Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 17
  1. #1

    Default Need help picking.

    I've been looking into getting a good radar/laser detector for some time now. I cannot decide between a Valentine V1 and the escort 8500 and the 9500. I live in the Tampa/Orlando area of Florida and i usually drive mostly city with some interstate on the weekends. If im going to spend the money, i want pretty much the best. What are your suggestions and why?

    Thanks!

  2. #2
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Dallas, Texas
    Posts
    14,448

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    Plus 5 for being one of the very few to actually give us enough information from which to help you make an intelligent choice!

    I think it basically comes down to what you expect of your detector. Do you want something that you can simply plug in and forget about until the crucial moment? Or are you a techno-gadget kind of guy who wants an interactive experience? The Bel is basically pretty low maintenance. A few initial settings. A short period of getting to know the normal falsing spots in your area. Then you just forget about it until it alerts. A V1 is a little more interactive and high maintenance. More sensitivity=more false alerts. if you mostly drive alone, it's not as big a deal, but if you usually have a wife and/or family on board, you and them will tire of it quickly. Also, the V1 gives you more information to interpret. Instead of simply telling you that it senses radar, you have to be ready to interpret where it's coming from. Yes, it's more work on your part, but most people who try it end up loving it and never want to use any other RD.

    Performance is very similar between them. V1 is slightly better on radar range, usually. V1 is significantly better on laser, but that isn't usually a big deal since it only rarely would save you from a ticket, as it would with radar.

    For city driving, range is not the big factor though. The Escort has the benefit of GPS compatibility, so you can programme out known falses, making it a little quieter. And generally speaking, the Escort is a little quieter anyhow. Again, it depends upon whether you want a plug-n-play RD, or a tool that you will have to work with.

    They're both fine instruments, and you can't go wrong either way. It's more a matter of what you're going to be happy working with. Techie? V1. Casual user who doesn't really want to get into the whole RD thing, get the Bel/Escort.

    "Buy the BEST and screw the rest." - fire65

    "im intrested to see how well you do.i never seen a car JTG before would be a first for me.." - radarrob

  3. #3
    Power User
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    My Home
    Posts
    3,169

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    Quote Originally Posted by masteroc View Post
    I've been looking into getting a good radar/laser detector for some time now. I cannot decide between a Valentine V1 and the escort 8500 and the 9500. I live in the Tampa/Orlando area of Florida and i usually drive mostly city with some interstate on the weekends. If im going to spend the money, i want pretty much the best. What are your suggestions and why?

    Thanks!
    Do your research here regarding your choices. There is no other better way than trying all detectors and know their strengths and weaknesses. Just because it's good for me doesn't mean it is good for you. All of those detectors have a 30 day refund policy except shipping if you buy direct from the manufacturer. Although all 3 mentioned are highly recommended, I would suggest that you either get the V1 or the 9500i. The 8500 lags behind with off axis specially with 35.5 radar guns. You can do a search using my user name for videos that is available for you to see when testing the V1, X50 8500 and the 9500i. Also check Radar Detector Tests and Reviews by Guys of LIDAR for more info.

    Radar detector is just part of the equation and a lot of it has to do with your driving habits, experience, knowing your weaknesses/strengths as a radar detector user, and knowing what the limits are for radar and lidar. Remember, your strengths are LEO's weaknesses and LEO's strength is your weakness. This comes over time and experience. Operating a radar gun is also a big plus if you have a chance to use it. It can give you valuable information about the radar's capability.

  4. #4
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Dallas, Texas
    Posts
    14,448

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    Plus 5. Excellent advice. It's such a personal choice that you'll really never know without trying them both out yourself.

    I'm no V1 freak, but since it does have the most bells and whistles, I would recommend checking it out first. If it is what you want, great. If it's overwhelming, or just more than you want to deal with, send it back and get the 9500 instead. That just seems the most logical order, if you can only check them out one at a time.

    "Buy the BEST and screw the rest." - fire65

    "im intrested to see how well you do.i never seen a car JTG before would be a first for me.." - radarrob

  5. #5

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    Thanks for the great responses guys!

    I guess I operate on both sides of the coin, sometimes I like to play around with settings to get the best effect, but sometimes I do like having things plug and play. The only thing that seemed a bit "technical" to me is the V1's arrows telling you where the radar/laser is. To me it seems that that is just too much information, if there is a radar/laser anywhere I intend to slow down. But I guess that has more to do with spotting the false alarms and such. I have been reading around, especially the GOL who do great and easy to follow tests, and it seems that both the Escort and the Valentine are pretty neck and neck when it comes to performance and features. I guess im just looking for a "deal breaker" so to speak that will push me one way or another. I usually drive alone, and I don't think that I would really mind the beeping. One the other hand, how useful is that GPS system on the Escort? Does it beep when coming up to a speed camera, or is it just there so that it knows when not to beep (for false alarms)?

    I think that so far I am more inclined to go with the Escort 9500 just for the ease of use factor. Is there anything about the V1 that would work out better for me in your opinion(I realize that it is hard for other people to answer this)? I am sorry to be asking so many questions, it just seems like a lot of money to be spending to be buying the wrong thing. Lastly, would the 8500 X50 work basically the same as the 9500i? I mean forgoing the gps feature and the other bells and whistles, would it still give me all the warnings that the 9500i gives?

    Thanks again for your responses and for reading my wall of text!

    Edit: Read your post above right after mine was posted. I think that the I will try the V1 first and if i don't like it, the Escort. As you and Azonehits say, it is a personal choice. I just wanted to make sure that they were both up to par on their effectiveness and if there were any quirks that got annoying to deal with.
    Last edited by masteroc; 08-17-2008 at 12:01 AM.

  6. #6
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Dallas, Texas
    Posts
    14,448

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    Two things that stand out as big positives to me about the V1. First, Valentine is great about customer service and upgrading your RD as software revisions come out, so you don't end up with an outdated detector. That always makes me feel better about an investment like that. Second, while it is a little more chatty than other detectors, the arrows and bogey counter do indeed give you a lot more information for you to determine what is a false and what is real. After a little city driving, you quickly develop the knack for sorting the wheat from the chaff. That's a lot harder to do without that information. I've heard of very few people who got used to the arrows and then later wanted to be without them. On the other hand, if you've never had them, you don't know what you're missing, so it's no big deal.

    Someone else will have to tell you how useful the GPS thing is. Sounds useful to me, but it's also more to deal with, and potentially puts you at risk.

    All that said, if I were buying one for my wife or parents, I'd get them the 9500 instead of the V1. The interactive experience is not for everyone.

    "Buy the BEST and screw the rest." - fire65

    "im intrested to see how well you do.i never seen a car JTG before would be a first for me.." - radarrob

  7. #7
    Speed Demon
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    545

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    If you think the false alarms will get annoying get the 9500i. The escort RD's have Speck mode that also gives you information about the radar your detecting. It's not arrows, but you'll be able to find out what your locals use so you can find out what their equipments capable of.

    With the V1 though you can program it to have K band automute, and you can turn X band off if it's not used in your area.

    Either way turn POP off, and tell us what you end up with

  8. #8
    Experienced
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    Sacramento, CA
    Posts
    300

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    I was just in the same boat as you. I decided to go with the 9500IX. Reason for this was for the GPS and it's abilty to update at home though USB. I also like the dotmatrix display more. After thinking about if for many days. It came down to Arrows with one and GPS with the other.
    Good luck on your decision, for me it was a hard choice to make.

  9. #9
    Radar Fanatic
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    on the highways
    Posts
    2,328

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    you said you want the best...

    and there are only two choices here...

    the V1 and the sti driver...
    JMHO...

  10. #10

    Default Re: Need help picking.

    I have three favorite RDs for mostly city and suburban use. They are the 9500i, 9500ix, and the Pro78.

    The 9500i and 9500ix are rather quiet around town when used in Auto Sensitivity mode. Search for my threads about why I call Auto Sensitivity mode "black magic" mode. TrueLock functionality has been greatly improved with the 9500ix. Escort has implemented some major algorithm changes in the 9500ix to make its automatic TrueLock both more accurate and extremely reliable.

    The Pro78 is what I consider to be a "poor man's" radar detector for use in cities and in the suburbs. It is fairly quiet around town and is nearly as good as a 9500i or 9500ix when these RDs are operated in Auto Sensitivity mode. Yet it can't touch the 9500ix's ability to become deathly quiet by automatically locking out and eliminating false alerts.

    The 9500i and 9500ix have Ka band sensitivities which all but match a V1, and this Ka band sensitivity is always at maximum no matter what mode you operate the 9500i or 9500ix in.

    The V1 on the other hand is a K band false alert magnet around town. I do not recommend it for mostly suburban and city driving due to the plethora of K band microwave automatic door openers. The V1's true market niche is that it is an excellent open road radar detector -- not a radar detector for use in cities.

    Just my thoughts for what they are worth!

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. used V1 not picking up anything
    By SlapMyFro in forum Valentine One
    Replies: 38
    Last Post: 03-28-2009, 01:50 PM
  2. STI not picking up K
    By Palestar in forum Beltronics
    Replies: 26
    Last Post: 06-16-2007, 05:40 AM
  3. picking up 35.5 Ghz w/my X50
    By Qui-Gon in forum Escort
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 04-18-2007, 02:27 PM
  4. Picking a CB Out
    By whistlerfan in forum Scanners, Ham Radios, & CB's
    Replies: 50
    Last Post: 03-29-2007, 06:26 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •