View Full Version : Grannies vs Teens: Who’s Scarier on The Road?
lordhawhaw
04-13-2010, 08:22 AM
Grannies vs Teens: Who’s Scarier on The Road | (http://www.theautoinsurance.com/grannies-v-teens-whos-scarier-on-the-road_2010-03-29/)
http://www.theautoinsurance.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/granniesvsteens.jpg
snoopyc4
04-13-2010, 09:08 AM
Nice. Thanks for sharing. I'm going with teens because they have a nasty habit of trying to race you when you try to pass them especially the ricer ones. Not only that but teen girls have a nasty habit of texting while driving.
For me , the elderly aren't nearly as bad. They tend to go slower than the flow of traffic but a simple lane change or patience will get me around them.
supercowpowers
04-13-2010, 09:17 AM
Sounds to me like a teen is more likely to get plastered late at night, run off the road, flip his pickup truck and kill himself because he wasn't wearing his seat belt. Granny is more likely to make a left turn in front of me in broad daylight and kill me because she has piss poor depth perception and ability to make quick decisions anymore.
v1user
04-13-2010, 12:45 PM
Nice. Thanks for sharing. I'm going with teens because they have a nasty habit of trying to race you when you try to pass them especially the ricer ones. Not only that but teen girls have a nasty habit of texting while driving.
For me , the elderly aren't nearly as bad. They tend to go slower than the flow of traffic but a simple lane change or patience will get me around them.
Grannies are predictable. You know they won't do anything but be in the same lane at 20mph under. Certain teens are not. I known when the local high school lets out there will be kids in their parent's BMW's, Volvo's, Lexus's .... literally racing on the highway swerving with no regard for anybody while talking on texting on their phone. I have no idea which way they are going to swerve or whether or not they will hit the breaks or gas. Plus, they constantly have to change from rap station to rap station.
The good news is all this happens in Laser Alley so I know they will get pwoned.
Texting is my number one pet peeve.
GreenRadar
04-13-2010, 12:51 PM
wow that is a tough question. I think it would probably have to be elderly people who are more dangerous, just because the older they get the worse they will get, plus there is that whole issue of no one wanting to deny an elder of keeping their license. With teens in most cases as they get older they wise up and drive safer, plus no one gives a dang about taking their license away
Obsidian
04-13-2010, 01:43 PM
Grannies. Most blue hairs can't/won't turn their heads.
Plus at least teens drive fast in general ... there's nothing worse than getting stuck behind some old man doing 20.
The Chariot
04-13-2010, 01:54 PM
Personally I feel safer sharing the road with old farts than teenagers/early twenty-somethings (no offense to anyone here in either category). Yeah, the farts piss me off now and then with their slow driving but I don't see them making the blatent bad moves and the dangerously poor choices as teens, which tend to make me go beyond pissed off... into the realm of ballistic. Never had a grandma in a fart can car try to race me or play dodge cars when I'm just minding my business on the way to some place. The same thing which makes good soldiers (young men with high risk behavior, disregard for others and immortality complexes) almost makes them poor drivers. An example of this type of thing:
http://www.radardetector.net/forums/lounge/59257-i-rioted-against-virginia-state-police.html
voyager7
04-13-2010, 02:09 PM
Tough call on this one, both have pros and cons.
v1user
04-13-2010, 02:49 PM
I'm still split. I just drove about 40 miles and got stuck behind this old ford ranger in the LL. He finally and slowly drifted over to the middle lane with no turn signal. As I looked at the driver, he was 16 or 17 years old with two hands on his cell phone texting. Then I looked at the front of his truck in my RVM and the whole passenger side looked it hit a telephone pole. Wonder how that happened.
A good thing about the new teen drivers is they make good rabbits with their crapola's in the windshield. They don't know the difference between instant on and a stop sign.
I feel like making giant flash cards for these idiots.
milkman
04-13-2010, 03:20 PM
Nice. Thanks for sharing. I'm going with teens because they have a nasty habit of trying to race you when you try to pass them especially the ricer ones. Not only that but teen girls have a nasty habit of texting while driving.
For me , the elderly aren't nearly as bad. They tend to go slower than the flow of traffic but a simple lane change or patience will get me around them.
Grannies are predictable. You know they won't do anything but be in the same lane at 20mph under. Certain teens are not. I known when the local high school lets out there will be kids in their parent's BMW's, Volvo's, Lexus's .... literally racing on the highway swerving with no regard for anybody while talking on texting on their phone. I have no idea which way they are going to swerve or whether or not they will hit the breaks or gas. Plus, they constantly have to change from rap station to rap station.
The good news is all this happens in Laser Alley so I know they will get pwoned.
Texting is my number one pet peeve.
