PDA

View Full Version : Review of Garmin Nuvi GPS (Very long)



lordhamster
02-16-2006, 09:02 AM
Well folks, its time for my official review.

I’ve been driving with GPS systems in my car now for many years. I’ve always been too cheap to spend $2000 for the factory models, and have never been too impressed by them to start with. So I’ve used a variety of methods of in-car navigation.

My first GPS was a Garmin eTrex. The unit had no automotive abilities, but it could get a speed and direction and could give me a distance (as the bird flies) to destination. Nifty but not too useful. Next I got a Magellan 350, same as the eTrex really, except it had more features. After the Magellan, I went all out and bought a Garmin GPS V, which was the first of Garmin’s advanced navigators. It was the first handheld (hiking type) GPS they made that also had Automotive routing capabilities. The system had a black and white screen, and a rocker pad. You could load 19MB worth of maps, which boiled down to just about one state’s worth of streets. You could enter any address and have the system guide you to it. In advance of turns, the GPS V would beep at you and show you an arrow in the direction of the turn on it’s black and white screen.

Over the years, I also tried a variety of PC based systems. I would hook up a notebook PC to my eTrex for example and then have software on the notebook that would take the GPS input and allow me to do the navigation. Those worked very well, except that I don’t have an SUV so the notebook, power inverter and GPS all took up tons of room and essentially precluded me from having a front seat passenger. In addition, this setup was a gigantic pain when it came to parking the car, because I’d have to hide everything etc.

So finally in Christmas of ’04 my wife bought me a Garmin Quest GPS. The Garmin Quest was a revolutionary unit. It was the size of a cell phone, had a color screen and a nice windshield mount. It also had a speaker built into the cigarette lighter cord that would speak upcoming turn instructions. “Turn right in .2 miles” for example. Like the GPS V it used a rocker panel for data entry… but had a much easier interface. The screen was nice and bright and it’s maps were amazing. The unit had 119mb of map space, which would hold my route from Toronto through Cleveland to Chicago… so basically the whole rustbelt, my stomping grounds. Though it was a phenomenal unit, it had some major drawbacks.
1. Rocker Pad – it is very painful to enter data via a rocker pad.. especially things like addresses.
2. Speaker in Cig lighter was very tiny sounding and only said turn right or turn left in blah miles or blah feet.
3. Small screen
4. So-so reception at times


While I liked the Garmin Quest, I was yearning for something better. So, I eventually got my hands on TomTom5 software for my Treo 650. This is the same software that powers the TomTom Go units. This software when coupled with a Bluetooth GPS receiver was a work of art. The interface was very simple, even idiot proof (no learning curve), the display was a clean 3-d display that showed you just the information you need and not more… Audio directions were clear albeit simple (it would also only tell you turn left or turn right in x yards.) I could even load different voices onto the unit. I currently have Arnold Schwarzeneger giving me directions on where to make my turns hehehe.

This would have been the perfect solution had it not been for a few nagging issues.
1. The Treo can only support one Bluetooth device at a time, so I could not navigate and use my headset to talk or get phone calls at the same time. This is more a Treo issue than TomTom’s though.
2. Maps: The TomTom maps are divided into regions. If you load the Midwest for example, then you can navigate to anywhere in the Midwest, but not outside… Even if you load multiple regions into memory, the system cannot navigate across regional borders. TomTom solves this by having one massive all USA map… unfortunately for those of us who Travel to Canada from the northern US states, this is useless. So I’d have to navigate to the border, then switch maps after I crossed, a real hassle.
3. Maps: The maps Tom Tom uses are from TeleAtlas… which are supposedly great in Europe, but they suck big time here in the US. My home address for example was in the system, but my entire development was shown as being offset by about 1000 feet. Its like the guy digitizing the map slipped with his mouse and dragged my neighborhood 1000 feet to the left. This results in my car driving through the woods on the screen.

In short, I love TomTom 5 on my Palm for cruising around Cleveland, but for longer trips its useless… in addition it’s maps are sketchy.


So, my search for the perfect GPS continued. So a few weeks ago I became aware that Garmin had a new unit out called the Nüvi. This new unit has all of north America and Puerto Rico pre-loaded on it, with 700mb of free space to spare for mp3s or audiobooks. In addition, it has an unused SD slot where I can pop in an SD card full of mp3s or pictures etc. In addition, the unit has some tremendous advances over my older system.
1. Touchscreen: Yes! Finally I have a unit with a good touch screen.
2. Text to Speech. The Nuvi will actually read street names when it announces turns. So rather than saying right turn in .2 miles. It says, “In .2 miles, turn right onto Chester Ave”
3. SiRF Star III chip. The same awesome chipset that my Bluetooth GPS receiver uses is now in this new Garmin. Somehow this chipset is the only GPS I’ve ever had that can get a perfect signal from inside my house!!! Not to mention anywhere within my car. My older units I’d have to position just right under the windshield if I wanted any hope of getting a signal.
4. Simplicity. Garmin has taken a page from TomTom’s book on this one. They have simplified the interface to such an extent that anyone can use the unit without ever having seen a GPS or seen the manual. This is what I call good design (TomTom units also have this good design).
5. Tiny! The unit is all screen. The whole thing is maybe half an inch thick by like 3.5 or 4 inches diagonal… which means it fits perfectly in my pocket when I leave the car.
6. MP3s. This feature was not too important to me since I have an Ipod, but it is nice that I can load it with Mp3 music. In addition, if I hook it up to my car Stereo, I can listen to the music over the car speakers. When the system needs to give me a navigational warning, the music is paused, the instruction given, then the music unpaused. How cool is that?
7. Maps: What can I say, Garmin uses NavTeq which are by far the best maps available of North America. I belive that NavTeq actually has crews that go out and drive the roads in special mapping vehicles to correct their maps.
8. Custom POI Loader: All of the newer Garmin units, including this one have the ability to load custom POIs and give proximity alerts. What does this mean? Well you can load for example the location of every fixed speed and redlight camera in your state, and be warned when you are within a pre-defined distance f the camera!


All in all, this is the best Automotive GPS unit I’ve ever had. Very nice interface, good audio, spoken street names, touchscreen, unbeatable reception and phenomenal maps. What more could I ask for. Well, other than perhaps a built in XM or Sirus receiver. 

Edit: I've added some photos and I'm going to mention my mounting technique here also...

The first Photo is the car mounted in my car via the use of a proclip custom vent mount for my car, and 3m Dual Lock fastners.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v704/lord_hamster/DSCN0730.jpg

The second photo is a closeup of the proclip as seen from above with my factory Nuvi mount attached to it via the 3m Dual Locks.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v704/lord_hamster/DSCN0732.jpg

Third photo is a frontal view, showing that the mount is very unnoticeable, so as not to attract thieves when the unit is not in the car.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v704/lord_hamster/DSCN0731.jpg

Fourth is an image from the guy who originally gave me the idea to mount the Nuvi this way... he made this image showing a closeup of the fastners.
http://holmes4.net/nuvi/n1.jpg

I have to say the 3M Dual Lock Fastners are the vest thing ever to have been invented since velcro... they are unbelibeably strong and stable, they mount the GPS to the dash as if it was nailed on, but allow me to remove it at will.

I got the Proclip at www.proclipusa.com
and the fastners at a local target store where they were sold in the home improvement section (with all the tape) under the brand name "Scotch Dual Lock fastners"

amoney
02-16-2006, 12:30 PM
The new Garmins really look great. The SD card slot is ingenius that you describe, mp3, etc.

Even the cheaper street pilot looks good.

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0007LJHVA.01.PT01._SCLZZZZZZZ_.jpg

RacerX
02-16-2006, 12:38 PM
Excellent review!

Pics please. :)

lordhamster
02-16-2006, 02:21 PM
Excellent review!

Pics please. :)

I'll post lots of pics and screenshots as soon as I have some time and have the thing mounted in my car... right now my car is in the shop and I've to the loaner.

lordhamster
02-16-2006, 02:23 PM
The new Garmins really look great. The SD card slot is ingenius that you describe, mp3, etc.

Even the cheaper street pilot looks good.

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0007LJHVA.01.PT01._SCLZZZZZZZ_.jpg

The other garmins like the C320,C330,C340 and the I2,I3,I4,I5 are all very good units with very similar features. Featurewise the C340 is almost identical (except for the mp3 etc which is meaningless) but the major thing that made me choose the Nuvi over those was the fact that the Nuvi uses SiRF Star III for the GPS chip. In my bluetooth GPS I had noticed how this thing can get a satellite lock anywhere...the Nuvi is the same... damn good signal locks..


Anyway, more on this topic as time permits.

In the mean time, check out the following review... its excellent and has tons of screenshots and shots of the unit itself: http://gpsinformation.info/nuvi/nuvireview.html

lordhamster
02-16-2006, 04:36 PM
Original Post updated with pics of mount in my car.

Look carefully and you can see my V1 remote display at the bottom of the first photo. :)

kai445
02-28-2006, 12:42 AM
The SiRFstarIII is a beast, simply demolishes the competition.

There is a chipset comparsion here - http://www.gpspassion.com/fr/articles.asp?id=143&page=2

Interesting things to note is the sensitivity in -dBm, and the number of correlators (correlators who's job it is to interpret the incoming signal). Also the number of channels being 20 is strange (crazy much... more than is possible to see in the sky at any given time).

HighVoltage
02-28-2006, 09:14 AM
In short, I love TomTom 5 on my Palm for cruising around Cleveland, but for longer trips its useless… in addition it’s maps are sketchy.

Mapopolis does a better job at this sort of thing. Also divided (by county, parish, etc) but it will load adjacent regions out of an SD card seemlessly. I use it with an Magellan on a T3 (where the touchscreen works).



I got the Proclip at www.proclipusa.com
and the fastners at a local target store where they were sold in the home improvement section (with all the tape) under the brand name "Scotch Dual Lock fastners"

I 2nd the Proclip and Scothch Dual lock fasteners.

Great review lordhamster. Ive been looking for a new solution as the T3 is getting tired.

lordhamster
02-28-2006, 12:25 PM
In short, I love TomTom 5 on my Palm for cruising around Cleveland, but for longer trips its useless… in addition it’s maps are sketchy.

Mapopolis does a better job at this sort of thing. Also divided (by county, parish, etc) but it will load adjacent regions out of an SD card seemlessly. I use it with an Magellan on a T3 (where the touchscreen works).



I got the Proclip at www.proclipusa.com
and the fastners at a local target store where they were sold in the home improvement section (with all the tape) under the brand name "Scotch Dual Lock fastners"

I 2nd the Proclip and Scothch Dual lock fasteners.

Great review lordhamster. Ive been looking for a new solution as the T3 is getting tired.

I've used Mapopolis, it has great maps and like you said seamless transitions from map to map, but it's interface is just to Clunky. I perfer the idiot proof interfaces of the new tomtoms and garmins.

I can't wait till proclip comes out w/ a proper holder for the nuvi. The dual lock fasteners work great, but not as good as a dedicated holder would.

trickedout
08-17-2006, 10:40 AM
is there an option to change the distance units to kms?

lordhamster
08-17-2006, 11:05 AM
is there an option to change the distance units to kms?

Yes, all units can be switched to Metric.

I actually just got maps for Germany where I'll be using the unit with Metric units.

gluhwein
08-17-2006, 01:26 PM
Forgive my seeming stupidity Hamster, but does your car installation only use the vent mount and NOT the device holder? I went to the Proclip website and it looks like I'd need to spend over $60 to use the stuff they recommend. Are you just using the vehicle mount and then using the velcro to attach the Nuvi to the mount? In other words, half the price!!?

LittleOverPSL
12-11-2006, 12:25 PM
lordhamster - thanks to this review, I finally went and bought the Nuvi 360. I was seriously considering the TomTom ONE, but after looking closely at some apparently minor features it became apparent that the Nuvi's overall package is pretty sweet for a sales/mktg person that travels. I got one as a gift for the better half :)

happya$$
02-13-2007, 06:41 PM
This is definately the pinacle of GPS's. What is so different about the Nuvi 360 other than Widescreen and bluetooth?

TRDdave
12-29-2007, 02:45 PM
Im looking to buy a gps, and its between the nuvi 220w and the 360, is it worth spending the extra 50 dollars on this model?

amoney
12-29-2007, 07:31 PM
Im looking to buy a gps, and its between the nuvi 220w and the 360, is it worth spending the extra 50 dollars on this model?

For the money I would recommend the 200W.

I was deciding between the Nuvi and the TOMTOM ONE 3rd Edition, I picked the TOMTOM, is was dirt cheap black friday sale from Amazon, needless to say it was sold out FAST.

Anyways I was eyeing the nuvi 350/650, but then realized you can get the same GPS performance from the 200W for half the price.

I am totalled thrilled with TOMTOM, I have used other units which performance was terrible.

Note that I have coe to learn that NO gPS is 100% perfect there are "trouble" addresses that all will have, even the same erros accross the board as MSN or Google maps. Garmin or TOMTOM are the best.

There are some very cool GOS comming out with virtual cities but at the moment its implementation is anything but complete.

My suggestion is save your money, because these units get obsoleted very quick.

