Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 19 of 19
  1. #11
    Radar Fanatic
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Midwest
    Posts
    2,686

    Default Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    sorry but the x50 misses a ton of I/O shots. Alpine showed me with his golden eagle. Every time he hit shot I/O bursts the x50 would not alert but the v1 in the same car would. The x-50 only alerted twice out of 10 shots and it alerted as pop, not i/o.

  2. #12
    Radar Fanatic
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    1,795

    Default Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    Thanks for the info. But I have been using the X50 on the road for 4 years with never a stop. Testing is great, but not the same as real road experience. In most testing different RD will miss different things because the test is as close to the same as people can make it. Roads change every 60 seconds. This means, ONLY TO ME, road test are the best. Climate, road, turns, hills, how the Rd is mounted, how the person reads and understands the alert, how fast a person responds to the alert, what band are we dealing with. In test they shoot head on. One of the main rules is, ALWAYS run with a rabbit, this makes things totally different. I have had IO hits at 2 miles with the X50. Run some test with a rabbit at a set distance and check these results. Without a rabbit ALL detectors will fail with IO.

  3. #13
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles Area
    Posts
    13,879

    Default Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    The quick triggering tests that people do all the time against the X50 are correct. You can beat an X50 like this when you try to . This however doesn't really translate to the real world. LEOs are not out there trying to beat a certain type of RD, they're trying to give out tickets. I/O shots are almost always more like a few seconds, not a few hundred milliseconds. The X50 does just fine in the real world against I/O.

  4. #14
    Founder of Stealthvation
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Cleveland, Ohio
    Posts
    11,174

    Default Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    Quote Originally Posted by djrams80 View Post
    The quick triggering tests that people do all the time against the X50 are correct. You can beat an X50 like this when you try to . This however doesn't really translate to the real world. LEOs are not out there trying to beat a certain type of RD, they're trying to give out tickets. I/O shots are almost always more like a few seconds, not a few hundred milliseconds. The X50 does just fine in the real world against I/O.
    Good point but the M4 platform has always been way overpriced IMHO
    RIP Duncan my BELOVED black lab son 8/7/99-3/23/11. I will miss you DEARLY.


    http://www.criminalcustomzshop.com/


    LET THE BIRTH OF MANY TESTING GROUPS HAPPEN!











    You want to know what it is like doing something for the love and passion and not for the mighty dollar then look up GOL!










    buyradardetectors rocks!

  5. #15
    Advanced Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    7,509

    Default Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    The ability of a detector to alert to short bursts isn't necessarily about officers quick-triggering their radar guns.

    Even with constant-on radar, when you are barely out of range the signal will "blip" in and out from reflections etc as you pass terrain, just from being in a moving vehicle. Say you have two detectors with identical sensitivity in the lab, but detector A alerts well to short bursts and detector B does not. Even though the two have identical lab sensitivity, detector A will give you more range in the real world, since detector B will not alert until it is close enough to the radar source for the signal to persist long enough to trigger an alert.

    It was these kinds of "blips" when barely out of range of the radar that would trigger the "33.8 issue" with the STI. The STi would see a "blip" and the logic determined it was a leaky detector and filtered out any subsequent signals at that freq.

    There are a lot of things people can say about the Whistlers. No Whistler has ever been demonstrated to equal the sensitivity of an M4 Belscort. However, Whistler has consistently shown to be at the top in the ability to alert to short bursts of radar.

  6. #16
    Founder of Stealthvation
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Cleveland, Ohio
    Posts
    11,174

    Smile Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    Quote Originally Posted by jimbonzzz View Post
    The ability of a detector to alert to short bursts isn't necessarily about officers quick-triggering their radar guns.

    Even with constant-on radar, when you are barely out of range the signal will "blip" in and out from reflections etc as you pass terrain, just from being in a moving vehicle. Say you have two detectors with identical sensitivity in the lab, but detector A alerts well to short bursts and detector B does not. Even though the two have identical lab sensitivity, detector A will give you more range in the real world, since detector B will not alert until it is close enough to the radar source for the signal to persist long enough to trigger an alert.

    It was these kinds of "blips" when barely out of range of the radar that would trigger the "33.8 issue" with the STI. The STi would see a "blip" and the logic determined it was a leaky detector and filtered out any subsequent signals at that freq.

    There are a lot of things people can say about the Whistlers. No Whistler has ever been demonstrated to equal the sensitivity of an M4 Belscort. However, Whistler has consistently shown to be at the top in the ability to alert to short bursts of radar.
    WTH are you doing on the Whistler forum? lol I think you are mad because my Pro 78 can beat your Solo LMAO
    RIP Duncan my BELOVED black lab son 8/7/99-3/23/11. I will miss you DEARLY.


    http://www.criminalcustomzshop.com/


    LET THE BIRTH OF MANY TESTING GROUPS HAPPEN!











    You want to know what it is like doing something for the love and passion and not for the mighty dollar then look up GOL!










    buyradardetectors rocks!

  7. #17
    Professional
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    1,299

    Default Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    Quote Originally Posted by jimbonzzz View Post
    There are a lot of things people can say about the Whistlers. No Whistler has ever been demonstrated to equal the sensitivity of an M4 Belscort. However, Whistler has consistently shown to be at the top in the ability to alert to short bursts of radar.
    I really really wish Mike would report more of these for newer detectors



    http://www.radardetector.net/forums/...html#post34608
    Quote Originally Posted by Michael B View Post
    Radar lab.........
    I have tested the following today.

    To quantify my tests I performed the following.
    Units were tested at the desired frequency and an external electronic trigger was used to control the radar burst.
    The burst times were monitored by an O-scope
    The unit was tested until it responded 10 out of 10 times.

    Whistler POP models
    K..............67ms
    33.8.........67ms
    34.7........150ms
    35.5........150ms

    Cobra POP models
    K.............500ms
    33.8.........worked well from 67 to 100ms but then no response from 100 to 500ms. 500+ the unit was 100% response.
    34.7........750ms
    35.5........500ms

    Bel RX65 I do not know the rev # but it was one of the early units L006503
    K............did not work below 500ms. 500-700ms was mixed results. 700+ was 100% response
    33.8.......60-100 was 100%. 120 to 500 0%. 500-750 was mixed. 750+ was 100%
    34.7.......800ms
    35.5.......800ms

    http://www.radardetector.net/forums/...html#post81892
    Quote Originally Posted by Michael B View Post
    You guys want to see delay information?
    I've got delay information.


    Bel Sti Test
    Rev A1 M7

    POP was set ON
    X was inconsistent sometimes -101, sometimes -110, sometime in between.
    K -116 the unit did not report POP K.
    33.8 -110 Good from 60ms to 100ms. No response if 200ms to 900ms. Responded mostly above 1 second
    34.3 -112 Responded sometimes from 400ms to 800ms. Responded mostly above 900ms.
    34.7 -111 Responded sometimes from 300ms to 700ms. Responded mostly above 800ms.
    35.5 -110 Responded sometimes from 400ms to 700ms. Responded mostly above 800ms.

    Factory reset is POP OFF so I tried that to see if anything was different. (It sure was)
    33.8 -110 No response if 60ms to 900ms. Responded mostly above 1 second. Had erratic operation
    34.3 -112 Responded mostly above 500ms.
    34.7 -111 Responded mostly above 400ms.
    35.5 -110 Responded mostly above 500ms.

    It would appear that the POP OFF mode will more frequently respond to ½ second triggers and POP ON mode must wait until 800ms to 1 second.

    For those of you experiencing falsing issues due to other radar detectors, you may wish to turn POP mode ON!

    POP attempts with POP ON. 10 random tries each at intervals of 10 seconds or more
    33.8 67ms 90% K Band 67ms 10%
    100ms 90% 100ms 20%
    200ms 10% 200ms 10%
    300ms 0% 300ms 10%
    400ms 0% 400ms 30%
    500ms 0% 500ms 70%
    600ms 0% 600ms 70%
    700ms 0% 700ms 100%
    800ms 0% 800ms 100%
    900ms 0% 900ms 100%
    1 sec most of the time see note* 1 sec 100%

    NOTE* I had several instances when 33.8 would not work at all even during full CW pulse.
    This unit may have some software of hardware issue. I had to reset the unit and it appeared to work again.

    Sensitivity and windows for X and K were reasonable over temperature and maintained sensitivity to the edges of X and K band

    Laser Performance was good but only valid 100 thru 500 Hz. Good enough for North America I guess.
    I seem to recall some Laser guns used overseas around 900Hz. Sorry to all of you guys over seas.

    http://www.radardetector.net/forums/...html#post83019
    Quote Originally Posted by jimbonzzz View Post
    These are the lab test results for the Valentine One.
    Big thanks to Michael B for the testing!




    Valentine Research V1 Test 02/07/06
    Rev 3.826

    Factory Preset is POP ON
    X -118 WOW
    Ku -111 (default is OFF)
    K -121 Responded 100% at time intervals above 100ms
    33.8 -112 80% at 67ms, 100% from 100 to 200ms, 20 to 80% from 300ms to 600ms, 100% above 700ms
    34.3 -115 0% below 500ms, 50% from 500 to 600ms, 100% above 700ms.
    34.7 -115 0% below 300ms, 50% from 300 to 600ms, 100% above 700ms
    35.5 -113 0% below 300ms, 50% from 300 to 700ms, 100% above 800ms.
    These times were based upon 10 tries at each interval of 100ms from 100ms up thru 1 sec.

    POP OFF
    K -121 Responded 100% above 200ms.
    33.8 -112 Responded 100% above 600ms.
    34.3 -115 Responded 100% above 700ms.
    34.7 -115 Responded 100% above 400ms.
    35.5 -113 Responded 100% above 400ms.
    Unit would sometimes alert at bursts less than the above during POP OFF mode but not consistently enough.

    POP attempts with POP ON. 10 random tries at intervals of 10 seconds or more
    33.8
    67ms 80%
    100ms 100%
    200ms 100%
    300ms 70%
    400ms 50%
    500ms 20%
    600ms 80%
    700ms 100%
    800ms 100%
    900ms 100%
    1 sec 100%


    K Band
    67ms 90%
    100ms 100%
    200ms 100%
    300ms 100%
    400ms 100%
    500ms 100%
    600ms 100%
    700ms 100%
    800ms 100%
    900ms 100%
    1 sec 100%


    Laser Performance was Excellent. The valid range was 30Hz thru 800Hz.
    I seem to recall some Laser guns used overseas around 900Hz.

    X and K windows are tight at 10.490 to 10.560 and 24.040 to 24.260
    Euro mode disables X
    Euro mode Ka freq are only valid from 33.7 thru 33.9GHz and 34.2 thru 34.4GHz
    Unit PRD Falsing test performed well when tested against major known brands and models at 50 feet.

    Sensitivity from the rear horn was as follows
    X -117
    Ku -110
    K -118
    33.8 -105
    34.3 -108
    34.7 -108
    35.5 -106

    And the classic http://www.radardetector.net/forums/...lses-more.html
    Last edited by ahmadr; 01-10-2009 at 06:05 AM.

  8. #18
    Old Timer
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Great Lakes
    Posts
    6,538

    Thumbs up Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    I think the X50 does quite well languy, just depends on the situation. Matter of fact, my Rev 3 X50 just the other day allowed me to pick up off axis k band through brick buildings and such which is very impressive. But since we are in the Whistler column and I have been testing the Pro 78, I have to say it is quite impressive.

  9. #19
    Power User
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Lubbock,Tx
    Posts
    3,497

    Default Re: Is it worth the extra $$$

    I will post this again of how fast Whistler is responding to Ka.


    http://www.radardetector.net/forums/...-response.html

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 6
    Last Post: 12-02-2010, 02:19 PM
  2. Autoscan worth the extra $$$?
    By Triman123 in forum Beltronics
    Replies: 16
    Last Post: 02-02-2009, 08:57 PM
  3. is the 9500i worth the extra bucks
    By v1dreamer in forum Radar Detectors - General
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 06-02-2008, 09:08 PM
  4. Is 995 worth the extra $ over 955
    By trojanboy in forum Beltronics
    Replies: 25
    Last Post: 11-30-2007, 08:56 AM
  5. Ordering my V1 do i need anything extra?
    By mrcllusb in forum Valentine One
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 04-01-2006, 09:46 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •