PDA

View Full Version : A reflection about speeding



Someone
08-30-2010, 04:30 PM
Decided to delete my post. Sorry

RadarGoat
08-30-2010, 04:40 PM
Is that like saying: Jumping out of an airplane without a parachute will not kill you?, it is the sudden stop. Although, jumping out of the airplane was certainly a factor.

MarshVegas
08-30-2010, 05:17 PM
Right ! It's not the speed ,it's the sudden stop!!!

Someone
08-30-2010, 06:41 PM
Is that like saying: Jumping out of an airplane without a parachute will not kill you?, it is the sudden stop. Although, jumping out of the airplane was certainly a factor.

Decided to delete my post. Sorry.

Someone
08-30-2010, 06:46 PM
Right ! It's not the speed ,it's the sudden stop!!!

Decided to Delete my post.

Raoul Duke
08-30-2010, 08:23 PM
Speed magnifies the forces delivered to an object when there is a collision. The more speed, the greater the forces.

barryswanson
08-30-2010, 09:15 PM
This thread reminds me of some of my friends who are drug users and come up with all sort of creative bull $hit to justify their actions.

Someone
08-30-2010, 10:22 PM
Speed magnifies the forces delivered to an object when there is a collision. The more speed, the greater the forces.

Decided to delete my post.

Someone
08-30-2010, 10:23 PM
This thread reminds me of some of my friends who are drug users and come up with all sort of creative bull $hit to justify their actions.


Deleted my post.

barryswanson
08-30-2010, 10:50 PM
Probably lol

supercowpowers
08-31-2010, 07:26 AM
Speed magnifies the forces delivered to an object when there is a collision. The more speed, the greater the forces.

Yet, it would feasible to build vehicles to better absord this energy.

My point was simply that it is easier to blame the drivers, than the car makers. Go figure!

So it's OK to hit stuff as long as your vehicle will protect you? Wow.

I don't drive at a speed I think I'd survive a crash from. I drive a speed that gives me time to react to what I can see and to maintain control with performance left over for evasive maneuvers like having to brake during a turn.

We blame drivers because it shouldn't be acceptable to crash. It's wasteful, and not everyone on or near the road has the protection of a vehicle around them.

Someone
08-31-2010, 09:18 AM
Speed magnifies the forces delivered to an object when there is a collision. The more speed, the greater the forces.

Yet, it would feasible to build vehicles to better absord this energy.

My point was simply that it is easier to blame the drivers, than the car makers. Go figure!

So it's OK to hit stuff as long as your vehicle will protect you? Wow.

I don't drive at a speed I think I'd survive a crash from. I drive a speed that gives me time to react to what I can see and to maintain control with performance left over for evasive maneuvers like having to brake during a turn.

We blame drivers because it shouldn't be acceptable to crash. It's wasteful, and not everyone on or near the road has the protection of a vehicle around them.

Decided to delete my post.

swarga
08-31-2010, 09:41 AM
Speed doesn't kill you. Alcohol doesn't kill you. Distractions don't kill you. Bad weather doesn't kill you. Other motorists don't kill you either. What is it then that will kill you?

Actually, it is sloth that will kill you. Consider the following scenario:

Mr. Safe N. Slow is driving slowly and (he believes) safely down a two-lane rural road with no passing zones. The posted limit is 55, but our protagonist is driving at a nice, safe 45 MPH, oblivious to the line of 20 cars stacked up behind him, drivers pounding their steering wheels in frustration. He refuses to use the turnouts or pull off the road, and the center stripe is a solid double yellow, so legally none of the stuck drivers can pass.

Finally, one of the stuck drivers gets fed up. He nips out across the double yellow center-line and begins to pass Mr. Slow. At that moment, a farm tractor pulls out of a driveway directly into the path of the passing car; they collide, killing the driver.

Mr. Slow, still completely oblivious, continues to putter along to his destination. If you ask Mr. Slow, he'll smugly brag about what a safe driver he is, proudly pointing to the fact that he has had no tickets or accidents for over 40 years. Meanwhile, an innocent driver is dead due to his sloth.

So yeah, it's not Speed that kills - it's Sloth.

Someone
08-31-2010, 01:18 PM
Speed doesn't kill you. Alcohol doesn't kill you. Distractions don't kill you. Bad weather doesn't kill you. Other motorists don't kill you either. What is it then that will kill you?

Actually, it is sloth that will kill you. Consider the following scenario:

Mr. Safe N. Slow is driving slowly and (he believes) safely down a two-lane rural road with no passing zones. The posted limit is 55, but our protagonist is driving at a nice, safe 45 MPH, oblivious to the line of 20 cars stacked up behind him, drivers pounding their steering wheels in frustration. He refuses to use the turnouts or pull off the road, and the center stripe is a solid double yellow, so legally none of the stuck drivers can pass.

Finally, one of the stuck drivers gets fed up. He nips out across the double yellow center-line and begins to pass Mr. Slow. At that moment, a farm tractor pulls out of a driveway directly into the path of the passing car; they collide, killing the driver.

Mr. Slow, still completely oblivious, continues to putter along to his destination. If you ask Mr. Slow, he'll smugly brag about what a safe driver he is, proudly pointing to the fact that he has had no tickets or accidents for over 40 years. Meanwhile, an innocent driver is dead due to his sloth.

So yeah, it's not Speed that kills - it's Sloth.


Decided to delete my post.

ivirovets
08-31-2010, 02:25 PM
Very True someone. The Long Island parkways were built when LI was just a leisurely vacation spot for rich people. They are not major commuter roads, and the death rates are very high due to the sharp corners and extremely short on ramps. Search "blood alley long island" on wikipedia.

switch626
08-31-2010, 06:38 PM
Speed magnifies the forces delivered to an object when there is a collision. The more speed, the greater the forces.

Yet, it would feasible to build vehicles to better absord this energy.

My point was simply that it is easier to blame the drivers, than the car makers. Go figure!

To me, this idea makes no sense. The logic of blaming the car manufacturer for the accident or the gun maker for a shooting. This line of thinking may be profitable in court, but has little to do with the bigger picture. Do these products play a role in fatal accidents? Of course they do, but they are usually not to blame for the situation that kils someone.

I like to think of it in terms of a comment that I found while reading NTSB reports on aiplane accidents. Catastrophic accidents are usually a culmination of a series of smaller failures.Each is a contibuting factor that compliments the effect of the other factors. It's not the speed, or the design of the car, or an impaired driver, or the location of the accident. It is instead that a driver was in a speeding in a particular car in a particular place, and was hit in a certain way by an impaired driver, etc. These things add up to a catastrophic failure.

The reason I bristle a little at remarks like the original post and some supporrting comments is that this takes an attitude of no responsibility by the driver. When we decide to speed or not to, we willingly accept the possible outcomes of that decision. We are free to decide to obey or not obey certain rules of the road. To blame the car or car maker for the outcome of our decisions is one step away from saying that we should not be free to choose to drive the car (since we aren't responsible for our decision anyway).

This reminds me of the kind of logic that comes from smoking a fat doobie! It is flawed logic, that I would rather avoid. As for me, I would prefer to choose my freedom. If I screw up and die as a result of my actions, at least I was able to choose. Even if in doing so I chose the consequences, let the chips fall where they may.

Raoul Duke
08-31-2010, 08:21 PM
Speed doesn't kill you. Alcohol doesn't kill you. Distractions don't kill you. Bad weather doesn't kill you. Other motorists don't kill you either. What is it then that will kill you?

Actually, it is sloth that will kill you. Consider the following scenario:

Mr. Safe N. Slow is driving slowly and (he believes) safely down a two-lane rural road with no passing zones. The posted limit is 55, but our protagonist is driving at a nice, safe 45 MPH, oblivious to the line of 20 cars stacked up behind him, drivers pounding their steering wheels in frustration. He refuses to use the turnouts or pull off the road, and the center stripe is a solid double yellow, so legally none of the stuck drivers can pass.

Finally, one of the stuck drivers gets fed up. He nips out across the double yellow center-line and begins to pass Mr. Slow. At that moment, a farm tractor pulls out of a driveway directly into the path of the passing car; they collide, killing the driver.

Mr. Slow, still completely oblivious, continues to putter along to his destination. If you ask Mr. Slow, he'll smugly brag about what a safe driver he is, proudly pointing to the fact that he has had no tickets or accidents for over 40 years. Meanwhile, an innocent driver is dead due to his sloth.

So yeah, it's not Speed that kills - it's Sloth.

That's a BS scenario to blame on sloth. The fault is clearly lies with the driver who crossed the line, violating traffic laws and common sense, to pass a slower vehicle.

MarshVegas
08-31-2010, 08:46 PM
no, what kills people is lack of training. When you ask someone what happened during a crash they often say something like, "oh the car did this. Or the car did that. Or it just went out of control."

well a car doesn't just "go out of control." we have the safest cars on the road right now that have ever existed.


crumple zones
front air bags
curtain air bags
knee airbags
seatbelt air bags
thorax air bags
pre-tensioning seatbelts
active handling systems
traction control
anti-lock brakes
collision detection systems
active braking systems that apply the brakes before a crash
adaptive cruise control
lane departure prevention systems
blind spot alerts
cross-traffic alert
reverse object detection sensors
backup cameras
hid headlights
adaptive headlights
anti-whiplash head rests
completely padded interiors
vehicle safety superstructures
tire pressure monitoring systems



these are just some of the features available or standard on a modern car today.

Not to mention that tire technology, suspension technology and braking technology are the best they have ever been. Yet every year we still lose over 43,000 people to car crashes. This does not include the 100,000+ people that are injured, maimed or paralyzed every year from car crashes. To put this in perspective only about 8,000 people die every year from gun shots in the us.

The roads are safer for the most part than they have ever been. Crash barriers, impact absorbers, lights, reflective technology, adaptive road signs, etc., are on just about every road in america. Yet people are still dying.

What is the single constant throughout all of this?

The driver.

I teach high performance and advanced driving and i can tell you first hand that i have seen the driver's education books that are still in use today. They teach things that are flat out wrong. They teach people to do things that are contrary to the laws of physics. They teach people outdated driving techniques that should have been left to rot with the ford pinto. The copyrights in the "drive right" book that i saw at stonewall jackson high school in manassas had copyright updates going back to the 1950's in it. They are still teaching this crap to people.

Did you know that in va you don't even have to know how to parallel park to get your driver's license? I would venture to guess that most of the people on this board make the same mistakes that everyone else on the road makes.

Until we make massive reforms to driver education then speed limits will be set artificially low, cars will be more expensive, roads will cost more to make, insurance costs will be inflated and fatalities and injuries will remain where they are.

If i had my way everyone would have to go back to driver's education for a re-certification every five years. At this recertification you would have to prove mastery of accident avoidance, threshold braking, understeer correction and oversteer correction maneuvers. You would have to pass a written test, not multiple choice about basic vehicle dynamics, motoring courtesy, basic vehicle maintenance and basic traffic law.

Those obtaining their licenses for the first time would go through a four phase licensing program. Phase 1 would be all classroom instruction and hands-on basic vehicle maintenance. Phase 2 would be classroom instruction and hands on basic driving, with limited on-road out of class driving for daylight hours only with no passengers. Phase 3 would be more classroom instruction, accident avoidance and handling maneuvers, and limited on-road out of class driving from dawn to dusk with no passengers. Phase 4 would finish classroom instruction and testing of vehicle driving mastery, with limited driving from 4am - 11pm, with no passengers.

There would be two classes of licenses: Regular and advanced. A regular license would entitle you to drive at the psl with annual vehicle safety inspections. An advanced license would require testing every two years for all elements of driving mastery, both written and on-road. Advanced licensees would get a special license and tag, their vehicle would be safety inspected twice a year, but the tag would allow them unlimited access to the left lane, and a 30 percent increase in the psl in all 45 - 70 mph zones during fair weather, with strict enforcement. Advanced license holders would have reduced fines for exceeding the limit, but too many violations would get their advanced status revoked.

Only cars that could brake from 70-0 in less than a certain distance would be eligible for an advanced tag, and only a very limited number of trucks or suvs would be eligible.

If you are a regular license holder and are caught driving with an advanced tag, you'd be looking at instant suspension and vehicle towing.

With a regular license you would only be able to use the left lane for passing or turning left. Camping out in the left lane would be a hefty fine. Advanced licensees who didn't yield to overtaking drivers would be subject to the same fines. Overtaking drivers who don't follow at a safe distance when the overtaken driver cannot move would be subject to hefty fines as well.

If this country would adopt a system like this deaths and injuries from traffic crashes would drop to half or more of their current level. The .gov could make more money off of licensing and training, reduce cost of vehicle development, reduce consumer costs of insurance and reduce medical costs. Driving would be safer, traffic would be reduced, and lives would be saved.

But the problem with our society today is that nobody wants to accept personal responsibility for their actions. So people would rather continue to point the blame for deaths and injuries related to car crashes onto things like the car, the road or speed, rather than where the blame belongs. With the drivers.

of coarse! You teach drivers ed. Job security

swarga
09-01-2010, 12:15 AM
That's a BS scenario to blame on sloth. The fault is clearly lies with the driver who crossed the line, violating traffic laws and common sense, to pass a slower vehicle.

Right, because everyone is a robot driver with infinite patience, and can tolerate an unlimited amount of BS from asshole drivers.

Now wake up from your fantasy. Drivers are human beings; it's in our nature to get pissed off at injustice and unfairness. And sometimes when people get sufficiently pissed off, they make poor judgment calls like passing in a no-passing zone. Trying to blame a human driver for getting fed up with being stuck behind Mr. Magoo is like trying to blame a little kid for darting out into the street while chasing a soccer ball; it's human nature and nothing you say is going to change it.

Just as responsible people drive more carefully in residential neighborhoods where kids play, Sloths should either drive at the normal speed of traffic or get the **** off the road before they kill someone.

Raoul Duke
09-01-2010, 05:40 AM
That's a BS scenario to blame on sloth. The fault is clearly lies with the driver who crossed the line, violating traffic laws and common sense, to pass a slower vehicle.

