Results 1 to 7 of 7
  1. #1
    Lead Foot
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    At the Vanishing Point
    Posts
    497

    Default Device to help people drive better?

    Interesting read.
    The gadget that could make you a better driver. - By Tom Vanderbilt - Slate Magazine

    It Knows If You've Been Speeding
    Can a device that tracks when I swerve, accelerate, and brake make me a better driver?
    By Tom Vanderbilt
    Posted Monday, Nov. 30, 2009, at 12:32 PM ET
    The everyday act of driving suffers from a feedback gap.

    Sure, there are immediate signs when you're not doing something right, like when the rumble strips jolt you awake as you distractedly drift to the side of road. But more often, our only feedback comes in the form of run-ins with the law. I recently picked up a traffic ticket—my first in almost a decade—for driving 68 mph on the 45 mph Goethals Bridge (which, as I now know, is radar-controlled). Running late for the airport, I knew I was I driving faster than I should have been but never would have guessed by how much. My feedback came in the form of a $200 ticket and the officer's gentle reproach: "You were a little hot on the gas pedal there, Thomas."

    Without consistent feedback, it can be tough for a motorist to answer the question: How good a driver am I? In fact, we tend to be overconfident behind the wheel. A risky driver may go for a long time without a crash out of sheer luck, the same way a person who eats a terrible diet may live for decades with no apparent ill effects. And when external feedback does arrive, in the form of a honk or comment from another driver, it is likely to spark cognitive dissonance (What's their problem?) in the face of our carefully constructed sense of self-esteem.

    But what if you had something in your car that was monitoring your behavior (and I'm not talking about your spouse)? What would you learn about your own driving? Would it change the way you act?

    I was in pursuit of answers to these questions when I recently installed a ROVER in my car. The ROVER, from a Colorado company called Cartasite, is a small black box that consists of a three-dimensional accelerometer—which can measure rapid acceleration, hard braking, and erratic lane shifts—as well as a GPS and the ability to send data over cellular networks. Basically, it's like an iPhone that happens to be plugged into your car's Onboard Diagnostics port, that small interface (usually found beneath the steering wheel) that mechanics use to reference car trouble and which also, it turns out, collects a wealth of ongoing data—about things like engine load or the amount of carbon in the engine—that is usually wasted.

    The arrangement was simple: I would drive, and David Armitage, CEO of Cartasite, would monitor my behavior and provide some relative benchmarks (the device is also installed in several thousand vehicles in Colorado). A few words about my driving. Having absorbed, in the course of researching my book Traffic, scads of dry analyses of the various ways things can go wrong on the road—not to mention the traumatic biomechanical consequences that can follow—I tend toward caution (with the aforementioned exception). Having a 6-month-old daughter and being well out of my 20s also tends to neuter those need-for-speed impulses. I generally treat braking as losing—some kind of admission I haven't adequately anticipated molecular disturbances in the traffic flow—and find nothing more satisfying than a perfectly timed approach to a light changing green. I also live in New York City, where on some weeks my entire driving profile is summed up thusly: 1) Tuesday morning: Start car, double-park car across street. 2) Leave car parked for one hour. 3) Return car to freshly street-swept curb. 4.) Leave car there until following Tuesday.

    It just so happened, however, that during the trial I was doing more driving than usual, enough at least to provide a suitable sample. What I can report is that although the device was not visible to me and was not emitting any sort of signals, I would not have been more aware of its presence if it had been a giant eye suspended from the rearview mirror. I began, in fact, to anthropomorphize it a bit; it became "David," (i.e., Cartasite's CEO, whom I envisioned as having a window open on his desktop monitoring my progress with day-trader intensity). When, on I-95 South, a florist's van changed lanes in front of me without warning, necessitating a firm press on the brake pedal, I thought, "David's going to see that one, but how will he know it was the van's fault?" When I handed over the keys to the valet at the Foxwoods Casino (I was there for a planning conference, I swear), I briefly hesitated, with visions of a Ferris Bueller-style attendant throwing off my results. And when I brought the car in for routine maintenance, the puzzled mechanic came over to ask if I knew about the strange device in my OBD port. This led me into a brief sort of John Le Carré reverie, as if I were some West Berlin station chief who's just learned he's being watched: which I was.

    The reports came a few weeks later. Among the variables tracked by the ROVER are hard braking, rapid acceleration, overspeed, nighttime driving (as the report noted, "fatigue, poor lighting and the possibility of other drivers being impaired may place you at much higher risk when driving at night"), mpg, and idling. In the first report, I was pleased to see I had no hard braking and no rapid acceleration, though I did have 22 minutes of idling and an average of 1.1 overspeed events per hour. I had actually thought this would be higher, as I was definitely exceeding 55 on certain marked sections of I-95—as was everyone else—but it turns out ROVER doesn't, for the moment at least, track speed in relation to actual posted speeds; in part, Armitage told me, because speed limit data are so spotty. By the next week I had pulled something of a minor miracle, at least for Cartasite: a perfect 100 score. Over 7:39 hours and 217.92 miles of driving, I had no hard braking events, no rapid acceleration, a mere four minutes of idling (the device begins recording idling events after three minutes), and no nighttime driving.

    I am, admittedly, a bit of an outlier when it comes to this sort of thing; having received my perfect score, it occurred to me that I should have placed another device in, say, a New York City taxi. But thanks to reports Cartasite shared with me (names omitted), you can get a sense of how steep the curve is: One driver, who notched a score of 72, clocked more than 30 hard braking events per hour and half as many rapid acceleration moments (Armitage suspects the driver may have been on a cell phone). In one fleet vehicle report that came in, the driver was reported to have been idling for seven hours—even though he had driven only 11 miles that day.

    As with "smart metering" systems for domestic electricity use, the idea here is that feedback—by giving people a sense of what other people's behavior is, or what the ideal behavior should be—can make people's behavior change. Idling is a perfect example: Since the costs are essentially invisible (particularly for company drivers) and the behavior seemingly innocuous, there's little incentive to stop. (People also misunderstand when it makes sense to idle: Studies have shown that drivers falsely believe idling is more efficient than stopping and starting the engine for pauses up to three minutes long, when it's reality only more efficient to idle for less than a minute.) But as Michael P. Vandenberg and Anne Steinemann have argued, the societal consequence of mass idling—while small in the context of overall driving—is still huge: "[I]f Americans could be induced to idle for only thirty seconds from a cold start and ten seconds while waiting, 12.8 billion pounds of carbon dioxide emissions could be eliminated per year. This behavior change also would generate savings of roughly 640 million gallons of gas." Put another way, Americans simply sitting in their car produce more emissions than the sum total emissions (including nondriving activities) of countries like Costa Rica.
    Last edited by 8freerunner8; 11-30-2009 at 12:14 PM.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Device to help people drive better?

    At least my GPS unit does some rudimentary hint on my irregular driving.

    For example, it would remind me (by the digitised voice) to observe the prescribe speed limit whenever I go over the PSL. Sometimes whenever it detects that my car begin to swerve and not running parallel to the road alignment it would go off "Please drive carefully".

    It may not be at par with the impressive Rover in terms of total driving analysis but something is at least better than nothing at all.

  3. #3
    Power User
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    South Central PA, where the Walmart has hitching posts
    Posts
    3,024

    Default Re: Device to help people drive better?

    Quote Originally Posted by Whizzpass View Post
    At least my GPS unit does some rudimentary hint on my irregular driving.

    For example, it would remind me (by the digitised voice) to observe the prescribe speed limit whenever I go over the PSL. Sometimes whenever it detects that my car begin to swerve and not running parallel to the road alignment it would go off "Please drive carefully".

    It may not be at par with the impressive Rover in terms of total driving analysis but something is at least better than nothing at all.
    It takes my Nuvi 250 a good long time to determine that I didn't get off the exit it wanted me to and that I'm still on the highway, I don't think it's accurate enough to know if I'm still in my lane or not. .... but I haven't tested this since I updated the firmware on it.

  4. #4
    Newcomer
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Cherry Hill NJ
    Posts
    67

    Default Re: Device to help people drive better?

    Running late for the airport, I knew I was I driving faster than I should have been but never would have guessed by how much. My feedback came in the form of a $200 ticket and the officer's gentle reproach: "You were a little hot on the gas pedal there, Thomas."

    Without consistent feedback, it can be tough for a motorist to answer the question: How good a driver am I?
    Interesting article, but I see a big flaw in some of this thinking and the device. Does going over the PSL make you a bad driver? Does driving at night make you a bad driver? Absolutely not, but the ROVER (and author?) seems to think it does.

  5. #5
    Power User
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    South Central PA, where the Walmart has hitching posts
    Posts
    3,024

    Default Re: Device to help people drive better?

    Quote Originally Posted by mattcam3 View Post
    Running late for the airport, I knew I was I driving faster than I should have been but never would have guessed by how much. My feedback came in the form of a $200 ticket and the officer's gentle reproach: "You were a little hot on the gas pedal there, Thomas."

    Without consistent feedback, it can be tough for a motorist to answer the question: How good a driver am I?
    Interesting article, but I see a big flaw in some of this thinking and the device. Does going over the PSL make you a bad driver? Does driving at night make you a bad driver? Absolutely not, but the ROVER (and author?) seems to think it does.
    The activity of driving at night is riskier due to other fatigued drivers, drunks and poorer visibility. I think insurance companies would be likely to push this, so they'd care about that.

    It sounds like the device doesn't have a database of speed limits for every road you drive on, and will only complain if you exceed the blanket speed limit in your area. So you could, for instance, drive 50 MPH through the middle of town and as long as you don't brake hard for any red lights or pedestrians you're an excellent driver.

    I guarantee I could average 85 MPH on a highway and be easier on the controls than someone driving "conservatively" in town (which means I'd be making fewer decisions responding to hazards and traffic signals), but obviously I'd fail to please this machine.

  6. #6
    Power User
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    SoCal
    Posts
    4,842

    Default Re: Device to help people drive better?

    Quote Originally Posted by 8freerunner8 View Post
    I generally treat braking as losing—some kind of admission I haven't adequately anticipated molecular disturbances in the traffic flow—and find nothing more satisfying than a perfectly timed approach to a light changing green.
    Yeah - this is the dip**** that never exceeds 35 MPH in a 50 MPH zone because he's trying to time the traffic light up ahead. Meanwhile, the light is controlled by a loop sensor in the pavement, so it's not going to change until someone actually arrives at the intersection and trips it. Bottom line, the only thing these dumbasses accomplish is getting in everyone else's way.

    By the next week I had pulled something of a minor miracle, at least for Cartasite: a perfect 100 score. Over 7:39 hours and 217.92 miles of driving, I had no hard braking events, no rapid acceleration, a mere four minutes of idling (the device begins recording idling events after three minutes), and no nighttime driving.
    This device is rewarding the wrong criteria. People who accelerate like molasses in January should not be rewarded, they should have their goddamn licenses revoked!

    If you really want to improve peoples' driving, invent a device that will reward behavior like this:

    • Keeping right except to pass
    • Accelerating like you actually have someplace to go
    • Completing your pass quickly, instead of lollygagging next to the semi for the next 20 minutes
    • Using your turn signals properly
    • Getting up to the speed of through traffic and finding a safe gap when merging


    This ROVER thing is a piece of garbage that only Joan Claybrook would like.

  7. #7

    Default Re: Device to help people drive better?

    Quote Originally Posted by 8freerunner8 View Post
    Device to help people drive better?
    A fully functioning brain....
    ".....in honour of the last American hero to whom speed means freedom of the soul. The question is not when's he gonna stop, but who is gonna stop him...."

    V1+LI


 

 

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 2
    Last Post: 02-26-2010, 08:20 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •