PDA

View Full Version : Car Safety vs Driver Skill



dmoney1988
07-14-2010, 09:38 PM
I wanted to start a discussion about all these new and imo unnecessary safety features in new cars like adaptive cruise control that takes the skill out of driving. I drive an older model car that only has a driver side airbag and abs brakes and I feel that this makes me drive more safer, less dumb mistakes, due to the fact that i do not have all those safety features like my mom new Honda accord. I is late and I need to wake up in the morning to go to work but what do y'all think about all of these safety features that are in cars today.

BTW: I will explain more about what i am talking about later after I have gotten some sleep.

TRun
07-14-2010, 10:11 PM
I got no airbags at all and only 2 wheels have abs. I think new cars have gone a little over the top with a bunch of useless gadgets that only annoy detector users. If you need your car to tell you something is in your blind spot then maybe you should take the bus.:cool:

Cauhauna
07-14-2010, 10:17 PM
I wanted to start a discussion about all these new and imo unnecessary safety features in new cars like adaptive cruise control that takes the skill out of driving. I drive an older model car that only has a driver side airbag and abs brakes and I feel that this makes me drive more safer, less dumb mistakes, due to the fact that i do not have all those safety features like my mom new Honda accord. I is late and I need to wake up in the morning to go to work but what do y'all think about all of these safety features that are in cars today.

BTW: I will explain more about what i am talking about later after I have gotten some sleep.

I disagree. Every added safety feature helps. An accident can happen to anyone, at any time. Most people are bad drivers...

that being said, it would be nice if they had chosen radar bands that weren't shared with police.

Lucky for us, all that stuff is usually in the highest end package, costing the most money, so they aren't all that common.

johndoesix
07-15-2010, 12:12 AM
I can't stand traction control. I'm one of those that think traction control is your right foot. ABS, on the street I haven't found a need for it yet. On the track, it does help with the flat spotting, but on some cars, higher friction pads confuse the ABS computer big time. I've been renting a lot of cars lately. The Charger that I had with the 6 cylinder was a lot fun in the rain. I hate airbags, but I know they can save my life. Even the small planes have them now. Stability control seems to spoil the fun if I can't figure out how to disable it. Looking at a new truck. It has both traction and stability control. I'll most likely be purchasing a programmer to change the parameters a bit if it's too difficult to disable. Sliding the rear a bit is a fun way to get rid of a tailgater. ;) Higher end cars? Most of the cars I've rented recently were compact and every one had all of the above. Amusing seeing traction control on a car that can barely spin the tires with it off. :p

category4
07-15-2010, 02:56 AM
Wait until you have 4-600 HP in a composite and carbon fiber body car ( no weight) and try to drive in the wet!!!

It's almost impossible without TC. Heck with the summer traction tires they use it's dicey when the temps drop below 40 until you get heat in the tires.

On the track or when pushing hard though in dry conditions yes the nannies have to go!!

dmoney1988
07-15-2010, 07:32 AM
I wanted to start a discussion about all these new and imo unnecessary safety features in new cars like adaptive cruise control that takes the skill out of driving. I drive an older model car that only has a driver side airbag and abs brakes and I feel that this makes me drive more safer, less dumb mistakes, due to the fact that i do not have all those safety features like my mom new Honda accord. I is late and I need to wake up in the morning to go to work but what do y'all think about all of these safety features that are in cars today.

BTW: I will explain more about what i am talking about later after I have gotten some sleep.

I disagree. Every added safety feature helps. An accident can happen to anyone, at any time. Most people are bad drivers...

that being said, it would be nice if they had chosen radar bands that weren't shared with police.

Lucky for us, all that stuff is usually in the highest end package, costing the most money, so they aren't all that common.



Wait until you have 4-600 HP in a composite and carbon fiber body car ( no weight) and try to drive in the wet!!!

It's almost impossible without TC. Heck with the summer traction tires they use it's dicey when the temps drop below 40 until you get heat in the tires.

On the track or when pushing hard though in dry conditions yes the nannies have to go!!

I understand both of yall view points but what I am trying to get across is do you think that with all the new safety features, will the new generation (not us) become lazy and rely heavly on the safety features like blind spot notification instead of looking themselves.

I am not trying to confuse safety features with " convenient features" like backup cameras and AAC and lane assist. some cars even stop/park themselves. It just seems to me that the car is doing more of the driving than the driver is doing when it comes to the "convenient features".

srtga
07-15-2010, 01:06 PM
Wait until you have 4-600 HP in a composite and carbon fiber body car ( no weight) and try to drive in the wet!!!

It's almost impossible without TC. Heck with the summer traction tires they use it's dicey when the temps drop below 40 until you get heat in the tires.

On the track or when pushing hard though in dry conditions yes the nannies have to go!!

Ditto. My car is heavy but all that torque/manual transmission with summer tires in the cold/rain can be hairy...

I got stuck out on a trip in a snowstorm last year and my car didn't make a lick of sense.

johndoesix
07-15-2010, 08:38 PM
A wet track in a 125hp Miata with the wrong tires can be dicey too. ;) It still requires proper use of the right foot on both pedals.

The Chariot
07-15-2010, 09:08 PM
Gotta agree with Cat4. My Roush will get sideways very easily in the rain from a stop if I'm not careful.

Good driving skills plus air bags (as many as possible), anti-lock brakes (especially in the rain), traction control (provided I can turn it off, which I can), etc., is better IMHO than good driving skills without safety backups especially since I have no control over what other drivers do. No matter how good you drive you want a 5 star crash rating, excellent offset impact ratings and 5 star side impact if someone crosses the yellow line and hits you head on, or runs a red light and t-bones you.

Same thing with mass. I'd rather be in a full size vehicle than a tin box (remember, the ratings are not against other vehicles).

The Chariot
07-15-2010, 09:11 PM
I understand both of yall view points but what I am trying to get across is do you think that with all the new safety features, will the new generation (not us) become lazy and rely heavly on the safety features like blind spot notification instead of looking themselves.

I am not trying to confuse safety features with " convenient features" like backup cameras and AAC and lane assist. some cars even stop/park themselves. It just seems to me that the car is doing more of the driving than the driver is doing when it comes to the "convenient features".

If you drive a truck and trailer a lot you'll love backup cameras!

NoWin
07-15-2010, 09:43 PM
Good question overall.


A wet track in a 125hp Miata with the wrong tires can be dicey too. ;)

I call that fun! (...being an autocrosser, I'm used to dicey)


It still requires proper use of the right foot on both pedals.

Bingo! But only a small percentage of the general public fit that composition. Imho, the majority of the safety features "built-in" are driven more as an liability limiter to the manufactures and nsurance companies than for out an out safety (per say). It makes great marketing copy...

Airbags are a prime example. They are there as primary safety barrier when one doesn't use seatbelts. (That was given to us at an airbag demo at a Chrysler plant back in the mid-90's) True, they combine a safety margin actor when used together, and we all know people who still don't use seatbelts. (My mom for example, no matter how hard I try to get her to use them)

Same goes for the anti-yaw stuff...designed to help give the the yuppie wife a false sense of security so she can drive her SUV at 85 on the Pike in the left lane and make that Oh dear there's my donut exit 300 feet ago.... but marketing imparts the "stability" aspect of the vehicle, and that is all the mind keys in on.

I'll leave the personal-responsibilty aspect out as that's a topic all it's own...

category4
07-15-2010, 10:24 PM
It's just human nature to allow technology to take over for skill. Look at math skills, very very people coming through school today can even make change! If the cash register does not tell them what to give back they are lost. If you don't believe me next time you go to the checkout had them the money and let them punch it in and after the change amount comes up hand them the # of pennies to make it so they will not need to give you pennies in change. I've had people hand me back more money in change than I gave them to make the purchase!!!

The same will happen to their already poor driving skills as more and more nannies become available. Only those of us that have the basic skills and continue to practice them will not see those skills erode.

voyager7
07-16-2010, 07:02 AM
Wait until you have 4-600 HP in a composite and carbon fiber body car ( no weight) and try to drive in the wet!!!

It's almost impossible without TC. Heck with the summer traction tires they use it's dicey when the temps drop below 40 until you get heat in the tires.

On the track or when pushing hard though in dry conditions yes the nannies have to go!!

TC has saved me once or twice in the rain.
When it rains that is the only time I have TC on, but since I had some work done to the car (530 hp now) the TC is turned off all the time and can't be turned on again. So if it happens to rain when I have the Cobra out I have to remember to take it a little slower.
As far as ABS goes I'm not overly impressed with it. ABS actually increases your brake distance when active.

dmoney1988
07-16-2010, 08:29 AM
I'll leave the personal-responsibilty aspect out as that's a topic all it's own...

I think that is the direction I wanted this thread to go when I created it. A person would think twice before doing 80 in the left lane and cutting 4 lanes to the right to get to an exit while cutting everyone off if they did not have those extra features. :rolleyes:


It's just human nature to allow technology to take over for skill. Look at math skills, very very people coming through school today can even make change! If the cash register does not tell them what to give back they are lost. If you don't believe me next time you go to the checkout had them the money and let them punch it in and after the change amount comes up hand them the # of pennies to make it so they will not need to give you pennies in change. I've had people hand me back more money in change than I gave them to make the purchase!!!

The same will happen to their already poor driving skills as more and more nannies become available. Only those of us that have the basic skills and continue to practice them will not see those skills erode.