I agree with both of you. The teens tend to be more agressive than the Grannies. Texting is a very BAD NO-NO when driving.
nategr8ns
04-13-2010, 04:57 PM
Nice. Thanks for sharing. I'm going with teens because they have a nasty habit of trying to race you when you try to pass them especially the ricer ones. Not only that but teen girls have a nasty habit of texting while driving.
For me , the elderly aren't nearly as bad. They tend to go slower than the flow of traffic but a simple lane change or patience will get me around them.
Definitely teens for me too. Even though I'm a teenager myself. Sure I drive fast, but at least I'm paying attention to driving while I'm driving.
Yesterday when I was on my way home, I was in the left lane (two lanes total) around a long turn before my exit. I decided that I could pass one more car before getting over, so I do. As I turn on my turn signal, he accelerates until there is only three feet or so between him and the car in front of him :mad:. I had to brake and pull in behind him.
Obsidian
04-13-2010, 05:27 PM
At least teens are at the physical peak of their senses and reflexes.
I see old people all the time who can't hear, see, walk, etc, who then go out and get into their cars and drive off. I saw an old lady recently who was so bent over she walked facing the ground, and somehow she could drive a car ... and it's almost always the senior citizens who plow through buildings because they could not differentiate between the brake and the throttle.
protias
04-13-2010, 06:20 PM
I can't make a decision on this one. Teens need a whole lot more training and old folks can't see/react 20' around them.
Limited SLIP
04-13-2010, 06:59 PM
At least teens are at the physical peak of their senses and reflexes.
I see old people all the time who can't hear, see, walk, etc, who then go out and get into their cars and drive off. I saw an old lady recently who was so bent over she walked facing the ground, and somehow she could drive a car ... and it's almost always the senior citizens who plow through buildings because they could not differentiate between the brake and the throttle.
I firmly believe ever 10 years there should be a driving test. keeps you out of bad habits. I had mine when I got my CDL!
snoopyc4
04-13-2010, 07:17 PM
As I turn on my turn signal, he accelerates until there is only three feet or so between him and the car in front of him :mad:. I had to brake and pull in behind him.
Yea, I can relate. They'd rather get in a wreck than have anyone pass them in any way. Racing was big back at my high school. The rich boys would bring out daddy's high end car and race each other on the freeway going at least 100+ mph (completely naked, no countermeasures). I laughed when one of them got busted for 108 in a 65. Daddy took his Corvette away after that. :rolleyes: Then you had the truck guys who swore that their exhaust systems could add 50+ hp and that they could out-accelerate any sport car they came across.
At least the elderly aren't aggressive and don't nearly move around as much as a teen who is trying to race you after you try to pass him/her.
voyager7
04-13-2010, 07:21 PM
I feel like making giant flash cards for these idiots.
A dry erase board works well.
AirMoore
04-13-2010, 07:25 PM
That is close:
BUT
On my motorcycle: Grannies are worse to me.
In my Car: Teens are worse to me.
I am split though:
Teens have the ability to be good drivers (via reflexes) but they do not drive with those reflexes, they text, or reprogram their radios etc... and of course the males who race, not drive.
Grannies simply lack the ability to be good drivers (via reflexes), but generally they use what they have left to drive to the best of their abilities, it is just those abilities are greatly diminished.
Both prove problematic, and I wish I didn't have to be out there with either of them...
This topic is too good but I can't pick on which is worse. I will say that I have seen some old people drive like lunatics and young people going snail speeds.
swarga
04-14-2010, 12:00 AM
That's easy: Grannies - because there are more of them.
Hahns5.2
04-14-2010, 07:48 PM
I've run into far more dangersous situations with old people than teenagers..
thx1138
04-14-2010, 08:38 PM
I had more near collisions with teens. I have more near death collisions with the elderly. Had a old guy cruising down the wrong side of a busy road at night. Luckily I was able to duck into a turn lane and he went right by me. A few surprise turns in front of me nearly took me out to.
Gotta say teens, even though I'm not far out of my teens. I've slowed down alot in the past year, and will admit to more than my fair share of stupid decisions while driving, however I loved to drive, and when I was driving fast I was driving, not multitasking, and I will even admit that I was one of those kids who had a big truck, and also drove my moms bimmer from time to time, and while I was a fast, and inexperienced driver, for the most part I feel I was safe.
That being said, I used to always drive because I couldn't handle riding with some of my friends they were terrible, no situational awareness, and no idea of looking ahead a reading the road, also female teenage drivers have to be the worst.
nategr8ns
04-16-2010, 08:51 AM
Gotta say teens, even though I'm not far out of my teens. I've slowed down alot in the past year, and will admit to more than my fair share of stupid decisions while driving, however I loved to drive, and when I was driving fast I was driving, not multitasking...
That is exactly how I feel. Although I haven't slowed down much (only when its late and I haven't had caffeine :D).
ScottEKCoupe
06-01-2010, 10:05 AM
I have seen ALOT of old people come into where I work and man they are scary.
Woodscolby
06-01-2010, 10:38 AM
I'm split on this one. I'm 18 and believe I am a relatively safe driver mainly because I pay attention to the road much more than the average teenager. I have seen more accidents in the past 4 years in the high school parking lot than I have seen in all 14 years prior.
First you have all the douchebags in their lifted trucks and straight-pipes or smokestacks taller than the cab of their freakin truck driving over the medians to avoid traffic or turning onto another road from a straight only lane because they think it is funny and they can.
Then you have the teenage girls who are always texting, singing, dancing, and changing the songs on their Ipods with their friends as they rear-end every car they possibly can.
Then you have the teenage guys in their riced out cars thinking they are cool because their car does 0-60 in 7.8 seconds with a top speed of 112mph and they are definitely going to try to prove it to you.
Then you have the teenage guys with nice cars that try to get you to race them every time they see you and constantly rev their engines next to you and cutting you off trying to provoke you into a race
And then you have the elderly with a complete lack of situational awareness failing to realize something like a car in front of them braking and then weaving across a solid white line to avoid hitting the car in front but almost taking out another 2 or 3 in the process:
YouTube - Elderly Retake Drivers Test? I think so...
The teenagers have the reactivity and are slightly more aware than your average elderly driver, but the majority choose to drive like idiots treating their car as a toy rather than a form of transport that can kill you relatively easily. They abuse the privilege of driving without a drop of common sense as to what consequences their actions can have.
The elderly are just too slow with their reactions. They often drive too slow and don't have the situational awareness to react to an event on the road. I have had so many close calls from elderly people failing to check their blind spots almost side-swiping me or driving incredibly slow and stopping in the middle of intersections at green lights or stopping in the middle of the road trying to figure out where they are going.
To me, it is a toss up between who the scarier driver is. I'm leaning towards the teenagers because I often can't expect what they are planning on doing. When the elderly drive, they give hesitant signs such as insistent breaking or lane drifting towards one side indicating they might move over leaving me a chance to react in most situations.
If I have my choice, I choose to ride with neither of them and drive myself. To each their own abilities and faults.
nategr8ns
06-02-2010, 02:27 PM
If I have my choice, I choose to ride with neither of them and drive myself. To each their own abilities and faults.
+1 all the way (on most of the post at least).
Also, only 18, but your countermeasures are already worth more than my car!
KnightHawk
06-02-2010, 07:04 PM
I have seen ALOT of old people come into where I work and man they are scary.
Like this granny going over 100mph.
msnbc tv- msnbc.com
nist7
06-23-2010, 02:12 PM
Elderly drivers hands down. I was almost hit head-on by an old lady in a Buick (what else do they drive, lol) when driving on a small residential road by a golf course. The road was a bit narrow but not impossibly so. I had to pull over to avoid being hit as I see her zooming by driving down the middle of the effing road.
Teens are almost as bad.
nategr8ns
06-23-2010, 08:45 PM
Elderly drivers hands down. I was almost hit head-on by an old lady in a Buick (what else do they drive, lol) when driving on a small residential road by a golf course. The road was a bit narrow but not impossibly so. I had to pull over to avoid being hit as I see her zooming by driving down the middle of the effing road.
Teens are almost as bad.
Same situation happens to me when I'm about to take a left-hand turn. I'm slowing down to take the turn, then some soccer mom pulls up to the stopsign, but in the middle of the road, and a bit too far. One day I'm not going to be able to take the turn wide and I'll hit them.
Woodscolby
06-23-2010, 09:24 PM
My friends dad got hit head on Sunday by a few 15 year olds that were huffing some aerosols then got into their parents car driving around. It was a 2 lane road 55mph, they were going much faster than 55, he attempted to weave but you can only do so much on a 2 lane road. He was in the Tundra.
Here are some pics my friend took of them:
http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs106.snc4/35639_1506240977062_1265419787_1423228_4788763_n.j pg
http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash2/hs046.ash2/35639_1506241057064_1265419787_1423229_6460641_n.j pg
http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs106.snc4/35639_1506241177067_1265419787_1423232_7210446_n.j pg
http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs106.snc4/35639_1506241257069_1265419787_1423233_6036456_n.j pg
http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs086.snc4/35639_1506241337071_1265419787_1423235_7436259_n.j pg
Things only got worse 2 days later when the same friend was rear ended himself on the highway. Traffic was slowing but the 3rd car back didn't notice.
