Yes OMG they cost a lot of money, and yes they are white, with the trendy apple logo.
Having used DD-WRT on a few Linkysys and Tomato they just didn't get the job done. I would still end up restarting them every 2 weeks instead of every other day which was nice but still a hassle.
I've had one airport extreme the g model for 4 years now, and it's never had to be restarted. Only for a firmware update, or if I where moving it around.
After I converted everything over to N I picked up the new Airport Extreme that supports N, and in a little over a year I've had to restart it once.
My theory isn't that Apple's software is any better, I think it's just the hardware. Take the same hardware that apple uses and put DD-WRT on it, and you would end up with a high end routing machine.
DrCoke
09-22-2009, 01:33 PM
I bought the Airport Extreame for $180 and returned it. I guess I had a defective one. The WIFI using 5G on the MacBook Pro is too d@m slow. Ending up buying a D-link and it was back to being fast. I'm sure any brand would work great as long as its dual band in case you got more than 1 thing running WIFI.
voyager7
09-22-2009, 01:49 PM
For home use a LinkSys will do you just fine.
I am running 5 computers (1 wireless) 2 X-box 360s, a ps2 and a print server.
No problem. Hard wire is the way to go, if you have the tools a cat 5/5e/6 is easy to make and a lot cheaper then buying.
I took the time and hard wired my house, any room you go into has a Ethernet port in the wall.
My home is 121 years old and wiring it was tricky but I managed to get it done.
OPTiK
09-23-2009, 09:05 AM
You want the best? Pick up a Routerboard w/Mikrotik's RouterOS.
"Best/Fastest and Wirelsss are an oxymoron." -> Not Quite. Wireless N is pretty damn fast.
"DD-WRT > everything else" -> Not true. I actually hate DD-WRT, its an incomplete piece with almost not tech support for things that don't work. RouterOS is pwn.
untrueparadox
09-23-2009, 06:00 PM
You want the best? Pick up a Routerboard w/Mikrotik's RouterOS.
"Best/Fastest and Wirelsss are an oxymoron." -> Not Quite. Wireless N is pretty damn fast.
"DD-WRT > everything else" -> Not true. I actually hate DD-WRT, its an incomplete piece with almost not tech support for things that don't work. RouterOS is pwn.
wired is much faster than the real world throughput of wireless N. something like 80mbps if ur lucky when ur a reasonable distance away using the 5ghz band. the theoretical speed of 300mbps is impossible to reach. really, wireless g advertises 54mbps, but unless if ur sitting right next to the router, its like 5mbps.
add on extra clients, ur network would be crawling. remember, a wireless access point/router is a hub, ur sharing the bandwidth between however many units. so if ur sending a file from one wireless client to another wireless, ud be getting about 50mbps at the most for the 2. if u got 5 clients simultaneously using the wireless band, u get like 1mbps per client, and thats slower than most of ur internet speeds.
fastest way is still through wired. u get 1000mbps, and the real world speed is closer to about 800-900mbps. ur hard drive doesnt even read and write that fast.
for many routers that need to be restarted every couple weeks with dd-wrt, chances are, theyre not fully optimized for them. asus routers are rock solid, and so are linksys and cisco. if u have the budget for a airport, get the wrt610n from linksys, u wont be disappointed. the stock firmware has more functions than dd-wrt offers.
OPTiK
09-24-2009, 08:59 AM
wired is much faster than the real world throughput of wireless N. something like 80mbps if ur lucky when ur a reasonable distance away using the 5ghz band. the theoretical speed of 300mbps is impossible to reach. really, wireless g advertises 54mbps, but unless if ur sitting right next to the router, its like 5mbps.
Wired will always be faster than wireless so your right, but the fact is do you really need a 1 gigabit network connection? Not unless you have a gigabit internet or a raid setup capable of sustaining gigabit file transfers. Most people at most will run a 20 mbps internet download, at which point your wireless N will be more than adequate.
add on extra clients, ur network would be crawling. remember, a wireless access point/router is a hub, ur sharing the bandwidth between however many units. so if ur sending a file from one wireless client to another wireless, ud be getting about 50mbps at the most for the 2. if u got 5 clients simultaneously using the wireless band, u get like 1mbps per client, and thats slower than most of ur internet speeds.
This is true if the traffic is sustained. If everyone that is connected to the hub is just browsing the internet then it will not slow down the wireless network since it is a short burst operation, but if everyone is torrenting then it will. Adding extra client will not necessarily slow down your network.
fastest way is still through wired. u get 1000mbps, and the real world speed is closer to about 800-900mbps. ur hard drive doesnt even read and write that fast.
True, but that just goes back to the idea do you really need wired? You really just want to match/exceed your internet bandwidth which wireless N will do.
thestaton
09-24-2009, 09:16 AM
I just did a test on my N network.
Upload was the limit at 10meg a sec.
OPTiK
09-24-2009, 12:16 PM
I just did a test on my N network.
Upload was the limit at 10meg a sec.
Thats basically ~80 mbps, which is pretty good in my opinion, and way faster than any internet you can get in the US (unless optimum fiber 101/20 is going)
thestaton
09-24-2009, 12:18 PM
I just did a test on my N network.
Upload was the limit at 10meg a sec.
Thats basically ~80 mbps, which is pretty good in my opinion, and way faster than any internet you can get in the US (unless optimum fiber 101/20 is going)
oh, it's way more than this cable connection could ever demand. Right now it's just 2 megs down (turbo mode, late am only) during the day it's about a meg down & about a meg up.
I can take the laptop pretty much anywhere in the house and get a clear HD feed w/ the Sling Box. Range is almost double that of G, but once you start to get to the boundaries, I might get 10k a second.
KenV99
12-14-2009, 02:37 PM
IMHO, it depends on what kind of clients you are trying to connect and what kind of data they will be carrying. XBOX? Laptop? HTPC? VOip phone? Will this be a g-only network or n-only or mixed? Are you going to stream hi-def video? Will you need robust QOS? What is the greatest distance that you will need to connect and is the placement multi-story?
Also, what kind of connectivity do you need from the WAN back into the LAN? Do you need an easy to connect and configure VPN? Will you be running a public facing server?
Pyrofallout
12-15-2009, 08:05 AM
FWIW, since my last post in here I have switched to a Airport Extreme Base Station, mainly for the simultaneos dual band wifi, but I also can connect my drobo and printer and access them across the network and across the WAN thanks to MobileMe.
sdmills
12-16-2009, 12:15 PM
I'm running a Belkin Gigabit-N with WPA2/PSK and a 36 character paraphrase. I only get 100bps rather than N-speeds, but it's more than sufficient for my home system. I've run it for going on two years and am extremely happy with it.
wumba
12-17-2009, 06:19 PM
X however man said Linksys + DD-WRT
I really think the WRT54g is the best all around still. Sad, I know. I have used several models of the WRT54g and wrt54g2, not to mention a few D-Link, Netgear, Actiontec, and Asus routers. Linksys are fairly easy setup (in my mind, I don't use the disk), and DD-WRT is still the best after market firmware.
That being said I agree with the above posts re: technical savvy. If you are not familiar you will probably be lost. The second gen of those suck BTW, the "coiled" antenna is about as useful as a glass mount cb antenna. I've worked with both router types in multiple revisions in varied environments.
From what I have read the new Wifi speeds still aren't standardized. Not a good idea IMO.
PS Don't forget to change your admin password and enable wpa! Wep is terrible security and wpa is also weak (can be cracked in ~10 minutes with a dictionary brute force attack). For businesses the recommendation is to run an encrypted VPN on top of the WPA encryption. Doubt you need this...
Idontgo55
12-17-2009, 06:38 PM
Linksys wrt300n is what I use Never had a problem with it works great