That is why when I teach my child how to drive, all of the active safety features would be turned off so from the start he or she would grow accustom to releying on them. As for the relying on tech part, i remember reading an article a while ago about an experiment at a local middle school. they gave the students caculators that caculated wrong answers during a test. They was suprised that majority of the students put the wrong answers that the caculator displayed instead of relying on what they know. I do not think that any tech should be heavily relyied on.




As far as ABS goes I'm not overly impressed with it. ABS actually increases your brake distance when active.

I did some research on ABS and found this out as well and i was suprised. BUT i dont know if this was for the older systems or for the new systems with muti channel abs systems with 4 wheel disc brakes. :confused:

swarga
07-16-2010, 09:54 AM
I wanted to start a discussion about all these new and imo unnecessary safety features in new cars like adaptive cruise control that takes the skill out of driving.

I disagree. Every added safety feature helps. An accident can happen to anyone, at any time. Most people are bad drivers...

EXACTLY. Things like ACC and lane departure warnings represent a dumbing down of driving to match the level of incompetence of the average driver. Kinda like how Florida has "Large Print Edition" roads (larger fonts on road signs, wider lines on pavement markings, etc.) to compensate for the failing vision of the large retiree population.

The real solution is to raise driver competence, not dumb everything down to the lowest common denominator. But we as a society lack the political will to do that, so conditions on the roads are going to get worse and worse until we either have complete gridlock or we develop cars that are completely autonomous and can drive themselves.

AirMoore
07-16-2010, 10:56 AM
You want to see a need for traction control... pshhh... 125+HP on less than 400Pounds, with a miniscule contact patch... talk about CARS needing them in the rain... lulz! I just don't have enough $$$ to ever put one on.



I (personally) like others to have as many safety devices as possible... because as aforementioned, most people SUCK at driving. Personally... I wish my car was stock-full of them, BUT ONLY with the option to turn them off when I wish. The only safety mechanism that I loathe driving with is ABS up here in the North... I'd much prefer to not have that on... but I sure like the fact other have theirs.

In summation: I am all for car safety, because the lack of driving skill.


Conversely: For the race track... I like to see less and less electronic aids, I think it highlights the true driver skill more, and that is what I want to see on the race-track: Skill, not a driving machine (literally).

The Chariot
07-16-2010, 11:29 AM
Dang burn them new fangled rear view mirrors, padded dashes, disc brakes, sway bars, shatter-proof windshields, seat belts, radial tires, hydraulic brakes, power assisted steering, crumple zones, side reflectors, power brakes, anti-lock brakes, side impact beams, collapsible steering columns and air bags!

Bah!! Who needs safety when a belief that my driving skills will save my ass will do just fine regardless of what happens. It was good enough for grandpa so its good enough for me!

:thumb2::driver:

TQUILL
07-16-2010, 12:23 PM
Safety features aren't necessarily there to protect the driver from his/herself... remember, they can help protect you from all the other idiots out there.

As for the premise of people driving worse when they know they have safety features... I disagree. Most people don't think about the odds of getting in an accident when they drive dangerously... most people think it will never happen to them.

Obsidian
07-16-2010, 03:05 PM
I would prefer no driver aids and getting rid of most safety features, but more because of what they do to the weight of cars. Heavy sucks. Unless there is extensive use of aluminum like the Z06 or carbon fiber as on the Elise and Exige then they will all be pigs.

On sports cars these days, TC will usually give you better lap times, but it's definitely more fun with it off.

dmoney1988
07-16-2010, 05:46 PM
Dang burn them new fangled rear view mirrors, padded dashes, disc brakes, sway bars, shatter-proof windshields, seat belts, radial tires, hydraulic brakes, power assisted steering, crumple zones, side reflectors, power brakes, anti-lock brakes, side impact beams, collapsible steering columns and air bags!

Bah!! Who needs safety when a belief that my driving skills will save my ass will do just fine regardless of what happens. It was good enough for grandpa so its good enough for me!

:thumb2::driver:

Come to think about it without the above features people would drive more carefully because you could die in a 10 mph crash :eek:. Yea Right like that going to happen :rolleyes:. Anyways I agree with the fact that it protects you from other bad drivers on the road and unexpected events like running into debris in the road but I still don't get ACC or lane departure assistance :confused:.

mahjong007
07-16-2010, 11:08 PM
at this year and ago. auto markets is very competitive. yes, all this safety features and gadgets in the new cars this days saves life and sometime can be helpful, but all this things all are designs to make sales. the more high-tech and enchance vehicle will tend to push the buyers into that specific vehicle. come on, lets be realistic.. who doesnt want to be high-tech savy and wants there vehicle to have the best and newest gadgets in them. when you buy a car, you look at the features correct?

The Chariot
07-17-2010, 11:29 AM
-snip- I still don't get ACC or lane departure assistance :confused:.

Personally I don't want/need them but I'd rather have the 80 year old grandpa in the next lane over having them then not having them! lol

protias
07-17-2010, 03:17 PM
I'm not sure current technology is at the point where it will save your from ice.