Quote:
Originally Posted by
Monte1
Trust the responses from the OWNERS of the Redline who had a problem, sent it back for a fix, got it back, and have put it though the TEST of REAL LIFE. If the problems are gone, one or both of them can be trusted.
This I agree with, wholeheartedly, but it does not inherently solve the problem. ;)
Quote:
If the problem persists, neither of them can be trusted at this time.
^ And that's the problem....
We don't know who to trust because, at least by my logic, we cannot reconcile what one party has said, versus the other.
I think you'll see what I mean, with this set of posts below.
This was just posted by
EscortRadar, one of the main Escort representatives, on the Escort Radar Forums:
Quote:
Originally Posted by EscortRadar
Quote:
Originally Posted by TSi+WRX
Was there a pervasive problem, or not?
Is there a true "software fix," or not?
:confused:
There is no pervasive problem with RedLine.
Yes, we can diagnose and repair a defective RedLine.
That seems like a clear and concise reply, right?
But logically, it's not.
Here's what I wrote back to him, and by reading it, I think you'll see what I mean.
Quote:
Originally Posted by TSi+WRX
There *is* no pervasive problem - or *was* there no such problem, ever?
It seems that, from everything that the other representatives have said, there *was* a problem, which has since been addressed.
And if there *was* a problem with the older units, are they going to be actively recalled? or are those early buyers left to their own devices, to discover if that "software glitch" - which has repeatedly been mentioned to have existed in the older units - will manifest based on their usage?
But is this fix in specific relation to that "software glitch?"
I have no doubt that y'all can diagnose and properly repair a faulty RedLine - as you can, should, and have demonstrated to be able to do with *ANY* of your past as well as current products.
But we're not talking about general problems, here. We're specifically addressing the noted "glitch" - and whether if there exists a specific "software fix" to address that "glitch."
If there *was* a software issue, would that not have been pervasive, throughout the entire product run up until the point at which such a glitch was discovered - and was addressed? Yes, there's now only been three unique units (Cbr, dslrip32, and Nine_c1), and out of the hundreds or even thousands sold to-date, even if we isolate those to only the "older" batch, that can be an anomaly...something that's truly a freak occurrence. But that statistic can be just as easily reversed: what are the odds of three separate and unique units, units which landed in the hands of experienced hobbyists who've been able to observe and note this issue not only in real-life use (Nine_c1), but who have been able to *document* the issue, under controlled testing (capable of manipulating the RADAR signal, so as to elicit a controlled alert circumstance, with known operation parameters from the RADAR's side of the equation - Cbr and dslrip32's unique units)?
:confused:
So, who are we to trust?
I think that both
Cbr and
dslrip - two individuals who returned their RedLines - would both come forward and say that part of what caused them to return the products, instead of seeking a "fix," is that
they've lost faith in Escort, based on the run-around that they've been given.
And it's this very run-around that's seen, above.
I've been a loyal Escort user since 1997/8. If you discount my one single fling with a Bel (note that I didn't even stray far), I've been an *exclusive* Escort user since that time.
I'm not rich, but I've got the ability to choose what countermeasures I run, and I *chose* the 9500i, specifically, over the V1, the last time I had this decision to make, when updating from my S7 Rev5 8500x50. I sought repair/refurbishing of my ZR3, and still use it, today.
Why did I just go through my "user history?"
Because I hope that you - and any newcomers to the community - will see that I'm not just some guy who's looking to bash Escort.
I'm a loyal customer who wants to see the best of the company.
And right now, my faith is very,
very shaken.
:mad::(