PDA

View Full Version : Anybody use Garmin GPS systems?



unmamfqlm
08-31-2010, 01:27 PM
I have a Tomtom one, and the thing is just about useless to me. It's not the Tomtom itself, but the maps and what not for it. I can't count how many times that it has taken me to dead ends, uneccesary routes, and to wrong locations in general. I do keep it updated, but it still doesn't fix the issues. I'm thinking about purchasing a Garmin to try out for a while to see if they may be better. What do you all think about the Garmin GPS systems?

josetrate
08-31-2010, 02:27 PM
Hi

I use garmin.. And I just wont Garmin for me and my friends....


For me the garmin just have one problem... The map refresh is a little slow.... With pois and without them... Maybe change the firmware by a costum firmware this cam be solved...

voyager7
08-31-2010, 03:48 PM
I run nothing but Garmin and have for years.

My brother and dad both have tom toms and IMHO they suck.

supercowpowers
08-31-2010, 03:52 PM
I've had a Garmin for about 3 years now, I can only hope the new ones are better.

There are only a few problems I've had with it. I can't remember any extreme failures like sending me to a dead end, so if these are the only problems I've had in 3 years I'd say it's probably better than your tomtom.

One time, I was trying to get to a guy's house to buy a set of wheels and tires. It got me on to the right road, but told me the destination was about half a mile before the actual house number.

The refresh rate and accuracy suffered in NYC. With buildings blocking 80% of the sky, I'm not sure if that's really a problem.

It considers staying straight on the same highway when there's another one that branches off to be a "turn". It was confusing at first because you had to read what it's asking you to do and pay attention to the map to tell if it really wants you to "turn" and get off or just make sure you're in the correct lane to go straight.

The distance-to-turn is not 100% accurate, but it's usually enough to let you figure out which road you're looking for.

POI settings are a little screwed up. According to Garmin I should be able to set POIs to give me ~30 seconds of alert at whatever speed I'm going at. That never worked, so I have to set them for distance - 1/2 mile is barely adequate on the highway and kind of annoying in town.

nomore55
08-31-2010, 04:32 PM
It's not the Tomtom itself, but the maps and what not for it.

Yeah, it's Navteq (Garmin) vs. TeleAtlas (Tom Tom). That's the problem. TeleAtlas is Europe-based, FWIW. Navteq is USA :)

I've seen some alarming comparisons between Garmin and TomTom in the trade publications.

nomore55
08-31-2010, 04:35 PM
BTW, unmamfqlm, if you are ready to upgrade, one of the Garmin dealers* has a sick deal on a re-furb'd 265WT for $120. I liked the unit it so much I bought a 2nd. The display and amount of info provided in the main view is awesome.

*we're not allowed to mention competitor names on the forum

Hunter
08-31-2010, 05:02 PM
I have Garmin for a few years.It works ace.

Rocketman59
08-31-2010, 05:13 PM
I have a Garmin 176C that I use on my M/C. It does not do routing but is fully waterproof, so the maps are fine. I was given a Garmin by work, I did not like the operation or the maps at all. I have been using a Magellan Maestro 4040 for about 3 years now. I LOVE IT! It has never taken me down a wrong street. It has a great docking station that I have in 2 cars. Works perfect and has blue tooth hands free. What it will not do is send GPS info over the Blue-Tooth to my Verizon Blackberry so I can run Trapster. Other wise my only complaint is the Magellan web site is out of the Map Upgrade CD for 45 days now. Gez, How long does it take to make CD'S. The best part was I picked it up on refurbished for $140.00.

http://www.gpsmagazine.com/2007/04/review_magellan_maestro_4040.php

Here is a link for a test of the unit. Tnx ;)

unmamfqlm
08-31-2010, 05:19 PM
It's not the Tomtom itself, but the maps and what not for it.

Yeah, it's Navteq (Garmin) vs. TeleAtlas (Tom Tom). That's the problem. TeleAtlas is Europe-based, FWIW. Navteq is USA :)

I've seen some alarming comparisons between Garmin and TomTom in the trade publications.

Ah, I see. I wasn't sure how the map stuff worked for GPS systems. That does make sense.

mahjong007
08-31-2010, 05:24 PM
I have a Tomtom one, and the thing is just about useless to me. It's not the Tomtom itself, but the maps and what not for it. I can't count how many times that it has taken me to dead ends, uneccesary routes, and to wrong locations in general. I do keep it updated, but it still doesn't fix the issues. I'm thinking about purchasing a Garmin to try out for a while to see if they may be better. What do you all think about the Garmin GPS systems?

i think u may encounter the same problem with garmin. i been using a garmin frequently and like the tomtom you have, it has the same problem. i'm not sure how much problem you are having with ur tomtom but i csn say, garmin will have close to the same with about any gps. longer route, dead ends, lag times.. but over all and all, i believe my gps help me countless when i'm lost or need go somewhere i need to be. one thing i dont like about my 780 is that the gps sometimes hard to get a lock. but who am i to compare, i never use anything else besides a garmin.. so i'm sure with some research you will find another one right for you to use.