Right, because everyone is a robot driver with infinite patience, and can tolerate an unlimited amount of BS from asshole drivers.

Now wake up from your fantasy. Drivers are human beings; it's in our nature to get pissed off at injustice and unfairness. And sometimes when people get sufficiently pissed off, they make poor judgment calls like passing in a no-passing zone. Trying to blame a human driver for getting fed up with being stuck behind Mr. Magoo is like trying to blame a little kid for darting out into the street while chasing a soccer ball; it's human nature and nothing you say is going to change it.

Just as responsible people drive more carefully in residential neighborhoods where kids play, Sloths should either drive at the normal speed of traffic or get the **** off the road before they kill someone.

Now you are playing the transfer the blame game. Blame everything/everyone else but the person at fault. I know its frustrating stuck behind someone puttering along well below the speed limit, but that never justifies or excuses the driver making a bad decision. The decision to cross the line and make an unsafe pass is squarely on the shoulders of the driver executing the manuever. You even acknowledged that when you said that when the driver gets pissed off they make poor judgement calls.

Don't make the mistake of comparing an adult driver with a child playing in the street. There is a world of difference between the two. The adult has years of experience and reasoning skills that a child doesn't yet posses.

Anyway, the original point I made, which seems to have gotten lost, is that speed magnifies the effects of any mishap.

Raoul Duke
09-01-2010, 05:41 AM
of coarse! You teach drivers ed. Job security

Not any driver's ed that you'd be familiar with. My driver's education usually involves speeds over 100 MPH. I was doing 160 MPH with one student.

Which track?

swarga
09-01-2010, 09:30 AM
Now you are playing the transfer the blame game.

No, I'm telling it like it is. Sloth is the direct cause of collisions and deaths every day. People mindlessly equate driving slowly with driving safely but that just isn't the case.


speed magnifies the effects of any mishap.

Of course, if the ****ing Sloth hadn't pulled out directly in front of high-speed oncoming traffic, there wouldn't have been a "mishap" in the first place. :D

Raoul Duke
09-01-2010, 05:30 PM
AsRacer, that is an impressive list. I just started DE this year and am having a blast. So far I have done Lightning, Limerock Park, and Watkins Glen.

Raoul Duke
09-01-2010, 05:51 PM
Now you are playing the transfer the blame game.

No, I'm telling it like it is. Sloth is the direct cause of collisions and deaths every day. People mindlessly equate driving slowly with driving safely but that just isn't the case.


speed magnifies the effects of any mishap.

Of course, if the ****ing Sloth hadn't pulled out directly in front of high-speed oncoming traffic, there wouldn't have been a "mishap" in the first place. :D

Don't change the fact pattern to justify your conclusions. Sloth was driving slowly while someone crossed the double yellow to pass and struck the farm tractor. Despite the frustrations with the slow driver, the fault here is clearly with the driver who attempted the pass. Nothing you say can change that fact. Blaming sloth for someone else's bad decision is merely trying to find a scapegoat and shifting the blame. Remember, we are driving on public roads with drivers of varying skill and need to adjust our driving accordingly. If you want to drive fast without Mr. Sloth, get to a track.

MarshVegas
09-01-2010, 06:06 PM
of coarse! You teach drivers ed. Job security

Not any driver's ed that you'd be familiar with. My driver's education usually involves speeds over 100 MPH. I was doing 160 MPH with one student.

Bro I'll TEACH YOU HOW TO DRIVE don't even

Someone
09-01-2010, 06:23 PM
Decided to delete my post.

Someone
09-01-2010, 06:26 PM
Decided to delete my post.

swarga
09-01-2010, 09:50 PM
Don't change the fact pattern to justify your conclusions.

WTF is a "fact pattern?" I'm not familiar with that term, and Google turns up nothing useful for it.



Sloth was driving slowly while someone crossed the double yellow to pass and struck the farm tractor. Despite the frustrations with the slow driver, the fault here is clearly with the driver who attempted the pass. Nothing you say can change that fact.

So let me propose a hypothetical scenario:

You drive your brand new Escalade with the 22" spinner rims down to Compton. You pull into a 7-Eleven and leave the engine running, the keys in the ignition, and the doors unlocked while you run inside for a Slurpee. You come out a few minutes later to an empty parking space.

Who is at fault for the theft of your ride? Is it 100% the fault of the homeboy who stole it, or do you share some of the blame?

Bottom line, people who do asinine things with their cars are responsible for the consequences of their actions.

Stealth Stalker
09-01-2010, 09:53 PM
Until people stop crashing then we're not going to see reductions in deaths. People aren't going to stop doing that until they become better drivers.
And that isn't going to happen until stupid people quit reproducing, so you guys need to learn to keep it in your pants! ;)

Raoul Duke
09-01-2010, 10:49 PM
A fact pattern is just what happened in your hypothetical scenario (sorry for the odd terminology, but that's what law school does to you). In your second hypothetical, the person who left the car unlocked and running is at fault for it being stolen. I agree with your bottom line, people are responsible for the consequences of their actions. We should not allow other people's behavior to affect our judgement so much that we make poor decisions.

Raoul Duke
09-01-2010, 10:50 PM
AsRacer, that is an impressive list. I just started DE this year and am having a blast. So far I have done Lightning, Limerock Park, and Watkins Glen.

It's addictive isn't it? I forgot about Limerock, raced there too. I hear they're not doing so well these days.

The secret is that once you get a bunch of schools under your belt you can then become an instructor. Once you're an instructor you can get your track time either for free or greatly reduced price. It makes the habit a little more affordable.

I expect that I one day I may have the opportunity to be an instructor. My understanding is that it takes several years unless you can dedicate 30-40 track days per year, which is something I can't afford to do yet.

MarshVegas
09-02-2010, 07:22 AM
Bro I'll TEACH YOU HOW TO DRIVE don't even

I'm happy to learn from whomever I can. I will always be a student when it comes to driving.

What are your credentials?

credentials hahahaha o.k. over 25 pages long per local/state police that was Years ago grown up now since the age of 4 rode dirt for about 20 years then supersportbikes for past 10 have absolutely been i love with going fast. Crashed plenty, manybroken bones and "crashing is learning" But honestly where you at? send me a pm maybe we could have somefun one day on a " closed course " of course

swarga
09-02-2010, 09:25 AM
A fact pattern is just what happened in your hypothetical scenario (sorry for the odd terminology, but that's what law school does to you).

Speaking of the law, there is something called "the rule of felony murder" which makes any participant in a felony criminally liable for any deaths that occur during or in furtherance of that felony. Sloth driving is not a felony, of course, but the same logic should apply to the misdemeanor/infraction of blocking faster traffic.


We should not allow other people's behavior to affect our judgement so much that we make poor decisions.

In a perfect world that would be the case. In the real world, nobody's perfect, people do get angry and make poor decisions, and the Sloths who trigger this "Road Rage" should not be allowed to just drive away scot-free; they should be held accountable for their anti-social behavior.

Sloth Kills!!!

Someone
09-02-2010, 09:54 AM
Decided to delete my post

Raoul Duke
09-02-2010, 09:11 PM
Speaking of the law, there is something called "the rule of felony murder" which makes any participant in a felony criminally liable for any deaths that occur during or in furtherance of that felony. Sloth driving is not a felony, of course, but the same logic should apply to the misdemeanor/infraction of blocking faster traffic.


Well, that is an accurate sumnmation of the felony muder rule, execpt, as you noted, there was no felony committed in this scenario.

Let's examine the following scenario. Driver A and Driver B are traveling along a city street. As they approach an intersection with a traffic light, the light turns yellow. Driver A slows down and stops as the light turns red. Driver B decides to run the light before it turns red and passes Driver A on the left, crosses the double yellow line, and collides with another vehicle in the intersection. Who's at fault here? Driver A or Driver B?

swarga
09-02-2010, 09:32 PM
Let's examine the following scenario. Driver A and Driver B are traveling along a city street. As they approach an intersection with a traffic light, the light turns yellow. Driver A slows down and stops as the light turns red. Driver B decides to run the light before it turns red and passes Driver A on the left, crosses the double yellow line, and collides with another vehicle in the intersection. Who's at fault here? Driver A or Driver B?

That's not a comparable scenario. Driver A in your example is operating his vehicle within the law. The Sloth blocking the 2-lane highway and refusing to pull off to allow stuck traffic to pass is in violation of the law in many states (AZ is one example).

Raoul Duke
09-02-2010, 11:03 PM
Let's examine the following scenario. Driver A and Driver B are traveling along a city street. As they approach an intersection with a traffic light, the light turns yellow. Driver A slows down and stops as the light turns red. Driver B decides to run the light before it turns red and passes Driver A on the left, crosses the double yellow line, and collides with another vehicle in the intersection. Who's at fault here? Driver A or Driver B?

That's not a comparable scenario. Driver A in your example is operating his vehicle within the law. The Sloth blocking the 2-lane highway and refusing to pull off to allow stuck traffic to pass is in violation of the law in many states (AZ is one example).

Why isn't it comparable? In the original scenario, sloth was doing 45mph in a 55 mph zone. That's well within the law. If a minimum speed is posted, then it is usually 40 mph for a 55 mph zone. Where is the traffic infraction?

johndoesix
09-02-2010, 11:35 PM
(snip)
But the problem with our society today is that nobody wants to accept personal responsibility for their actions. So people would rather continue to point the blame for deaths and injuries related to car crashes onto things like the car, the road or speed, rather than where the blame belongs. With the drivers.

Amen to everything you said, although some of it was snipped. I had one student let go of the f'ing steering wheel when the car got sideways and screamed! Nevermind that I asked if she knew how to handle a sliding car. Now mention skid control at highway speeds or at some of the speeds we speed at and that's a whole different story. Remember, everybody knows how to drive fast in a straight line.

Oh, and if only folks could understand what's it's like to go side by side around a corner with another racer (in your class or not) for the duration of a race. :p

swarga
09-03-2010, 09:09 AM
Let's examine the following scenario. Driver A and Driver B are traveling along a city street. As they approach an intersection with a traffic light, the light turns yellow. Driver A slows down and stops as the light turns red. Driver B decides to run the light before it turns red and passes Driver A on the left, crosses the double yellow line, and collides with another vehicle in the intersection. Who's at fault here? Driver A or Driver B?

That's not a comparable scenario. Driver A in your example is operating his vehicle within the law. The Sloth blocking the 2-lane highway and refusing to pull off to allow stuck traffic to pass is in violation of the law in many states (AZ is one example).

Why isn't it comparable? In the original scenario, sloth was doing 45mph in a 55 mph zone. That's well within the law. If a minimum speed is posted, then it is usually 40 mph for a 55 mph zone. Where is the traffic infraction?

From the California Vehicle Code (other states have similar laws):



21656. On a two-lane highway where passing is unsafe because of
traffic in the opposite direction or other conditions, a slow-moving
vehicle, including a passenger vehicle, behind which five or more
vehicles are formed in line, shall turn off the roadway at the
nearest place designated as a turnout by signs erected by the
authority having jurisdiction over the highway, or wherever
sufficient area for a safe turnout exists, in order to permit the
vehicles following it to proceed. As used in this section a
slow-moving vehicle is one which is proceeding at a rate of speed
less than the normal flow of traffic at the particular time and
place.


BTW, I'm not surprised you don't know about these laws. It seems that nobody does.

Raoul Duke
09-03-2010, 09:07 PM
swarga, NY has a similar law, but it states:

1181. Minimum speed regulations. (a) No person shall drive a motor vehicle at such a slow speed as to impede the normal and reasonable movement of traffic except when reduced speed is necessary for safe operation or in compliance with law.

Since neither statue puts a number on the speed that defines a slow moving vehicle, the question becomes what is the normal flow of traffic (for CA) or normal and reasonable movement of traffic (for NY). In a 55mph zone, how slow does a vehicle have to travel before it qualifies as being too slow for the normal flow of traffic?

swarga
09-03-2010, 10:50 PM
Since neither statue puts a number on the speed that defines a slow moving vehicle, the question becomes what is the normal flow of traffic (for CA) or normal and reasonable movement of traffic (for NY). In a 55mph zone, how slow does a vehicle have to travel before it qualifies as being too slow for the normal flow of traffic?

The speed limit is irrelevant. If the normal flow of traffic on the road is X, then X-1 is too slow. People who are too scared to drive at X should take another route or let someone else drive, not cause needless headaches for everyone else on the road.

The problem is, for some people it is a matter of pride and ego. It seems as though pulling over to the right lane or using a turnout is akin to being castrated for these guys. Personally, I have zero problems getting out of the way of faster traffic; the last thing I want is some pissed off driver riding on my ass on a two-lane highway. The sooner I pull over and let him pass, the sooner he is out of my life.

chriskohtc
09-04-2010, 12:07 AM
I had one student let go of the f'ing steering wheel when the car got sideways and screamed! Nevermind that I asked if she knew how to handle a sliding car.

At least she didn't go, "Jesus, take the wheel!!!"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcR8N_v0ymQ

Gator Bite
09-04-2010, 08:01 AM
Speed doesn't kill you. Alcohol doesn't kill you. Distractions don't kill you. Bad weather doesn't kill you. Other motorists don't kill you either. What is it then that will kill you?

Actually, it is sloth that will kill you. Consider the following scenario:

Mr. Safe N. Slow is driving slowly and (he believes) safely down a two-lane rural road with no passing zones. The posted limit is 55, but our protagonist is driving at a nice, safe 45 MPH, oblivious to the line of 20 cars stacked up behind him, drivers pounding their steering wheels in frustration. He refuses to use the turnouts or pull off the road, and the center stripe is a solid double yellow, so legally none of the stuck drivers can pass.

Finally, one of the stuck drivers gets fed up. He nips out across the double yellow center-line and begins to pass Mr. Slow. At that moment, a farm tractor pulls out of a driveway directly into the path of the passing car; they collide, killing the driver.

Mr. Slow, still completely oblivious, continues to putter along to his destination. If you ask Mr. Slow, he'll smugly brag about what a safe driver he is, proudly pointing to the fact that he has had no tickets or accidents for over 40 years. Meanwhile, an innocent driver is dead due to his sloth.

So yeah, it's not Speed that kills - it's Sloth.

Funny you author this hypothetical scenario. It's spooky close to what just happened just 15 minutes from where I live. On a local road (Route 34) there were a bunch of cars stacked up behind a slow moving car. This can happen a lot on this road, because it's a favorite short cut between Danbury to Rt-8 in Derby. Anyway, an impatient driver decided he wasn't going to wait for a passing zone. He shot out over the double yellow line into the other lane, in his Toyota Tacoma, and went for a pass. He passed a car or two, then from the other direction around a blind turn came my neighbors sister in her Toyota Corrola. She was in the proper lane, he was not. They went head on, she died, he lived. Funny thing is, it's his ass that got arrested, not the sloth's. (See news article (http://www.nhregister.com/articles/2010/06/08/blotter/doc4c0db128c0239876945696.txt).)

Because this was my neighbor's sister, I was able to get a lot of info. The guy who was driving the Tacoma had a suspended license, for all sorts of bad driving, including misuse of lanes (passing over a double yellow). He also said some really stupid stuff like, "she (the dead victim) should have bough a bigger car", implying that is why she's now dead, because she chose a Corrola.

Sorry Swarga. I can't agree with you. I find myself in this scenario way too often, and I find it very frustrating. But the double yellow is there for a reason and it's not to piss us off. It's because the road there does not offer a safe passing environment. Visibility, side streets, congestions, etc... may play a part in that decision.


The problem is, for some people it is a matter of pride and ego. It seems as though pulling over to the right lane or using a turnout is akin to being castrated for these guys. Personally, I have zero problems getting out of the way of faster traffic; the last thing I want is some pissed off driver riding on my ass on a two-lane highway. The sooner I pull over and let him pass, the sooner he is out of my life.

Oh man, you don't know the half of it. Try coming up on a mini van in a bright red Porsche. I swear to god people intentionally slow down in front of me just to protest my choice in vehicle and piss me off. This doesn't happen to me in my daily driver VW Passat. As soon as I jump into the Porsche, everyone wants to drive slower than ever. I've given up on getting my kicks on the street. It's just pointless and dangerous. Like Raoul Duke, this is how I have my fun:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qd_J8LmwzBM

Once you've spent a little time doing this in a controlled setting, the whole idea of driving fast on the street becomes ridiculous to you. On the track there are no side streets where cars can enter your path. There is no oncoming traffic. There are flaggers that warn you if there is a hazard beyond your vision. The other drivers out there all drive predictably, and there are rules on how to pass. Don't get me wrong, if I can find a twisty back road and there is no one in front of me, I'm going to have some fun. But I will NOT cross a double yellow to pass someone so that I can have fun. It's just dangerous (beyond being illegal).

EDIT (addition): BTW - When I'm doing this, my 9500ci is turned OFF. No need for detectors, jammers, laser viels here..... :cool:

swarga
09-07-2010, 12:26 AM
On a local road (Route 34) there were a bunch of cars stacked up behind a slow moving car. Anyway, an impatient driver decided he wasn't going to wait for a passing zone. He shot out over the double yellow line into the other lane, in his Toyota Tacoma, and went for a pass. He passed a car or two, then from the other direction around a blind turn came my neighbors sister in her Toyota Corrola. She was in the proper lane, he was not. They went head on, she died, he lived.

Sorry Swarga. I can't agree with you.

So let me ask you this: Suppose that Sloth with all the cars stacked up behind him had stayed home that day. Wouldn't your neighbor's sister still be alive? After all, Mr. Tacoma would have had nobody to pass, so he would have stayed on his own side of the road, and there would have been no collision.

Gator Bite
09-07-2010, 06:34 AM
So let me ask you this: Suppose that Sloth with all the cars stacked up behind him had stayed home that day. Wouldn't your neighbor's sister still be alive? After all, Mr. Tacoma would have had nobody to pass, so he would have stayed on his own side of the road, and there would have been no collision.

That's a mighty big 'if'. I hope you don't really think like this. I have to assume that you're just trying to make discussion, because if you do really believe that the sloth had any liability in this, then I'm scared for those who share the streets with you. Speed limits are just that, limits. They are not 'minimum requirements'. Maybe the slow moving car was driven by someone elderly, who has less vision and reflexes than us younger drivers, someone who is safer at 35 mph.

Here's a more realistic 'if'. If Mr. Tacoma (Mr. Neustadter) had obeyed the traffic laws, Marie would still be alive today, and her two adorable daughters, 10 and 12 years old, would still have a mother. Or how about this one, "If Mr. Neustadter had obeyed the conditions of his suspension (driver's license), Marie would be alive today."

Honestly, they can't punish this guy enough (Mr. Neustadter), in my opinion. He should get life in prison for taking those girl's mother from them.