FYI I spent $150 bucks, the Nuvi200W goes for $225 on Amazon, free shipping too.

Jabomb9
12-29-2007, 10:41 PM
I actually just got the 200W for Christmas from my parents and I find it truly amazing. I have an eTrex Legend that I use when I go snowmobiling on Mt. Hood and it works great for that. But as the OP said, the eTrex series is pretty useless for anything automotive related. But I did get the maps for it earlier and it is cool, but impractical for driving because the screen is pretty poor and there are no turn-by-turn directions unless you upload a route from the MapSource software on your PC - which is okay for certain things, but the maps are limited because of the small memory of the unit.

But now for the Nuvi 200W - I LOVE this thing and can't believe that I didn't pick one up earlier. First off, I would suggest the widescreen version of any GPS unit because I looked at the regular Nuvis at the store and the screen seems too small after using the widescreen version. The sheer amount of information that it has onboard out of the box is mind-blowing. It has every street (with the exception of 2-3 that have just recently been constructed, so it is understandable) and every POI that I have encountered (with the address and phone number). I am also impressed by its ability to to the turn-by-turn directions anywhere, and if you miss a turn, it will automatically re-calculate the route. Also, the detour feature is godly. The sensitivity of the chip is also great. I can go through backcountry woods where there is NO view of the sky and the unit holds a full-strength signal.

Some more great features:
- The built-in rechargeable battery is very nice for leaving it on if you're leaving the unit briefly and don't want to have it power up again.
- The day/night modes are very nice so you don't have to have a white background in your face at night (the colors reverse).
- The ability to buy new maps and update the unit is great.
- The SD card slot is pretty useless for me, because I can't imagine myself viewing pictures on it and the lack of an MP3 player does not bother me at all.

And I bought the sandbag friction mount for the dashboard because it is super easy to take down and hide.

amoney
12-29-2007, 10:55 PM
Thats basicly the only thing seperating Garmin Nuvi and TOMTOM One, is tha battery life.

Nuvi is 6-8 hours

One is 2 hrs.

The Nuvi 200W is a great buy!

FYI I have found the turn by turn directions to be so accurate that you do not need the added street name to be spoken.

Jabomb9
12-29-2007, 11:08 PM
Yea the turn-by-turn directions are very accurate. When taking an exit that has multiple lanes, it reminds you several times (plenty in advance) as to which lane to take. And when you're not navigating, there's a bar at the top that shows the next cross street, which I find very useful. Rather than looking around street lights, stop lights, other obstructions, just look at the screen for the next street. Anyway, I love it and would recommend it to anybody.

TRDdave
12-30-2007, 02:36 PM
Cool, I made a typo, for me the decision was between the 200W and the 260*! Although, I am irritated to find that today, the sale has ended, everywhere, and all of the units are approx $50 more expensive than they were previously. I'll take the advice, I'll wait, and in the mean time, I'll do some more researching.

TRDdave
12-31-2007, 03:05 PM
I bought the nuvi 200W, at best buy for 211 with tax. I got way lucky, I asked them to price match walmart who was selling it for 248 +tax, and the guy at walmart gave him the wrong price, told him it was like 224, which is the price of the regular 200. Anyway, I used some rewardzone coupons and got it down to 211 with tax, not a bad deal!

Jabomb9
12-31-2007, 03:48 PM
Nice!

It's a fantastic unit.

amoney
12-31-2007, 08:34 PM
Costco is puting the 200W for sale January 2008 for $199 online plus shipping/tax

Amazon pice fluctuates around $225, free shipping.

thinkcrawley
01-16-2008, 12:37 AM
they are pretty good until your passenger side window is smashed, and then it is taken.

lugnuts
01-16-2008, 06:53 AM
I picked up the nuvi 660 at best buy over thanksgiving for $400 and I love this thing.

thinkcrawley-that suck that yours got stolen. the nuvi is so small I take it out of my car and put in my pocket every time I park my car. I have a soft top Jeep so I don't leave anything in view that a thief would want.

bart99gt
02-09-2008, 07:18 AM
I always take mine down, even at home sometimes (we just have a carport).

The statements made earlier about the SiRF Star III chipset are absolutely dead on though. I think Garmin makes their own brand chipset or builds the SiRF one under license because their site no longer mentions it directly on their website. Anyway, that is exactly why I don't recommend the older StreetPilot c3xx series to anyone. They might be cheap (c330s were going for as little as $130 I think) but for a little more you can get a much better performing unit.