Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 23

Thread: Running 2 RDs

  1. #11
    Professional
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    856

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Quote Originally Posted by Weeth View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by VanMan View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Weeth View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by VanMan View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    a Redline will get you owned in Texas.
    A Redline will get you owned with ANY instant-on radar...
    Not true. There are tons of videos with the redline detecting I/O, some of which are mine. Just check YouTube or the video section here.

    It will not detect I/O as well with a v1 next to it!
    I did not have good luck with it myself, and after looking at enough tests I decided against it. Perhaps I am wrong but everyone here quotes GOL and I like their testing...the V1's speed seems to hold a huge edge over the Redline's platform.
    I didn't see the Redline in that test?

    I don't think you're doing it intentionally, but saying
    A Redline will get you owned with ANY instant-on radar...
    is misleading. Instant on radar is not the same as quick trigger, which is what the redline supposedly struggles with. Most I/O shots last longer than a second, which is more than enough time for the redline to respond. Depending on the terrain, the Redline's better sensitivity increases the chance of getting an I/O shot that V1 will not.

    Search youtube for videos of the Redline vs. I/O.
    The test did the STi Driver and come to think about it I do believe the Ka-band performance on the Redline is slightly better but how big of a difference it is I do not know. Even the STiR struggled. The S7's did almost twice as good as the STi Driver.

    IIRC the Stalker Dual locks a speed in .5 seconds with 'hold' mode...is that QT and not IO as I thought it was IO?? Nine will likely enlighten me shortly. Perhaps I am off if 'hold' it QT. Either way, the Redline did not perform against the Stalker Duals using 'hold' here as other models have. My S7s tear them up all day but the Redline has struggled with it to the point in which it sat quiet through a few. They are the standard here and LEOs here frequently use them in 'hold' mode (I get hit with it at least once every 2 days). Mind you, I run Ka-guard off. With Ka-guard on, the V1 also fails to reliably detect the signals in my area.

  2. #12
    Radar Fanatic
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    Cyberspace
    Posts
    2,569

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    I don't believe the STi-R was segmented with RDR off in that test, which is what makes it king of I/O. A GOL will have to comment, because I'm not sure.

    I don't know how the Redline performs vs. the STI-D on I/O, so I'll take your word for it. While it's not the best with I/O, the Redline still detects it. I've already posted my video. I don't encounter enough to have more on film, but it's detected a nice I/O Ka shot when I was using it by itself.

    Once again, check youtube.

    Also, I hope ECCTG tests the Redline soon so we can put this to rest. Judging by the real world videos I've seen, it does fine!

  3. #13
    Professional
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    856

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Quote Originally Posted by Weeth View Post
    I don't believe the STi-R was segmented with RDR off in that test, which is what makes it king of I/O. A GOL will have to comment, because I'm not sure.

    I don't know how the Redline performs vs. the STI-D on I/O, so I'll take your word for it. While it's not the best with I/O, the Redline still detects it. I've already posted my video. I don't encounter enough to have more on film, but it's detected a nice I/O Ka shot when I was using it by itself.

    Once again, check youtube.

    Also, I hope ECCTG tests the Redline soon so we can put this to rest. Judging by the real world videos I've seen, it does fine!
    If the Redline had RDR, and a few other small tweaks, it would be the best radar detector ever made.

  4. #14
    Old Timer
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    New Hampshire
    Posts
    6,805

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Quote Originally Posted by VanMan View Post
    IIRC the Stalker Dual locks a speed in .5 seconds with 'hold' mode...is that QT and not IO as I thought it was IO??
    The difference between IO and QT is how long the radar is left in transmit mode. The Stalker takes 0.5 seconds to display a speed after being taken out of hold mode. This is why if you're the target, you're toast regardless of what RD you run. But if you're not the target, and your RD is sensitive enough, it can pick up the shot intended for cars in front of you (i.e. your rabbit(s)), so you can slow down in time.

    Now, once the LEO takes the radar out of hold, he may do one of two things. Most of the time, he'll leave it transmitting for a few seconds, say to get a tracking history of the target speed, or to clock a few cars in succession before putting the radar back on hold. This is "normal" instant-on. In this case any RD will alert including the Redline. Alternatively, the LEO may take it out of hold only until a speed is displayed, then put it back on hold within a second (QT or quick-trigger). This is the method that the Redline has trouble with due to its RDR (anti-Cobra) filtering.
    If I'm passing you on the right, YOU are in the wrong lane!

    If speed kills, how come I'm still alive?

    Active Countermeasures: V1 3.858, Escort Redline, Beltronics STi-R+, LI Dual 7.1x CPU/8.7 Heads (front)
    Other/Backup Countermeasures: V1 3.813 (loaned to friend), Beltronics Pro RX65 M4 6.3
    Vehicle: 2002 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro
    LEO Toys: Kustom Pro Laser II & III
    Encounters/Saves August 2011: Radar 3/1, Laser 0/0


  5. #15
    Professional
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    856

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Thanks! In that case the hold is used as QT as I get a 'blip' (usually 3-5 LEDs) on the V1 and then silence...which the Redline did not do very well for me. They go hold, shoot 1 car, back to hold. So I am wrong. The Redline did IO fine and it did not do QT well. Mind you the V1 with Ka-guard on isn't much different so its either hear every Cobra or get QT...errr


    Quote Originally Posted by kpatz View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by VanMan View Post
    IIRC the Stalker Dual locks a speed in .5 seconds with 'hold' mode...is that QT and not IO as I thought it was IO??
    The difference between IO and QT is how long the radar is left in transmit mode. The Stalker takes 0.5 seconds to display a speed after being taken out of hold mode. This is why if you're the target, you're toast regardless of what RD you run. But if you're not the target, and your RD is sensitive enough, it can pick up the shot intended for cars in front of you (i.e. your rabbit(s)), so you can slow down in time.

    Now, once the LEO takes the radar out of hold, he may do one of two things. Most of the time, he'll leave it transmitting for a few seconds, say to get a tracking history of the target speed, or to clock a few cars in succession before putting the radar back on hold. This is "normal" instant-on. In this case any RD will alert including the Redline. Alternatively, the LEO may take it out of hold only until a speed is displayed, then put it back on hold within a second (QT or quick-trigger). This is the method that the Redline has trouble with due to its RDR (anti-Cobra) filtering.

  6. #16
    Advanced Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Upstate New York where the Stalker Dual is King
    Posts
    1,533

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    QT is just a very brief instant on shot. How brief depends on several factors.......but the intent is to get a speed reading with a transmit time as short as possible in order to escape detection by motorists packing a Radar Detector. Some LEO's refer to it as POP but the mechanics are entirely different and most radars take at least 1/4 of a second to register a speed as opposed to real POP which takes under 1/10 of a second.


    Factors:
    • Moving or Stationary........Moving mode usually takes a bit longer as the radar has to first latch onto the patrol speed before it can produce a target speed. Radar manufacturers have developed VSS (Vehicle Speed Sensor) cables that assist the radar in aquiring the correct patrol speed faster making target aquistion much faster.
    • Weather / Traffic / RFI.........Rain, traffic and even the under dash blower motor can all effect target aquisition times. The more clutter in the return signal, the longer the radar takes to verify and display a speed.
    • Target vehicle..........some cars produce a stronger return than others. In order to pull a Quick Trigger, you need a nice clean return of adequate power level. So some vehicles can be popped at 1/4 mile while others have to be closer before you can get a reading using quick triggers.
    Note that in this test, the 1st target vehicle is a Honda with a relatively low profile front end. I miss him on the 1st two shots!

    The vehicle used in the next three runs is an Acura with a nice chrome plated grill. I get him just about every time from the moment he rounds the bend.



    This second video is a timed test of just how low you can go and get a speed reading pulling QT's. It's performed in stationary mode with no traffic other than the target vehicle on a clear dry night. So 1/4 second is about the best I believe possible with a two piece unit. The handheld guns might be just a tad quicker in that some guns will transmit when pulling the trigger and go back on hold with the release..........the real advantage is the gun automatically locks the target speed if one is read.

    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  7. #17
    Speed Demon
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Central TN
    Posts
    581

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Quote Originally Posted by VanMan View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    a Redline will get you owned in Texas.
    A Redline will get you owned with ANY instant-on radar...
    Oh really?





    Note the time lapse between when the STi-R+ alerts and the Redline alerts; its about .5 seconds in my book.
    Since Jag bragged about how good Whistler's are, note how many shots my Whistler 3600 missed in these two videos--1500' line-of-sight from the LEO and both of us were stationary--that's what I call "best case" conditions.

    Here's another one of the Redline and STi-R+.


    The way I interpret it is having the RL on the windshield sweeping all bands (X, K and all Ka), and the STi-R+ on top of the headache rack looking over the top of the cab, and sweeping X, K and bands 2,5 & 8 of Ka --33.8, 34.7 & 35.5 with RDR off-- gives it about a .5 second advantage.

  8. #18
    Professional
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    856

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Quote Originally Posted by Swamp View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by VanMan View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    a Redline will get you owned in Texas.
    A Redline will get you owned with ANY instant-on radar...
    Oh really?





    Note the time lapse between when the STi-R+ alerts and the Redline alerts; its about .5 seconds in my book.
    Since Jag bragged about how good Whistler's are, note how many shots my Whistler 3600 missed in these two videos--1500' line-of-sight from the LEO and both of us were stationary--that's what I call "best case" conditions.

    Here's another one of the Redline and STi-R+.


    The way I interpret it is having the RL on the windshield sweeping all bands (X, K and all Ka), and the STi-R+ on top of the headache rack looking over the top of the cab, and sweeping X, K and bands 2,5 & 8 of Ka --33.8, 34.7 & 35.5 with RDR off-- gives it about a .5 second advantage.
    Hmm..I stand corrected

  9. #19
    Speed Demon
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Central TN
    Posts
    581

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Quote Originally Posted by VanMan View Post
    [

    Hmm..I stand corrected
    No problem!
    Just for the record, I am not claiming that the RL detects Quick-Trigger (sub 1-second trigger pulls), and as Woodscolby stated, in TX and OK the V1 (or STi-R+) would be a better choice.

    When I mounted my RL and V1 within 6" of each other, the RL went deaf, dumb and blind. It was scary! Since I mounted the RL top left and the V1 top right on the windshield, the RL consistently alerts before the V1, sometimes by a very large margin.
    I bought a V1 strictly out of concerns over the RL's Q/T detection abilities (or lack thereof), so even IF the V1 causes interference with the RL, the RL won't diminish the V1's Q/T sensitivity, so I feel that I have gained an advantage.
    Last edited by Swamp; 08-11-2011 at 07:41 AM. Reason: Added more

  10. #20
    Good Citizen
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Posts
    153

    Default Re: Running 2 RDs

    Quote Originally Posted by Swamp View Post
    When I mounted my RL and V1 within 6" of each other, the RL went deaf, dumb and blind. It was scary! Since I mounted the RL top left and the V1 top right on the windshield, the RL consistently alerts before the V1, sometimes by a very large margin.
    I bought a V1 strictly out of concerns over the RL's Q/T detection abilities (or lack thereof), so even IF the V1 causes interference with the RL, the RL won't diminish the V1's Q/T sensitivity, so I feel that I have gained an advantage.
    Could you explain exactly where both units where that disabled the RL?

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. running hot v1?
    By radarcy in forum Valentine One
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 04-29-2011, 09:37 PM
  2. Running V1 and STi-R together
    By SaltyinNJ in forum Radar Detectors - General
    Replies: 31
    Last Post: 04-05-2011, 02:43 PM
  3. Car running hot
    By focalcivic in forum Car Talk
    Replies: 14
    Last Post: 06-04-2010, 09:34 AM
  4. Running a V1 and STi together??
    By wolfpacal in forum Valentine One
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 10-24-2009, 10:00 AM
  5. Running POP
    By acme in forum Whistler
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 07-10-2007, 06:02 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •