Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 23
  1. #1

    Default New to the forums, with an x50 :)

    I just got my first detector (x50) last weekend and have fallen in love. Before last weekend I knew absolutely nothing about radar, etc, I have learned a lot in a week it seems. I am just a little obsessed :/ It's not so much that I even speed, but the pure fun in tracking what bands of radar the LEO's here use, how far I can pick them up, and which cars are shooting where. I drove to SC, 16 hrs both ways to see this girl I liked, and after getting home, exhausted, I went out and drove here locally on the main road looking... In a week I have found that most use CO K Band here but the newer cars (chargers) and the state troopers, use Ka. I did use it on the way home from SC, picked up a lot of CO Ka and used rabbits most of the time if I was speeding. I have not seen a laser shot or any IO yet which is good Anyway, I would like to mention that I love erickonphoenix's videos and his wisdom. I have learned so much from him and everyone else on the forum, and would like to thank him greatly. That's all for now though, just wanted to introduce myself I have work in 4 hours, maybe I will find some fun on the way.

  2. #2
    Lead Foot
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    469

    Default

    Always nice to meet a fellow X50 fan.

    Wait until you hear the laser alert. There just aren't words to describe it, but I nearly had a heart attack when mine went off for the first time a few years ago. It is so loud and piercing. It will shock the s--- out of you and you will feel like jumping out of your skin. Just be ready.

  3. #3
    Good Citizen
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Northern NJ
    Posts
    99

    Default

    i had my first laser alert earlier this month on my x50 and o man did i crap my pants haha. it scared the living daylights outta me it was so loud and piercing, as you say. it is def one of those alerts that gets your heart going.

  4. #4

    Default

    Oh great :? I nearly crapped myself yesterday when Ka went off, since its a higher freq. I did pick up laser one time for a split second but it had to have been a false from something, it hasn't happened since. I dislike this state so much though

  5. #5
    Lead Foot
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    469

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by xecuter2
    Oh great :? I nearly crapped myself yesterday when Ka went off, since its a higher freq. I did pick up laser one time for a split second but it had to have been a false from something, it hasn't happened since. I dislike this state so much though
    Have you encountered POP yet? I received a few alerts but was unable to locate the source so I just assumed they were false alarms.

  6. #6
    Old Timer
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Cleveland/Shaker Heights, Ohio, USA
    Posts
    7,732

    Default

    POP on the x50 is highly problematic. Here's my usual presentation as to why:

    For me, there's many different levels to this "POP problem," and there's one in particular which I think is very important to us x50-users.

    Specifically, the detector's ability to pick up true POP, when it's actually used.

    The V1, as various tests have shown, is considerably more capable in this respect than the x50. The Whistler Pro-78 also has some very interesting POP capabilities/features. This is an area which I think the x50 could certainly be better on. But regardless......

    I honestly think that even for those who live within "potential POP" areas, they should add in this consideration, their detector's actual ability to detect (i.e. "catch") true POP, into their personal debate as to whether to enable this feature or not.

    I'd think that if POP were a true concern, you'd want to first start with the best detector for the job, and that's certainly not the x50, which, despite its tremendous propensity towards POP-falsing, unfortunately seems quite incapable of reporting true POP hits, via the various GOL tests that specifically examine POP-detection performance.

    As for my usual stance on POP.......

    For me, the POP problem is two-fold.

    First: is there POP-enabled hardware in your area?

    And second, more importantly: is POP actually being actively USED?

    Just because the hardware is available doesn't mean that it's used. There's proof of this even locally where I live - a near-by township owns the equipment and their officers are trained for it, but, thanks to the ride-along that a fellow Forum member took, it was noted that they confessed to simply never bothering to use that function.

    Unfortunately, the only way to really know whether the second concern is valid would be to verify, through a primary source, whether or not POP is in-use. This can understandably be difficult.

    Even if you/your detector witnessed a "first POP, then K/Ka-band burst" scenario - even if someone was pulled-over - which *should* be indicative of a true-POP-use based enforcement scenario, you STILL cannot know for-sure, 100%, if POP was actually used. .

    There's simply no way that you can prove it wasn't a false-positive from repeated I/O.

    Similarly, note that while having a tandem-vehicle, dual detector scenario (i.e. one car with POP-off, other with POP-on) would rule-out false positives, it cannot conclusively rule-out a false negative (i.e. neither detector reporting POP, but POP actually being used).

    The only way, with current technology, to truly ascertain whether POP is in use is to (1) visually identify the equipment, then (2) have a confession from its operator whether POP was used at the moment it was detected on your detector.

    As-such, with these difficulties in-mind, you have to evaluate your own risk-benefit ratio.

    With my x50 Rev5, with POP enabled, I do get POP falses. They're annoying, and, to an extent, they also make me somewhat desensitized to the alerts. The former is bad and the latter even worse, as it erodes my trust/confidence in the detector.

    For nearly 3 yearsd, I kept my x50 POP-enabled because there are surrounding locales with POP-enabled equipment in-circulation. I unfortunately could not (and still cannot) rule-out, positively, their use, so I'd taken it upon myself to be more cautions - although I'd always debating the true value of my practice, given the falses.

    More recently, though, I've changed my mind about this.

    I now run with POP-detection disabled on my Rev5 x50.

    Why?

    I've judged that chances of me actually catching POP on my Rev5 x50 - even if it *is* truly being being used - based on the GOL testing of both past and present x50 units, is, I think, rather slim.

    This, combined with the fact that I drive in an increasingly dense urban area where POP falsing is an ever-present and persistent problem, has made me think twice about running with POP enabled on my detector.

    Where I live and where I chiefly commute, enabling POP on my Rev5 x50 is simply not feasible, especially since I value a decently quiet ride, and more importantly, maintaining that all-important "trust-in-equipment" quotient

    To me, the constant falsing did nothing but to make me start to "lose faith" in my detector - and that's *never* a good thing.

    I'm not saying that anyone here should or should not run POP-detection on your specific detector(s). The V1, with POP enabled, for example, was able to pick up most of the POP alerts. But even then, one must still contend with POP-falses.

    I'm just trying to point out both sides of the problem - and hope that you will make an informed decision based on the facts of the situation. There's pros and cons either way, you've simply got to evaluate your unique situation, and see what works best for you.

    -------

    Cliff's Notes version:

    Don't enable POP alert unless you can verify with CERTAINTY that will encounter POP enforcement in your primary-travel area/routes.

    If POP enforcement is a "possibility," then evaluate the risk-to-benefit ratio carefully, and take into account both the annoyance of POP falsing (which can be anything from other detectors, I/O K/Ka band, or even "the planets being in just the right alignment" - yes, it's that bad) as well as the fact that the more your detector falses, the more you will become accustomed to such falses and will become de-tuned to the detector's alerts (in effect, you'll start to "lose trust" in your detector - there are many instances noted here on these Forums of where even "veterans" have ignored their detectors, to their regret later).

    I can't tell anyone here what to do.

    I can only present the full story, and let you decide, for yourself, what's most important to you. Smiley

    Don't think that somehow enabling POP will magically protect you. Even top-flight detectors have trouble detecting POP reliably, and there's always "regular" I/O to worry about, too. Also, there's no detector that will reliably filter-out POP-falses - remember that your end-user confidence-in-equipment is a big factor in usage proficiency.

    On the other hand, also don't think: "POP will never happen to me." There's simply no good way to confirm this unless you have privileged information or have a truly visual *and* verbal confirmation from the citing officer.

    As a result, I humbly believe that using either assertion as the basis of your detector-usage practices is NEVER the right way to approach this.

    Review the risks and benefits, know the reasons. Make the decision for yourself, based on the facts presented and your personal preferences.

    ---------------------------------------------------

    Here, Azonehits and others of RD.net present some very valuable insights/suggestions to both present as well as future concerns of POP:

    http://www.radardetector.net/viewtop...ht=pop+problem



    -------------------

    That was all written some time ago, and still, there's simply no way around the logical demands that are imposed on trying to confirm POP hits, as well as in trying to justify - for the lack of better words - the use of POP detection.

    With that in-mind:

    Currently, I do have POP detection enabled on my 9500i.

    I'm simply doing so as a "test," as, based on the latest GOL results, it seems that the 9500i still has quite a bit of catch-up to do, when compared to the V1, in this respect. I still don't quite have faith that the 9500i will save me from a POP trap.

    As I stated above, with my Rev5 x50, I saw quite a bit of POP-related falsing, mostly due to leaky detectors in adjacent vehicles. To my surprise, I have yet to experience this issue with the 9500i in over two weeks of "testing," the only time the detector falsed to POP was in the presence of a high-end Mercedes SUV, in a situation where some kind of side/blind-spot warning device, on that vehicle, likely triggered due to proximity.

    More than likely, I'll probably wind up reverting to running the 9500i with POP disabled again, within a few more weeks - this is unless the detector can positively convince me that it's false ratio is going to be super low.

    To me, "losing faith" in the detector is a deathblow.

  7. #7

    Default

    I have not picked up any POP yet and I highly doubt they use it here. Thanks for the information WRX^. I figure though, why not have it try to pick up pop, maybe it will help it catch a short burst or something. I guess in this state though, they run CO mostly since people shouldn't be using countermeasures :roll:

  8. #8
    Lead Foot
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    469

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by xecuter2
    I have not picked up any POP yet and I highly doubt they use it here. Thanks for the information WRX^. I figure though, why not have it try to pick up pop, maybe it will help it catch a short burst or something. I guess in this state though, they run CO mostly since people shouldn't be using countermeasures :roll:
    I'm sorry, but what state do you live in? I got from your first post that you went to SC to visit your girlfriend, but you're not in Virginia are you?

  9. #9
    Lead Foot
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    469

    Default

    TSi+WRX - Thanks for the detailed info on POP. I was always kind of curious as to why Escort detectors have it disabled by default, but it makes sense to me now. I have it enabled on mine. Mostly just for fun to see what I can find. However, I drive in highway mode on the highway most of the time (very little city driving in my commute) and therefore take all alerts seriously until I can identify the source of the signal - whether it be real or false. I make no exceptions with POP. If I can't identify the source and the detector stops alerting, I usually stay at PSL a couple miles at least before picking it back up again.

  10. #10
    Old Timer
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Cleveland/Shaker Heights, Ohio, USA
    Posts
    7,732

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by xecuter2
    I have not picked up any POP yet and I highly doubt they use it here. Thanks for the information WRX^. I figure though, why not have it try to pick up pop, maybe it will help it catch a short burst or something. I guess in this state though, they run CO mostly since people shouldn't be using countermeasures :roll:
    NP. Glad to help. The "POP-concern" is a difficult one to walk through, and the reason why I wrote up that long post about it was because it confused me, too.

    As for catching "quick trigger" bursts - enabling or disabling POP should not have an effect:

    http://www.radardetector.net/viewtopic.php?t=33264

    ^ The logic in this post is that enabling POP still only allows the detector to look at those very specific POP bursts, and therefore will not help detect "quick triggers."

    At the same time, it's speculated that enabling POP may cause the detector to respond slightly slower (thus decrease its "detection range," if you will) to non-POP threats, as the detector must cycle through more "steps" during its "sweep." This idea seems logical, and it seems to be supported by the data obtained from the GOL's August 2007 detector test, under the "Experiments with Settings" section, where the data from both Bel/Escort detectors seem to support this assertion.

    Quote Originally Posted by justin81
    TSi+WRX - Thanks for the detailed info on POP. I was always kind of curious as to why Escort detectors have it disabled by default, but it makes sense to me now.
    ^ Same as up above.

    I have it enabled on mine. Mostly just for fun to see what I can find.
    That's why I have it on now, too. I want to see just how different the 9500i is, from my old x50, when it came to the various POP concerns.

    However, I drive in highway mode on the highway most of the time (very little city driving in my commute) and therefore take all alerts seriously until I can identify the source of the signal - whether it be real or false. I make no exceptions with POP. If I can't identify the source and the detector stops alerting, I usually say at PSL a couple miles at least before picking it back up again.
    The mere fact that you're more of a highway commuter may give you some extra "buffer" for POP falses. In my 4 years with my x50, I'd really only encountered POP falsing when in the city.

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. New to the forums
    By Stealthspeed in forum Introduce Yourself
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 04-28-2012, 12:00 PM
  2. New to forums
    By 1stDegreeSpeeder in forum Introduce Yourself
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: 04-13-2011, 11:52 PM
  3. New to forums
    By MoreGs in forum Introduce Yourself
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 05-19-2009, 09:56 PM
  4. Car forums?
    By xXCriticizeXx in forum Car Talk
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 11-02-2006, 07:30 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •