PDA

View Full Version : Windshields that limit detector range



OhioDriver
03-07-2005, 04:32 PM
My Valentine v1.8 user manual states that certain windshields such as those on the Chevrolet Venture minivan greatly reduce detection range, due to a metallic film or solar barrier. Since I might be in the market for a new vehicle, (such as a Dodge Caravan or Chrysler van), I called the Valentine toll free number to get an updated list of vehicles on the "windshield problem" list, but they said they don't have an updated list. Does anyone keep such a list?

On the Ohio roads, I get an X-band warning only when I already see the patrol car. To have a sporting chance, it would help to get warnings when the patrol is blasting other cars ahead of mine with the instant-on X-band.

For those who are stuck with a "problem windshield". is there anything that can be done about it? I presume it wouldn't make any difference to get another detector to replace the Valentine v1.8. Replacing the windshield would not be an attractive alternative. What about problems with remotely mounted detectors, aside from the added expense?

:?:

brick
03-07-2005, 05:00 PM
If you really are stuck with a "problem windshield" then a remote is really the only way to go. Even though their performance is limited due to low antenna location it will be significantly better than a regular detector behind a metal film.

I think that you can tell bad winshields apart by their color. Have you ever seen cars driving down the road that have sort of off-color tint (red to purple or gold)? That's what they look like. It's caused by a very thin metallic film that's used as a heating element. If the windshield looks like normal glass I think it should be OK.

fallen8511
03-07-2005, 05:29 PM
Or you could just replace the windshield (provided it has the metal film) you have at a local autoglass place. It costs usually about $200.

cjs180
03-07-2005, 07:11 PM
How about the rear antenna (V1) with a pickup w/ a cap on the back? Will it go through the cap windows providing they are clean? or am I up a creek with out a paddle?

Thanks in advance for any input. Chris

OhioDriver
03-07-2005, 08:00 PM
Thanks for the quick responses. I reread a detailed specifications book, and the Chevy Venture definitely has a metalized coating on the windshield which is touted to keep the vehicle cooler on a hot sunny day. It also has an embedded radio antenna, but that does not span across the entire width of the upper windshield, so the antenna is not a problem.

Amazingly, the Valentine v1.8 responds to laser at the same instant as the Blinder M20, even though the Valentine is mounted behind very dark tint at the top of the windshield. So the main problem with the solar glass is that few early radar warnings can be given, based on other cars in front of me that are being shot with the instant-on X-band.

pemarsh
03-07-2005, 09:34 PM
I too would be interested in such a list....my Lexus has auto wipers...so I wonder if that windshiled has some funky thing on it too

Crash
03-08-2005, 04:24 AM
The only thing for you to do is to enclose the V1 into a housing with plexiglass (or something similar) in the front. Then buy a remote audio adapter and the concealed display, put the housing into the grille with the V1 front having a clear FOV and routing the remote audio adapter and the display to the cabin. You can turn the V1 on and off via the remote audio adapter. It´s a cost effective way to get around the problem.

SETITOFF
03-08-2005, 05:21 AM
How about the rear antenna (V1) with a pickup w/ a cap on the back? Will it go through the cap windows providing they are clean? or am I up a creek with out a paddle?

Thanks in advance for any input. Chris

Your cap is going to be a barrier more so than the windows. RF energy will not pass through the metal/fiberglass cap and very little (if any) will pass through the cap windows. Your rear detection is basically shot.

SETITOFF
03-08-2005, 05:23 AM
I too would be interested in such a list....my Lexus has auto wipers...so I wonder if that windshiled has some funky thing on it too

You may want to check with Lexus to find out what type windshield you have and if it has any affect on radar reception.

SmaartAasSaabr
03-13-2005, 08:19 PM
I am not certain that the Venture is such an animal with the solar barrier windshield.

The top speed of one is only 174km/h anyway so why do you need an RD? :lol:

I do KNOW the older "Dustbuster" GM vans had solar barrier windshields (first cars to have this) because the windshield was just so unbelieveably huge. Especially when compared to one of my 900's with this little curved sliver of glass, maybe weighs 2 pounds :lol:

The Venture is no longer produced, they gave it a Pinnochio treatment and it's now called the Uplander.

marlinspike
03-13-2005, 10:09 PM
Saabr, how do you deal with the curve of the glass? My W126 glass has got such a nasty curve I either have to mount my RD so it's cocked to the left or so that it's rotated on its axis like 30 degrees. I just do a little of both.

SmaartAasSaabr
03-13-2005, 10:20 PM
I use the middle

on either side the detector is pointing directly 90 degrees with straight ahead :shock:

marlinspike
03-13-2005, 10:34 PM
Hmmm, I can't do center cause of my rear view mirror, and even being like 5 inches left of center is so curved. I guess this was the most aerodynamic sedan ever made at the time of its release.
Richard

SmaartAasSaabr
03-13-2005, 10:37 PM
I got mine down low now... my driver's side wiper neatly hides the suction cups...

problem is that the a-pillars are quite narrow (but the strongest ever made at the time...) and the windshield wraps around severely. So a car beside me on either side can see the detector easily if they turn their head around. :x

postman
03-15-2005, 07:20 PM
I have a glare strip across my window :D My detector is on my visor :D The detector has no problem with it :lol: And it is GOOD stuff...Test it at local Mart :D

lordhamster
03-18-2005, 10:39 AM
On the Ohio roads, I get an X-band warning only when I already see the patrol car. To have a sporting chance, it would help to get warnings when the patrol is blasting other cars ahead of mine with the instant-on X-band.


:?:

Sorry to be a little off topic here, but I also have a v1 1.8 and drive in Cleveland. In my 2years of having the detector I have yet to ever see a legitimate X-band hit anywhere I've driven in ohio. Granted, I only ever drive in Northeast ohio and occasionaly down to columbus, or west to chicago or eat to toronto on 90.... but still.

What areas in Ohio use X? I'd even been considering turning off my X band because it drives me nuts. I'm glad to hear from you that it is still in use.

OhioDriver
03-21-2005, 10:15 PM
I rarely seem to encounter X-band in Cuyahoga county, but elsewhere I hit it on I-71, I-271, Rt. 42, Rt 250, Rt 20, and elsewhere. On the two lane roads, they seem to use it only in instant-on mode when you are within about 500 feet, so you don't have time to slow down on a direct hit. The V1.8 occasionally picks up an X-signal when traffic ahead of me is being hit first, but it often only gives a couple of short beeps, making you think you must have picked up a false signal. So I always make sure I'm within the limit if I get any kind of X-warning. Another consideration is that the "L" mode seems to suppress X-warnings too much. I'm speculating that Ohio's instant-on X-band must be a low energy signal that doesn't travel too far, and does not penetrate metalized windows very well.

Zelmo
04-05-2005, 12:36 PM
My wife drives a van that has one of the solar tinted windshields. The only time I would want to put my detector in that vehicle is for a trip. Do these windshields totally ruin the effectiveness of the detectors on K band, or is it just not as good? I don't normally drive the van at speeds that would be a problem, but every now and then you speed up a little to get past a slower moving vehicle in the right lane and to get out of the way of someone on your tail. I would hate to get nailed right at that point.

BiGeAsYgUy
04-05-2005, 01:41 PM
Check here:

http://valentine1.com/lab/Previously6.asp

Zelmo
04-05-2005, 01:49 PM
I had already read that. It doesn't answer my question.

brick
04-05-2005, 02:26 PM
At the very least a windshield like that limits the strength of the signal that you can receive to only the very strong. This means that you could be missing out on weak but very important instant-on signals. Personally, I wouldn't have much faith in a detector under those conditions. If we only needed to know about the strong signals then detector manufacturers wouldn't go to all the trouble they do to increase sensitivity. If you were serious about it I'd recommend a remote unit to get around the windscreen issue. (Actually, that Whistler model might not be a bad deal...what are they, $200?) Otherwise smart driving practices are going to be your best defense.

SmaartAasSaabr
04-05-2005, 03:19 PM
The detector will still work, just not as well as with a normal windscreen.

There are several options, however.

#1 you can simply duct tape the detector to the front side of the windscreen, however it may just blow off :lol:

#2 you can install an inexpensive remote unit, aka the Whistler above. It's an interesting unit, I'd buy one but I have far too many cars.

If you have a good RD, and aren't doing any bullet-train runs I wouldn't worry. Keep in mind that minivans aren't a very big target for police... I can't even remember the last time I saw one on the side of the road with a cop next to it - except a couple times where the minivan in question was the police vehicle itself :shock:

Zelmo
04-05-2005, 04:09 PM
Thanks. Here is an example of how I would use it in the van. (Keep in mind this might come up once every 2 months as this is not the vehicle I normally drive.)

I recently had to drive the PA turnpike to and from Pittsburgh in one day. On the way out I saw one state trooper working oncoming traffic. On the way back, I ran through ten different speed traps in my direction. I normally go speed limit +8 because they cannot give you a ticket at that ratio. Every now and then I would come up on someone with their cruise control set at +6. If I didn’t speed up to +12 or so it would take forever to get around them and there would be a bunch of irate drivers behind me. I just want some warning to get down that 4mph to slide by.

SmaartAasSaabr
04-05-2005, 04:14 PM
In this case the detector should be more than sufficient with the glass.

Unless it's an RMR or something... :lol:

Zelmo
04-05-2005, 04:17 PM
Unless it's an RMR or something

No. I am getting a V1. I was trying to figure out if I should get a second mounting bracket so I didn't need to disturb my regular one.