Cruisin'Spartan
08-31-2010, 06:39 PM
I've had a Garmin 255w for about 2 and 1/2 years, and I love it. It's never steered me wrong. I use it about 5 days a week for work (still delivery driving, working on getting my post college job, interview soon). When I have to use it (it's always on though) it always gets me dead on or very close to the house or business location I'm looking for.

AirMoore
08-31-2010, 07:48 PM
I have been using a Garmin Nuvi 200W for a long-time now... and I love it. Every GPS in my family is a Garmin... of course you will always have little hiccups... but it is just another tool to get me to my destination, I never let it drive for me.

Hunter
08-31-2010, 09:14 PM
I've had a Garmin 255w for about 2 and 1/2 years, and I love it. It's never steered me wrong. I use it about 5 days a week for work (still delivery driving, working on getting my post college job, interview soon). When I have to use it (it's always on though) it always gets me dead on or very close to the house or business location I'm looking for.

This is the exact one i have.Gotta love it.

thx1138
08-31-2010, 09:51 PM
I've had the nuvi255 for a little over a year. No complaints with routing. Easy to detour around traffic jams. Display and touch interface pretty good (qwerty keypad). Database for attractions, stores, gas stations is pretty good.

Complaints: Battery degrades very quickly. I even sent it back in under warranty, but after a year the battery doesn't hold charge very long (maybe one hour). Also tall buildings in Chicago interfered a bit with reception. Satellite acquisition can take a minute when you power it up.

Overall, very postive experience when using it in the car

OpenRoad
09-01-2010, 02:07 AM
Garmin seems to have the corner on this market. They are decent, and very affordable.

They do have some issues, my biggest pet peeve with these is their travel directions and "Turn in XXX miles" on the display. They have a 'feature' that informs you to "do not exit here" whenever you intersect with a state or national highway. It says, "keep left onto xxx", when all but the exit lane apply. At least it does not do it for every exit.

I wish there was a mode that shows when you ACTUALLY have to exit, so you can plan accordingly. A few minor code changes would make them perfect.

protias
09-01-2010, 03:46 PM
Yes, I have two. Both of them are far better than my Magellan.

srtga
09-01-2010, 04:34 PM
I like my Garmin although it occasionally lets me down.

Been thinking about one of these:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHqdGUNYX10&feature=related

protias
09-01-2010, 04:38 PM
I like my Garmin although it occasionally lets me down.

Been thinking about one of these:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHqdGUNYX10&feature=related

That's pretty neat.

WLH
09-01-2010, 04:48 PM
I also have a Garmin 255w and while it is basic it get the job done.

Hunter
09-01-2010, 05:05 PM
Yes, I have two. Both of them are far better than my Magellan.

my sister gave my dad a magellan....and he says it is totally useless..lol

protias
09-01-2010, 05:07 PM
Yes, I have two. Both of them are far better than my Magellan.

my sister gave my dad a magellan....and he says it is totally useless..lol

The Magellan takes forever to get a signal (more than 5 minutes on a good day).

Hunter
09-01-2010, 05:14 PM
That is what he said also.That is sad,cause those things are not cheap.

protias
09-01-2010, 05:19 PM
That is what he said also.That is sad,cause those things are not cheap.

Until you try to sell it. A year after I purchase my 860T (paid 700), I looked at what the resell value was, it was at 200! I can only imagine what it is now (4 years after I purchased it).

srtga
09-01-2010, 05:41 PM
I like my Garmin although it occasionally lets me down.

Been thinking about one of these:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHqdGUNYX10&feature=related

That's pretty neat.

Yea but is it any good? I believe navteq and teleatlas do GPS maps and Garmin uses navteq.

protias
09-01-2010, 06:01 PM
I like my Garmin although it occasionally lets me down.

Been thinking about one of these:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHqdGUNYX10&feature=related

That's pretty neat.

Yea but is it any good? I believe navteq and teleatlas do GPS maps and Garmin uses navteq.

It looks like Garmin uses navteq. As for the unit itself, I'm not seeing anything on Garmin's site. The closest I see is the current "top of the line" models: 3790T, 3760T, 3750.

hiddencam
09-01-2010, 07:42 PM
I have been using a Garmin Nuvi 200W for a long-time now... and I love it. EDitto, been using a Garmin Nuvi 200W for a couple years and it's excellent. Not perfect, but almost. Sometimes it gets me askew, but 99% of the time it's on the money. I would highly recommend it.

jdreynss
09-02-2010, 01:49 PM
I have a Tomtom one, and the thing is just about useless to me. It's not the Tomtom itself, but the maps and what not for it. I can't count how many times that it has taken me to dead ends, uneccesary routes, and to wrong locations in general. I do keep it updated, but it still doesn't fix the issues. I'm thinking about purchasing a Garmin to try out for a while to see if they may be better. What do you all think about the Garmin GPS systems?

I have owned a couple of garmin units, and I now own a tomtom. While i really did love the garmin units, the maps on them were horrible. In recent years there has been a lot of new streets built in my town. Many of these new streets have existed for 2-3 years, and they still do not appear on the garmin maps. I found that these same streets are on the Tomtom maps, and that is why I switched.

brasstownbald
09-02-2010, 03:35 PM
One of the biggest differences between the two is not so much the standard purpose of a GPS, which is navigating, but the special features such as POI's or points of interest and the file systems and formats used for that plus external software availability such as garmin's POI Loader and MapSource programs. They are really nice and help you get a LOT more out of your GPS than plain vanilla navigation.

IF you're not really familiar with GPS's and advanced functions and setting custom POI's etc then this may not mean much to you at this point.

If you're the type to want very basic plug and play functionality, then either is fine. I can't speak for the Tom Tom but I can verify that occasionally the Garmin will get you lost or confused. Not often...but it does happen. I think this would happen "occasionally" with ANY GPS. Nothing's perfect. I disagree that the maps are horrible. 99 percent; of the time they are just fine. Garmin is a very big outfit with a lot of years experience and their source for maps is very well established.

But if you are a "gadget" person and you tend to like utilizing electronic gadets to their fullest extent, IMO there will come a day that you will be glad you chose a Garmin because of the enormous flexibility with customization. I have an entry level GPS (Garmin Nuvi 205) and it does all the custom things I need very nicely.

Just to give you a quick example, I have ALL the Interstate rest areas in my Nuvi with custom alerts (sounds and visual pictures) and many have custom proximity alerts so that I get alerts on the GPS at distances I custom set for each Rest Area. This has been extremely handy while traveling. I like a 2.5 mile advance warning for rest stops.

The Tom Tom might also do all of this, but I believe the way the Garmin does it makes it much easier.

Again, if ALL you need is basic navigation and you never think you'll want to fully utilize it, then either is fine.

that guy
09-04-2010, 09:53 AM
I have a garmin and it sucks it keeps shutting itself off when ever i use it... i'm about to throw it out and just use my droids navigation from now on, I tested it next to the garmin and its ten times more accurate than the garmin also when you arive to the location it shows you a picture of the front of the house/store/where ever your going. so you know your in the right place very helpful if you never been there before.

OpenRoad
09-04-2010, 02:40 PM
I have a garmin and it sucks it keeps shutting itself off when ever i use it... i'm about to throw it out and just use my droids navigation from now on, I tested it next to the garmin and its ten times more accurate than the garmin also when you arive to the location it shows you a picture of the front of the house/store/where ever your going. so you know your in the right place very helpful if you never been there before.

That is a bug in some Garmins... you should be able to get an update online. (Mine was doing exactly the same thing, restarting itself now and then)

btw, that embedded video is really annoying... :)

Akosikojak
09-05-2010, 03:08 AM
Been running my Garmin Nuvi for almost 3 yrs and have had no major issues.

Only have one minor gripe that sometimes when making left/right turns to another road It sometimes is slow to refresh the map.

spartcus
09-06-2010, 01:28 AM
I have the Garmin nuvi 200 and just love it, just took a trip to Las Vegas with it.

partsfreak
09-26-2010, 03:35 PM
I have had a Garmin NUVI 760 for about 5 years now. It is currently at Garmin for a recall on the battery. In general it has been pretty good. I had to pay about $120.00 for the lifetime map updates because of the massive amount of new road construction in my city. It had no idea where it was going and many times tried to send me onto roads that no longer existed.(It takes awhile for Garmin to get updates as well). The unit is off by approx 100 yds which can be a problem at times. It tells you that you are at your destination after you have passed it, or when you are still a block away.(pisses me off!) It has tried to send me the wrong way on one way streets and has told me to go the wrong way onto an expressway exit ramp. It sometimes doesn't recognize a street address so I have to enter the nearest intersection to navigate too.(I go to places so country that you have to go to town to hunt). The points of interest and trip details features are great. One last thing. The camball auto video camera i have can hook up to the unit so I can use it as a monitor. Best thing about it is I got mine for free. What a deal.

srtga
09-27-2010, 12:31 AM
I just changed from a 255 to a 1350 and I'm diggin' the new one. Functionality is about the same but the bigger screen allows for more data plus you can choose what info is displayed. I like having miles to destination and direction of travel on the main screen along with ETA. It also displays speed in red when you're above PSL...

SteadySpeedin
09-27-2010, 11:07 PM
I love my garmin, but it has had a few problems. The first being sound, you can barely hear it at 100%. The second being that, every time I'm in an unfamiliar area and I want to get to Taco Bell or Applebee's, it will send me into a residential neighborhood and tell me to navigate off road. That really pisses me off.