View Full Version : Failure to Yield... You have got to be kidding me!!
smashedpumpkins
06-11-2010, 06:58 PM
My wife left this afternoon after eating lunch from our apartment. The exit of the parking lot is always a blind spot because vehicles are parked along the side of the road. She poked her nose out of the parking lot so she could see and legally yield to any oncomming cars before taking a left turn. Sure enough a car was coming so she fully stopped and let the car pass by. The cop pulled forward and completely stopped right in front of the parking lot staring at my wife. My wifes vehicle was 10 feet from the cop across the road. She was not interfering with any traffic. She was sitting at the exit. After 5 awkward seconds of sitting still my wife decided the officer for some reason wanted her to exit the parking lot and drive away. She did and sure enough she was pulled over. The citation was written for "Failure to Yield". The officer took her information without saying a word, handed her a ticket and left. My wife didn't have the chance to put in any input.
No one was cut off, and there was no failure to yield! Unless you count the cop?
The situation is obviously subject to interpretation and was fully justified by my wife. We live in a Mormon college town where the only source of income is handing out tickets. Speeding and parking tickets are handed out like candy here. We're definitely going to fight the ticket, but the turn over here is almost not existent. This is extremely frustrating, my wifes 21 and I'm only 20. This $85 ticket is only the start to at least $1,000 in insurance premiums. She has a speeding ticket on record for going 7MPH over in a 65 PSL.
It's extremely frustrating especially since the odds of winning are slim to none.
GreenRadar
06-11-2010, 07:01 PM
sounds like a crappy situation, good luck with fighting it, hope you win.
In the mean time you should move to a different town one where traffic laws are the least of their worries :D
smashedpumpkins
06-11-2010, 11:51 PM
sounds like a crappy situation, good luck with fighting it, hope you win.
In the mean time you should move to a different town one where traffic laws are the least of their worries :D
Yeah no kidding I'll be moving and starting my Masters program in a little over a year. Still, so far away. I've got to find a way to get this off my mind.
smashedpumpkins
06-27-2010, 02:50 PM
We went to court on the day the ticket said to be there, but no one was around. We talked with the clerk and they said we had to fill out a paper and the date would be set for mid July. They schedule every single fight back to back. We're going to walk into court with a judge whose already pissed off at every other person arguing. Sigh...
The Chariot
06-27-2010, 03:30 PM
We went to court on the day the ticket said to be there, but no one was around. We talked with the clerk and they said we had to fill out a paper and the date would be set for mid July. They schedule every single fight back to back. We're going to walk into court with a judge whose already pissed off at every other person arguing. Sigh...
No judge, officer, etc? As in... they weren't holding a court session? That sucks, they just royally wasted your time. :(
smashedpumpkins
06-27-2010, 07:05 PM
We went to court on the day the ticket said to be there, but no one was around. We talked with the clerk and they said we had to fill out a paper and the date would be set for mid July. They schedule every single fight back to back. We're going to walk into court with a judge whose already pissed off at every other person arguing. Sigh...
No judge, officer, etc? As in... they weren't holding a court session? That sucks, they just royally wasted your time. :(
Yeah they did, my wife and I were completely dressed up and ready to prove our point. The court house was pretty much empty. It was very annoying.
GTO_04
06-28-2010, 07:45 AM
Was court in session that day? If so, and the other side did not show up, you should have asked for a dismissal! Your odds of getting a dismissal would have been better had you hired an attorney though.
GTO_04
smashedpumpkins
06-28-2010, 04:47 PM
Was court in session that day? If so, and the other side did not show up, you should have asked for a dismissal! Your odds of getting a dismissal would have been better had you hired an attorney though.
GTO_04
Not sure, they just said this is how they deal with all of the tickets. My fathers an Attorney and he said it's usual in smaller cities. We received the pre-trial date for July 14th.
supercowpowers
06-29-2010, 07:04 AM
Pre-trial for a freaking traffic citation?!
Pre-trial for a freaking traffic citation?!
I've known a lot of small towns, especially those sustained only bu a college or a single large employer have courts like this. It's an awesome "**** you" to anyone out of state/town as well as frustrating to everyone that lives there.
smashedpumpkins
07-14-2010, 09:11 AM
Today's the day to fight! I'm sure we'll lose, but it's worth a shot.
forty5cal
07-14-2010, 10:23 AM
Good luck bro!
th3 factory freak
07-14-2010, 10:26 AM
My wife left this afternoon after eating lunch from our apartment. The exit of the parking lot is always a blind spot because vehicles are parked along the side of the road. She poked her nose out of the parking lot so she could see and legally yield to any oncomming cars before taking a left turn. Sure enough a car was coming so she fully stopped and let the car pass by. The cop pulled forward and completely stopped right in front of the parking lot staring at my wife. My wifes vehicle was 10 feet from the cop across the road. She was not interfering with any traffic. She was sitting at the exit. After 5 awkward seconds of sitting still my wife decided the officer for some reason wanted her to exit the parking lot and drive away. She did and sure enough she was pulled over. The citation was written for "Failure to Yield". The officer took her information without saying a word, handed her a ticket and left. My wife didn't have the chance to put in any input.
No one was cut off, and there was no failure to yield! Unless you count the cop?
The situation is obviously subject to interpretation and was fully justified by my wife. We live in a Mormon college town where the only source of income is handing out tickets. Speeding and parking tickets are handed out like candy here. We're definitely going to fight the ticket, but the turn over here is almost not existent. This is extremely frustrating, my wifes 21 and I'm only 20. This $85 ticket is only the start to at least $1,000 in insurance premiums. She has a speeding ticket on record for going 7MPH over in a 65 PSL.
It's extremely frustrating especially since the odds of winning are slim to none.
The first thing you need to do is sit down and write down everything that happened as soon as possible, otherwise you'll forget it.
You then need to take a good quality digital camera and take plenty of photos, even a video would be nice to show the situation in that stop sign.
I don't see any issues with stopping fully, then proceeding just a little bit to make sure there is no on-coming traffic before you merge onto a road. If this cop is stupid or was just desperate to ticket someone, he will find out about it in court.
If you present your case with all this evidence I feel you have a pretty good chance of having this tossed out.
Solidjake
07-14-2010, 11:32 AM
Where ever you live, move the hell out.
Btw, did she use her turn signal?
smashedpumpkins
07-14-2010, 03:10 PM
Where ever you live, move the hell out.
Btw, did she use her turn signal?
Yeah she did.
You wouldn't believe it... The "Pre-Trial" was just a group of people in a court room walking up 1 by 1 to talk 1 on 1 with the prosecutor where he told almost everyone you can either go to traffic school or go to trial. Long story short, we're going to have to wait ANOTHER month to go to trial. We're going to do exactly what you said and bring pictures to show how her view is blocked by parked cars and why she did nothing wrong.
The records say the cop was forced to slam his brakes so he wouldn't get hit. Absolutely RIDICULOUS. My wife edged out and was 10 yards from the cop when he stopped. We got to talking with an attorney and he said it's very possible the judge will see both my wives point of view and the cops and will dismiss it. But, odds are we're going into a rigged fight. And the attorney said it really depends on the judge we get.
We really didn't have a clue where the failure to yield was until today. We're tired of being yanked around over a traffic citation. It seems like they do everything they can to get you to plead guilty. If we lose, I'll still be glad we went out with a fight.
th3 factory freak
07-14-2010, 03:30 PM
Where ever you live, move the hell out.
Btw, did she use her turn signal?
Yeah she did.
You wouldn't believe it... The "Pre-Trial" was just a group of people in a court room walking up 1 by 1 to talk 1 on 1 with the prosecutor where he told almost everyone you can either go to traffic school or go to trial. Long story short, we're going to have to wait ANOTHER month to go to trial. We're going to do exactly what you said and bring pictures to show how her view is blocked by parked cars and why she did nothing wrong.
The records say the cop was forced to slam his brakes so he wouldn't get hit. Absolutely RIDICULOUS. My wife edged out and was 10 yards from the cop when he stopped. We got to talking with an attorney and he said it's very possible the judge will see both my wives point of view and the cops and will dismiss it. But, odds are we're going into a rigged fight. And the attorney said it really depends on the judge we get.
We really didn't have a clue where the failure to yield was until today. We're tired of being yanked around over a traffic citation. It seems like they do everything they can to get you to plead guilty. If we lose, I'll still be glad we went out with a fight.
Good, you got a month to prepare, you're on the right track.
I would also mention that if it was a failure to yield, the result would have been an accident.
Now let me see if I got this right. The cop saw your wife moving a bit after she stopped.
Did he see her stop?
This cop sounds like a moron to me.
hiddencam
07-14-2010, 04:18 PM
Is the attorney you spoke to representing you at trial? If not, get one FTW! :)
lostidentity
07-14-2010, 06:51 PM
so simple solution here would be request dash cam footage......
If it shows him stopped and staring at your wife and then she pulls out then youre good.
if it doesnt show her pull out youre still good because he didnt have to "slam on his brakes."