Here's an if that's just as reasonable as the one you presented. "If the courts threw Mr. Neustadter in prison for 3 years for crossing the double yellow line last December, Marie would still be alive today." Throwing someone in jail for crossing the double yellow is no more reasonable than blaming this tragedy on a slow driver.

swarga
09-07-2010, 09:17 AM
I hope you don't really think like this. I have to assume that you're just trying to make discussion, because if you do really believe that the sloth had any liability in this, then I'm scared for those who share the streets with you.

Why? My "Sloth Kills" argument is every bit as valid as the "Speed Kills" argument.

Raoul Duke
09-07-2010, 11:36 PM
Since neither statue puts a number on the speed that defines a slow moving vehicle, the question becomes what is the normal flow of traffic (for CA) or normal and reasonable movement of traffic (for NY). In a 55mph zone, how slow does a vehicle have to travel before it qualifies as being too slow for the normal flow of traffic?

The speed limit is irrelevant. If the normal flow of traffic on the road is X, then X-1 is too slow. People who are too scared to drive at X should take another route or let someone else drive, not cause needless headaches for everyone else on the road.

The problem is, for some people it is a matter of pride and ego. It seems as though pulling over to the right lane or using a turnout is akin to being castrated for these guys. Personally, I have zero problems getting out of the way of faster traffic; the last thing I want is some pissed off driver riding on my ass on a two-lane highway. The sooner I pull over and let him pass, the sooner he is out of my life.

Now we get to the heart of the matter. How do you decide what the normal flow of traffic on the road should be? Who decides what the normal flow of traffic should be? Remember, the speed limit is a maximum speed for the road (assuming normal dry road conditions). Exceed it at your own peril.

So, according your scenario, the speed limit is irrelevant and each driver should decide what the normal flow of traffic should be. So, driver A driving at PSL +10 is driving too slow for driver B who wants to drive the PSL +20? Sounds like a surefire recipe for anarchy on the roads. What if there are 5 cars on the road doing the PSL? Does the 6th car that wants to drive faster dictate the "normal" flow of traffic?

swarga
09-08-2010, 12:23 AM
Now we get to the heart of the matter. How do you decide what the normal flow of traffic on the road should be?

We have these things called speed surveys. They are objective and scientific - unlike most speed limits, which are politically determined.


Who decides what the normal flow of traffic should be?Why, 85% of drivers do, that's who. Google up the concept of "85th percentile speed" sometime.


Remember, the speed limit is a maximum speed for the road (assuming normal dry road conditions). Exceed it at your own peril. Remember, most speed limits are set not by scientific surveys, sound engineering, or safety principles, but for revenue enhancement. The main peril for exceeding a speed limit is to your wallet.


So, according your scenario, the speed limit is irrelevantNo, according to the law the speed limit is irrelevant. You'll notice that CVC 21656 makes no mention of any speed limits.

Fritter
09-09-2010, 09:34 PM
Swarga, the driver who lost patience and crossed into oncoming traffic is at fault. Period. He made the decision to cross into oncoming traffic because he put his needs in front of his fellow motorists. He was selfish and his actions caused the loss of life. He could have just stayed where he was at and fumed at the "sloth" without endangering others on the road with his careless and selfish act.

Did the "sloth" clog traffic? Yes. Did it inconvienience others? Obviously. But did he "make" the driver cross into the oncoming lanes? no. He did not.

People who think like you do make me smile. Job security.:)

F

Raoul Duke
09-09-2010, 10:37 PM
You'll notice that CVC 21656 makes no mention of any speed limits.

Correct. However, when you read that provision as part of the California Vehicle Code, you will notice another provision of the code which reads,

V C Section 22349 Maximum Speed Limit
Maximum Speed Limit

22349. (a) Except as provided in Section 22356, no person may drive a vehicle upon a highway at a speed greater than 65 miles per hour.

(b) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person may drive a vehicle upon a two-lane, undivided highway at a speed greater than 55 miles per hour unless that highway, or portion thereof, has been posted for a higher speed by the Department of Transportation or appropriate local agency upon the basis of an engineering and traffic survey. For purposes of this subdivision, the following apply:

(1) A two-lane, undivided highway is a highway with not more than one through lane of travel in each direction.

(2) Passing lanes may not be considered when determining the number of through lanes.

(c) It is the intent of the Legislature that there be reasonable signing on affected two-lane, undivided highways described in subdivision (b) in continuing the 55 miles-per-hour speed limit, including placing signs at county boundaries to the extent possible, and at other appropriate locations.

However, section 22349 sets the maximum speed limits on public roads. Although other sections do not specifically or explicitly mention a speed limit, this section is the controlling section of the vehicle code. So it does not matter that 21656 is silent about a speed limit. If you don't believe this, ask a California attorney to explain it to you.

Fritter, drivers who violate the vehicle code and cause accidents also keep lawyers employed.