Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 11
  1. #1

    Default Practical RD comparison

    I'd like some opinions on the following:

    Given that many (not all) consider 9500ci (and possibly STI-R) as the most sensitive Ka detectors on the market, what is likely to be the more sensitive setup when accounting for different mounting options:

    Comparison: Grill mounted 9500 ci (or STI-R) versus high windshield mounted quality detector (9500i/ix or V1...). Basically, what I'm asking is when the realities of traffic, roadside obstrutions, etc. are taken into account, do people feel that the increased sensitivy of the 9500ci/STI-R remote detectors might be negated when mounted low, compared to other high-mounted options?

    Thanks.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    Darned good question. So far, from my experiences, a high windshield mounted RD such as a 9500i, 9500ix, STi, or V1 come very close to matching and sometimes slightly exceeding the performance of the average 9500ci or STi-R remote installation. The problem seems to be that a lot of times these remote RD's are mounted too low -- maybe only a foot off the ground. It seems that mounting these remote antennas approximately 2 feet off the ground creates a significant improvement in performance. I have my 9500ci's antenna mounted 2 feet off the ground at the top of my car's front grille.

    Around town my 9500ci and my high windshield mounted STi generally perform the same. Yet, whenever I am headed up a shallow hill towards distant door openers, my 9500ci easily wins by alerting several seconds sooner than my STi. I've noticed rather similar results on the highway as well. My 9500ci wins every time when encountering radar over a hill. Yet in moderate to heavier traffic, most of the time my 9500ci and STi begin to alert within seconds of each other.

    It would be really neat if GoL would do tests with a 9500ci or STi-R mounted at 1, 2 and 3 foot height locations on the front of a vehicle.

  3. #3
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles Area
    Posts
    13,879

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    I run my 9500ci and my V1 together all the time. I live in LA. I have as much traffic as anyone. My 9500ci beats my V1 probably about 95% of the time. Here are the last two CHP videos I posted.

    My 9500ci beats my V1 by 3 seconds in this video...

    [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-abMFD9vZHM]YouTube - CHP Running Rear Facing Stalker[/ame]

    ...and by 15 seconds in this video

    [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFTR4Fmo_gw]YouTube - CHP Shooting Radar at the Back of Traffic[/ame]

  4. #4
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Dallas, Texas
    Posts
    14,448

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    In the first video, it takes you nearly a full minute from the initial V1 alert to get to the radar source. In the second video, it takes you half a minute. So again, I just really don't see $1200 dollars worth of benefit in getting an alert at 2.7 miles over 2.5 miles. The difference, while pretty on paper, simply doesn't add up to any practical benefit, and certainly not $1200 dollars' worth.
    Last edited by Stealth Stalker; 05-22-2009 at 07:55 AM.

    "Buy the BEST and screw the rest." - fire65

    "im intrested to see how well you do.i never seen a car JTG before would be a first for me.." - radarrob

  5. #5

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    Quote Originally Posted by Stealth Stalker View Post
    The difference, while pretty on paper, simply doesn't add up to any practical benefit, and certainly not $1200 dollars' worth.
    It does if you live in or regularly drive through more mountainous or more curvy terrain compared to CA or FL.

  6. #6
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles Area
    Posts
    13,879

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    Quote Originally Posted by Stealth Stalker View Post
    In the first video, it takes you nearly a full minute from the initial V1 alert to get to the radar source. In the second video, it takes you half a minute. So again, I just really don't see $1200 dollars worth of benefit in getting an alert at 2.7 miles over 2.5 miles. The difference, while pretty on paper, simply doesn't add up to any practical benefit, and certainly not $1200 dollars' worth.
    Your argument is that the extra sensitivity of the 9500ci is useless. Against C/O radar, of course this is true. The V1 is also overkill against C/O radar. A cobra is usually good enough against C/O. The problem that I have with your argument is that you've seemed to decide that the sensitivity of the V1 is necessary, but anything more is useless. Seems arbitrary to me. category4's K band video clearly shows that there are cases where the extra sensitivity can save someone a ticket.

  7. #7

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    djrams80: "I run my 9500ci and my V1 together all the time. I live in LA. I have as much traffic as anyone. My 9500ci beats my V1 probably about 95% of the time. Here are the last two CHP videos I posted."



    Where exactly are those RDs mounted (perhaps you have detailed this in a previous thread)?

    thanks.

  8. #8
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Dallas, Texas
    Posts
    14,448

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    Quote Originally Posted by djrams80 View Post
    Your argument is that the extra sensitivity of the 9500ci is useless. Against C/O radar, of course this is true. The V1 is also overkill against C/O radar. A cobra is usually good enough against C/O.
    You misunderstand my argument, which I thought I clearly stated was a cost effectiveness issue. You're paying $533 dollars for every extra tenth of a mile of sensitivity with the 9500ci. That's not necessarily useless. It's simply not useful enough to be worth an extra $1200 dollars over the V1, especially when you are giving up serious reaction time, which is much more important to I/O defence than sensitivity. The CI simply passes the point of diminishing returns on your investment.

    I didn't buy the V1 because of it's sensitivity. I bought it because of the arrows. The sensitivity is just a bonus. I'd probably be just as happy with the sensitivity of a BEL 995, an STi, or an X50 if it had arrows.

    Other than that extra three tenths of a mile -- which is over two miles to begin with -- there is no benefit to the 9500ci over the 9500ix. So again, that's all you're getting for the extra $1200 dollars, so it's just not worth it.

    "Buy the BEST and screw the rest." - fire65

    "im intrested to see how well you do.i never seen a car JTG before would be a first for me.." - radarrob

  9. #9
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles Area
    Posts
    13,879

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    Quote Originally Posted by hippocrates View Post
    Where exactly are those RDs mounted (perhaps you have detailed this in a previous thread)?
    9500ci here:



    V1 here:


  10. #10
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles Area
    Posts
    13,879

    Default Re: Practical RD comparison

    Quote Originally Posted by Stealth Stalker View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by djrams80 View Post
    Your argument is that the extra sensitivity of the 9500ci is useless. Against C/O radar, of course this is true. The V1 is also overkill against C/O radar. A cobra is usually good enough against C/O.
    You misunderstand my argument, which I thought I clearly stated was a cost effectiveness issue. You're paying $533 dollars for every extra tenth of a mile of sensitivity with the 9500ci. That's not necessarily useless. It's simply not useful enough to be worth an extra $1200 dollars over the V1, especially when you are giving up serious reaction time, which is much more important to I/O defence than sensitivity. The CI simply passes the point of diminishing returns on your investment.

    I didn't buy the V1 because of it's sensitivity. I bought it because of the arrows. The sensitivity is just a bonus. I'd probably be just as happy with the sensitivity of a BEL 995, an STi, or an X50 if it had arrows.

    Other than that extra three tenths of a mile -- which is over two miles to begin with -- there is no benefit to the 9500ci over the 9500ix. So again, that's all you're getting for the extra $1200 dollars, so it's just not worth it.
    That extra $1200 comes with many things than just extra sensitivity, but you know that. I think your sensitivity argument, while it seems logical, does not always play out that way in the real world. I have two instances where my 9500ci detected an I/O shot that my V1 missed. The 9500ci's superior sensitivity probably saved category4 a ticket in this video. It guessing that he was about blow around this left lane hog, right into a speed trap. A couple of saves like that and the extra money is justified.

    [ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbT2jODIcWc"]YouTube - 9500ci K band IO save[/ame]
    Last edited by djrams80; 05-23-2009 at 01:49 AM.

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. BCT-10 practical in PA?
    By mikered30 in forum Scanners, Ham Radios, & CB's
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 01-15-2010, 05:31 AM
  2. So is mounting high more practical?
    By kuepol in forum Beltronics
    Replies: 23
    Last Post: 01-24-2008, 07:36 PM
  3. Do you think the J feature is practical or not?
    By RadarBunny in forum Valentine One
    Replies: 19
    Last Post: 11-05-2006, 11:33 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •