Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 21 to 30 of 37

Thread: Moving on...

  1. #21
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles Area
    Posts
    13,879

    Default Re: Moving on...

    Quote Originally Posted by whistlerfan View Post
    Let me reword the above post. If you want a budget detector go with cobra because they really are a budget detector. If you want a mid price detector go with whistler.
    I have to hit the "keep it real" button on this one. I'd say that Whistler is a "budget RD company" in every sense of the word.

    As far as detection goes, VR and Belscort are the standard right now. While driving around with the Whistler flagship for about a week now, I got to thinking. This SE seems no better than Freebird's SE. Every RD made by Belscort or VR is more sensitive than this brand new, top-of-the-line Whistler, with one single solitary exception, the Solo S2, which basically no one here considers usable. In fact, you can go on Ebay and purchase a refurbished 8500 directly from Escort, which uses basically "decade old" technology, that will outperform this top-of-the-line Whistler. As far as sensitivity goes, the Whistler has to fall into the "budget RD" catergory.

    The features on this Whistler are pretty good, but nothing really ground breaking. The top-of-the-line Belscort and VR models all have distinctly unique features, which distinguish them in the RD world. The 9500's have TrueLock, the STi has complete Spectre invisibility and the V1 has the arrows. So, as far as features go, the Whistler would also have to be considered a "budget" alternative, since it lacks a completely unique feature set.

    In my opinion, there seems to be nothing about this RD that would make someone choose it over all of the "top dogs", except price, or maybe some predetermined prejudice. So, based on my conclusions, I'd say that makes the Whistler a "budget RD". I'm sure that my opinion will make you Whistler fans mad, but I'm just "keeping it real", like I always do.

  2. #22
    Speed Demon
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    547

    Default Re: Moving on...

    I would agree that Whistler makes excellent budget detectors as well.

    However, there is nothing wrong with using a budget detector, and IMO my XTR-690 has good sensitivity considering the price I paid for it.

    The Whistler has definitely proven itself to me more than once, and I think people don't necessarily give Whistler detectors enough credit.

  3. #23
    Power User
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Lubbock,Tx
    Posts
    3,497

    Default Re: Moving on...

    Quote Originally Posted by djrams80 View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by whistlerfan View Post
    Let me reword the above post. If you want a budget detector go with cobra because they really are a budget detector. If you want a mid price detector go with whistler.
    I have to hit the "keep it real" button on this one. I'd say that Whistler is a "budget RD company" in every sense of the word.

    As far as detection goes, VR and Belscort are the standard right now. While driving around with the Whistler flagship for about a week now, I got to thinking. This SE seems no better than Freebird's SE. Every RD made by Belscort or VR is more sensitive than this brand new, top-of-the-line Whistler, with one single solitary exception, the Solo S2, which basically no one here considers usable. In fact, you can go on Ebay and purchase a refurbished 8500 directly from Escort, which uses basically "decade old" technology, that will outperform this top-of-the-line Whistler. As far as sensitivity goes, the Whistler has to fall into the "budget RD" catergory.

    The features on this Whistler are pretty good, but nothing really ground breaking. The top-of-the-line Belscort and VR models all have distinctly unique features, which distinguish them in the RD world. The 9500's have TrueLock, the STi has complete Spectre invisibility and the V1 has the arrows. So, as far as features go, the Whistler would also have to be considered a "budget" alternative, since it lacks a completely unique feature set.

    In my opinion, there seems to be nothing about this RD that would make someone choose it over all of the "top dogs", except price, or maybe some predetermined prejudice. So, based on my conclusions, I'd say that makes the Whistler a "budget RD". I'm sure that my opinion will make you Whistler fans mad, but I'm just "keeping it real", like I always do.
    When i get my 78 SE in a few months i will flood this forum with Ka 34.7 videos.Heck i will even send you my REV c 78 to test and run for a while. I gurantee it will make your head spin. Veil guy said the SE was similar to the V1.??. I'm not mad I just have 40,000 miles on REV C and Ka band. Its easy for Whistler haters to think Whistler is a "budget" detector. A cobra is a budget detector and a Whistler is a mid-grade RD. Your thinking i haven't owned anything but Whistler huh? Well i have had 2 passport x 50's. Many of my family members own Belscort and V1's. I have used a V1 for 3 months and was only real impressed with K band and the dual Antenna's. As far as Ka band REV C was pretty damn close maybe cause the terrain but thats my expierence
    Last edited by Jag42; 06-04-2009 at 11:15 PM.

  4. #24
    Speed Demon
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    547

    Default Re: Moving on...

    BTW, I mean budget based on price, not on performance and features.

    If talking about those, I feel that mid-grade is much more appropriate.

  5. #25
    Yoda of Radar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Los Angeles Area
    Posts
    13,879

    Default Re: Moving on...

    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    When i get my 78 SE in a few months i will flood this forum with Ka 34.7 videos.
    That's cool, but with nothing to compare the detection range to, I'm not sure what this will prove.

    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    Heck i will even send you my REV c 78 to test and run for a while. I gurantee it will make your head spin.
    I highly doubt it, but send it. I'll run some video. I bet it will give you some perspective.

    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    Veil guy said the SE was similar to the V1.??.
    ...And I say this statement is completely false, at least for retail units. My V1 KEERUSHES this retail Whistler I'm running. If this was a fight, it would have been stopped in the first round, by KO!

