I don't think so, there is a big wide hole on either side and a small grille on the bottom. And a small hole again on top.Originally Posted by ronsc1985
It's pretty clear the primary shielding method is the dual antennae horns...
I don't think so, there is a big wide hole on either side and a small grille on the bottom. And a small hole again on top.Originally Posted by ronsc1985
It's pretty clear the primary shielding method is the dual antennae horns...
if the holes are smaller than the wavelength of the leaking RF energy then the signal can't get through the hole
The magnesium case may play at least a small part in the shielding, but that alone cannot make it totally stealth. I doubt that BEL went to the magnesium case for aesthetics alone, unless they are copying VR.![]()
GTO_04
I'm pretty sure the full case plays a much bigger part than you give it credit for.
Electronics design can only do so much to control RF leakage; physicaly blocking the signal does the most good and covers whats left.
without seeing the insides of an sti i can't really say but if you take the plasic outer case off you can get by with it but i'm willing to bet a good amount of money that if you crack open the magnesium case exposing all the electronics an RDD should sniff it out no problem.
Yes but how can it really block anything with the hole?I mean some very low frequency signals can't pass but I don't think Spectre goes that low :wink:
:wink: There you go, you guys are starting to get it. The case is for esthetics. High price, metal case, Spectre proof, powered speaker and marketed at Truck Stops. Target audience? C'mon anyone. Truckers would appreciate the ruggedness of the metal case, yes?Originally Posted by SmaartAasSaabr
The simple fact that the case has HUGE RF holes in the front, the rear and both sides should tell everyone that the case isn't what makes this unit Non-detectable.
Originally Posted by SmaartAasSaabr
Does anyone in this thread really understand radio frequencies? wavelenths vs. shilelding etc?
i'm starting to think no they dont.
The 1:1 ratio wavelength of 24.125ghz is 1/2" if you have a hole in an all metal enclousure thats less than that any radio frequencies are going to have a hard time getting out of that; same with the mesh; if the holes in the mesh are smaller than the wavelenth that rf energy is going to bounce right off and not go through. 24ghz is high for an internal oscillator or heterodyne signal so the wavelengths will only get LONGER as signal frequency decreases.
If you don't believe me go find some sheet metal; weld a box up w/ a lid; and cut a 4" hole and put a radio inside it. Keep the antenna in it and see how many stations you can pick up. The same goes for metal buildings; that is why you get **** for reception in them and elevators (which are big metal boxes).
why do you think old C-band satellite dishes are made of a wire mesh material. Well not all but a lot of them.
Simply put the metal case that surrounds the electronics inside an sti IS THE MOST IMPORTANT SHIELD for rf leakage. Am I the only one that understands this?
/edit: someone really needs to post pictures of the guts of the sti
Originally Posted by Computerjlt
No.
By far most of the leakage is transmitted back out the antenna, a common scenario is the first LO feeding back through the first mixer.
Probably the main thing that makes the STi stealth is the use of LNA's (Low Noise Amplifiers) in the front end. The LNAs provide good reverse isolation, letting radar in, but preventing oscillator frequencies etc from leaking out.
Before the STi's release, the only detector that used these LNA's was the V1, which explains why the older V1s did magnitudes better than other detectors against the Spectre (before the STi, of course). This might also be one reason why the STi is now the V1's closest competitor.
My guess is that whatever leakage the LNAs don't take care of is probably taken care of using RF filters (microstrip, waveguide, etc)...
*****
Bookmarks