PDA

View Full Version : Is Immediancy Of Response Really Important?



RunningRabbit
11-25-2005, 11:01 AM
I got to thinking... how really important is this? So I ran a few calculations...

30 MPH = 44 feet per second traveled
40 MPH = 58.6 feet per second traveled
50 MPH = 73.3 feet per second traveled
60 MPH = 88 feet per second traveled
70 MPH = 102.6 feet per second travel
80 MPH = 117.3 feet per second traveled
90 MPH = 132 feet per second traveled
100 MPH = 146.6 feet per second traveled

So if you have a radar detector that warns you a half a second sooner than another, say at 80 MPH. You were warned 58.5 feet sooner if the detectors both picked up radar at the exact same time.

If a detector had slightly less sensitivity than another, It's response time may make up for that and the alert may sound at the same time as the slightly more sensitive one.

Obviously, at higher speeds, immediancy of response is more important. Speedzones did a test on this and the two Bel units did very well.

SpeedFreak
11-25-2005, 08:03 PM
Nice calculations, sometimes you can be saved by seconds. Immediancy Of Response is a good thing to check when shopping for RDs

spankyaf
11-28-2005, 05:27 PM
With Laser we're talking milliseconds (.3 sec) for a lock. You bet its important

Techhead
12-16-2005, 04:20 PM
The V1 Responded well in this test...

http://www.radardetector.net/V1-vs.-8500-X50-instant-on-shootout-865t.php

jimbonzzz
12-16-2005, 06:16 PM
There's another video to that shows a similar thing: V1 vs X50 on K-Band: one of the jammertests videos that Chris did.

http://www.jammertests.com/f/JammerTests.com_tests_V1X50_POP.wmv

For those that don't know, the video was supposed to be a POP video, however it was later found to not actually be in POP mode, so the video was a quick-trigger instant-on video. (Detals on this here:
http://www.radardetector.net/viewtopic.php?t=1156)

Jim

ghz1
12-16-2005, 09:58 PM
My dealer tells the bell Bell 995 is one of the fastest. Even faster than the V1 .825 (they tell me). But i would rather wait another 1/2 sec or so and get no false Ka hits any day of they week. The only time i wish the V1 was a bit faster would be when mobile speed camera's are mounted just around a shape corner. For the record ive never had a ticket from them yet the V1 will still give enough warning.

crazyVOLVOrob
12-16-2005, 11:56 PM
My dealer tells the bell Bell 995 is one of the fastest. Even faster than the V1 .825 (they tell me). But i would rather wait another 1/2 sec or so and get no false Ka hits any day of they week. The only time i wish the V1 was a bit faster would be when mobile speed camera's are mounted just around a shape corner. For the record ive never had a ticket from them yet the V1 will still give enough warning.According the SML shootout, It is the fastest!!! And by the way I have never had a False KA alert......Keep in mind they didn't over load the detectors with a signal

Detector----------Immediacy of Response Time

Bel Vector 995 ----------0.60 second

Bel RX 65----------0.67 second

Whistler ( all models)----------0.73 second

Bel 895----------0.77 second

Passport X50----------0.96 second

Valentine One----------1.01 second

Cobra ( both models)----------1.24 second

PNI Steel Eye----------1.48 second

Radio Shack 3000----------2.34 second

ghz1
12-17-2005, 06:26 AM
yes there are some of things the 995 will not do but my dealer really likes the 995 and it looks like its got a nice build too. So you could say the 995 has a good bang for the bucks. It's not the be all and end all but not bad for the money. bottoms up here here
Ps I wouln't recommend anybody to turn on there Euro mode unless they live in euro land. We have some kind of moblie van gusto ka 34.6 here and euro mode won't help you with S%it here.

Techhead
12-17-2005, 09:10 AM
There's another video to that shows a similar thing: V1 vs X50 on K-Band: one of the jammertests videos that Chris did.

http://www.jammertests.com/f/JammerTests.com_tests_V1X50_POP.wmv

For those that don't know, the video was supposed to be a POP video, however it was later found to not actually be in POP mode, so the video was a quick-trigger instant-on video. (Detals on this here:
http://www.radardetector.net/viewtopic.php?t=1156)

Jim

I like the independent test that you can actually witness the results. These big test groups, you wonder how much of a kick back they get for promoting a product. Even though they claim they are unbiased. Seeing is believing! 8)

crazyVOLVOrob
12-17-2005, 11:08 AM
yes there are some of things the 995 will not do but my dealer really likes the 995 and it looks like its got a nice build too. So you could say the 995 has a good bang for the bucks. It's not the be all and end all but not bad for the money. bottoms up here here
Ps I wouln't recommend anybody to turn on there Euro mode unless they live in euro land. We have some kind of moblie van gusto ka 34.6 here and euro mode won't help you with S%it here.I could be wrong but Euromode is used to scan spefically for that band of radar.....

995 is a great bang for your buck and is right up with the top 3...minus some features

carlito
12-17-2005, 12:16 PM
My dealer tells the bell Bell 995 is one of the fastest. Even faster than the V1 .825 (they tell me). But i would rather wait another 1/2 sec or so and get no false Ka hits any day of they week. The only time i wish the V1 was a bit faster would be when mobile speed camera's are mounted just around a shape corner. For the record ive never had a ticket from them yet the V1 will still give enough warning.According the SML shootout, It is the fastest!!! And by the way I have never had a False KA alert......Keep in mind they didn't over load the detectors with a signal

Detector----------Immediacy of Response Time

Bel Vector 995 ----------0.60 second

Bel RX 65----------0.67 second

Whistler ( all models)----------0.73 second

Bel 895----------0.77 second

Passport X50----------0.96 second

Valentine One----------1.01 second

Cobra ( both models)----------1.24 second

PNI Steel Eye----------1.48 second

Radio Shack 3000----------2.34 second

For those mobile speed camera put your V1 in Euromode if they are Multinova's I dont really agree with this test SML did.I my self find that the VEctor895 is alot slower at detecting radar than the x50 its alot faster 8)


carlito

mplsfalls
12-19-2005, 05:55 PM
This is the exact reason I will not buy a V1. It seems like some people would rather have their V1 than the ability to think independantly. I fear losing my abilty to reason from looking at the arrows.

SmaartAasSaabr
12-19-2005, 08:07 PM
This is the exact reason I will not buy a V1. It seems like some people would rather have their V1 than the ability to think independantly. I fear losing my abilty to reason from looking at the arrows.

http://www.radarfalle.de/technik/warn_stoertechnik/images/v1.jpg

valentine uber alles! :lol:

Hessen
12-19-2005, 08:29 PM
This is the exact reason I will not buy a V1. It seems like some people would rather have their V1 than the ability to think independantly. I fear losing my abilty to reason from looking at the arrows.

http://www.radarfalle.de/technik/warn_stoertechnik/images/v1.jpg

valentine uber alles! :lol:

Ein Folk, Ein Reich, Ein Valentine...... :P

mplsfalls
12-20-2005, 12:39 PM
Translate please...

nvr2fast
12-20-2005, 12:54 PM
yes there are some of things the 995 will not do but my dealer really likes the 995 and it looks like its got a nice build too. So you could say the 995 has a good bang for the bucks. It's not the be all and end all but not bad for the money. bottoms up here here
Ps I wouln't recommend anybody to turn on there Euro mode unless they live in euro land. We have some kind of moblie van gusto ka 34.6 here and euro mode won't help you with S%it here.I could be wrong but Euromode is used to scan spefically for that band of radar.....

995 is a great bang for your buck and is right up with the top 3...minus some features

Nope... Euro V1 only scans 34.3Ghz... and at most +/-100Mhz, so thats 34.2-34.4Ghz. I have seen some Multanovas at 34.1xx (when they're supposed to be at 34.3xx) so your mileage may vary. I just wouldn't take the chance turning on the EURO mode.

Techhead
01-08-2006, 10:13 AM
I wonder if in the "Speed Zone" test they had all the available frequencies to scan programmed or any filters on, on the V1. That would make a difference in response time.

It would be nice if the V1 could chop off .40 secs of response time if all conditions were equal, but I personally can not say that my other RD, the X50 is as sensitive from around the corners and over the hills as my V1. Or responded sooner. We will have to see how the latest V1 version does in terms of response time and performance, along with the new STI & others in future testing.

I believe the http://www.guysoflidar.com/ will be running another UNBIASED test this month. Maybe they could do a response time test as well.

Running Rabbit, just one thing. That assumes all constant variables do not change. With atmospheric conditions and other influences, cars, weather, etc, response time can never accurately be measured in the real world.

Lidar Guys, when you doing your next round of tests?

jimbonzzz
01-08-2006, 10:41 AM
The plan is to do some testing later this month. We might be able to test immediacy of response if we have time.

I'm not sure of the best way to test it though. Clearly, the "stopwatch method" used in other tests allows too much room for human error. It has been suggested that we film both the radar and the detector on video, and analyze the video later. That way, we can count the frames between when the radar displays "transmit" and when the detector alerts, or even insert "timers" like Outrun does for his jammer videos. However, that would require having both the detector and the radar visible in the video, and as many of us know, sometimes some very strange things happen at close range due to "overload". Maybe, aiming the gun away from the detector would mitigate the issue some, but I still don't think it is a 100% solution.

Jim

compu44
01-08-2006, 12:00 PM
Well, if the audio doppler sound is immediate when triggering the gun, you could use two microphones, one on the gun and one on the detector, send one to your left channel sound card in, one to the right, and measure the difference in time with a software like CoolEdit.

RunningRabbit
01-14-2006, 10:03 AM
I wonder if in the "Speed Zone" test they had all the available frequencies to scan programmed or any filters on, on the V1. That would make a difference in response time.

It would be nice if the V1 could chop off .40 secs of response time if all conditions were equal, but I personally can not say that my other RD, the X50 is as sensitive from around the corners and over the hills as my V1. Or responded sooner. We will have to see how the latest V1 version does in terms of response time and performance, along with the new STI & others in future testing.

I believe the http://www.guysoflidar.com/ will be running another UNBIASED test this month. Maybe they could do a response time test as well.

Running Rabbit, just one thing. That assumes all constant variables do not change. With atmospheric conditions and other influences, cars, weather, etc, response time can never accurately be measured in the real world.

Lidar Guys, when you doing your next round of tests?

I would tend to agree with you. Ive read cases where the V1 will respond to quick burst of radar and others will not. Yet the V1 was not at the top of the list for immediate response time in this one test from Speedzone.

Suf Daddy
01-25-2006, 08:13 PM
BINGO.......we have a winnahhhhhhhhhh.

Too bad you couldn't easily adapt a LED or light to the transmitter of the radar....

YOu COULD use a split screen with two cameras and a switcher /mixer/Video Caputer board like the security cameras do....

Hmmmm. you Could feed one camera on the radar into a TV near the detector so its all on 1 screen.

WHAT ABOUT a lap top with a capture card (video input) and Jim's V1 software for the signal pick up?

Oh yeah the distances?
http://www.radardetector.net/LIDAR-Sweep-Panning-errors-calculated-by-distance-7457t.php

-Suf Daddy



The plan is to do some testing later this month. We might be able to test immediacy of response if we have time.

I'm not sure of the best way to test it though. Clearly, the "stopwatch method" used in other tests allows too much room for human error. It has been suggested that we film both the radar and the detector on video, and analyze the video later. That way, we can count the frames between when the radar displays "transmit" and when the detector alerts, or even insert "timers" like Outrun does for his jammer videos.
Jim

Holla
01-25-2006, 11:42 PM
This is the exact reason I will not buy a V1. It seems like some people would rather have their V1 than the ability to think independantly. I fear losing my abilty to reason from looking at the arrows.

http://www.radarfalle.de/technik/warn_stoertechnik/images/v1.jpg

valentine uber alles! :lol:

That is the most sexxy picture ever! I dont see the V-1 ever being outdone for a long time---It would take ALOT for me to ever switch RD's

MITHRANDIR
04-01-2006, 10:42 AM
Translate please...

Roughly:

Ein Folk, Ein Reich, Ein Valentine...... :P

One People, One country, One Valentine. :P