The Chariot
06-23-2010, 10:12 PM
That's why I drive the vehicles I drive. :)
Frenzy
06-23-2010, 11:44 PM
Coming from a younger driver perspective, I'd have to say the elderly. They cause me to pass people on 2 lane roads. 90% of the time I do it legally, and when I pass on a double yellow it's safe, and I do it at night, so I can see oncoming headlights. I pass in where it's smart/safe to do so. It also depends on the speed they are driving, like 50/55 I won't pass them illegally. For example, if they are doing about 37 in a 55, I'll pass them in a spot declared illegal to so. Usually, when you pass the elderly the brake anyways, making the pass easier to do so.
I drive quickly about 65-70 in a 55, but my town runs C/O K band =), and I rarely see NYS Troopers in town, let alone having someone pulled over.
However, this weekend I'm afraid of the teens. Driving deliveries during H.S. graduation weekend is nerve-racking atm. =(
Moral of the post: Teens are better drivers, we make good rabbits on highways.
nategr8ns
06-24-2010, 06:50 PM
H.S. Graduation still hasn't happened yet?
Graduation here was three weeks ago.
After that, there's this one kid who has about 5 cars. He's going to be a senior next year. Two of his cars are Jaguars BTW, the one in this story is some boxy car from the '80s. Anyway, after school a few times he likes to lay rubber around the parking lot. Makes me jealous TBH, but I wouldn't do it in a crowded parking lot.
Oh man, what it would be like to be able to do AWD burnouts in my Subaru... lol
nate4488
06-24-2010, 08:08 PM
I am going to have to say old people are scarier. Only because I am 19 and hate to diss my own age group.
supercowpowers
06-24-2010, 08:38 PM
I am going to have to say old people are scarier. Only because I am 19 and hate to diss my own age group.
You have to be honest enough to judge your own peers before you can improve them.
I'm sure old people are also reluctant to criticize themselves, which is the first step to realizing something is wrong.
DCxMagus
08-22-2010, 12:03 PM
Elderly hands down, with the teen drivers with the fart cans you can just "let them win" their little race and they usually go along their merry away as a rabbit, with the elderly people they have NO awareness of the world around them nor the ability to react to it if need be in any sort of timely fashion. From a psychological stand point it is very easy to manipulate a teen driver into doing what you want them to do, if they want to be aggressive and are rev left and right give it a small amount of gas, let off and OMG they are soo cool and fast in their stock EX civic without VTEC and a fart can. Have one of the douchebags in the monstrous lifted trucks? sorry but there is no way an F150 with exhaust and 50" tires is going to out accelerate anything... ever.
BUT to be honest I'm from southern orange county have plenty of both of these types of people and they don't even hold a candle to the dangerous driving ability of 5'3" housewives in their massive SUV they can barely see over the dashboard off, let alone the rear view or side view mirrors who have cell phones glue to their ears 24/7 and signal when they are already halfway in another lane. Ever single one of them that I have "expressed" my views of their driving ability too never even had a CLUE they cut like 3 people off, they just felt soo "safe" in their SUV the could care less if they crash through 5 cars on the way to the store.
ivirovets
08-22-2010, 06:00 PM
I'm 20. When I was 16, I did a lot of stupid, reckless things while driving. I was a moron, and the first RD I bought was a cobra :p I did do a lot of stupid things in my first few years of driving, but several near accidents scared it out of me. Old people are scarier however, especially in situations requiring a fast reaction. If you've ever driven on the long island parkways, and seen a terrified granny try to merge from an extra-short NSP on-ramp into 80mph traffic, you know what I'm talking about.
StlouisX50
08-31-2010, 11:34 AM
I say the elderly or the people with handicap plates. However you do have those elderly and handicap plate public that drive like a bat out of hell :)
brasstownbald
08-31-2010, 12:21 PM
Young people tend to drive stupid cause they don't THINK of the consequences.
Old people tend to drive stupid cause they CAN'T think, CAN'T see, CAN'T hear or don't give a crap because the consequences don't matter any more.
So who's "scarier"?
Hmmm...depends. Case by case. Neither group is my first choice to drive near.
fatchick1o9
09-03-2010, 08:41 PM
I would like to submit a 3rd catergory for consideration. People with Handicapped RVM Placards.
95 percent of those motherF'ing idiots drive like maniacs. Like they have nothing to loose because they are already a crippled, useless drag on society. I spend about 30+ hrs /week driving for work and every single car with a blue Handicapped sign drives like a F'ing moron. And if they are a handicapped gimp in a Prius...holy S-bomb...it's twice as bad. Something about driving a Prius seems to make people re-tarded.
Now I understand how they became handicapped in the 1st place. No goddamn common sense