    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    I'm not mad I just have 40,000 miles on REV C and Ka band.
    But, it's my opinion that you have no perspective. I don't think you understand how a "top-notch" RD performs. You run your Whistler every day and you think it works great. There are tons of Cobra users out there that think their RD workd great also. It's my opinion that if you were running my setup on a regular basis, you'd have the same opinion of the Whistlers as I do. The brand new Whistler I'm running, which is supposed to be the most sensitive Whistler ever, is not in the same class as my lowest performer, which is my 9500ix.

    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    Its easy for Whistler haters to think Whistler is a "budget" detector.
    I guess we're back to the "Whistler Hater" thing again. You told me that if I ran one for a while, I'd be impressed. Well I have and I'm not, at least not so far. This thing just isn't very good and it's supposed to better than the one you're running. I think I've given it a fair shot and will continue to do so, but at some point, you might want to ask yourself why those of us that have used many top-notch RDs are not as impressed with the Whistlers that you are so in love with.

    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    A cobra is a budget detector and a Whistler is a mid-grade RD
    Or....a Cobra belongs in the "completely useless RD" catergory, while the top-notch Whistlers belong in the "budget RD" catergory. Again, perspective.

  6. #26
    Lead Foot
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Orange County, CA
    Posts
    336

    Default Re: Moving on...

    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    Its easy for Whistler haters to think Whistler is a "budget" detector.
    I currently use a Whistler and I would definately call them budget detectors. Granted mine is crappy and like 7 years old, but my opinion that they are great budget detectors would not change if I was using a $150 "top of the line" Whistler, such as the Pro 78 or XTR-695

  7. #27
    Newcomer
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Vegas
    Posts
    56

    Default Re: Moving on...

    so the XTR 695 I bought is a POS

    so many opnions on this site, hard to discern. I guess that falls into any hobbyist site though, I'm into Astronomy, R/C and overclocking..always somebody with a different product or opinion

    I'm going to give the 695 a run for a couple of weeks, I can always exchange for a budget Beltronics if the whistler sucks in my area.

  8. #28
    Professional
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    850

    Default Re: Moving on...

    Quote Originally Posted by djrams80 View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by whistlerfan View Post
    Let me reword the above post. If you want a budget detector go with cobra because they really are a budget detector. If you want a mid price detector go with whistler.
    I have to hit the "keep it real" button on this one. I'd say that Whistler is a "budget RD company" in every sense of the word.

    As far as detection goes, VR and Belscort are the standard right now. While driving around with the Whistler flagship for about a week now, I got to thinking. This SE seems no better than Freebird's SE. Every RD made by Belscort or VR is more sensitive than this brand new, top-of-the-line Whistler, with one single solitary exception, the Solo S2, which basically no one here considers usable. In fact, you can go on Ebay and purchase a refurbished 8500 directly from Escort, which uses basically "decade old" technology, that will outperform this top-of-the-line Whistler. As far as sensitivity goes, the Whistler has to fall into the "budget RD" catergory.

    The features on this Whistler are pretty good, but nothing really ground breaking. The top-of-the-line Belscort and VR models all have distinctly unique features, which distinguish them in the RD world. The 9500's have TrueLock, the STi has complete Spectre invisibility and the V1 has the arrows. So, as far as features go, the Whistler would also have to be considered a "budget" alternative, since it lacks a completely unique feature set.

    In my opinion, there seems to be nothing about this RD that would make someone choose it over all of the "top dogs", except price, or maybe some predetermined prejudice. So, based on my conclusions, I'd say that makes the Whistler a "budget RD". I'm sure that my opinion will make you Whistler fans mad, but I'm just "keeping it real", like I always do.
    DJ,

    Keeping it real...you are the man. No BS in your post just facts. Keep it coming!

  9. #29
    Power User
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Lubbock,Tx
    Posts
    3,497

    Default Re: Moving on...

    Quote Originally Posted by ssick92 View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Jag42 View Post
    Its easy for Whistler haters to think Whistler is a "budget" detector.
    I currently use a Whistler and I would definately call them budget detectors. Granted mine is crappy and like 7 years old, but my opinion that they are great budget detectors would not change if I was using a $150 "top of the line" Whistler, such as the Pro 78 or XTR-695
    Whistler 1753 is a good RD but with no filtering it falses most of the time. Have fun with your 8500 as well !
    Last edited by Jag42; 06-05-2009 at 09:22 AM.

  10. #30

    Default Re: Moving on...

    I think at this time. We really need more videos of the SE in action. Where just really lacking videos to form a firm conclusion that would finally determine which way these units are point in both performance or if there is something wrong. There is next to nothing on direct threat videos done on the SE. That's when it counts. Veil guy most have saw allot more then we did for him to come off surprise about the units. I think everything is highly premature at this stage. The Pro 78 and Xtr 690 I know received a huge amount of negative comments when it was under Rev B. Rev C silenced allot of that.
    Last edited by whistlerfan; 06-05-2009 at 01:34 PM.

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. Moving To NY/NJ
    By zee3b in forum Radar Detectors - General
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 08-07-2011, 07:42 PM
  2. Moving my RD
    By venexoz in forum Whistler
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 05-01-2006, 12:32 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •