View Full Version : Laser Interceptor Hype
The LI tests look good but an independently purchased unit needs to be tested. I'd also like to see it have at least a year's worth of field time to see how reliable it will be and how the company responds to complaints.
In the interim, I recently bought a Blinder M20. Here are my reasons:
1) It appears to be the most reliable hardware of the units I've read about.
2) The unit is LED based which is safer for other drivers during operation.
3) The unit is completely sealed against weather which is critical in regions with lots of rain and snow.
4) They have the best warranty.
5) They don't operate as if they are based out of a garage in Eastern Europe.
6) LEDs are less prone to failure and can't be overdriven and burned up like diodes.
I read the GOL tests. They look like they did a very good job. I do have one criticism though. JTG is funny, but is not really the goal of a laser jammer. For me, a jammer gives me a few precious seconds to respond and slow down. I only need the jammer to work for about 10 seconds and then I don't care if they get a speed reading.
With this in mind, I'd propose that the GOL tests include not only JTG tests, but something more realistic. I'd like to see a testing protocol that had reading points at 250 ft. intervals. So you'd try to get a speed reading at 1500, 1250, 1000,....250 ft. You'd have ten seconds to get a speed reading. If you couldn't get a reading in that time and the driver gets a warning of the laser gun activation for the entire 10 seconds then I'd say the jammer passes the test.
Thoughts?
happya$$
05-28-2007, 02:37 PM
The LI tests look good but an independently purchased unit needs to be tested. I'd also like to see it have at least a year's worth of field time to see how reliable it will be and how the company responds to complaints.
In the interim, I recently bought a Blinder M20. Here are my reasons:
1) It appears to be the most reliable hardware of the units I've read about.
2) The unit is LED based which is safer for other drivers during operation.
3) The unit is completely sealed against weather which is critical in regions with lots of rain and snow.
4) They have the best warranty.
5) They don't operate as if they are based out of a garage in Eastern Europe.
6) LEDs are less prone to failure and can't be overdriven and burned up like diodes.
I read the GOL tests. They look like they did a very good job. I do have one criticism though. JTG is funny, but is not really the goal of a laser jammer. For me, a jammer gives me a few precious seconds to respond and slow down. I only need the jammer to work for about 10 seconds and then I don't care if they get a speed reading.
With this in mind, I'd propose that the GOL tests include not only JTG tests, but something more realistic. I'd like to see a testing protocol that had reading points at 250 ft. intervals. So you'd try to get a speed reading at 1500, 1250, 1000,....250 ft. You'd have ten seconds to get a speed reading. If you couldn't get a reading in that time and the driver gets a warning of the laser gun activation for the entire 10 seconds then I'd say the jammer passes the test.
Thoughts?
I would at least have bought an M40 and make sure you pair it with Veil and a laser shield (if you have a front plate).
I would at least have bought an M40 and make sure you pair it with Veil and a laser shield (if you have a front plate).
Got Veil. I'll be applying it to a front plate cover and headlights. I had thought about an M40, but the front grill of my car would have a hard time accommodating all the heads. We'll see how the M20 goes and maybe I'll add a couple heads.
interceptor
05-28-2007, 03:47 PM
i realy dont see a link from topic name to topic... 8)
happya$$
05-28-2007, 03:47 PM
I would at least have bought an M40 and make sure you pair it with Veil and a laser shield (if you have a front plate).
Got Veil. I'll be applying it to a front plate cover and headlights. I had thought about an M40, but the front grill of my car would have a hard time accommodating all the heads. We'll see how the M20 goes and maybe I'll add a couple heads.
Either way you have one hell of a combo
sethy
05-28-2007, 09:50 PM
Well, LED's can be overdriven like diodes...
I will say this, I dont think the blinder is a good idea for larger vehicles, but so far it has been the most reliable jammers in the industry so far as lack of preformance (on my cavi)
As of now, my AL's are starting to false, and those officers only target me for 6 or 7 seconds before they stop. I am starting to think they are getting readings and my AL heads are dying. I never had a problem like this with the m40.
However, if the LA is used in your area- you are toast. I had JTG on everything but the LA when I had my lasershield, veil, and m40, but the LA cut right through it all like it was nothing.
ELVATO
05-28-2007, 11:31 PM
The though about JTG runs is that if a jammer can JTG, then it will provide those "10 seconds" you are looking for, at whatever distance you are targeted. If a jammer gets punch through at 500 feet, the theory goes that if you were targeted at 500 feet or less, they LEO will basically get an instant reading.
WTH, safer for other drivers? It's not like you have LE-10s all over your car. :lol: From what I understand, most all the current diode jammers are "eye safe." Don't think you're going to be blinding someone soon :lol: Now if the same driver passes you all the time, while you jam the same laser trap every day....
The though about JTG runs is that if a jammer can JTG, then it will provide those "10 seconds" you are looking for, at whatever distance you are targeted. If a jammer gets punch through at 500 feet, the theory goes that if you were targeted at 500 feet or less, they LEO will basically get an instant reading.
The problem is the testing doesn't substantiate this result. It's only testing how long the gun remains confused from 1000+ feet to zero. It isn't testing whether the gun remains confused long enough to allow a typical driver to slow down. That's the test answer you really want.
So again I understand JTG, but I think the testing methodology could yield good results from testing for JTG and testing at the typical firing distances for enough jam time to be effective even if JTG is not achieved.
WTH, safer for other drivers? It's not like you have LE-10s all over your car. :lol: From what I understand, most all the current diode jammers are "eye safe." Don't think you're going to be blinding someone soon :lol: Now if the same driver passes you all the time, while you jam the same laser trap every day....
In college I had a friend who did laser light shows. He had a 50mw Argon laser that could damage your eye faster than you could blink if it got you dead on or by reflection. Laser diodes today are easily that powerful and usually much more so. In the race to make the most powerful jammer I wouldn't be surprised if these vendors are putting out a large amount of power from these devices. The only way to tell is to get the proper equipment to measure the output.
So there is a chance, however small, that you could be operating a laser device that could be dangerous because you don't know the output power of these units aside from what the vendor claims. Many of these units have self-test features that could harm your eyes or they could be reflected in rear view mirrors of other drivers and injure their eyes or back to you while driving and hurt you! Because the IR energy is invisible, your eye doesn't know it's being damaged and won't blink to protect itself.
Not only that, but again it's easy to overdrive these devices and burn them out. Finally, I'm willing to bet that LEDs are far more reliable in the harsh application environment of an automobile being used in all weather and at highway speeds. It doesn't matter how powerful the jammer is if it is unreliable.
I'm not trying to cause trouble, just posting some of my thoughts as I researched these devices and had to sort through all the laser diode hype.
However, if the LA is used in your area- you are toast. I had JTG on everything but the LA when I had my lasershield, veil, and m40, but the LA cut right through it all like it was nothing.
My area doesn't use LA guns, mainly Kustom brands. I bought the M20 but the vendor (Blinder USA) said they are actually M25 heads. I'm wondering if the newer heads would work better?
PshoootR
05-29-2007, 12:21 AM
I think JTG is something like maximum range testing as done with radar detectors, only in reverse. It CAN be useful, but is not definitive. The best test of a detector, jammer or anything else is to test it as it will actually be used in the real world. Most cops that I encounter using radar, and the occasional lidar gun, are shooting at medium to medium-short distances. Just as most deer taken by center-fire rifle hunters are not taken at 300 yards, but probably at more like 50 - 200 yards, most experienced cops do not try to take long shots with their weapons of choice, at least not in the eastern USA.
If a jammer will JTG from, say, 1000 Yards in a test, it may be REASONABLE to assume that it will do so from 250 yards, but the test does not actually prove that it will. It could be that at 250 yards the lidar will "burn through" before the jammer has time to react. The only way to know for sure is to test at 250 yards. Testing at long, medium and close range is the best way to determine that a jammer will have your ass covered. These are just my thoughts, worth what you paid for them :lol: . I don't yet have a jammer as I have encountered very few lidars and am waiting and hoping for one that approximates my V1 in reliability. BTW, the V1 generally alerts when the car ahead is lasered, and if I'm driving "point", or alone, I'm very careful about scanning visually for likely traps.
The problem is the testing doesn't substantiate this result. It's only testing how long the gun remains confused from 1000+ feet to zero. It isn't testing whether the gun remains confused long enough to allow a typical driver to slow down. That's the test answer you really want.
So again I understand JTG, but I think the testing methodology could yield good results from testing for JTG and testing at the typical firing distances for enough jam time to be effective even if JTG is not achieved.
this is like..... i have demonstrated a ferrai to 300km/hr, and you are arguing that this isn't real enough since we dont drive 300km/hr everyday. so you ask me to test for you 120 km/hr to see if it is "good enough" car?? :roll:
i think the fact that a car can go all the way up to 300km/hr means something, dont you think?
So there is a chance, however small, that you could be operating a laser device that could be dangerous because you don't know the output power of these units aside from what the vendor claims. Many of these units have self-test features that could harm your eyes or they could be reflected in rear view mirrors of other drivers and injure their eyes or back to you while driving and hurt you! Because the IR energy is invisible, your eye doesn't know it's being damaged and won't blink to protect itself.
if that's the case i would rather worry more toward the LEOs shooting at the drivers with their LIDAR, since they aim at the front plate most of the time and the chance of the beam accidentally shot directly to the driver's eyes is much more than the laser "reflected" from the rear view mirror of the front car.
plus, the laser from a jammer is not coherent enough as the argon laser u mentioned. so the power of damage is different.
g-zona
05-29-2007, 03:06 AM
In college I had a friend who did laser light shows. He had a 50mw Argon laser that could damage your eye faster than you could blink if it got you dead on or by reflection. Laser diodes today are easily that powerful and usually much more so. In the race to make the most powerful jammer I wouldn't be surprised if these vendors are putting out a large amount of power from these devices. The only way to tell is to get the proper equipment to measure the output.
So there is a chance, however small, that you could be operating a laser device that could be dangerous because you don't know the output power of these units aside from what the vendor claims. Many of these units have self-test features that could harm your eyes or they could be reflected in rear view mirrors of other drivers and injure their eyes or back to you while driving and hurt you! Because the IR energy is invisible, your eye doesn't know it's being damaged and won't blink to protect itself.
They are all 1M class! Class 1M lasers produce large-diameter beams, or beams that are divergent. The MPE for a Class 1M laser cannot normally be exceeded unless focusing or imaging optics are used to narrow down the beam. If the beam is refocused, the hazard of Class 1M lasers may be increased and the product class may be changed.
In the jammers there is no optics after the diode, so the beam is not focused!
fulcrum
05-30-2007, 06:15 AM
...
2) The unit is LED based which is safer for other drivers during operation.
5) They don't operate as if they are based out of a garage in Eastern Europe.
6) LEDs are less prone to failure and can't be overdriven and burned up like diodes.
...
The story about laser jammers being unsafe for others drivers is nonsense. A laserjammer projects a lot less IR energy per square inch than a lasergun. (At ranges more than a few inches) The difference in projected energy becomes more at larger distances.
If your logic is correct then police laserguns are very dangerous because they are pointed directly at the car and use high quality optics to focus the beam as much as possible.................
Operate as if they are based out of a garage in Eastern Europe? In the tests I mostly read, the laser diode based jammers outperform the LED based designs. These products from "Eastern European garages" seem to work a lot better than your 'not so very friendly' remark suggests.
Believe me, it is very easy to burn up a LED. (And yes, it's even easier to destroy a laser diode)
In LED based laserjammers, the LEDs are driven over their max. specs. I would argue that the laser diodes are more reliable, because they normally are not used outside their specs. The way LEDs fail is different from the way laser diodes fail. You can overdrive LEDs if you're willing to accept negative impact on lifespan etc. The margins with LEDs are much higher than with laser diodes.
I'll acknowledge that without a focusing system the laser diodes will not be a problem outside of a few inches away from the lens.
...
Operate as if they are based out of a garage in Eastern Europe? In the tests I mostly read, the laser diode based jammers outperform the LED based designs. These products from "Eastern European garages" seem to work a lot better than your 'not so very friendly' remark suggests.
Operate out of a garage examples:
1) Short warranties.
2) No formal distributors in the States.
3) Violate patents of competing products (at least for a couple of them).
4) Don't respond to e-mails.
5) Many reported problems here with heads going bad.
Etc.
Believe me, it is very easy to burn up a LED. (And yes, it's even easier to destroy a laser diode)
In LED based laserjammers, the LEDs are driven over their max. specs. I would argue that the laser diodes are more reliable, because they normally are not used outside their specs. The way LEDs fail is different from the way laser diodes fail. You can overdrive LEDs if you're willing to accept negative impact on lifespan etc. The margins with LEDs are much higher than with laser diodes.
I can cook a laser diode much faster than an LED. They're also much more sensitive to electrical variations, static, etc. than diodes. I suspect the higher failure rates these devices see over the LED counterparts is due to the harsh environment of an automobile, overdriving the diodes, vibration, car electrical system variances, or a combination thereof.
People are spending nearly $1000 for the laser diode systems. They are more powerful than the LED versions but seem to have some signifcant drawbacks in terms of reliability from what I've read and seen. So whether they are worth the price premium is quite suspect in my opinion. Especially when you factor in how the companies that offer them operate and back their products.