-
Did I do Something Wrong?
This is not a trolling post to get a round of V1 vs Belscort bashing
I just installed the STi-r. Just one day of experience I think I have a problem. I run the V1 (3.872) and was comparing the it to the STi-r. So far only the usual annoying K band door openers to test against. I thought the Bel would be significantly better on K band (from other users posts and GOL testing), however I am not seeing good results. I receive alerts, but frankly the V1 is performing significantly better instead of the other way round. This is not what I expected against constant-on K band sources.
I've tried running with both detectors, and one at a time. In heavy traffic and-or light/no traffic, very same results. I've put the Bel in HWY mode, Auto, but the results don't change. I posted pics of the antenna in the show off your install thread. The antenna head is not recessed or obstructed.
Any ideas?? Unit Variation?? Call Bel and ask for service?
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
well your antenna is upside down as you just learned, and my V1 beats my STI R 90% on K band. It's Ka band you'll be impressed with. the STI - R beats it 99% of the time for me.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
I also run both Sti-R and V1,but my Sti-R is better against Off axis K band sources....
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
thx1138
This is not a trolling post to get a round of V1 vs Belscort bashing
I just installed the STi-r. Just one day of experience I think I have a problem. I run the V1 (3.872) and was comparing the it to the STi-r. So far only the usual annoying K band door openers to test against. I thought the Bel would be significantly better on K band (from other users posts and GOL testing), however I am not seeing good results. I receive alerts, but frankly the V1 is performing significantly better instead of the other way round. This is not what I expected against constant-on K band sources.
I've tried running with both detectors, and one at a time. In heavy traffic and-or light/no traffic, very same results. I've put the Bel in HWY mode, Auto, but the results don't change. I posted pics of the antenna in the show off your install thread. The antenna head is not recessed or obstructed.
Any ideas?? Unit Variation?? Call Bel and ask for service?
I like the disclaimer.
I've tested my V1 3.872 Vs. X50 Vs. 9500ix (when I still had it) against various K speed signs ... against some of them the V1 wins clearly and by a long way, but against some it's essentially a tossup. Forward facing of course. Point is, there are a lot of variables in real world testing ... Even the last GOL test, the V1 beat the STI-R on 1 of 3 runs.
I'd say find some more testing sources before you give up on the STI-R.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
If I have POP turned on with the V1 it will alert before the STi-R about half the time and the other half the STi-R will alert first. When I have the POP off on the V1 it will get beat most of time on K band. Like aa said you will be impressed when it comes to some of the Ka alerts that you get. Also, like sniper said off axis is where the STi-R shines that and forward facing radar.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
on top of it the STi-R has excellent door opener filtering
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Lucky225
on top of it the STi-R has excellent door opener filtering
Seeing that I've only tested against my local pharmacies, maybe that explains it. I need to find some speed signs or a LEO
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
thx1138
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Lucky225
on top of it the STi-R has excellent door opener filtering
Seeing that I've only tested against my local pharmacies, maybe that explains it. I need to find some speed signs or a LEO
x2 find some leo's and see how you do, i recommend also searching around, as you see in our sigs, me and meto have RDR off, and Ka segmentation on. I would recommend leaving RDR on if you are in an area where there are a lot of radar detector users, as you'll get a lot of Ka falses otherwise (It works the same was as the V1 Ka Guard).
I also have improved Ka detection with the segmentation on. a few searches of the forums will explain it
P.S. I have POP and Laser off.. dunno if it helps any.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
I have noticed that on real threats the STi-R alerts first most of the time, but on doe openers and other false threats the V1 does better.
I presume as mentioned above this is due to the filtering in the STi-R.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
I have run my Sti-R against my IX and X50 and the results are similar. My X50 appears to be unusually hot to K band and beats both of the other units. Not by much but none the less it is still alerting quicker.
But when it comes to KA band the Sti-r leaves the other two in the dust with the ix coming in second and the X50 a close third.
The absolute biggest advantage I have seen with the STi-r is its ability to pick up radar around curves and over hills much better than the others.
I think you are ok!;)
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
category4
I have noticed that on real threats the STi-R alerts first most of the time, but on doe openers and other false threats the V1 does better.
I presume as mentioned above this is due to the filtering in the STi-R.
Not in highway mode though right? Are you talking about autoscan I assume?
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TQUILL
Quote:
Originally Posted by
category4
I have noticed that on real threats the STi-R alerts first most of the time, but on doe openers and other false threats the V1 does better.
I presume as mentioned above this is due to the filtering in the STi-R.
Not in highway mode though right? Are you talking about autoscan I assume?
No in highway mode.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
category4
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TQUILL
Quote:
Originally Posted by
category4
I have noticed that on real threats the STi-R alerts first most of the time, but on doe openers and other false threats the V1 does better.
I presume as mentioned above this is due to the filtering in the STi-R.
Not in highway mode though right? Are you talking about autoscan I assume?
No in highway mode.
Ah, I didn't know the Sti-r filtered anything in highway mode.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TQUILL
Quote:
Originally Posted by
category4
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TQUILL
Quote:
Originally Posted by
category4
I have noticed that on real threats the STi-R alerts first most of the time, but on doe openers and other false threats the V1 does better.
I presume as mentioned above this is due to the filtering in the STi-R.
Not in highway mode though right? Are you talking about autoscan I assume?
No in highway mode.
Ah, I didn't know the Sti-r filtered anything in highway mode.
I am assuming it does, since it seems to pick up less false threats than the V1 but still picks up real threats as fast or faster than the V1.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Thanks guys for the feedback and real life experience. Looks like all is well. Just need some real radar to test.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
category4
I am assuming it does, since it seems to pick up less false threats than the V1 but still picks up real threats as fast or faster than the V1.
It most certainly filters K and Ka band in Highway mode. The RDR settings set to off remove some filtering for Ka related to junk detectors.
There needs to be another setting where ALL (or mostly all) filtering is removed.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Should the STi-r alert readily to a Bushnell k band shot, ie the STi-r shouldn't filter the Bushnell, right?
I test fired a few times and its hit or miss when I fire the Bushnell within the car. I'm really wondering if there is something wrong with K band. No Ka hits yet to judge.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
were you doing the bushnell as quick trigger? or holding the trigger down?
if i do quick trigger with my bushnell, the STI - R picks it up 1/5 times. the v1 gets it pretty much every time. so that's normal. belscort was never top dog at I/O shots.
and are you saying it NEVER picks it up? or ocasionally
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
I hold the bushnell trigger for like 3-5 seconds and I cannot get the Sti-r to alert unless I get out of the car and move the bushnell closer to the front of the car. If I'm parked in the garage I sometimes get an alert if I aim it forward and the signal hits the wall and bounces toward the receiver.
I would expect it to alert easily to the bushnell no matter which way I aim it given the proximity of the radar source to the receiver.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Update: I pulled the receiver out this afternoon, got an RA number and sent it back for a new receiver. Hopefully the 2nd unit will be right.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
thx1138
Update: I pulled the receiver out this afternoon, got an RA number and sent it back for a new receiver. Hopefully the 2nd unit will be right.
that might of been a smart move, if it doesn't even alert to the bushnell after 5 seconds, something isn't right.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
I have a brand new STi-r install (with LI as well), and in a couple hours of driving around in default band mode, it seems to me that the STi has K band "everywhere", alerting when the V1 never gets it. I have it in H mode, RDR on. Virtually all the alerts are 24.2xx, and I assume attributed to door openers etc. On two traffic radar signs, the V1 beat the STi by a big margin, with the STi not ramping at all but getting it near the signs at 7 or so.
I've had three encounters with Ka this morning, and each time STi beat V1 by a few seconds.
I need to read up more on K sources -- are there police radar in the 24.2xx, and if not can it be turned off, or do I just live with the falses if I want to monitor K?
Thanks,
Cal
PS, I should have said I haven't been on the highway much yet; maybe in the more urban area I ought to be using autoscan or citynox?
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Does your car have adaptive cruise control? If so, disable it and see how it goes.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
My car does have ACC, but it was not engaged... so no energy emitted then, right? Do you mean total disconnect it? By the way, I should have clarified in the first post, I didn't ALWAYS have a K-alert on the STi, just most of the time. It was silent for stretches of a mile or two in rural areas but then would pick up another 24.2xx.
Cal
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
calpalmer
My car does have ACC, but it was not engaged... so no energy emitted then, right? Do you mean total disconnect it? By the way, I should have clarified in the first post, I didn't ALWAYS have a K-alert on the STi, just most of the time. It was silent for stretches of a mile or two in rural areas but then would pick up another 24.2xx.
Cal
Some cars ACCs transmit constantly. I'm not sure if that is the case for the BMWs or not. 24.2xx is the exact reading I get from the Mercedes ACCs.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Thanks, maybe I'll take a look to see if there is something I can disconnect. All of these damned circuits are ECU monitored it seems, so it'll be a problem.
I still think it's the STi sensitivity, rather than ACC, because as I mentioned maybe 10% of the time I had no signal of any kind ...
Cal
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
I spent a little more time in the car today, trying to decipher the STi's K alerts, at 24.2xx. It's definitely not the ACC. First, it alerts whether ACC is active or not. Second, it doesn't correlate to any reflections back from other vehicles, buildings, etc. Most importantly, though: I had several occasions in the rural area of our region where I had no alerts, and I even tracked closely behind a delivery van with the ACC locked on him, and had no alerts. But overall, in the hour loop I drove I was probably 75% of the time in a built-up environment, and most of that time I had some kind of K alert going. Way more than the V1 reported.
I'll keep watching it to see if I can figure anything else out about it.
Cal
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
cal,
I think the BMW ACC system is always on to pre-load the brakes in what it determines as an emergency situation. BMW has some info here, this phrase sounds like it is always on "Radar sensors at the front of the vehicle permanently scan the road ahead." BMW has two forms of this technology: ACC, and ACC w/stop and go.
The Hella LIDAR based ACC system used in the Chrysler 300C is reportedly always-on.
The V1 is mostly shielded from the ACC radar due to it's location in the cabin while the STi-R's receiver is probably mounted very close to the ACC unit and not as shielded.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
I'll check the link out. I suspected it may be always on, but how would my alerts be explained by ACC, when I have periods (sometimes short, sometimes long ones) with no alert registered at all. If this K issue was interference from the ACC I'd always have it (I would think).
Cal
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Replacement head got here today..re-installing now.
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
EscortRadar
cal,
I think the BMW ACC system is always on to pre-load the brakes in what it determines as an emergency situation. BMW has some info
here, this phrase sounds like it is always on "Radar sensors at the front of the vehicle permanently scan the road ahead." BMW has two forms of this technology: ACC, and ACC w/stop and go.
The Hella LIDAR based ACC system used in the Chrysler 300C is reportedly always-on.
The V1 is mostly shielded from the ACC radar due to it's location in the cabin while the STi-R's receiver is probably mounted very close to the ACC unit and not as shielded.
Thanks for this link. It was helpful information, confirms that my ACC is constantly on. Since I have a lot of K hits going on with the STi-R, but not constantly so (as I posted, maybe 25% the detector is alert-free), is that consistent with the ACC being the source of the K interference?
I have a call into the local SM at BMW Northwest to ask how I can disable the ACC to test this out.
Cal
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
UPDATE: Just finished getting the hard mounts set-up for the new STi-r head. The new head appears to be working very, very well. When you look for a Ka speed trap, I can never find one. K band is very similar to the V1. Hard to tell, sometimes one or the other alerts first. I think the STi-r might have an off axis advantage. More to follow...just glad to get the head exchanged and re-installed/
-
Re: Did I do Something Wrong?
My tests also show that even old V1s have superior range than the STi (real live tests). Still, i am pleased with the range since it is sufficient. We are all limited by newer technologies in Ka and laser. The stealth feature is the main reason why i still prefer STi over the V1. It's a choice between stealth and range.